Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Conference on Quantum, Nano and Micro Technologies (ICQNM)

All Languages in NP Have Very Short Quantum Proofs

Hugue Blier, Alain Tapp

Published Feb 1, 2009• 50 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this paper, we show that all languages in NP have logarithmic-size quantum proofs which can be verified provided that two unentangled copies are given. More formally, we introduce the complexity class QMAlog(2) and show that 3COL E QMAlog(2). To obtain this strong and surprising result we have to relax the usual requirements: the completeness is one but the soundness is 1-1/poly. Since the natural classical equivalent of QMAlog(2) is uninteresting (it would be equal to P), this result, like many others, stresses the fact that quantum information is fundamentally different from classical information. It also contributes to our understanding of entanglement since QMAlog = BQP[7].

DOI
10.1109/icqnm.2009.21

Related papers

All languages in NP have very short quantum proofs

Hugue Blier, Alain Tapp

In this note we show that all languages in NP have very short (logarithmic size) quantum proofs which can be verified provided that two unentangled copies are given. We thus introduce a new complexity class QMAlog(2) and show that NP ⊆ QMAlog(2). This gives a new perspective when compared to the previously known result QMAlog = BQP. 1

•Sep 5, 2007•10 citations

NP vs QMA_\log(2)

Salman Beigi

Although it is believed unlikely that $\NP$-hard problems admit efficient quantum algorithms, it has been shown that a quantum verifier can solve NP-complete problems given a "short" quantum proof; more precisely, NP\subseteq QMA_{\log}(2) where QMA_{\log}(2) denotes the class of quantum Merlin-Arthur games in which there are two unentangled provers who send two logarithmic size quantum witnesses to the verifier. The inclusion NP\subseteq QMA_{\log}(2) has been proved by Blier and Tapp by stating a quantum Merlin-Arthur protocol for 3-coloring with perfect completeness and gap 1/24n^6. Moreover, Aaronson et al. have shown the above inclusion with a constant gap by considering $\widetilde{O}(\sqrt{n})$ witnesses of logarithmic size. However, we still do not know if QMA_{\log}(2) with a constant gap contains NP. In this paper, we show that 3-SAT admits a QMA_{\log}(2) protocol with the gap 1/n^{3+\epsilon}} for every constant \epsilon>0.

arXiv:0810.5109•Quantum Information and Computation•Jan 1, 2010•36 citations

Quantum proof systems and entanglement theory

Salman Abolfathe Beikidezfuli

Quantum complexity theory is important from the point of view of not only theory of computation but also quantum information theory. In particular, quantum multi-prover interactive proof systems are defined based on complexity theory notions, while their characterization can be formulated using LOCC operations. On the other hand, the main resource in quantum information theory is entanglement, which can be considered as a monotonic decreasing quantity under LOCC maps. Indeed, any result in quantum proof systems can be translated to entanglement theory, and vice versa. In this thesis I mostly focus on quantum Merlin-Arthur games as a proof system in quantum complexity theory. I present a new complete problem for the complexity class QMA. I also show that computing both the Holevo capacity and the minimum output entropy of quantum channels are NP-hard. Then I move to the multiple-Merlin-Arthur games and show that assuming some additivity conjecture for entanglement of formation, we can amplify the gap in QMA(2) protocols. Based on the same assumption, I show that the QMA(k)-hierarchy collapses to QMA(2). I also prove that QMAlog(2), which is defined the same as QMA(2) except that the size of witnesses is logarithmic, with the gap n-(3+e) contains NP. Finally, motivated by the previous results, I show that the positive partial transpose test gives no bound on the trace distance of a given bipartite state from the set of separable states.

•Jan 1, 2009•0 citations

The Power of Unentanglement

Scott Aaronson, Salman Beigi, Andrew Drucker +2 more

The class $\mathsf{QMA}( k) $, introduced by Kobayashi et al., consists of all languages that can be verified using $k$ unentangled quantum proofs. Many of the simplest questions about this class have remained embarrassingly open: for example, can we give any evidence that $k$ quantum proofs are more powerful than one? Does $\mathsf{QMA}( k) =\mathsf{QMA}( 2) $ for $k\geq2$? Can $\mathsf{QMA}( k) $ protocols be amplified to exponentially small error? In this paper, we make progress on all of the above questions. We give a protocol by which a verifier can be convinced that a 3SAT formula of size $m$ is satisfiable, with constant soundness, given $\widetilde{O}(\sqrt{m}) $ unentangled quantum witnesses with $O( \log m) $ qubits each. Our protocol relies on the existence of very short PCPs. We show that assuming a weak version of the Additivity Conjecture from quantum information theory, any $\mathsf{QMA}( 2) $ protocol can be amplified to exponentially small error, and $\mathsf{QMA}( k) =\mathsf{QMA}( 2) $ for all $k\geq2$. We prove the nonexistence of “perfect disentanglers” for simulating multiple Merlins with one.

arXiv:0804.0802•Theory of Computing•Jan 1, 2009•70 citations

Quantum Information and the PCP Theorem

Ran Raz

Our main result is that the membership x ∈ SAT (for x of length n) can be proved by a logarithmic-size quantum state |Ψ〉, together with a polynomial-size classical proof consisting of blocks of length polylog(n) bits each, such that after measuring the state |Ψ 〉 the verifier only needs to read one block of the classical proof. This shows that if a short quantum witness is available then a (classical) PCP with only one query is possible. Our second result is that the class QIP/qpoly contains all languages. That is, for any language L (even non-recursive), the membership x ∈ L (for x of length n) can be proved by a polynomial-size quantum interactive proof, where the verifier is a polynomial-size quantum circuit with working space initiated with some quantum state |ΨL,n 〉 (depending only on L and n). Moreover, the interactive proof that we give is of only one round, and the messages communicated are classical. The advice |ΨL,n 〉 given to the verifier can also be replaced by a classical probabilistic advice, as long as this advice is kept as a secret from the prover. Our result can hence be interpreted as: the class IP/rpoly contains all languages. For the proof of the second result, we introduce the quantum low-degree-extension of a string of bits. The main result requires an additional machinery of quantum lowdegree-test.

•Apr 10, 2005•0 citations

Quantum Arthur-Merlin games

Chris Marriott, John Watrous

This paper studies quantum Arthur-Merlin games, which are a restricted form of quantum interactive proof system in which the verifier's messages are given by unbiased coin-flips. The following results are proved. For one-message quantum Arthur-Merlin games, which correspond to the complexity class QMA, completeness and soundness errors can be reduced exponentially without increasing the length of Merlin's message. Previous constructions for reducing error required a polynomial increase in the length of Merlin's message. Applications of this fact include a proof that logarithmic length quantum certificates yield no increase in power over BQP and a simple proof that QMA /spl sube/ PP. In the case of three or more messages, quantum Arthur-Merlin games are equivalent in power to ordinary quantum interactive proof systems. In fact, for any language having a quantum interactive proof system there exists a three-message quantum Arthur-Merlin game in which Arthur's only message consists of just a single coin-flip that achieves perfect completeness and soundness error exponentially close to 1/2. Any language having a two-message quantum Arthur-Merlin game is contained in BP /spl middot/ PP. This gives some suggestion that three messages are stronger than two in the quantum Arthur-Merlin setting.

IEEE Conference on Computational Complexity (CCC)•Nov 12, 2004•32 citations
In this paper, we show that all languages in NP have logarithmic-size quantum proofs which can be verified provided that two unentangled copies are given. More formally, we introduce the complexity class QMAlog(2) and show that 3COL E QMAlog(2). To obtain this strong and surprising result we have to relax the usual requirements: the completeness is one but the soundness is 1-1/poly. Since the natural classical equivalent of QMAlog(2) is uninteresting (it would be equal to P), this result, like many others, stresses the fact that quantum information is fundamentally different from classical information. It also contributes to our understanding of entanglement since QMAlog = BQP[7].
Although it is believed unlikely that $\NP$-hard problems admit efficient quantum algorithms, it has been shown that a quantum verifier can solve NP-complete problems given a "short" quantum proof; more precisely, NP\subseteq QMA_{\log}(2) where QMA_{\log}(2) denotes the class of quantum Merlin-Arthur games in which there are two unentangled provers who send two logarithmic size quantum witnesses to the verifier. The inclusion NP\subseteq QMA_{\log}(2) has been proved by Blier and Tapp by stating a quantum Merlin-Arthur protocol for 3-coloring with perfect completeness and gap 1/24n^6. Moreover, Aaronson et al. have shown the above inclusion with a constant gap by considering O~(n)\widetilde{O}(\sqrt{n})O(n​) witnesses of logarithmic size. However, we still do not know if QMA_{\log}(2) with a constant gap contains NP. In this paper, we show that 3-SAT admits a QMA_{\log}(2) protocol with the gap 1/n^{3+\epsilon}} for every constant \epsilon>0.
Quantum complexity theory is important from the point of view of not only theory of computation but also quantum information theory. In particular, quantum multi-prover interactive proof systems are defined based on complexity theory notions, while their characterization can be formulated using LOCC operations. On the other hand, the main resource in quantum information theory is entanglement, which can be considered as a monotonic decreasing quantity under LOCC maps. Indeed, any result in quantum proof systems can be translated to entanglement theory, and vice versa. In this thesis I mostly focus on quantum Merlin-Arthur games as a proof system in quantum complexity theory. I present a new complete problem for the complexity class QMA. I also show that computing both the Holevo capacity and the minimum output entropy of quantum channels are NP-hard. Then I move to the multiple-Merlin-Arthur games and show that assuming some additivity conjecture for entanglement of formation, we can amplify the gap in QMA(2) protocols. Based on the same assumption, I show that the QMA(k)-hierarchy collapses to QMA(2). I also prove that QMAlog(2), which is defined the same as QMA(2) except that the size of witnesses is logarithmic, with the gap n-(3+e) contains NP. Finally, motivated by the previous results, I show that the positive partial transpose test gives no bound on the trace distance of a given bipartite state from the set of separable states.
The class $\mathsf{QMA}( k) $, introduced by Kobayashi et al., consists of all languages that can be verified using kkk unentangled quantum proofs. Many of the simplest questions about this class have remained embarrassingly open: for example, can we give any evidence that kkk quantum proofs are more powerful than one? Does $\mathsf{QMA}( k) =\mathsf{QMA}( 2) $ for k≥2k\geq2k≥2? Can $\mathsf{QMA}( k) $ protocols be amplified to exponentially small error? In this paper, we make progress on all of the above questions. We give a protocol by which a verifier can be convinced that a 3SAT formula of size mmm is satisfiable, with constant soundness, given $\widetilde{O}(\sqrt{m}) $ unentangled quantum witnesses with $O( \log m) $ qubits each. Our protocol relies on the existence of very short PCPs. We show that assuming a weak version of the Additivity Conjecture from quantum information theory, any $\mathsf{QMA}( 2) $ protocol can be amplified to exponentially small error, and $\mathsf{QMA}( k) =\mathsf{QMA}( 2) $ for all k≥2k\geq2k≥2. We prove the nonexistence of “perfect disentanglers” for simulating multiple Merlins with one.
Our main result is that the membership x ∈ SAT (for x of length n) can be proved by a logarithmic-size quantum state |Ψ〉, together with a polynomial-size classical proof consisting of blocks of length polylog(n) bits each, such that after measuring the state |Ψ 〉 the verifier only needs to read one block of the classical proof. This shows that if a short quantum witness is available then a (classical) PCP with only one query is possible. Our second result is that the class QIP/qpoly contains all languages. That is, for any language L (even non-recursive), the membership x ∈ L (for x of length n) can be proved by a polynomial-size quantum interactive proof, where the verifier is a polynomial-size quantum circuit with working space initiated with some quantum state |ΨL,n 〉 (depending only on L and n). Moreover, the interactive proof that we give is of only one round, and the messages communicated are classical. The advice |ΨL,n 〉 given to the verifier can also be replaced by a classical probabilistic advice, as long as this advice is kept as a secret from the prover. Our result can hence be interpreted as: the class IP/rpoly contains all languages. For the proof of the second result, we introduce the quantum low-degree-extension of a string of bits. The main result requires an additional machinery of quantum lowdegree-test.
This paper studies quantum Arthur-Merlin games, which are a restricted form of quantum interactive proof system in which the verifier's messages are given by unbiased coin-flips. The following results are proved. For one-message quantum Arthur-Merlin games, which correspond to the complexity class QMA, completeness and soundness errors can be reduced exponentially without increasing the length of Merlin's message. Previous constructions for reducing error required a polynomial increase in the length of Merlin's message. Applications of this fact include a proof that logarithmic length quantum certificates yield no increase in power over BQP and a simple proof that QMA /spl sube/ PP. In the case of three or more messages, quantum Arthur-Merlin games are equivalent in power to ordinary quantum interactive proof systems. In fact, for any language having a quantum interactive proof system there exists a three-message quantum Arthur-Merlin game in which Arthur's only message consists of just a single coin-flip that achieves perfect completeness and soundness error exponentially close to 1/2. Any language having a two-message quantum Arthur-Merlin game is contained in BP /spl middot/ PP. This gives some suggestion that three messages are stronger than two in the quantum Arthur-Merlin setting.