Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

All-forward semiclassical simulations of nonlinear response functions

Shaul Mukamel, Jeremy B. Maddox

Published Jun 16, 2004• 23 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We propose a quantum trajectory algorithm for computing nonlinear response functions of condensed phase molecular systems based on a time-ordered expansion of the density matrix. The nth-order response function is expressed as a sum of 2(n) impulsive response pathways representing trajectories involving zero, one, and up to n interactions with short external pulses. These are evaluated using a forward propagation algorithm based upon a Liouville space extension of the Bohmian propagation method.

DOI
10.1063/1.1756582

Related papers

Phase-space algorithm for simulating quantum nonlinear response functions of bosons using stochastic classical trajectories

Benoit Palmieri, Yuki Nagata, Shaul Mukamel

Using the positive P-representation of the density matrix, we develop an algorithm for calculating the quantum many-body nonlinear response functions of a system of bosons driven impulsively by external fields. The formalism maps the quantum time evolution of N boson degrees of freedom into a stochastic dynamics of 4N classical degrees of freedom. The first- and the third-order response functions are calculated by propagating the parameters of the P-representation using a set of coupled Langevin equations with multiplicative noise. These parameters serve as classical variables. Two classical ways for computing the response functions are presented. In the nonequilibrium method, an observable is calculated for weak impulsive pulses, and the response functions are obtained by taking its derivatives with respect to the pulse amplitudes. In the alternative, equilibrium simulation, the response functions are expressed in terms of time-correlation functions involving the P-representation parameters and stability matrices representing the perturbation of the trajectories. The stability matrices can be propagated simultaneously with the Langevin equations for the parameters. The formalism is generalized for a many-body boson system coupled to a harmonic bath.

Physical Review E•Oct 12, 2010•2 citations

Superoperator representation of nonlinear response: Unifying quantum field and mode coupling theories

Shaul Mukamel

Computing response functions by following the time evolution of superoperators in Liouville space (whose vectors are ordinary Hilbert space operators) offers an attractive alternative to the diagrammatic perturbative expansion of many-body equilibrium and nonequilibrium Green's functions. The bookkeeping of time ordering is naturally maintained in real (physical) time, allowing the formulation of Wick's theorem for superoperators, giving a factorization of higher order response functions in terms of two fundamental Green's functions. Backward propagations and analytic continuations using artificial times (Keldysh loops and Matsubara contours) are avoided. A generating functional for nonlinear response functions unifies quantum field theory and the classical mode coupling formalism of nonlinear hydrodynamics and may be used for semiclassical expansions. Classical response functions are obtained without the explicit computation of stability matrices.

arXiv:cond-mat/0307390•Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Aug 26, 2003•46 citations

Quasiparticle density-matrix representation of nonlinear time-dependent density-functional response functions

Oleg L. Berman, Shaul Mukamel

The time-dependent density-functional (TDDFT) equations may be written either for the Kohn-Sham orbitals in Hilbert space or for the single-electron density matrix in Liouville space. A collective-oscillator, quasiparticle, representation of the density response of many-electron systems which explicitly reveals the relevant electronic coherence sizes is developed using the Liouville-space representation of adiabatic TDDFT. Closed expressions for the nonlinear density-density response are derived, eliminating the need to solve nonlinear integral equations, as required in the Hilbert-space formulation of the response.

arXiv:cond-mat/0301131•Physical Review A•Apr 15, 2003•22 citations

Generalized time-dependent density-functional-theory response functions for spontaneous density fluctuations and nonlinear response: Resolving the causality paradox in real time

Shaul Mukamel

Time-ordered superoperators are used to develop a unified description of nonlinear density response and spontaneous fluctuations of many-electron systems. The $p\mathrm{th}$-order density response functions are decomposed into ${2}^{p+1}$ non-causal Liouville space pathways. Individual pathways are symmetric to the interchange of their space, time, and superoperator indices and can thus be calculated as functional derivatives. Other combinations of these pathways represent spontaneous density fluctuations and the response of such fluctuations to an external field. The resolution of the causality paradox of time-dependent density-functional theory (TDDFT) is shown to be intimately connected with the nonretarded nature of fluctuations.

Physical Review A•Feb 23, 2005•26 citations

A unified framework for efficient quantum simulation of nonlinear spectroscopy

Long Xiong, Xiaoyang Wang, Xiaoxia Cai +1 more

Nonlinear spectroscopy is a cornerstone of quantum science, providing unique access to multi-point correlations, quantum coherence, and couplings that are invisible to linear methods. However, classical simulation of these phenomena is fundamentally limited by the exponential growth of the Hilbert space, and practical quantum algorithms for the nonlinear regime have remained largely unexplored. Here, we present a unified quantum algorithmic framework for computing $n$-th order nonlinear spectroscopies. By reformulating multi-time responses as a weighted sum of expectation values at finite pump amplitudes via a generalized parameter shift rule, our approach bypasses the costly evaluation of high-order commutators and time-dependent operator expansions. This reformulation enables efficient execution via real-time evolution on current quantum hardware, ensuring inherent noise resilience. We validate the framework on IBM's superconducting quantum processors, successfully obtain higher-order response functions of a 12-qubit XXZ spin-chain. Furthermore, the versatility of our method is demonstrated by resolving quasi-particle excitation spectra in spin-liquids and identifying interaction-induced cross-peaks in atomic systems. Our results establish a practical and scalable pathway for probing complex quantum dynamics on near-term quantum devices, extending the reach of quantum simulation into the nonlinear domain.

quant-pharXiv:2604.16164•Apr 20, 2026•1 citation

Approximate quantum trajectory dynamics for reactive processes in condensed phase

Sophya V. Garashchuk, Jacek Jakowski, Vitaly A. Rassolov

A method of molecular dynamics with quantum corrections, practical for studies of large molecular systems, is reviewed. The approach is based on the Bohmian formulation of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation in which a wavefunction is represented by an ensemble of interdependent trajectories. The quantum effects come from the quantum potential acting on trajectories on par with the usual classical potential. The quantum potential is determined from the evolving nuclear wavefunction, i.e. from the quantum trajectory (QT) ensemble itself. For practical and conceptual reasons the quantum potential and corresponding quantum nuclear effect are computed only for the selected light nuclei. For studies of reactive chemical processes, the classical potential is computed on-the-fly using the density functional tight binding method of electronic structure. A massively parallel implementation, based on the message passing interface allows for efficient simulations of ensembles of thousands of trajectories describing systems of up to 200 atoms. As a biochemical application, the approximate QT approach is used to model the tunnelling-dominated proton transfer in soybean-lipoxygenase-1. A materials science application is represented by a study of the nuclear quantum effect on adsorption of hydrogen and deuterium on a C37H15 molecule, which is a model ‘flake’ of graphene.

Molecular Simulation•Apr 24, 2014•10 citations
We propose a quantum trajectory algorithm for computing nonlinear response functions of condensed phase molecular systems based on a time-ordered expansion of the density matrix. The nth-order response function is expressed as a sum of 2(n) impulsive response pathways representing trajectories involving zero, one, and up to n interactions with short external pulses. These are evaluated using a forward propagation algorithm based upon a Liouville space extension of the Bohmian propagation method.
Using the positive P-representation of the density matrix, we develop an algorithm for calculating the quantum many-body nonlinear response functions of a system of bosons driven impulsively by external fields. The formalism maps the quantum time evolution of N boson degrees of freedom into a stochastic dynamics of 4N classical degrees of freedom. The first- and the third-order response functions are calculated by propagating the parameters of the P-representation using a set of coupled Langevin equations with multiplicative noise. These parameters serve as classical variables. Two classical ways for computing the response functions are presented. In the nonequilibrium method, an observable is calculated for weak impulsive pulses, and the response functions are obtained by taking its derivatives with respect to the pulse amplitudes. In the alternative, equilibrium simulation, the response functions are expressed in terms of time-correlation functions involving the P-representation parameters and stability matrices representing the perturbation of the trajectories. The stability matrices can be propagated simultaneously with the Langevin equations for the parameters. The formalism is generalized for a many-body boson system coupled to a harmonic bath.
Computing response functions by following the time evolution of superoperators in Liouville space (whose vectors are ordinary Hilbert space operators) offers an attractive alternative to the diagrammatic perturbative expansion of many-body equilibrium and nonequilibrium Green's functions. The bookkeeping of time ordering is naturally maintained in real (physical) time, allowing the formulation of Wick's theorem for superoperators, giving a factorization of higher order response functions in terms of two fundamental Green's functions. Backward propagations and analytic continuations using artificial times (Keldysh loops and Matsubara contours) are avoided. A generating functional for nonlinear response functions unifies quantum field theory and the classical mode coupling formalism of nonlinear hydrodynamics and may be used for semiclassical expansions. Classical response functions are obtained without the explicit computation of stability matrices.
The time-dependent density-functional (TDDFT) equations may be written either for the Kohn-Sham orbitals in Hilbert space or for the single-electron density matrix in Liouville space. A collective-oscillator, quasiparticle, representation of the density response of many-electron systems which explicitly reveals the relevant electronic coherence sizes is developed using the Liouville-space representation of adiabatic TDDFT. Closed expressions for the nonlinear density-density response are derived, eliminating the need to solve nonlinear integral equations, as required in the Hilbert-space formulation of the response.
Time-ordered superoperators are used to develop a unified description of nonlinear density response and spontaneous fluctuations of many-electron systems. The pthp\mathrm{th}pth-order density response functions are decomposed into 2p+1{2}^{p+1}2p+1 non-causal Liouville space pathways. Individual pathways are symmetric to the interchange of their space, time, and superoperator indices and can thus be calculated as functional derivatives. Other combinations of these pathways represent spontaneous density fluctuations and the response of such fluctuations to an external field. The resolution of the causality paradox of time-dependent density-functional theory (TDDFT) is shown to be intimately connected with the nonretarded nature of fluctuations.
Nonlinear spectroscopy is a cornerstone of quantum science, providing unique access to multi-point correlations, quantum coherence, and couplings that are invisible to linear methods. However, classical simulation of these phenomena is fundamentally limited by the exponential growth of the Hilbert space, and practical quantum algorithms for the nonlinear regime have remained largely unexplored. Here, we present a unified quantum algorithmic framework for computing nnn-th order nonlinear spectroscopies. By reformulating multi-time responses as a weighted sum of expectation values at finite pump amplitudes via a generalized parameter shift rule, our approach bypasses the costly evaluation of high-order commutators and time-dependent operator expansions. This reformulation enables efficient execution via real-time evolution on current quantum hardware, ensuring inherent noise resilience. We validate the framework on IBM's superconducting quantum processors, successfully obtain higher-order response functions of a 12-qubit XXZ spin-chain. Furthermore, the versatility of our method is demonstrated by resolving quasi-particle excitation spectra in spin-liquids and identifying interaction-induced cross-peaks in atomic systems. Our results establish a practical and scalable pathway for probing complex quantum dynamics on near-term quantum devices, extending the reach of quantum simulation into the nonlinear domain.
A method of molecular dynamics with quantum corrections, practical for studies of large molecular systems, is reviewed. The approach is based on the Bohmian formulation of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation in which a wavefunction is represented by an ensemble of interdependent trajectories. The quantum effects come from the quantum potential acting on trajectories on par with the usual classical potential. The quantum potential is determined from the evolving nuclear wavefunction, i.e. from the quantum trajectory (QT) ensemble itself. For practical and conceptual reasons the quantum potential and corresponding quantum nuclear effect are computed only for the selected light nuclei. For studies of reactive chemical processes, the classical potential is computed on-the-fly using the density functional tight binding method of electronic structure. A massively parallel implementation, based on the message passing interface allows for efficient simulations of ensembles of thousands of trajectories describing systems of up to 200 atoms. As a biochemical application, the approximate QT approach is used to model the tunnelling-dominated proton transfer in soybean-lipoxygenase-1. A materials science application is represented by a study of the nuclear quantum effect on adsorption of hydrogen and deuterium on a C37H15 molecule, which is a model ‘flake’ of graphene.