Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science

Privacy and interaction in quantum communication complexity and a theorem about the relative entropy of quantum states

Rahul Jain, Jaikumar Radhakrishnan, P. Sen

Published Jun 26, 2003• 69 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We prove a fundamental theorem about the relative entropy of quantum states, which roughly states that if the relative entropy, S(/spl rho//spl par//spl sigma/)/spl Delta/=Tr /spl rho/(log /spl rho/-log /spl sigma/), of two quantum states /spl rho/ and /spl sigma/ is at most c, then /spl rho//2/sup O(c)/ 'sits inside' /spl sigma/. Using this 'substate' theorem, we give tight lower bounds for the privacy loss of bounded error quantum communication protocols for the index function problem. We also use the 'substate' theorem to give tight lower bounds for the k-round bounded error quantum communication complexity of the pointer chasing problem, when the wrong player starts, and all the log n bits of the kth pointer are desired.

DOI
10.1109/sfcs.2002.1181967

Related papers

A property of quantum relative entropy with an application to privacy in quantum communication

Rahul Jain, Jaikumar Radhakrishnan, Pranab Sen

We prove the following information-theoretic property about quantum states. Substate theorem: Let ρ and σ be quantum states in the same Hilbert space with relative entropy S (ρ ‖ σ) ≔ Tr ρ (log ρ - log σ) = c . Then for all ϵ > 0, there is a state ρ′ such that the trace distance ‖ρ′ - ρ‖ tr : Tr √(ρ′ - ρ) 2 ≤ ϵ, and ρ′/2 O ( c /ϵ 2 ) ≤ σ. It states that if the relative entropy of ρ and σ is small, then there is a state ρ′ close to ρ, i.e. with small trace distance ‖ρ′ - ρ‖ tr , that when scaled down by a factor 2 O ( c ) ‘sits inside’, or becomes a ‘substate’ of, σ. This result has several applications in quantum communication complexity and cryptography. Using the substate theorem, we derive a privacy trade-off for the set membership problem in the two-party quantum communication model. Here Alice is given a subset A ⊆ [ n ], Bob an input i ∈ [ n ], and they need to determine if i ∈ A . Privacy trade-off for set membership: In any two-party quantum communication protocol for the set membership problem, if Bob reveals only k bits of information about his input, then Alice must reveal at least n /2 O( k ) bits of information about her input. We also discuss relationships between various information theoretic quantities that arise naturally in the context of the substate theorem.

arXiv:0705.2437•Journal of the ACM•Sep 1, 2009•56 citations

Direct Sum Theorem for Bounded Round Quantum Communication Complexity

Dave Touchette

We prove a direct sum theorem for bounded round entanglement-assisted quantum communication complexity. To do so, we use the fully quantum definition for information cost and complexity that we recently introduced, and use both the fact that information is a lower bound on the communication, and the fact that a direct sum property holds for quantum information complexity. We then give a protocol for compressing a single copy of a protocol down to its quantum information cost, up to terms depending on the number of rounds and the allowed increase in error. Two important tools to derive this protocol are a smooth conditional min-entropy bound for a one-shot quantum state redistribution protocol, and the quantum substate theorem of Jain, Radhakrishnan and Sen (FOCS'02) to transform this bound into a von Neumann conditional entropy bound. This result further establishes the newly introduced notions of quantum information cost and complexity as the correct quantum generalisations of the classical ones in the standard communication complexity setting. Finding such a quantum generalization of information complexity was one of the open problem recently raised by Braverman (STOC'12).

arXiv:1409.4391•Sep 15, 2014•7 citations

Short Proofs of the Quantum Substate Theorem

Rahul Jain, Ashwin Nayak

The Quantum Substate Theorem due to Jain (2002) gives us a powerful operational interpretation of relative entropy, in fact, of the observational divergence of two quantum states, a quantity that is related to their relative entropy. Informally, the theorem states that if the observational divergence between two quantum states ρ, σ is small, then there is a quantum state ρ'close to ρ in trace distance, such that ρ'when scaled down by a small factor becomes a substate of σ. We present new proofs of this theorem. The resulting statement is optimal up to a constant factor in its dependence on observational divergence. In addition, the proofs are both conceptually simpler and significantly shorter than the earlier proof.

arXiv:1103.6067•IEEE Transactions on Information Theory•Jan 17, 2012•24 citations

On rounds in quantum communication

Hartmut Klauck

We investigate the power of interaction in two player quantum communication protocols. Our main result is a rounds-communication hierarchy for the pointer jumping function $f_k$. We show that $f_k$ needs quantum communication $Ω(n)$ if Bob starts the communication and the number of rounds is limited to $k$ (for any constant $k$). Trivially, if Alice starts, $O(k\log n)$ communication in $k$ rounds suffices. The lower bound employs a result relating the relative von Neumann entropy between density matrices to their trace distance and uses a new measure of information. We also describe a classical probabilistic $k$ round protocol with communication $O(n/k\cdot(\log^{(k/2)}n+\log k)+k\log n)$ in which Bob starts the communication. Furthermore as a consequence of the lower bound for pointer jumping we show that any $k$ round quantum protocol for the disjointness problem needs communication $Ω(n^{1/k})$ for $k=O(1)$.

arXiv:quant-ph/0004100•Apr 26, 2000•5 citations

Lower bounds for quantum communication complexity

Hartmut Klauck

We prove new lower bounds for bounded error quantum communication complexity. Our methods are based on the Fourier transform of the considered functions. First we generalize a method for proving classical communication complexity lower bounds developed by R. Raz (1995) to the quantum case. Applying this method we give an exponential separation between bounded error quantum communication complexity and nondeterministic quantum communication complexity. We develop several other Fourier based lower bound methods, notably showing that /spl radic/(s~(f)/log n) n, for the average sensitivity s~(f) of a function f, yields a lower bound on the bounded error quantum communication complexity of f (x/spl and/y/spl oplus/yz), where x is a Boolean word held by Alice and y, z are Boolean words held by Bob. We then prove the first large lower bounds on the bounded error quantum communication complexity of functions, for which a polynomial quantum speedup is possible. For all the functions we investigate, only the previously applied general lower bound method based on discrepancy yields bounds that are O(log n).

Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science•Jan 1, 2001•40 citations

Prior Entanglement, Message Compression and Privacy in Quantum Communication

Rahul Jain, Jaikumar Radhakrishnan, Pranab Sen

Consider a two-party quantum communication protocol for computing some function f : {0, 1}/sup n/ /spl times/ {0, 1}/sup n/ /spl rarr/ Z. We show that the first message of P can be compressed to 0(k) classical bits using prior entanglement if it carries at most k bits of information about the sender's input. This implies a general direct sum result for one-round and simultaneous quantum protocols. It also implies a new round elimination lemma in quantum communication, which allows us to extend recent classical lower bounds on the cell probe complexity of some data structure problems, e.g. approximate nearest neighbor searching on the Hamming cube {0, 1}/sup n/, to the quantum setting. We then show an optimal tradeoff between the privacy losses of Alice and Bob in computing f in terms of the one-round quantum communication complexity of f with prior entanglement. This tradeoff is independent of the number of rounds of communication. The above message compression and privacy tradeoff results use a lot of qubits of prior entanglement, leading one to wonder how much prior entanglement is really required by a quantum protocol. We show that Newman's [1991] technique of reducing the number of public coins in a classical protocol cannot be lifted to the quantum setting. We do this by defining a general notion of black-box reduction of prior entanglement that subsumes Newman's technique. Intuitively, a black-box reduction does not change the unitary transforms of Alice and Bob; it only decreases the amount of entanglement of the prior entangled state. We prove that such a black-box reduction is impossible for quantum protocols by exhibiting a particular one-round quantum protocol for the equality function where the black-box technique fails to reduce the amount of prior entanglement by more than a constant factor.

IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (CCC)•Jun 28, 2005•61 citations
We prove a fundamental theorem about the relative entropy of quantum states, which roughly states that if the relative entropy, S(/spl rho//spl par//spl sigma/)/spl Delta/=Tr /spl rho/(log /spl rho/-log /spl sigma/), of two quantum states /spl rho/ and /spl sigma/ is at most c, then /spl rho//2/sup O(c)/ 'sits inside' /spl sigma/. Using this 'substate' theorem, we give tight lower bounds for the privacy loss of bounded error quantum communication protocols for the index function problem. We also use the 'substate' theorem to give tight lower bounds for the k-round bounded error quantum communication complexity of the pointer chasing problem, when the wrong player starts, and all the log n bits of the kth pointer are desired.
We prove the following information-theoretic property about quantum states. Substate theorem: Let ρ and σ be quantum states in the same Hilbert space with relative entropy S (ρ ‖ σ) ≔ Tr ρ (log ρ - log σ) = c . Then for all ϵ > 0, there is a state ρ′ such that the trace distance ‖ρ′ - ρ‖ tr : Tr √(ρ′ - ρ) 2 ≤ ϵ, and ρ′/2 O ( c /ϵ 2 ) ≤ σ. It states that if the relative entropy of ρ and σ is small, then there is a state ρ′ close to ρ, i.e. with small trace distance ‖ρ′ - ρ‖ tr , that when scaled down by a factor 2 O ( c ) ‘sits inside’, or becomes a ‘substate’ of, σ. This result has several applications in quantum communication complexity and cryptography. Using the substate theorem, we derive a privacy trade-off for the set membership problem in the two-party quantum communication model. Here Alice is given a subset A ⊆ [ n ], Bob an input i ∈ [ n ], and they need to determine if i ∈ A . Privacy trade-off for set membership: In any two-party quantum communication protocol for the set membership problem, if Bob reveals only k bits of information about his input, then Alice must reveal at least n /2 O( k ) bits of information about her input. We also discuss relationships between various information theoretic quantities that arise naturally in the context of the substate theorem.
We prove a direct sum theorem for bounded round entanglement-assisted quantum communication complexity. To do so, we use the fully quantum definition for information cost and complexity that we recently introduced, and use both the fact that information is a lower bound on the communication, and the fact that a direct sum property holds for quantum information complexity. We then give a protocol for compressing a single copy of a protocol down to its quantum information cost, up to terms depending on the number of rounds and the allowed increase in error. Two important tools to derive this protocol are a smooth conditional min-entropy bound for a one-shot quantum state redistribution protocol, and the quantum substate theorem of Jain, Radhakrishnan and Sen (FOCS'02) to transform this bound into a von Neumann conditional entropy bound. This result further establishes the newly introduced notions of quantum information cost and complexity as the correct quantum generalisations of the classical ones in the standard communication complexity setting. Finding such a quantum generalization of information complexity was one of the open problem recently raised by Braverman (STOC'12).
The Quantum Substate Theorem due to Jain (2002) gives us a powerful operational interpretation of relative entropy, in fact, of the observational divergence of two quantum states, a quantity that is related to their relative entropy. Informally, the theorem states that if the observational divergence between two quantum states ρ, σ is small, then there is a quantum state ρ'close to ρ in trace distance, such that ρ'when scaled down by a small factor becomes a substate of σ. We present new proofs of this theorem. The resulting statement is optimal up to a constant factor in its dependence on observational divergence. In addition, the proofs are both conceptually simpler and significantly shorter than the earlier proof.
We investigate the power of interaction in two player quantum communication protocols. Our main result is a rounds-communication hierarchy for the pointer jumping function fkf_kfk​. We show that fkf_kfk​ needs quantum communication Ω(n)Ω(n)Ω(n) if Bob starts the communication and the number of rounds is limited to kkk (for any constant kkk). Trivially, if Alice starts, O(klog⁡n)O(k\log n)O(klogn) communication in kkk rounds suffices. The lower bound employs a result relating the relative von Neumann entropy between density matrices to their trace distance and uses a new measure of information. We also describe a classical probabilistic kkk round protocol with communication O(n/k⋅(log⁡(k/2)n+log⁡k)+klog⁡n)O(n/k\cdot(\log^{(k/2)}n+\log k)+k\log n)O(n/k⋅(log(k/2)n+logk)+klogn) in which Bob starts the communication. Furthermore as a consequence of the lower bound for pointer jumping we show that any kkk round quantum protocol for the disjointness problem needs communication Ω(n1/k)Ω(n^{1/k})Ω(n1/k) for k=O(1)k=O(1)k=O(1).
We prove new lower bounds for bounded error quantum communication complexity. Our methods are based on the Fourier transform of the considered functions. First we generalize a method for proving classical communication complexity lower bounds developed by R. Raz (1995) to the quantum case. Applying this method we give an exponential separation between bounded error quantum communication complexity and nondeterministic quantum communication complexity. We develop several other Fourier based lower bound methods, notably showing that /spl radic/(s~(f)/log n) n, for the average sensitivity s~(f) of a function f, yields a lower bound on the bounded error quantum communication complexity of f (x/spl and/y/spl oplus/yz), where x is a Boolean word held by Alice and y, z are Boolean words held by Bob. We then prove the first large lower bounds on the bounded error quantum communication complexity of functions, for which a polynomial quantum speedup is possible. For all the functions we investigate, only the previously applied general lower bound method based on discrepancy yields bounds that are O(log n).
Consider a two-party quantum communication protocol for computing some function f : {0, 1}/sup n/ /spl times/ {0, 1}/sup n/ /spl rarr/ Z. We show that the first message of P can be compressed to 0(k) classical bits using prior entanglement if it carries at most k bits of information about the sender's input. This implies a general direct sum result for one-round and simultaneous quantum protocols. It also implies a new round elimination lemma in quantum communication, which allows us to extend recent classical lower bounds on the cell probe complexity of some data structure problems, e.g. approximate nearest neighbor searching on the Hamming cube {0, 1}/sup n/, to the quantum setting. We then show an optimal tradeoff between the privacy losses of Alice and Bob in computing f in terms of the one-round quantum communication complexity of f with prior entanglement. This tradeoff is independent of the number of rounds of communication. The above message compression and privacy tradeoff results use a lot of qubits of prior entanglement, leading one to wonder how much prior entanglement is really required by a quantum protocol. We show that Newman's [1991] technique of reducing the number of public coins in a classical protocol cannot be lifted to the quantum setting. We do this by defining a general notion of black-box reduction of prior entanglement that subsumes Newman's technique. Intuitively, a black-box reduction does not change the unitary transforms of Alice and Bob; it only decreases the amount of entanglement of the prior entangled state. We prove that such a black-box reduction is impossible for quantum protocols by exhibiting a particular one-round quantum protocol for the equality function where the black-box technique fails to reduce the amount of prior entanglement by more than a constant factor.