Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Why Time's Description in Modern Physics is Still Incomplete

Avshalom C. Elitzur, Shahar Dolev

Published Jan 1, 2003• 9 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

We present some novel results indicating that time's description in present-day physics is deficient. We use Hawking's information-erasure hypothesis to counter his own claim that time's arrow depends only on initial conditions. Next, we propose quantum mechanical experiments that yield inconsistent histories, sug- gesting that not only events but also entire histories might be governed by a more fundamental dynamics. 1. The Stalemate The problem associated with time's nature is well known. It stems from two aspects of time that cannot be reconciled:

Related papers

Hidden Determinism, Probability, and Time's Arrow

Hans Primas

In present-day physics the fundamental dynamical laws are taken as a time-translation-invariant and time-reversal-invariant one-parameter groups of automorphisms of the underlying mathematical structure. In this context-independent and empirically inaccessible description there is no past, present or future, hence no distinction between cause and effect. To get the familiar description in terms of causes and effects, the time-reversal symmetry of the fundamental dynamics has to be broken. Thereby one gets two representations, one satisfying the generally accepted rules of retarded causality (no effect can precede its cause). The other one describes the strange rules of advanced causality. For entangled (but not necessarily interacting) quantum systems the arrow of time must have the same direction for all subsystems. But for classical systems, or for classical subsystems of quantum systems, this argument does not hold. As a cosequence, classical systems allow the conceptual possibility of advanced causality in addition to retarded causality. Every mathematically formulated dynamics of statistically reproducible events can be extended to a description in terms of a one-parameter group of automorphisms of an enlarged mathematical structure which describes a fictitious hidden determinism. Consequently, randomness in the sense of mathematical probability theory is only a weak generalization of determinism. The popular ideas that in quantum theory there are gaps in the causal chain which allow the accommodation of the freedom of human action are fantasies which have no basis in present-day quantum mechanics. Quantum events are governed by strict statistical laws. Freedom of action is a constitutive necessity of all experimental science which requires a violation of the statistical predictions of physics. We conclude that the presently adopted first principles of theoretical physics can neither explain the autonomy of the psyche nor account for the freedom of action necessary for experimental science.

•Jan 1, 2002•15 citations

Arrow of Time and Quantum Physics

Detlev Buchholz A, Klaus Fredenhagen

Abstract Based on the hypothesis that the (non-reversible) arrow of time is intrinsic in any system, no matter how small, the consequences are discussed. Within the framework of local quantum physics it is shown how such a semi-group action of time can consistently be extended to that of the group of spacetime translations in Minkowski space. In presence of massless excitations, however, there arise ambiguities in the theoretical extensions of the time translations to the past. The corresponding loss of quantum information on states upon time is determined. Finally, it is explained how the description of operations in classical terms combined with constraints imposed by the arrow of time leads to a quantum theoretical framework. These results suggest that the arrow of time is fundamental in nature and not merely a consequence of statistical effects on which the Second Law is based.

arXiv:2305.11709•Foundations of Physics•Sep 21, 2023•10 citations

An Operational Framework for Testing Irreducible History Dependence in Physical Systems

Jos Aben

An Operational Framework for Testing Irreducible History Dependence in Physical Systems Abstract / Description This 14-page scientific preprint presents an operational framework for investigating whether realized physical history contributes independent predictive information beyond a sufficiently characterized present physical state. The research addresses a fundamental question in physics: Can two systems with different causal histories, but equivalent present physical states, exhibit distinguishable future behavior? The framework connects the arrow of time, causal history, non-Markovian dynamics, quantum processes, physical memory, and experimental falsifiability. The article synthesizes previously documented empirical and computational analyses, including superconducting-qubit investigations (V21–V25), matched-state comparisons, latent-state reconstruction, and independent environmental validation. A central reported result is that approximately 98.1% of the initially observed additional predictive contribution of measured history was absorbed by a richer causal latent-state representation at the principal tested history depth. This supports the importance of conventional physical memory and incomplete state descriptions when interpreting apparent history dependence. The article proposes a controlled experimental methodology for distinguishing conventional memory effects from potentially irreducible history-dependent contributions. It includes two scientific figures, formal testing criteria, reproducibility requirements, and a pathway for future independent experimental evaluation. The present work does not claim the discovery of a new physical law or report new experimental measurements. Its contribution is a structured, falsifiable methodology for identifying the experimental conditions under which additional physical explanations might become necessary. Full Research Report and Reproducibility Resources This preprint is derived from the comprehensive 321-page research report: The Realization Arrow of Time: An Operational Framework for the Transition from Physical Possibility to Realized Causal History. Author: Jos Aben (2026) Original Zenodo DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22745724 The original Zenodo publication provides the complete theoretical framework, empirical validation documentation, frozen experimental protocols, computational analyses, and associated reproducibility packages (Archives A, B and C). Researchers interested in independently evaluating the methods, examining the underlying results, or extending the proposed experimental programme are encouraged to consult the complete research record. Publication status: Independent scientific preprint. Not peer reviewed. Keywords: Arrow of time; irreducible history dependence; causal history; physical realization; present-state sufficiency; non-Markovian dynamics; quantum measurement; experimental falsifiability; reproducibility.

•Nov 14, 2026•0 citations

Quantum causality determines the arrow of time

John F. Donoghue, Gabriel Menezes

In the philosophy of science, the origin of an arrow of time is viewed as problematic. We describe here how this arrow really follows from the causal structure of quantum physics. This connection is not really new -- it is just overlooked in most discussions of the arrow of time.

arXiv:2003.09047•Mar 19, 2020•1 citation

The Observer as a Local Breakdown of Atemporality

Giani Moreno Gabriel

The nature of time remains a central problem in fundamental physics, spanning quantum mechanics, thermodynamics, and relativity. In this work, we develop an observer-dependent framework in which time is not assumed as a fundamental background parameter, but emerges operationally from restricted access to a globally timeless quantum state. Building on and extending the Page–Wootters mechanism, we introduce a unified relational formula that shows how three traditionally distinct aspects of temporality arise from the same structure: quantum dynamics from conditioning on physical clock states, thermodynamic irreversibility from partial tracing over inaccessible degrees of freedom, and observer-relative time from the locality of the clock subsystem. No modification of unitary quantum mechanics, collapse postulates, or fundamental time flow is required. Analytical arguments and numerical simulations demonstrate that, in the limit of complete information access, all temporal ordering disappears, while effective Schrödinger dynamics and an arrow of time emerge naturally under informational and observational constraints. These results support a central claim: time is not a property of the universe itself, but a property of descriptions generated by physical observers embedded within it.

•Feb 10, 2026•0 citations

On the Incompleteness of Physics: Time as a Fundamental Misconception

Yu, Liang

We argue that modern physics—including classical mechanics, relativity, and quantum mechanics—suffers from a fundamental incompleteness rooted in the treatment of time as a variable. Starting from parity violation and the absence of intrinsic lifetime in quantum wave functions, we show that: (1) only matter can observe change, yet physics uses light (which has no time) to define spacetime; (2) the time coordinate is either meaningless (without motion) or not independent (with motion); (3) physics writes equations from a God's eye view but performs measurements from a material observer's view; (4) matter, change, and time form a circular dependency that cannot be resolved within the current framework. The incompleteness of physics is not technical but structural.

•Jan 18, 2026•0 citations
We present some novel results indicating that time's description in present-day physics is deficient. We use Hawking's information-erasure hypothesis to counter his own claim that time's arrow depends only on initial conditions. Next, we propose quantum mechanical experiments that yield inconsistent histories, sug- gesting that not only events but also entire histories might be governed by a more fundamental dynamics. 1. The Stalemate The problem associated with time's nature is well known. It stems from two aspects of time that cannot be reconciled:
In present-day physics the fundamental dynamical laws are taken as a time-translation-invariant and time-reversal-invariant one-parameter groups of automorphisms of the underlying mathematical structure. In this context-independent and empirically inaccessible description there is no past, present or future, hence no distinction between cause and effect. To get the familiar description in terms of causes and effects, the time-reversal symmetry of the fundamental dynamics has to be broken. Thereby one gets two representations, one satisfying the generally accepted rules of retarded causality (no effect can precede its cause). The other one describes the strange rules of advanced causality. For entangled (but not necessarily interacting) quantum systems the arrow of time must have the same direction for all subsystems. But for classical systems, or for classical subsystems of quantum systems, this argument does not hold. As a cosequence, classical systems allow the conceptual possibility of advanced causality in addition to retarded causality. Every mathematically formulated dynamics of statistically reproducible events can be extended to a description in terms of a one-parameter group of automorphisms of an enlarged mathematical structure which describes a fictitious hidden determinism. Consequently, randomness in the sense of mathematical probability theory is only a weak generalization of determinism. The popular ideas that in quantum theory there are gaps in the causal chain which allow the accommodation of the freedom of human action are fantasies which have no basis in present-day quantum mechanics. Quantum events are governed by strict statistical laws. Freedom of action is a constitutive necessity of all experimental science which requires a violation of the statistical predictions of physics. We conclude that the presently adopted first principles of theoretical physics can neither explain the autonomy of the psyche nor account for the freedom of action necessary for experimental science.
Abstract Based on the hypothesis that the (non-reversible) arrow of time is intrinsic in any system, no matter how small, the consequences are discussed. Within the framework of local quantum physics it is shown how such a semi-group action of time can consistently be extended to that of the group of spacetime translations in Minkowski space. In presence of massless excitations, however, there arise ambiguities in the theoretical extensions of the time translations to the past. The corresponding loss of quantum information on states upon time is determined. Finally, it is explained how the description of operations in classical terms combined with constraints imposed by the arrow of time leads to a quantum theoretical framework. These results suggest that the arrow of time is fundamental in nature and not merely a consequence of statistical effects on which the Second Law is based.
An Operational Framework for Testing Irreducible History Dependence in Physical Systems Abstract / Description This 14-page scientific preprint presents an operational framework for investigating whether realized physical history contributes independent predictive information beyond a sufficiently characterized present physical state. The research addresses a fundamental question in physics: Can two systems with different causal histories, but equivalent present physical states, exhibit distinguishable future behavior? The framework connects the arrow of time, causal history, non-Markovian dynamics, quantum processes, physical memory, and experimental falsifiability. The article synthesizes previously documented empirical and computational analyses, including superconducting-qubit investigations (V21–V25), matched-state comparisons, latent-state reconstruction, and independent environmental validation. A central reported result is that approximately 98.1% of the initially observed additional predictive contribution of measured history was absorbed by a richer causal latent-state representation at the principal tested history depth. This supports the importance of conventional physical memory and incomplete state descriptions when interpreting apparent history dependence. The article proposes a controlled experimental methodology for distinguishing conventional memory effects from potentially irreducible history-dependent contributions. It includes two scientific figures, formal testing criteria, reproducibility requirements, and a pathway for future independent experimental evaluation. The present work does not claim the discovery of a new physical law or report new experimental measurements. Its contribution is a structured, falsifiable methodology for identifying the experimental conditions under which additional physical explanations might become necessary. Full Research Report and Reproducibility Resources This preprint is derived from the comprehensive 321-page research report: The Realization Arrow of Time: An Operational Framework for the Transition from Physical Possibility to Realized Causal History. Author: Jos Aben (2026) Original Zenodo DOI: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22745724 The original Zenodo publication provides the complete theoretical framework, empirical validation documentation, frozen experimental protocols, computational analyses, and associated reproducibility packages (Archives A, B and C). Researchers interested in independently evaluating the methods, examining the underlying results, or extending the proposed experimental programme are encouraged to consult the complete research record. Publication status: Independent scientific preprint. Not peer reviewed. Keywords: Arrow of time; irreducible history dependence; causal history; physical realization; present-state sufficiency; non-Markovian dynamics; quantum measurement; experimental falsifiability; reproducibility.
The nature of time remains a central problem in fundamental physics, spanning quantum mechanics, thermodynamics, and relativity. In this work, we develop an observer-dependent framework in which time is not assumed as a fundamental background parameter, but emerges operationally from restricted access to a globally timeless quantum state. Building on and extending the Page–Wootters mechanism, we introduce a unified relational formula that shows how three traditionally distinct aspects of temporality arise from the same structure: quantum dynamics from conditioning on physical clock states, thermodynamic irreversibility from partial tracing over inaccessible degrees of freedom, and observer-relative time from the locality of the clock subsystem. No modification of unitary quantum mechanics, collapse postulates, or fundamental time flow is required. Analytical arguments and numerical simulations demonstrate that, in the limit of complete information access, all temporal ordering disappears, while effective Schrödinger dynamics and an arrow of time emerge naturally under informational and observational constraints. These results support a central claim: time is not a property of the universe itself, but a property of descriptions generated by physical observers embedded within it.
We argue that modern physics—including classical mechanics, relativity, and quantum mechanics—suffers from a fundamental incompleteness rooted in the treatment of time as a variable. Starting from parity violation and the absence of intrinsic lifetime in quantum wave functions, we show that: (1) only matter can observe change, yet physics uses light (which has no time) to define spacetime; (2) the time coordinate is either meaningless (without motion) or not independent (with motion); (3) physics writes equations from a God's eye view but performs measurements from a material observer's view; (4) matter, change, and time form a circular dependency that cannot be resolved within the current framework. The incompleteness of physics is not technical but structural.