Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society

The Bose-Einstein statistics of particles, with special reference to the case of low temperatures

R. Dingle

Published Apr 1, 1949• 17 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In this paper, it has been shown that the usual demonstrations of the phenomenon of Bose-Einstein condensation are invalid. Exact formal solutions have been derived for the partition functions and the mean occupation numbers in classical and Bose statistics, and the theory of fluctuations in the case of Bose statistics has been given. In a second paper, convenient approximations will be derived for the mean occupation numbers in Bose statistics, and it will be shown that for temperatures well above the critical temperature of the supposed Bose-Einstein condensation the well-known result for the mean occupation numbers is valid, whilst for temperatures rather lower than this critical value it will be shown that particles will condense into the lowest available state. The critical temperatureT0is given by where the summation is over all energy levels except the lowest.

DOI
10.1017/s030500410002483x

Related papers

Bose–Einstein Statistics

Robert H. Swendsen

The properties of the ideal Bose gas are calculated from the integral equations for the energy and the number of particles as a function of the temperature and chemical potential. It is shown that the integral equations break down below the Einstein temperature that corresponds to the transition to the low-temperature state. The lowest single-particle energy level must be treated explicitly to get the proper equations. With the inclusion of the lowest single-particle energy level, the low-temperature behavior is calculated. The occupation of the lowest level becomes comparable to the total number of particles in the system below the Einstein temperature, and equal to the total number of particles at zero temperature. A numerical solution to the properties of the Bose gas is discussed, and the detailed calculations are assigned to the problems at the end of the chapter.

Oxford University Press eBooks•Dec 10, 2019•1 citation

Bose–Einstein Condensation

Tim Byrnes, Ebubechukwu O. Ilo-Okeke

This chapter introduces the basic physics of Bose--Einstein condensation. We first start with why there is a difference between distinguishable and indistinguishable particles in terms of the number of states that are available in a composite system. Then Bose and Einstein's argument of why one expects a high probability of occupation of the ground state is discussed. This is derived then more rigorously for the grand canonical ensemble, showing that at some critical temperature there should be a macroscopic occupation of the ground state. Next, the low-lying energy spectrum of an interacting Bose--Einstein condensate is derived, leading to the Bogoliubov dispersion. The significance of the Bogoliubov dispersion as the origin of superfluidity is then discussed, in terms of superfluditysuperfluidity. Laudau'sLandau's criterion for superfluidity is derived, by general principles of Galilean transformations of Schrodinger's equation.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Jul 23, 2021•1 citation

Condensate Statistics in One-Dimensional Interacting Bose Gases: Exact Results

Iacopo Carusotto, Yvan Castin

Recently, a quantum Monte Carlo method alternative to the path integral Monte Carlo method was developed for solving the N-boson problem; it is based on the stochastic evolution of classical fields. Here we apply it to obtain exact results for the occupation statistics of the condensate mode in a weakly interacting trapped one-dimensional Bose gas. The temperature is varied across the critical region down to temperatures lower than the trap level spacing. We also derive the condensate statistics in the Bogoliubov theory: this reproduces the exact results at low temperature and explains the suppression of odd numbers of noncondensed particles at T approximately 0.

arXiv:cond-mat/0206211•Physical Review Letters•Jan 22, 2003•35 citations

On the Bose-Einstein condensation

S.R. DE GROOT, G.J. Hooyman, Cornelis A. Ten Seldam

Abstract The Bose-Einstein condensation of a gas is investigated. Starting from the well-known formulae for Bose statistics, the problem has been generalized to include a variety of potential fields in which the particles of the gas move, and the number w of dimensions has not been restricted to three. The energy levels are taken to be εi≡εs1,....,s10=constanth2ms1α−1a12+...+swαaw2(1≤α≤2) the quantum numbers being s1 ,w= 1, 2, ..., and a1, ..., aw being certain characteristic lengths. (For α = 2, the potential field is that of the w-dimensional rectangular box; for α = 1, we obtain the w-dimensional harmonic oscillator field.) A direct rigorous method is used similar to that proposed by Fowler & Jones (1938). It is shown that the number q = w/α determines the appearance of an Einstein transition temperature T0·For q≤ 1 there is no such point, while for q > 1 a transition point exists. For 1 < q≤ 2, the mean energy ϵ- per particle and the specific heat dϵ-/dT are continuous at T = T0· For q > 2, the specific heat is discontinuous at T = T0, giving rise to a A λ-point. A well-defined transition point only appears for a very large (theoretically infinite) number N of particles. T0 is finite only if the quantity v = N/(a1 .... aw)2/ α¯is finite. For a rectangular box, v is equal to the mean density of the gas. If v tends to zero or infinity as N→ ∞, then T0 likewise tends to zero or infinity. In the case q > 1, and at temperatures T < T 0' there is a finite fraction N0 /N of the particles, given by N 0/N = 1-(T/T0)q, in the lowest state. London’s formula (1938 b) for the three-dimensional box is an example of this equation. Some further results are also compared with those given by London’s continuous spectrum approximation.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical Sciences•Sep 22, 1950•137 citations

XV. The condensation of a perfect Bose-Einstein gas.—II

A. R. Fraser

In an earlier paper formulae were given for the macroscopic behaviour of a perfect Bose-Einstein gas. In this paper formulae are given for the mean occupation numbers of the energy levels and for the fluctuations in these numbers. These formulae are in agreement with those obtained by earlier (invalid) methods.

The London Edinburgh and Dublin Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science•Feb 1, 1951•19 citations

Bose-Einstein statistics for a finite number of particles

Pedro Pessoa

This paper presents a study of the grand canonical Bose-Einstein (BE) statistics for a finite number of particles in an arbitrary quantum system. The thermodynamical quantities that identify BE condensation---namely, the fraction of particles in the ground state and the specific heat---are calculated here exactly in terms of temperature and fugacity. These calculations are complemented by a numerical calculation of fugacity in terms of the number of particles, without taking the thermodynamic limit. The main advantage of this approach is that it does not rely on approximations made in the vicinity of the usually defined critical temperature, rather it makes calculations with arbitrary precision possible, irrespective of temperature. Graphs for the calculated thermodynamical quantities are presented in comparison to the results previously obtained in the thermodynamic limit. In particular, it is observed that for the gas trapped in a three-dimensional box, the derivative of specific heat reaches smaller values than what was expected in the thermodynamic limit---here, this result is also verified with analytical calculations. This is an important result for understanding the role of the thermodynamic limit in phase transitions and makes possible to further study BE statistics without relying neither on the thermodynamic limit nor on approximations near critical temperature.

arXiv:2110.02890•Physical Review A•Oct 25, 2021•5 citations
In this paper, it has been shown that the usual demonstrations of the phenomenon of Bose-Einstein condensation are invalid. Exact formal solutions have been derived for the partition functions and the mean occupation numbers in classical and Bose statistics, and the theory of fluctuations in the case of Bose statistics has been given. In a second paper, convenient approximations will be derived for the mean occupation numbers in Bose statistics, and it will be shown that for temperatures well above the critical temperature of the supposed Bose-Einstein condensation the well-known result for the mean occupation numbers is valid, whilst for temperatures rather lower than this critical value it will be shown that particles will condense into the lowest available state. The critical temperatureT0is given by where the summation is over all energy levels except the lowest.
The properties of the ideal Bose gas are calculated from the integral equations for the energy and the number of particles as a function of the temperature and chemical potential. It is shown that the integral equations break down below the Einstein temperature that corresponds to the transition to the low-temperature state. The lowest single-particle energy level must be treated explicitly to get the proper equations. With the inclusion of the lowest single-particle energy level, the low-temperature behavior is calculated. The occupation of the lowest level becomes comparable to the total number of particles in the system below the Einstein temperature, and equal to the total number of particles at zero temperature. A numerical solution to the properties of the Bose gas is discussed, and the detailed calculations are assigned to the problems at the end of the chapter.
This chapter introduces the basic physics of Bose--Einstein condensation. We first start with why there is a difference between distinguishable and indistinguishable particles in terms of the number of states that are available in a composite system. Then Bose and Einstein's argument of why one expects a high probability of occupation of the ground state is discussed. This is derived then more rigorously for the grand canonical ensemble, showing that at some critical temperature there should be a macroscopic occupation of the ground state. Next, the low-lying energy spectrum of an interacting Bose--Einstein condensate is derived, leading to the Bogoliubov dispersion. The significance of the Bogoliubov dispersion as the origin of superfluidity is then discussed, in terms of superfluditysuperfluidity. Laudau'sLandau's criterion for superfluidity is derived, by general principles of Galilean transformations of Schrodinger's equation.
Recently, a quantum Monte Carlo method alternative to the path integral Monte Carlo method was developed for solving the N-boson problem; it is based on the stochastic evolution of classical fields. Here we apply it to obtain exact results for the occupation statistics of the condensate mode in a weakly interacting trapped one-dimensional Bose gas. The temperature is varied across the critical region down to temperatures lower than the trap level spacing. We also derive the condensate statistics in the Bogoliubov theory: this reproduces the exact results at low temperature and explains the suppression of odd numbers of noncondensed particles at T approximately 0.
Abstract The Bose-Einstein condensation of a gas is investigated. Starting from the well-known formulae for Bose statistics, the problem has been generalized to include a variety of potential fields in which the particles of the gas move, and the number w of dimensions has not been restricted to three. The energy levels are taken to be εi≡εs1,....,s10=constanth2ms1α−1a12+...+swαaw2(1≤α≤2) the quantum numbers being s1 ,w= 1, 2, ..., and a1, ..., aw being certain characteristic lengths. (For α = 2, the potential field is that of the w-dimensional rectangular box; for α = 1, we obtain the w-dimensional harmonic oscillator field.) A direct rigorous method is used similar to that proposed by Fowler & Jones (1938). It is shown that the number q = w/α determines the appearance of an Einstein transition temperature T0·For q≤ 1 there is no such point, while for q > 1 a transition point exists. For 1 < q≤ 2, the mean energy ϵ- per particle and the specific heat dϵ-/dT are continuous at T = T0· For q > 2, the specific heat is discontinuous at T = T0, giving rise to a A λ-point. A well-defined transition point only appears for a very large (theoretically infinite) number N of particles. T0 is finite only if the quantity v = N/(a1 .... aw)2/ α¯is finite. For a rectangular box, v is equal to the mean density of the gas. If v tends to zero or infinity as N→ ∞, then T0 likewise tends to zero or infinity. In the case q > 1, and at temperatures T < T 0' there is a finite fraction N0 /N of the particles, given by N 0/N = 1-(T/T0)q, in the lowest state. London’s formula (1938 b) for the three-dimensional box is an example of this equation. Some further results are also compared with those given by London’s continuous spectrum approximation.
This paper presents a study of the grand canonical Bose-Einstein (BE) statistics for a finite number of particles in an arbitrary quantum system. The thermodynamical quantities that identify BE condensation---namely, the fraction of particles in the ground state and the specific heat---are calculated here exactly in terms of temperature and fugacity. These calculations are complemented by a numerical calculation of fugacity in terms of the number of particles, without taking the thermodynamic limit. The main advantage of this approach is that it does not rely on approximations made in the vicinity of the usually defined critical temperature, rather it makes calculations with arbitrary precision possible, irrespective of temperature. Graphs for the calculated thermodynamical quantities are presented in comparison to the results previously obtained in the thermodynamic limit. In particular, it is observed that for the gas trapped in a three-dimensional box, the derivative of specific heat reaches smaller values than what was expected in the thermodynamic limit---here, this result is also verified with analytical calculations. This is an important result for understanding the role of the thermodynamic limit in phase transitions and makes possible to further study BE statistics without relying neither on the thermodynamic limit nor on approximations near critical temperature.