Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Generalization of Quantum Mechanics

T. E. Phipps

Published Jun 15, 1960• 16 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The possibility of generalizing quantum mechanics in such a way as to retain its predictive results, while comprehending additional solutions, is examined. It is found that this can be done through a perfected formal correspondence with Hamilton-Jacobi mechanics, by which one is led to consider generalizations of the Heisenberg postulate of the form ${p}_{k}{q}_{j}\ensuremath{-}{q}_{j}{p}_{k}=S{\ensuremath{\delta}}_{\mathrm{jk}}$, where $S$ is a quantum analog of Hamilton's principal function. The formalism is shown to be equivalent to a simple change in Hamiltonian, with transformed momentum operators satisfying conventional commutation relations, and with an additional relationship involving formal analogs of the classical "initial constants" adjoined. A particular choice of $S(=\frac{\ensuremath{\hbar}}{i})$ leads to a theory identical with wave mechanics a part from a constant (unobservable) phase factor on the wave function. The fact that $S$ may possess other, nonconstant values, demonstrated by a specific example, suggests the ability of the mechanical equations to describe a broader class of physical states than has hitherto been investigated.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.118.1653

Related papers

On a Generalization in Quantum Theory: Is ℏ\hbarℏ Constant?

Ronald J. Adler, David Santiago

We here consider a generalization of the Klein-Gordon scalar wave equation which involves a single arbitrary function. The quantization may be viewed as allowing $\hbar$ to be a function of the momentum or wave vector rather than a constant. The generalized theory is most easily viewed in the wave vector space analog of the Lagrangian. We need no reference to spacetime. In the generalized theory the de Broglie relation between wave vector and momentum is generalized, as are the canonical commutation relations and the uncertainty principle. The generalized uncertainty principle obtained is the same as has been derived from string theory, or by a general consideration of gravitational effects during the quantum measurement process. The propagator of the scalar field is also generalized, and an illustrative example is given in which it factors into the usual propagator times a "propagator form factor."

arXiv:hep-th/9908073•Aug 9, 1999•12 citations

Effects of transformed Hamiltonians on Hamilton-Jacobi theory in view of a stronger connection to wave mechanics

Michele Marrocco

Hamilton-Jacobi theory is a fundamental subject of classical mechanics and has also an important role in the development of quantum mechanics. Its conceptual framework results from the advantages of transformation theory and, for this reason, relates to the features of the generating function of canonical transformations connecting a specific Hamiltonian H to a new Hamiltonian K chosen to simplify Hamilton's equations of motion. Usually, the choice is between K=0 and a cyclic K depending on the new conjugate momenta only. Here, we investigate more general representations of the new Hamiltonian. Furthermore, it is pointed out that the two common alternatives of K=0 and a cyclic K should be distinguished in more detail. An attempt is made to clearly discern the two regimes for the harmonic oscillator and, not surprisingly, some correspondences to the quantum harmonic oscillator appear. Thanks to this preparatory work, generalized coordinates and momenta associated with the Hamilton's principal function S (i.e., K=0) are used to determine dependences in the Hamilton's characteristic function W (i.e., cyclic K). The procedure leads to the Schrodinger's equation where the Hamilton's characteristic function plays the role of the Schrodinger's wave function, whereas the first integral invariant of Poincare' takes the place of the reduced Planck constant. This finding advances the pedagogical value of the Hamilton-Jacobi theory in view of an introduction to Schrodinger's wave mechanics without the tools of quantum mechanics.

arXiv:1910.12120•Oct 26, 2019•0 citations

On a generalization of quantum mechanics of biquaternions

E. Conte

A generalization of the quantum mechanical formalism by biquaternions is proposed. By a direct example, it is evidenced that such a generalization explains in an algebraic manner the {open_quotes}wave packet reduction{close_quotes} of quantum mechanics. 8 refs.

•Jun 1, 1993•0 citations

Foundations of Quantum Mechanics: Generalizations of the Mathematical Axiomatic Derivation of the Schrödinger Equation

Olavo Leopoldino da Silva Filho

An axiomatic approach to quantum mechanics that has, as a theorem, the Schrödinger equation may be of enormous value to cope with interpretation issues, since all the interpretation constructs must be present in the axioms, or directly derived by them from their mathematical unfolding. Thus, it is critical to show that this axiomatic derivation is reliable beyond any possible doubt. To show this, it is possible to make generalizations and extensions of the axioms to derive the Schrödinger equation in the underlying generalized or extended formats. In previous papers, we have shown that the axiomatic approach we propose can be used to derive the Schrödinger equation as a direct axiom. Since then, we have also shown that it was possible to generalize that derivation to coordinate systems other than the Cartesian, as well as its relativistic extensions that lead to the relativistic wave equations. An extension to dissipative systems was also performed, allowing us to mathematically derive the Caldirola–Kanai equation from first principles. All these derivations were performed using pure states and in the absence of the electromagnetic field. This means that we can further generalize the approach to embrace these two possibilities. Being an axiomatic approach, we show that we need only to slightly modify the axioms to derive the Schrödinger equation for these two contexts. Despite being quite direct, the algebraic complexity of these derivations should give the reader the desired confidence in the proposed axioms.

Mathematics•Jun 3, 2026•0 citations

Path Concepts in Hamilton-Jacobi Theory

Rolf W. Landauer

It is pointed out that the classical analog to a wave function is not a single orbit but a set of paths as defined by the solution of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation. A review is given of Hamilton-Jacobi theory in language appropriate to these path concepts. It is shown that there is a classical analog to a wave packet. Quantum-mechanically, constants of motion are not arbitrary but must be characteristic values of commuting operators. It is shown by examples that the possible classical states are similarly restricted. The conditions are discussed under which a classical set of paths is derivable from the solution of a Hamilton-Jacobi equation.

American Journal of Physics•Sep 1, 1952•7 citations

GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF QUANTUM MECHANICS

Steven Weinberg

We have seen in the previous chapter how useful wave mechanics can be in solving physical problems. But wave mechanics has several limitations. It describes physical states by means of wave functions, which are functions of the positions of the particles of the system, but why should we single out position as the fundamental physical observable? For instance, we might want to describe states in terms of probability amplitudes for particles to have certain values of the momentum or energy rather than the position. A more fundamental limitation: There are attributes of physical systems that cannot be described at all in terms of the positions and momenta of a set of particles. One of these attributes is spin, which will be the subject of Chapter 4. Another is the value of the electric or magnetic field at some point in space, treated in Chapter 11. This chapter will describe the principles of quantum mechanics in a formalism which is essentially the “transformation theory” of Dirac, mentioned briefly in Section 1.4. This formalism generalizes both the wave mechanics of Schrödinger and the matrix mechanics of Heisenberg, and is sufficiently comprehensive to apply to any sort of physical system.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 22, 2012•56 citations
The possibility of generalizing quantum mechanics in such a way as to retain its predictive results, while comprehending additional solutions, is examined. It is found that this can be done through a perfected formal correspondence with Hamilton-Jacobi mechanics, by which one is led to consider generalizations of the Heisenberg postulate of the form pkqj\ensuremath−qjpk=S\ensuremathδjk{p}_{k}{q}_{j}\ensuremath{-}{q}_{j}{p}_{k}=S{\ensuremath{\delta}}_{\mathrm{jk}}pk​qj​\ensuremath−qj​pk​=S\ensuremathδjk​, where SSS is a quantum analog of Hamilton's principal function. The formalism is shown to be equivalent to a simple change in Hamiltonian, with transformed momentum operators satisfying conventional commutation relations, and with an additional relationship involving formal analogs of the classical "initial constants" adjoined. A particular choice of S(=\ensuremathℏi)S(=\frac{\ensuremath{\hbar}}{i})S(=i\ensuremathℏ​) leads to a theory identical with wave mechanics a part from a constant (unobservable) phase factor on the wave function. The fact that SSS may possess other, nonconstant values, demonstrated by a specific example, suggests the ability of the mechanical equations to describe a broader class of physical states than has hitherto been investigated.
We here consider a generalization of the Klein-Gordon scalar wave equation which involves a single arbitrary function. The quantization may be viewed as allowing ℏ\hbarℏ to be a function of the momentum or wave vector rather than a constant. The generalized theory is most easily viewed in the wave vector space analog of the Lagrangian. We need no reference to spacetime. In the generalized theory the de Broglie relation between wave vector and momentum is generalized, as are the canonical commutation relations and the uncertainty principle. The generalized uncertainty principle obtained is the same as has been derived from string theory, or by a general consideration of gravitational effects during the quantum measurement process. The propagator of the scalar field is also generalized, and an illustrative example is given in which it factors into the usual propagator times a "propagator form factor."
Hamilton-Jacobi theory is a fundamental subject of classical mechanics and has also an important role in the development of quantum mechanics. Its conceptual framework results from the advantages of transformation theory and, for this reason, relates to the features of the generating function of canonical transformations connecting a specific Hamiltonian H to a new Hamiltonian K chosen to simplify Hamilton's equations of motion. Usually, the choice is between K=0 and a cyclic K depending on the new conjugate momenta only. Here, we investigate more general representations of the new Hamiltonian. Furthermore, it is pointed out that the two common alternatives of K=0 and a cyclic K should be distinguished in more detail. An attempt is made to clearly discern the two regimes for the harmonic oscillator and, not surprisingly, some correspondences to the quantum harmonic oscillator appear. Thanks to this preparatory work, generalized coordinates and momenta associated with the Hamilton's principal function S (i.e., K=0) are used to determine dependences in the Hamilton's characteristic function W (i.e., cyclic K). The procedure leads to the Schrodinger's equation where the Hamilton's characteristic function plays the role of the Schrodinger's wave function, whereas the first integral invariant of Poincare' takes the place of the reduced Planck constant. This finding advances the pedagogical value of the Hamilton-Jacobi theory in view of an introduction to Schrodinger's wave mechanics without the tools of quantum mechanics.
An axiomatic approach to quantum mechanics that has, as a theorem, the Schrödinger equation may be of enormous value to cope with interpretation issues, since all the interpretation constructs must be present in the axioms, or directly derived by them from their mathematical unfolding. Thus, it is critical to show that this axiomatic derivation is reliable beyond any possible doubt. To show this, it is possible to make generalizations and extensions of the axioms to derive the Schrödinger equation in the underlying generalized or extended formats. In previous papers, we have shown that the axiomatic approach we propose can be used to derive the Schrödinger equation as a direct axiom. Since then, we have also shown that it was possible to generalize that derivation to coordinate systems other than the Cartesian, as well as its relativistic extensions that lead to the relativistic wave equations. An extension to dissipative systems was also performed, allowing us to mathematically derive the Caldirola–Kanai equation from first principles. All these derivations were performed using pure states and in the absence of the electromagnetic field. This means that we can further generalize the approach to embrace these two possibilities. Being an axiomatic approach, we show that we need only to slightly modify the axioms to derive the Schrödinger equation for these two contexts. Despite being quite direct, the algebraic complexity of these derivations should give the reader the desired confidence in the proposed axioms.
It is pointed out that the classical analog to a wave function is not a single orbit but a set of paths as defined by the solution of the Hamilton-Jacobi equation. A review is given of Hamilton-Jacobi theory in language appropriate to these path concepts. It is shown that there is a classical analog to a wave packet. Quantum-mechanically, constants of motion are not arbitrary but must be characteristic values of commuting operators. It is shown by examples that the possible classical states are similarly restricted. The conditions are discussed under which a classical set of paths is derivable from the solution of a Hamilton-Jacobi equation.
We have seen in the previous chapter how useful wave mechanics can be in solving physical problems. But wave mechanics has several limitations. It describes physical states by means of wave functions, which are functions of the positions of the particles of the system, but why should we single out position as the fundamental physical observable? For instance, we might want to describe states in terms of probability amplitudes for particles to have certain values of the momentum or energy rather than the position. A more fundamental limitation: There are attributes of physical systems that cannot be described at all in terms of the positions and momenta of a set of particles. One of these attributes is spin, which will be the subject of Chapter 4. Another is the value of the electric or magnetic field at some point in space, treated in Chapter 11. This chapter will describe the principles of quantum mechanics in a formalism which is essentially the “transformation theory” of Dirac, mentioned briefly in Section 1.4. This formalism generalizes both the wave mechanics of Schrödinger and the matrix mechanics of Heisenberg, and is sufficiently comprehensive to apply to any sort of physical system.