The DCA
+algorithm was recently introduced by Stear, Maier, and Schulthess [Phys. Rev. B 88, 115101 (2013)] to extend the dynamic cluster approximation (DCA) with a continuous lattice self-energy in order to achieve better convergence with cluster size. Here we extend the DCA
+algorithm to the calculation of two-particle correlation functions by introducing irreducible vertex functions with continuous momentum dependence consistent with the DCA
+self-energy. This enables a significantly more controlled and reliable study of phase transitions than with the DCA. We test the new method by calculating the superconducting transition temperature
Tc in the attractive Hubbard model and show that it reproduces previous determinantal quantum Monte Carlo results. We then calculate
Tc in the doped repulsive Hubbard model, for which previous DCA calculations could only access the weak-coupling (
U=4t) regime for large clusters. We show that the new algorithm provides access to much larger clusters and delivers asymptotically converged results for
Tc for both the weak (
U=4t) and intermediate (
U=7t) coupling regimes, and thereby enables the accurate determination of the exact infinite cluster size result.
We provide microscopic diagrammatic derivations of the molecular coherent potential approximation (MCA) and dynamical cluster approximation (DCA) and show that both are $\ensuremath{\Phi}$ derivable. The MCA (DCA) maps the lattice onto a self-consistently embedded cluster with open (periodic) boundary conditions, and therefore violates (preserves) the translational symmetry of the original lattice. As a consequence of the boundary conditions, the MCA (DCA) converges slowly (quickly) with corrections
O(1/Lc) [O(1/Lc2)], where
Lc is the linear size of the cluster. These analytical results are demonstrated numerically for the one-dimensional symmetric Falicov-Kimball model.
The dynamical cluster approximation (DCA) is a quantum cluster extension to the single-site dynamical mean-field theory that incorporates spatially nonlocal dynamic correlations systematically and nonperturbatively. The
DCA+ algorithm addresses the cluster shape dependence of the DCA and improves the convergence with cluster size by introducing a lattice self-energy with continuous momentum dependence. However, we show that the
DCA+ algorithm is plagued by a fundamental problem when its self-consistency equations are formulated using the bare Green's function of the cluster. This problem is most severe in the strongly correlated regime at low doping, where the
DCA+ self-energy becomes overly metallic and local, and persists to cluster sizes where the standard DCA has long converged. In view of the failure of the
DCA+ algorithm, we propose to complement DCA simulations with a post-interpolation procedure for single-particle and two-particle correlation functions to preserve continuous momentum dependence and the associated benefits in the DCA. We demonstrate the effectiveness of this practical approach with results for the half-filled and hole-doped two-dimensional Hubbard model.