Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Conference on Computational Complexity

On the power of quantum proofs

Ran Raz, Amir Shpilka

Published Jun 21, 2004• 31 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We study the power of quantum proofs, or more precisely, the power of Quantum Merlin-Arthur (QMA) protocols, in two well studied models of quantum computation: the black box model and the communication complexity model. Our main results are obtained for the communication complexity model. For this model, we identify a complete promise problem for QMA protocols, the Linear Subspaces Distance problem. The problem is of geometrical nature: Each player gets a linear subspace of R m and considers the sphere of unit vectors in that subspace. Their goal is to output 1 if the distance between the two spheres is very small (say, smaller than 0.1 · √ 2) and 0 if the distance is very large (say, larger than 0.9 · √ 2). We show that: 1. The QMA communication complexity of the problem is O(log m). 2. The (classical) MA communication complexity of the problem is Ω(m ɛ) (for some ɛ> 0). 3. The (standard) quantum communication complexity of the problem is Ω ( √ m). In particular, this gives an exponential separation between QMA communication complexity and MA communication complexity.

DOI
10.1109/ccc.2004.21

Related papers

On the power of quantum proofs

Ran Raz, Amir Shpilka

We study the power of quantum proofs, or more precisely, the power of quantum Merlin-Arthur (QMA) protocols, in two well studied models of quantum computation: the black box model and the communication complexity model. Our main results are obtained for the communication complexity model. For this model, we identify a complete promise problem for QMA protocols, the linear sub-spaces distance problem. The problem is of geometrical nature: each player gets a linear subspace of R/sup m/ and considers the sphere of unit vectors in that subspace. Their goal is to output 1 if the distance between the two spheres is very small (say, smaller than 0.1 /spl middot/ /spl radic/2) and 0 if the distance is very large (say, larger than 0.9 /spl middot/ /spl radic/2). We show that: 1. The QMA communication complexity of the problem is O(logm). 2. The (classical) MA communication complexity of the problem is /spl Omega/(m/sup /spl epsi//) (for some /spl epsi/ > 0). 3. The (standard) quantum communication complexity of the problem is /spl Omega/(/spl radic/m). In particular, this gives an exponential separation between QMA communication complexity and MA communication complexity. For the black box model we give several observations. First, we observe that the block sensitivity method, as well as the polynomial method for proving lower bounds for the number of queries, can both be extended to QMA protocols. We use these methods to obtain lower bounds for the QMA black box complexity of functions. In particular, we obtain a tight lower bound of /spl Omega/(N) for the QMA black box complexity of a random function, and a tight lower bound of /spl Omega/(/spl radic/N) for the QMA black box query complexity of NOR(X/sub 1/,..., X/sub n/). In particular, this shows that any attempt to give short quantum proofs for the class of languages Co - NP have to go beyond black box arguments. We also observe that for any Boolean function G(X/sub 1/,..., X/sub n/), if for both G and 7minus;G there are QMA black box protocols that make at most T queries to the black box, then there is a classical deterministic black box protocol for G that makes 0(T/sup 6/) queries to the black box. In particular, this shows that in the black box model QMA /spl cap/ Co - QMA = P. On the positive side, we observe that any (total or partial) Boolean function G(X/sub 1/,..., X/sub n/) has a QMA black box protocol with proofs of length N that makes only 0(/spl radic/N) queries to the black box. Finally, we observe a very simple proof for the exponential separation (for promise problems) between QMA black box complexity and (classical) MA black box complexity (first obtained by Watrous).

IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (CCC)•Nov 12, 2004•21 citations

Exponential separation of quantum and classical communication complexity

Ran Raz

Communication complexity has become a central completity model.In that model, we count the amount of communication bits needed between two parties in order to solve certain computational problems.We show that for certain communication complezity problems quantum communication protocols are exponentially faster than classical ores.More explicitly, we give an example for a communication complexity relation (0~ promise problem) P such that: 1) The quantum communication complexity of P is O(log m). 2) The classical probabilistic communication complexity of P is Q(m'l'/ logm).(where m is the length of the inputs).This gives an ezponential gap between quantum communication complexity and classical probabilistic communication complexity.Only a quadratic gap was previously known.Our problem P is of geometrical nature, and is a finite precision variation of the following problem: Player I gets as input a unit vector z E R" and two orthogonal subspaces MO, MI c R". Player II gets as input an orthogonal matrixT : R" + R".Their goal is to answer 0 if T(x) E MO and 1 if T(x) E M,, (and any an~luer in any other case).We give an almost tight analysis for the quantum communication complexity and for the classical-probabilistic communication complexity of this problem.

ACM Symposium on Theory of Computing (STOC)•May 1, 1999•242 citations

On Arthur Merlin Games in Communication Complexity

Hartmut Klauck

We show several results related to interactive proof modes of communication complexity. First we show lower bounds for the QMA-communication complexity of the functions Inner Product and Disjointness. We describe a general method to prove lower bounds for QMA-communication complexity, and show how one can 'transfer' hardness under an analogous measure in the query complexity model to the communication model using Sherstov's pattern matrix method. Combining a result by Vereshchagin and the pattern matrix method we find a communication problem with AM-communication complexity $O(\log n)$, PP-communication complexity $Ω(n^{1/3})$, and QMA-communication complexity $Ω(n^{1/6})$. Hence in the world of communication complexity noninteractive quantum proof systems are not able to efficiently simulate co-nondeterminism or interaction. These results imply that the related questions in Turing machine complexity theory cannot be resolved by 'algebrizing' techniques. Finally we show that in MA-protocols there is an exponential gap between one-way protocols and two-way protocols (this refers to the interaction between Alice and Bob). This is in contrast to nondeterministic, AM-, and QMA-protocols, where one-way communication is essentially optimal.

arXiv:1101.0523•Jan 3, 2011•8 citations

On Arthur Merlin Games in Communication Complexity

Hartmut Klauck

We show several results related to interactive proof modes of communication complexity. First we show lower bounds for the QMA-communication complexity of the functions Inner Product and Disjointness. We describe a general method to prove lower bounds for QMA-communication complexity, and show how one can 'transfer' hardness under an analogous measure in the query complexity model to the communication model using Sherstov's pattern matrix method.Combining a result by Vereshchagin and the pattern matrix method we find a partial function with AM-communication complexity O(log n), PP-communication complexity Ω(n1/3), and QMA-communication complexity Ω(n1/6). Hence in the world of communication complexity noninteractive quantum proof systems are not able to efficiently simulate co-nondeterminism or interaction. These results imply that the related questions in Turing machine complexity theory cannot be resolved by 'algebrizing' techniques. Finally we show that in MA-protocols there is an exponential gap between one-way protocols and two-way protocols for a partial function (this refers to the interaction between Alice and Bob). This is in contrast to nondeterministic, AM-, and QMA-protocols, where one-way communication is essentially optimal.

IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (CCC)•Jun 1, 2011•40 citations

Quantum proof systems and entanglement theory

Salman Abolfathe Beikidezfuli

Quantum complexity theory is important from the point of view of not only theory of computation but also quantum information theory. In particular, quantum multi-prover interactive proof systems are defined based on complexity theory notions, while their characterization can be formulated using LOCC operations. On the other hand, the main resource in quantum information theory is entanglement, which can be considered as a monotonic decreasing quantity under LOCC maps. Indeed, any result in quantum proof systems can be translated to entanglement theory, and vice versa. In this thesis I mostly focus on quantum Merlin-Arthur games as a proof system in quantum complexity theory. I present a new complete problem for the complexity class QMA. I also show that computing both the Holevo capacity and the minimum output entropy of quantum channels are NP-hard. Then I move to the multiple-Merlin-Arthur games and show that assuming some additivity conjecture for entanglement of formation, we can amplify the gap in QMA(2) protocols. Based on the same assumption, I show that the QMA(k)-hierarchy collapses to QMA(2). I also prove that QMAlog(2), which is defined the same as QMA(2) except that the size of witnesses is logarithmic, with the gap n-(3+e) contains NP. Finally, motivated by the previous results, I show that the positive partial transpose test gives no bound on the trace distance of a given bipartite state from the set of separable states.

•Jan 1, 2009•0 citations

Quantum versus Classical Proofs and Advice

Scott Aaronson, Greg Kuperberg

This paper studies whether quantum proofs are more powerful than classical proofs, or in complexity terms, whether QMA = QCMA.We prove three results about this question.First, we give a "quantum oracle separation" between QMA and QCMA.More concretely, we show that any quantum algorithm needs Ω 2 n m+1 queries to find an n-qubit "marked state" |ψ , even if given an m-bit classical description of |ψ together with a quantum black box that recognizes |ψ .Second, we give an explicit QCMA protocol that nearly achieves this lower bound.Third, we show that, in the one previously-known case where quantum proofs seemed to provide an exponential advantage, classical proofs are basically just as powerful.In particular, Watrous gave a QMA protocol for verifying non-membership in finite groups.Under plausible group-theoretic assumptions, we give a QCMA protocol for the same problem.Even with no assumptions, our protocol makes only polynomially many queries to the group oracle.We end with some conjectures about quantum versus classical oracles, and about the possibility of a classical oracle separation between QMA and QCMA.

IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (CCC)•Jun 1, 2007•53 citations
We study the power of quantum proofs, or more precisely, the power of Quantum Merlin-Arthur (QMA) protocols, in two well studied models of quantum computation: the black box model and the communication complexity model. Our main results are obtained for the communication complexity model. For this model, we identify a complete promise problem for QMA protocols, the Linear Subspaces Distance problem. The problem is of geometrical nature: Each player gets a linear subspace of R m and considers the sphere of unit vectors in that subspace. Their goal is to output 1 if the distance between the two spheres is very small (say, smaller than 0.1 · √ 2) and 0 if the distance is very large (say, larger than 0.9 · √ 2). We show that: 1. The QMA communication complexity of the problem is O(log m). 2. The (classical) MA communication complexity of the problem is Ω(m ɛ) (for some ɛ> 0). 3. The (standard) quantum communication complexity of the problem is Ω ( √ m). In particular, this gives an exponential separation between QMA communication complexity and MA communication complexity.
We study the power of quantum proofs, or more precisely, the power of quantum Merlin-Arthur (QMA) protocols, in two well studied models of quantum computation: the black box model and the communication complexity model. Our main results are obtained for the communication complexity model. For this model, we identify a complete promise problem for QMA protocols, the linear sub-spaces distance problem. The problem is of geometrical nature: each player gets a linear subspace of R/sup m/ and considers the sphere of unit vectors in that subspace. Their goal is to output 1 if the distance between the two spheres is very small (say, smaller than 0.1 /spl middot/ /spl radic/2) and 0 if the distance is very large (say, larger than 0.9 /spl middot/ /spl radic/2). We show that: 1. The QMA communication complexity of the problem is O(logm). 2. The (classical) MA communication complexity of the problem is /spl Omega/(m/sup /spl epsi//) (for some /spl epsi/ > 0). 3. The (standard) quantum communication complexity of the problem is /spl Omega/(/spl radic/m). In particular, this gives an exponential separation between QMA communication complexity and MA communication complexity. For the black box model we give several observations. First, we observe that the block sensitivity method, as well as the polynomial method for proving lower bounds for the number of queries, can both be extended to QMA protocols. We use these methods to obtain lower bounds for the QMA black box complexity of functions. In particular, we obtain a tight lower bound of /spl Omega/(N) for the QMA black box complexity of a random function, and a tight lower bound of /spl Omega/(/spl radic/N) for the QMA black box query complexity of NOR(X/sub 1/,..., X/sub n/). In particular, this shows that any attempt to give short quantum proofs for the class of languages Co - NP have to go beyond black box arguments. We also observe that for any Boolean function G(X/sub 1/,..., X/sub n/), if for both G and 7minus;G there are QMA black box protocols that make at most T queries to the black box, then there is a classical deterministic black box protocol for G that makes 0(T/sup 6/) queries to the black box. In particular, this shows that in the black box model QMA /spl cap/ Co - QMA = P. On the positive side, we observe that any (total or partial) Boolean function G(X/sub 1/,..., X/sub n/) has a QMA black box protocol with proofs of length N that makes only 0(/spl radic/N) queries to the black box. Finally, we observe a very simple proof for the exponential separation (for promise problems) between QMA black box complexity and (classical) MA black box complexity (first obtained by Watrous).
Communication complexity has become a central completity model.In that model, we count the amount of communication bits needed between two parties in order to solve certain computational problems.We show that for certain communication complezity problems quantum communication protocols are exponentially faster than classical ores.More explicitly, we give an example for a communication complexity relation (0~ promise problem) P such that: 1) The quantum communication complexity of P is O(log m). 2) The classical probabilistic communication complexity of P is Q(m'l'/ logm).(where m is the length of the inputs).This gives an ezponential gap between quantum communication complexity and classical probabilistic communication complexity.Only a quadratic gap was previously known.Our problem P is of geometrical nature, and is a finite precision variation of the following problem: Player I gets as input a unit vector z E R" and two orthogonal subspaces MO, MI c R". Player II gets as input an orthogonal matrixT : R" + R".Their goal is to answer 0 if T(x) E MO and 1 if T(x) E M,, (and any an~luer in any other case).We give an almost tight analysis for the quantum communication complexity and for the classical-probabilistic communication complexity of this problem.
We show several results related to interactive proof modes of communication complexity. First we show lower bounds for the QMA-communication complexity of the functions Inner Product and Disjointness. We describe a general method to prove lower bounds for QMA-communication complexity, and show how one can 'transfer' hardness under an analogous measure in the query complexity model to the communication model using Sherstov's pattern matrix method. Combining a result by Vereshchagin and the pattern matrix method we find a communication problem with AM-communication complexity O(log⁡n)O(\log n)O(logn), PP-communication complexity Ω(n1/3)Ω(n^{1/3})Ω(n1/3), and QMA-communication complexity Ω(n1/6)Ω(n^{1/6})Ω(n1/6). Hence in the world of communication complexity noninteractive quantum proof systems are not able to efficiently simulate co-nondeterminism or interaction. These results imply that the related questions in Turing machine complexity theory cannot be resolved by 'algebrizing' techniques. Finally we show that in MA-protocols there is an exponential gap between one-way protocols and two-way protocols (this refers to the interaction between Alice and Bob). This is in contrast to nondeterministic, AM-, and QMA-protocols, where one-way communication is essentially optimal.
We show several results related to interactive proof modes of communication complexity. First we show lower bounds for the QMA-communication complexity of the functions Inner Product and Disjointness. We describe a general method to prove lower bounds for QMA-communication complexity, and show how one can 'transfer' hardness under an analogous measure in the query complexity model to the communication model using Sherstov's pattern matrix method.Combining a result by Vereshchagin and the pattern matrix method we find a partial function with AM-communication complexity O(log n), PP-communication complexity Ω(n1/3), and QMA-communication complexity Ω(n1/6). Hence in the world of communication complexity noninteractive quantum proof systems are not able to efficiently simulate co-nondeterminism or interaction. These results imply that the related questions in Turing machine complexity theory cannot be resolved by 'algebrizing' techniques. Finally we show that in MA-protocols there is an exponential gap between one-way protocols and two-way protocols for a partial function (this refers to the interaction between Alice and Bob). This is in contrast to nondeterministic, AM-, and QMA-protocols, where one-way communication is essentially optimal.
Quantum complexity theory is important from the point of view of not only theory of computation but also quantum information theory. In particular, quantum multi-prover interactive proof systems are defined based on complexity theory notions, while their characterization can be formulated using LOCC operations. On the other hand, the main resource in quantum information theory is entanglement, which can be considered as a monotonic decreasing quantity under LOCC maps. Indeed, any result in quantum proof systems can be translated to entanglement theory, and vice versa. In this thesis I mostly focus on quantum Merlin-Arthur games as a proof system in quantum complexity theory. I present a new complete problem for the complexity class QMA. I also show that computing both the Holevo capacity and the minimum output entropy of quantum channels are NP-hard. Then I move to the multiple-Merlin-Arthur games and show that assuming some additivity conjecture for entanglement of formation, we can amplify the gap in QMA(2) protocols. Based on the same assumption, I show that the QMA(k)-hierarchy collapses to QMA(2). I also prove that QMAlog(2), which is defined the same as QMA(2) except that the size of witnesses is logarithmic, with the gap n-(3+e) contains NP. Finally, motivated by the previous results, I show that the positive partial transpose test gives no bound on the trace distance of a given bipartite state from the set of separable states.
This paper studies whether quantum proofs are more powerful than classical proofs, or in complexity terms, whether QMA = QCMA.We prove three results about this question.First, we give a "quantum oracle separation" between QMA and QCMA.More concretely, we show that any quantum algorithm needs Ω 2 n m+1 queries to find an n-qubit "marked state" |ψ , even if given an m-bit classical description of |ψ together with a quantum black box that recognizes |ψ .Second, we give an explicit QCMA protocol that nearly achieves this lower bound.Third, we show that, in the one previously-known case where quantum proofs seemed to provide an exponential advantage, classical proofs are basically just as powerful.In particular, Watrous gave a QMA protocol for verifying non-membership in finite groups.Under plausible group-theoretic assumptions, we give a QCMA protocol for the same problem.Even with no assumptions, our protocol makes only polynomially many queries to the group oracle.We end with some conjectures about quantum versus classical oracles, and about the possibility of a classical oracle separation between QMA and QCMA.