Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Mind and Matter

Does Consciousness Collapse the Wave Packet

Dick J. Bierman

Published Jan 1, 2003• 28 citations
OpenAlex

Abstract

The “subjective reduction” interpretation of measurement in quantum physics proposes that the collapse of the wave-packet, associated with measurement, is due to the consciousness of human observers. A refined conceptual replication of an earlier experiment, designed and carried out to test this interpretation in the 1970s, is reported. Two improvements are introduced. First, the delay between pre-observation and final observation of the same quantum event is increased from a few microseconds in the original experiment to one second in this replication. Second, rather than using the final observers’ verbal response as the dependent variable, his early brain responses as measured by EEG are used. These early responses cover a period during which an observer is not yet conscious of an observed event. Our results support the “subjective reduction” hypothesis insofar as significant differences in the brain responses of the final observer are found, depending on whether or not the pre-observer has been looking at the quantum event (exact binomial p < 0.02). Alternative “normal” explanations are discussed and rejected. It is concluded that the present results do justify further research along these lines.

Related papers

Does Consciousness Collapse the Wave Function

Dick J. Bierman

A conceptual replication of the Hall-experiment to test the 'subjective reduction' interpretation of the measurement problem in Quantum Physics is reported. Two improvements are introduced. First the delay between pre-observation and final observation of the same quantum event is increased from a few microseconds in the original experiment to 1 second in this replication. Second, rather than using the observers conscious response as the dependent variable, we use the early brain responses as measured by EEG. These early responses cover a period where the observer is not yet conscious of the quantum event. Results support the 'subjective reduction' hypothesis because significant differences between the brain responses of the final observer are found dependent upon the pre-observer looking or not looking at the quantum event (exact binomial p < 0.02). Alternative 'normal' explanations are discussed and rejected. It is concluded that the present results do justify further research along these lines.

arXiv:physics/0312115•Dec 18, 2003•3 citations

Empirical Research on the Radical Subjective Solution of the Measurement Problem. Does Time get its Direction through Conscious Observation?

Dick J. Bierman

In a number of experimental studies we explored the so‐called ‘radical subjective’, and rather controversial, solution of the measurement problem. This solution posits that an interaction with a conscious entity is required to complete the measurement. Thus the collapse of the wave packet is assumed to be causally linked to a conscious observation. Under the assumption that the brain is sensitive for the difference between observing a quantum (superposition) state and a classical state this radical solution can be tested. A radioactive source was used to trigger beeps that first were delayed for 1 second and then were observed by a (final) observer from whom a continuous recording of brain activity was made. In about 50% of the events, another (pre) observer got feedback of this quantum event before the final observer. In those cases, presumably the pre‐observer’s observation resulted in collapse of the wave‐packet while in the other half of the cases the final observer was ‘producing’ the collapse. The brain signals of the final observer for the two types of events were compared. The ambiguous results of the studies will be discussed. If consciousness is the crucial ingredient for ‘collapse’ to occur, then this might also give a new anthropocentric hypothesis with regard to the ‘arrow of time’. The projection postulate implies a irreversible process of reduction and hence can be seen as one of the few non time‐symmetric processes in physics. If consciousness is required to have a collapse then it might follow that consciousness introduces time asymmetry into physics. New neuro‐cognitive models of consciousness suggest that the neural correlate of conscious experience (rather than non conscious processing) is the occurrence of massive parallel recurrent (i.e. non linear) neural activation. Thus the collapse of the wave packet would become associated with a strong non‐linear process. This fits, at least in a metaphorical sense, with the theoretical results where an introduction on a non linear term in the Schr̈odinger equation results in an ‘objective’ reduction of the wave packet.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2006•19 citations

The Case Against Objective Measurement

Richard A. Mould

We consider two straightforward rules that govern the stochastic choice in a single quantum mechanical event. They are shown to lead to absurd results if an objective state reduction is allowed to compete with an observer state reduction. Since the latter collapse is empirically verifiable, the existence of the former is thrown into question. Key Words: Born Interpretation, brain states, continuous observation, conscious observer, objective measurement, observer measurement, probability current, state reduction, wave collapse.

arXiv:quant-ph/0309048•Sep 4, 2003•2 citations

Role of Conscious Attention and Prior Knowledge in Quantum Measurement Collapse

Akshaya Ganji

Background: Quantum mechanics describes the behavior of matter and light at the atomic and subatomic levels.In quantum mechanics, a key principle is that quantum objects can exhibit both wave-like and particle-like behavior.This is called "wave-particle duality" (Squires, 1999).Moreover, quantum mechanics presents us with a mixture of possibilities, where the particles exist in a state of superposition until an observation occurs.When we measure, the wave function collapses into a single outcome.To address this, it's imperative to understand what exactly constitutes an observation in quantum mechanics and its role in wave function collapse.Objectives: This study explores the concept of measurement from both a physical and philosophical perspective, examining different interpretations of consciousness and how observation influences the outcomes of quantum experiments.More specifically, it focuses on how mental states, such as expectation or previous knowledge could impact wave function collapse.Complementing the existing body of research, this review expands to explore several critical questions surrounding the nature of observation in quantum mechanics. Methods:The study conducted a literature review to establish the theoretical background and relevance.Forty-five participants (ages 13+) were randomly assigned to one of three groups: Expectation/Attention, Neutral Observation, or Automated Control.Each group observed 100 random binary outcomes generated using Random.org,with the Expectation group instructed to mentally focus on increasing the number of 1s.The experiment was conducted using PsychoPy, with all outcomes and timing automatically logged.A statistical analysis using ANOVA and post-hoc tests revealed significant group differences, particularly between the Neutral group and the others.Results: Expected Group (primed with prior knowledge) yielded the highest median (63), suggesting expectation may amplify observed values.The Neutral Group (baseline awareness) recorded the lowest results (median=57).The Control Group (standard observation) occupied an intermediate range.Neutral < Control < Expected in median values.The expected group shows 2× the IQR of Control/Neutral, indicating higher variability.No outliers detected in any group using the 1.5×IQR rule.These patterns tentatively support the proposed link between conscious states (e.g., expectation/knowledge) and quantum phenomena.To validate the differences across the control, expected, and neutral groups, a one-way ANOVA test was taken, which revealed a statistically significant difference in the counts of ones between the groups (p = 0.000014).Post-hoc analysis using Tukey's HSD indicated that the neutral group significantly differed from both the control and expected groups, while the control and expected groups did not significantly differ from each other.Additionally, the effect size (η² = 0.64), indicates a large and meaningful difference between the groups.Conclusions: This study provides preliminary evidence that conscious mental states, particularly expectation, may measurably influence quantum measurement outcomes.The observed positional trends and increased variability in the Expected group suggest that the observer's mindset is not merely a passive condition but may actively modulate the measurement process.While the findings align with and expand upon previous research linking consciousness to quantum phenomena, they also introduce new considerations regarding variability and individual cognitive influence.Nonetheless, this work offers a meaningful step toward understanding the complex relationship between consciousness and the physical world and underscores the need for continued interdisciplinary research to further explore this potential connection.

•Jul 24, 2025•0 citations

Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: The Measurement Problem, Entanglement, and the Case Against Consciousness as a Physical Mechanism

Ralph C DeMartino

The measurement problem — the question of why quantum superpositions appear to collapse to definite outcomes upon measurement — remains one of the most consequential unresolved questions in the foundations of physics. Despite the extraordinary empirical success of quantum mechanics, the field has for decades operated under an unofficial norm of interpretive silence, a posture Sean Carroll and others have identified as both intellectually dishonest and scientifically costly. This paper argues that the experimental evidence, properly understood through the framework of quantum entanglement and decoherence, provides strong grounds for rejecting the hypothesis that consciousness plays a causal role in wavefunction collapse. Three tiers of experimental evidence are examined: the double slit experiment with which-path detection, Bell inequality tests confirming non-local entanglement, and the LIGO gravitational wave detections demonstrating macroscopic quantum coherence at cosmological scales without any role for conscious observation. The paper concludes that the consciousness hypothesis is not supported by experimental physics and that Carroll's call for serious investment in foundational research is scientifically justified and philosophically urgent.

•May 9, 2026•0 citations

Consciousness as an ultra-weak quantum measurement effect in an optical diffraction experiment

Dean I. Radin

The consciousness-collapse interpretation of quantum mechanics was explored by testing if human observation might act like a weak quantum measurement effect in an optical interferometer. Forty-seven participants selected via a worldwide search for individuals with experience in focusing their attention were each provided with a custom-made optical apparatus. Using this device, they ran a preassigned series of test sessions to see if illumination recorded in a portion of the interference pattern would be affected when a feedback signal based on that measure was observed versus unobserved. Another portion of the interference pattern was recorded simultaneously but never observed to provide control data. Environmental sensors and real-time encryption of the illumination data were among the methods included in the design of the experiment to help ensure data integrity.With all data combined the results did not support three preregistered hypotheses, but for one of those hypotheses participants partitioned by those experienced in an outward vs. an inward focus of attention achieved significantly better results in reducing interference (p = 0.008). An exploratory hypothesis also found a significant difference in skewness of the distribution of interference measures recorded in observed vs. unobserved periods (p = 0.004). In addition, an exploratory analysis showed a clear trend – a progressive decline in interference – while participants observed a portion of the interference pattern, as compared to data recorded simultaneously from an unobserved portion (p = 5.9 × 10-14). By comparison, applying the same analysis during no-observation periods found no differences in trends (p = 0.77). Control data run with no observers present and subjected again to this same trend analysis showed uniformly nonsignificant results. Alternative explanations, including possible environmental influences that might have caused these outcomes, as well as recommendations for future studies, are discussed.

•Oct 8, 2024•0 citations
The “subjective reduction” interpretation of measurement in quantum physics proposes that the collapse of the wave-packet, associated with measurement, is due to the consciousness of human observers. A refined conceptual replication of an earlier experiment, designed and carried out to test this interpretation in the 1970s, is reported. Two improvements are introduced. First, the delay between pre-observation and final observation of the same quantum event is increased from a few microseconds in the original experiment to one second in this replication. Second, rather than using the final observers’ verbal response as the dependent variable, his early brain responses as measured by EEG are used. These early responses cover a period during which an observer is not yet conscious of an observed event. Our results support the “subjective reduction” hypothesis insofar as significant differences in the brain responses of the final observer are found, depending on whether or not the pre-observer has been looking at the quantum event (exact binomial p < 0.02). Alternative “normal” explanations are discussed and rejected. It is concluded that the present results do justify further research along these lines.
A conceptual replication of the Hall-experiment to test the 'subjective reduction' interpretation of the measurement problem in Quantum Physics is reported. Two improvements are introduced. First the delay between pre-observation and final observation of the same quantum event is increased from a few microseconds in the original experiment to 1 second in this replication. Second, rather than using the observers conscious response as the dependent variable, we use the early brain responses as measured by EEG. These early responses cover a period where the observer is not yet conscious of the quantum event. Results support the 'subjective reduction' hypothesis because significant differences between the brain responses of the final observer are found dependent upon the pre-observer looking or not looking at the quantum event (exact binomial p < 0.02). Alternative 'normal' explanations are discussed and rejected. It is concluded that the present results do justify further research along these lines.
In a number of experimental studies we explored the so‐called ‘radical subjective’, and rather controversial, solution of the measurement problem. This solution posits that an interaction with a conscious entity is required to complete the measurement. Thus the collapse of the wave packet is assumed to be causally linked to a conscious observation. Under the assumption that the brain is sensitive for the difference between observing a quantum (superposition) state and a classical state this radical solution can be tested. A radioactive source was used to trigger beeps that first were delayed for 1 second and then were observed by a (final) observer from whom a continuous recording of brain activity was made. In about 50% of the events, another (pre) observer got feedback of this quantum event before the final observer. In those cases, presumably the pre‐observer’s observation resulted in collapse of the wave‐packet while in the other half of the cases the final observer was ‘producing’ the collapse. The brain signals of the final observer for the two types of events were compared. The ambiguous results of the studies will be discussed. If consciousness is the crucial ingredient for ‘collapse’ to occur, then this might also give a new anthropocentric hypothesis with regard to the ‘arrow of time’. The projection postulate implies a irreversible process of reduction and hence can be seen as one of the few non time‐symmetric processes in physics. If consciousness is required to have a collapse then it might follow that consciousness introduces time asymmetry into physics. New neuro‐cognitive models of consciousness suggest that the neural correlate of conscious experience (rather than non conscious processing) is the occurrence of massive parallel recurrent (i.e. non linear) neural activation. Thus the collapse of the wave packet would become associated with a strong non‐linear process. This fits, at least in a metaphorical sense, with the theoretical results where an introduction on a non linear term in the Schr̈odinger equation results in an ‘objective’ reduction of the wave packet.
We consider two straightforward rules that govern the stochastic choice in a single quantum mechanical event. They are shown to lead to absurd results if an objective state reduction is allowed to compete with an observer state reduction. Since the latter collapse is empirically verifiable, the existence of the former is thrown into question. Key Words: Born Interpretation, brain states, continuous observation, conscious observer, objective measurement, observer measurement, probability current, state reduction, wave collapse.
Background: Quantum mechanics describes the behavior of matter and light at the atomic and subatomic levels.In quantum mechanics, a key principle is that quantum objects can exhibit both wave-like and particle-like behavior.This is called "wave-particle duality" (Squires, 1999).Moreover, quantum mechanics presents us with a mixture of possibilities, where the particles exist in a state of superposition until an observation occurs.When we measure, the wave function collapses into a single outcome.To address this, it's imperative to understand what exactly constitutes an observation in quantum mechanics and its role in wave function collapse.Objectives: This study explores the concept of measurement from both a physical and philosophical perspective, examining different interpretations of consciousness and how observation influences the outcomes of quantum experiments.More specifically, it focuses on how mental states, such as expectation or previous knowledge could impact wave function collapse.Complementing the existing body of research, this review expands to explore several critical questions surrounding the nature of observation in quantum mechanics. Methods:The study conducted a literature review to establish the theoretical background and relevance.Forty-five participants (ages 13+) were randomly assigned to one of three groups: Expectation/Attention, Neutral Observation, or Automated Control.Each group observed 100 random binary outcomes generated using Random.org,with the Expectation group instructed to mentally focus on increasing the number of 1s.The experiment was conducted using PsychoPy, with all outcomes and timing automatically logged.A statistical analysis using ANOVA and post-hoc tests revealed significant group differences, particularly between the Neutral group and the others.Results: Expected Group (primed with prior knowledge) yielded the highest median (63), suggesting expectation may amplify observed values.The Neutral Group (baseline awareness) recorded the lowest results (median=57).The Control Group (standard observation) occupied an intermediate range.Neutral < Control < Expected in median values.The expected group shows 2× the IQR of Control/Neutral, indicating higher variability.No outliers detected in any group using the 1.5×IQR rule.These patterns tentatively support the proposed link between conscious states (e.g., expectation/knowledge) and quantum phenomena.To validate the differences across the control, expected, and neutral groups, a one-way ANOVA test was taken, which revealed a statistically significant difference in the counts of ones between the groups (p = 0.000014).Post-hoc analysis using Tukey's HSD indicated that the neutral group significantly differed from both the control and expected groups, while the control and expected groups did not significantly differ from each other.Additionally, the effect size (η² = 0.64), indicates a large and meaningful difference between the groups.Conclusions: This study provides preliminary evidence that conscious mental states, particularly expectation, may measurably influence quantum measurement outcomes.The observed positional trends and increased variability in the Expected group suggest that the observer's mindset is not merely a passive condition but may actively modulate the measurement process.While the findings align with and expand upon previous research linking consciousness to quantum phenomena, they also introduce new considerations regarding variability and individual cognitive influence.Nonetheless, this work offers a meaningful step toward understanding the complex relationship between consciousness and the physical world and underscores the need for continued interdisciplinary research to further explore this potential connection.
The measurement problem — the question of why quantum superpositions appear to collapse to definite outcomes upon measurement — remains one of the most consequential unresolved questions in the foundations of physics. Despite the extraordinary empirical success of quantum mechanics, the field has for decades operated under an unofficial norm of interpretive silence, a posture Sean Carroll and others have identified as both intellectually dishonest and scientifically costly. This paper argues that the experimental evidence, properly understood through the framework of quantum entanglement and decoherence, provides strong grounds for rejecting the hypothesis that consciousness plays a causal role in wavefunction collapse. Three tiers of experimental evidence are examined: the double slit experiment with which-path detection, Bell inequality tests confirming non-local entanglement, and the LIGO gravitational wave detections demonstrating macroscopic quantum coherence at cosmological scales without any role for conscious observation. The paper concludes that the consciousness hypothesis is not supported by experimental physics and that Carroll's call for serious investment in foundational research is scientifically justified and philosophically urgent.
The consciousness-collapse interpretation of quantum mechanics was explored by testing if human observation might act like a weak quantum measurement effect in an optical interferometer. Forty-seven participants selected via a worldwide search for individuals with experience in focusing their attention were each provided with a custom-made optical apparatus. Using this device, they ran a preassigned series of test sessions to see if illumination recorded in a portion of the interference pattern would be affected when a feedback signal based on that measure was observed versus unobserved. Another portion of the interference pattern was recorded simultaneously but never observed to provide control data. Environmental sensors and real-time encryption of the illumination data were among the methods included in the design of the experiment to help ensure data integrity.With all data combined the results did not support three preregistered hypotheses, but for one of those hypotheses participants partitioned by those experienced in an outward vs. an inward focus of attention achieved significantly better results in reducing interference (p = 0.008). An exploratory hypothesis also found a significant difference in skewness of the distribution of interference measures recorded in observed vs. unobserved periods (p = 0.004). In addition, an exploratory analysis showed a clear trend – a progressive decline in interference – while participants observed a portion of the interference pattern, as compared to data recorded simultaneously from an unobserved portion (p = 5.9 × 10-14). By comparison, applying the same analysis during no-observation periods found no differences in trends (p = 0.77). Control data run with no observers present and subjected again to this same trend analysis showed uniformly nonsignificant results. Alternative explanations, including possible environmental influences that might have caused these outcomes, as well as recommendations for future studies, are discussed.