A class of receivers called conditionally nulling receivers is defined for quantum noise limited optical communications. These receivers have the ability to decide at each moment in time whether or not to coherently combine a predetermined local oscillator field with the received optical field, prior to performing an energy measurement (photodetection) on the combined field. Conditionally nulling receivers are applicable to pulse position modulation and related modulation schemes, which have the property that, at each moment in time, the transmitted signal is in one of only two states, on or off. The local oscillator field which may or may not be added by the receiver is an exact replica of the negative of the received on field; hence, the receiver can exactly null the on signal if the on signal is present and the receiver chooses to use the local field. An ideal conditionally nulling receiver achieves very nearly the same error probability (within a multiplicative factor varying froom 1 to 2.15) as the optimum quantum measurement for quantum noise limited detection of M-ary PPM signals. In contrast, other known receiving methods, such as direct, heterodyne, and homodyne detection, are exponentially suboptimum.
Optical pulse-position modulation (PPM) is one of the primary modulation formats being investigated for use in deep-space communications, as well as terrestrial fiber optical communications. We consider the problem of demodulating M-ary optical PPM waveforms, and propose a structured receiver whose mean probability of symbol error is smaller than all known receivers, and approaches the Helstrom (quantum) limit of the minimum probability of error (MPE) of discriminating between the coherent-state PPM signals. The receiver uses photodetection coupled with optimized phase-coherent optical feedback control through the PPM pulse slots and a phase-sensitive parametric amplifier. We present a general framework of optical receivers known as the ‘conditional pulse nulling receiver’, and present new results on ultimate limits and achievable regions of the trade-off space between the spectral versus photon efficiency of PPM, for the single-spatial-mode far-field pure-loss optical communication channel.
The conditions for a quantum measurement to discriminate a set of states with the minimum probability of error were specified by Yuen, Kennedy and Lax, and are often termed the YKL conditions [1]. Since light is quantum mechanical, the ultimate limit on minimum-error discrimination of an optical modulation constellation is determined by the YKL bound. Standard optical receivers (i.e., direct, homodyne or heterodyne detection)-even at their respective ideal operation limits-cannot achieve this performance. Recently, it was shown that a `sequential waveform nulling' (SWN) receiver can, not only discriminate an arbitrary M-ary coherent-state (ideal laser-light) constellation asymptotically at the YKL bound in the high-power limit, but that it achieves a factor of 4 better in the asymptotic error-probability exponent compared with heterodyne detection-the only conventional optical receiver that can in principle be employed for detecting an arbitrary phase-and-amplitude modulated constellation [2]. The SWN receiver can be built with standard optical components; i.e., beamsplitters, local-oscillator lasers, delay loops and single-photon detectors. However on the other hand, in the high power regime, heterodyne detection is known to achieve a reliable communication rate that asymptotically approaches the Holevo capacity of a lossy-noisy optical channel (the ultimate limit to the classical capacity of a quantum channel) [3]. In fact, in the high power regime, heterodyne detection was also shown recently to achieve the optimal second-order coding rate, when using the optimal (Gaussian) input distribution [4]. In this paper, we show that when restricted to the M-ary phase-shift keying (PSK) ensemble, that the SWN receiver's superiority over heterodyne detection in its asymptotic error exponent of the demodulation error probability, translates to a slightly higher capacity and a pronouncedly higher finite blocklength reliable-communication rate. We also quantify, via a numerical calculation, the dependence of the SWN receiver's capacity on the order in which the PSK constellation points are nulled. Our results suggest that for short-latency PSK-modulated optical communication in the high spectral efficiency regime-for which heterodyne detection is the conventional receiver choice-that it may be beneficial to employ the SWN receiver, despite the widely-regarded capacity optimality of heterodyne detection in this operating regime.
Optical pulse position modulation (PPM) places a laser pulse, a.k.a. a coherent state of amplitude
αof mean photon number
N=∣α∣2, in one of
Mconsecutive time slots, Ideal photon detection on each slot achieves a mean probability of error
((M−1)/1M)e−Nof distinguishing the
iMPPM codewords, since
e−Nis the probability the pulse-containing slot does not produce a click, per Poisson-shot-noise photo-detection theory. The quantum (Helstrom) limit of the minimum probability of error is lower than above, has a closed-form expression, and scales as
∼e−2Nwhen
Me−N≪1. The optimal receiver must make a quantum joint measurement on all
Mslots. Even though receiver algorithms exist that achieve the
∼e−2Nscaling in the high
Nregime, none are known that bridge the classical-quantum gap for small
N, the primary regime of interest for optical PPM. It is also not known how close to the Helstrom limit can one get using LOCC. (local operations and classical communications), i.e., a receiver that slices each of the
Mslots into
ntiny slices, makes a measurement on the first slice, and based on the measurement result picks a measurement to apply to the next slice, etc., until all the
Mnslices have been measured. In this paper, we propose an LOCC receiver for demodulating PPM that uses semiclassical coherent feedback control and photon detection, which outperforms all known PPM receivers, including one that employed squeezing, a non-classical operation. To bridge the remaining gap to the Helstrom limit, one might need truly quantum operations within a joint (non-LOCC) receiver.
Discriminating coherent states of light is an important instance of quantum state discrimination that is central to all applications of laser light. We obtain the ultimate quantum limit on the error probability exponent for discriminating among any M multimode coherent-state signals via the recently developed theory of the quantum Chernoff exponent in M-ary multi-copy state discrimination. A receiver called the Sequential Waveform Nulling (SWN) receiver is proposed for discriminating an arbitrary coherent-state ensemble using only auxiliary coherent-state fields, beam splitters, and non-number-resolving single photon detectors. An explicit error probability analysis of the SWN receiver is used to show that it achieves the quantum limit on the error probability exponent, which is shown to be a factor of four greater than the error probability exponent of an ideal heterodyne-detection receiver on the same ensemble. Apart from being of fundamental interest, these results are relevant to communication, sensing, imaging, and quantum information processing systems that use laser light.
The mathematical structure of the quantum-optimum detection operators for optical signals is derived, and approximated in a three-dimensional number-state basis for the case of weak optical signals. It is shown that mathematical rotation of the received signal-states in Hilbert-space approaches the quantum-optimum detection performance for optical signals such as On-Off Keying (OOK), BPSK (binary phase-shift keying), and binary Pulse Position Modulation (2-PPM) signaling formats originating from interplanetary or even greater interstellar distances. The approximate three-dimensional number-state model is interpreted to help identify the physical operations required to implement the quantum-optimum receiver with well-known field-preparation and signal-processing techniques for these three modulation formats. Graphs demonstrating the practical performance of receivers approximated by three-dimensional detection operators are evaluated, and compared with the theoretical limit on ideal receiver performance dictated by the laws of quantum mechanics.
In quantum communication theory, a realization of the optimum quantum receiver that minimizes the error probability is one of fundamental problems. A quantum receiver is described by detection operators. Therefore, it is very important to derive the optimum detection operators for a realization of the optimum quantum receiver. In general, it is difficult to derive the optimum detection operators, except for some simple cases. In addition, even if we could derive the optimum detection operators, it is not trivial what device corresponds to the operators. In this paper, we show a realization method of a quantum receiver which is described by a projection-valued measure (PVM) and apply the method to 3-ary phase-shift-keyed (3PSK) coherent-state signals.