Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Journal of Modern Physics C

NONEXISTENCE OF d-WAVE-SUPERCONDUCTIVITY IN THE QUANTUM MONTE CARLO SIMULATION OF THE HUBBARD MODEL

Hans‐Georg Matuttis, Nobuyasu Ito

Published Jun 1, 2005• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

For the existence of d-wave-superconductivity in the Hubbard model, previous quantum Monte Carlo results by other authors, which showed a power law increase of the d-wave susceptibility, seem to contradict a recently published theorem. We show those quantum Monte Carlo calculations were numerically contaminated, analyze the numerical problem and propose a numerically more stable computing scheme.

DOI
10.1142/s0129183105007571

Related papers

Quantum Monte Carlo and the Hubbard Model

Douglas J. Scalapino

Here we discuss quantum Monte Carlo and the Hubbard model. We note that while there is a fermion sign problem for the doped Hubbard model, Monte Carlo calculations have shown that the leading pairfield susceptibility has d-wave symmetry and that the pairing interaction is mediated by S = 1 particle-hole fluctuations.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Aug 14, 2014•2 citations

Quantum Monte Carlo and the Hubbard model

Douglas J. Scalapino

Here we discuss quantum Monte Carlo and the Hubbard model. We note that while there is a fermion sign problem for the doped Hubbard model, Monte Carlo calculations have shown that the leading pairfield susceptibility has d-wave symmetry and that the pairing interaction is mediated by S = 1 particle-hole fluctuations.

•Jan 1, 1994•0 citations

NUMERICAL STABILITY AND THE SIGN PROBLEM IN THE DETERMINANT QUANTUM MONTE CARLO METHOD

Eugene Loh, James E. Gubernatis, Richard T. Scalettar +3 more

A recent paper by Matuttis and Ito questions the numerical accuracy of a widely-used fermion Monte Carlo algorithm. They also claim that the increase in the d-wave pairfield susceptibility χd(T) of a doped 4×4 Hubbard model at low temperature, previously found using this algorithm, is an artifact due to numerical errors. Here, we provide tests which show that this algorithm is numerically accurate and show that the simulation of χd for a 2×2 lattice agrees with exact diagonalization results. We also provide more complete data for χd on a 4×4 lattice that is consistent with our previous results.

International Journal of Modern Physics C•Aug 1, 2005•32 citations

Enhanced pair correlation functions in the two-dimensional Hubbard model

Takashi Yanagisawa

In this study we have computed the pair correlation functions in the two-dimensional Hubbard model using a quantum Monte Carlo method. We employ a new diagonalization algorithm in the quantum Monte Carlo method which is free from the negative sign problem. We show that the d-wave pairing correlation function is indeed enhanced slightly for the positive on-site Coulomb interaction U when doping away from the half-filling. When the system size becomes large, the pair correlation function P d increases for U > 0 compared to the non-interacting case, while P d is suppressed for U > 0 when the system size is small. The enhancement ratio P d [ U ]/ P d [ U = 0] will give a criterion on the existence of superconductivity. The ratio P d [ U ]/ P d [ U = 0] increases almost linearly ∝ L when the system size L × L is increased. This increase is a good indication of the existence of a superconducting phase in the two-dimensional Hubbard model. There is, however, no enhancement of pair correlation functions in the half-filled case, which indicates the absence of superconductivity without hole doping.

arXiv:1304.1273•New Journal of Physics•Mar 11, 2013•28 citations

Pairing in the two-dimensional Hubbard model: An exact diagonalization study

H. Q. Lin, J. E. Hirsch, Douglas J. Scalapino

We have studied the pair susceptibilities for all possible pair wave functions that fit on a two-dimensional (2D) eight-site Hubbard cluster by exact diagonalization of the Hamiltonian. Band fillings corresponding to four and six electrons were studied (two or four holes in the half-filled band) for a wide range of Hubbard interaction strengths and temperatures. Our results show that all pairing susceptibilities are suppressed by the Hubbard repulsion. We have also carried out perturbation-theory calculations which show that the leading-order ${U}^{2}$ contributions to the d-wave pair susceptibility suppresses d-wave pairing over a significant temperature range. These results are consistent with recent Monte Carlo results and provide further evidence suggesting that the 2D Hubbard model does not exhibit superconductivity.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•May 1, 1988•81 citations

RENORMALISATION GROUP ANALYSIS OF THE TWO-DIMENSIONAL HUBBARD MODEL: SPIN CORRELATIONS AND D-WAVE SUPERCONDUCTIVITY

Walter Metzner

The repulsive two-dimensional Hubbard model is analysed within a functional renormalisation group (RG) approach. The flow equation for the effective interactions is evaluated on 1-loop level. The effective interactions diverge at a finite energy scale which is exponentially small for small bare interactions. To analyse the nature of the instabilities signalled by the diverging interactions, we compute the flow of the superconducting susceptibilities for various pairing symmetries and also charge and spin density susceptibilities. Depending on the choice of the model parameters (hopping amplitudes, interaction strength and band-filling) we find spin density wave instabilities or d-wave superconductivity as leading instability close to half-filling. This calculation establishes the existence of d-wave superconductivity in the Hubbard model beyond doubt.

International Journal of Modern Physics B•Nov 10, 2003•0 citations
For the existence of d-wave-superconductivity in the Hubbard model, previous quantum Monte Carlo results by other authors, which showed a power law increase of the d-wave susceptibility, seem to contradict a recently published theorem. We show those quantum Monte Carlo calculations were numerically contaminated, analyze the numerical problem and propose a numerically more stable computing scheme.
A recent paper by Matuttis and Ito questions the numerical accuracy of a widely-used fermion Monte Carlo algorithm. They also claim that the increase in the d-wave pairfield susceptibility χd(T) of a doped 4×4 Hubbard model at low temperature, previously found using this algorithm, is an artifact due to numerical errors. Here, we provide tests which show that this algorithm is numerically accurate and show that the simulation of χd for a 2×2 lattice agrees with exact diagonalization results. We also provide more complete data for χd on a 4×4 lattice that is consistent with our previous results.
In this study we have computed the pair correlation functions in the two-dimensional Hubbard model using a quantum Monte Carlo method. We employ a new diagonalization algorithm in the quantum Monte Carlo method which is free from the negative sign problem. We show that the d-wave pairing correlation function is indeed enhanced slightly for the positive on-site Coulomb interaction U when doping away from the half-filling. When the system size becomes large, the pair correlation function P d increases for U > 0 compared to the non-interacting case, while P d is suppressed for U > 0 when the system size is small. The enhancement ratio P d [ U ]/ P d [ U = 0] will give a criterion on the existence of superconductivity. The ratio P d [ U ]/ P d [ U = 0] increases almost linearly ∝ L when the system size L × L is increased. This increase is a good indication of the existence of a superconducting phase in the two-dimensional Hubbard model. There is, however, no enhancement of pair correlation functions in the half-filled case, which indicates the absence of superconductivity without hole doping.
We have studied the pair susceptibilities for all possible pair wave functions that fit on a two-dimensional (2D) eight-site Hubbard cluster by exact diagonalization of the Hamiltonian. Band fillings corresponding to four and six electrons were studied (two or four holes in the half-filled band) for a wide range of Hubbard interaction strengths and temperatures. Our results show that all pairing susceptibilities are suppressed by the Hubbard repulsion. We have also carried out perturbation-theory calculations which show that the leading-order U2{U}^{2}U2 contributions to the d-wave pair susceptibility suppresses d-wave pairing over a significant temperature range. These results are consistent with recent Monte Carlo results and provide further evidence suggesting that the 2D Hubbard model does not exhibit superconductivity.
The repulsive two-dimensional Hubbard model is analysed within a functional renormalisation group (RG) approach. The flow equation for the effective interactions is evaluated on 1-loop level. The effective interactions diverge at a finite energy scale which is exponentially small for small bare interactions. To analyse the nature of the instabilities signalled by the diverging interactions, we compute the flow of the superconducting susceptibilities for various pairing symmetries and also charge and spin density susceptibilities. Depending on the choice of the model parameters (hopping amplitudes, interaction strength and band-filling) we find spin density wave instabilities or d-wave superconductivity as leading instability close to half-filling. This calculation establishes the existence of d-wave superconductivity in the Hubbard model beyond doubt.