Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General

Quantum indistinguishability: alternative constructions of the transported basis

Michael Berry, Jonathan M. Robbins

Published Jun 9, 2000• 29 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Our earlier arguments (Berry M V and Robbins J M 1997 Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 453 1771-90) leading to the spin-statistics relation are summarized and then revisited. Constructions are described that satisfy all our previous requirements but lead to the wrong exchange sign (one such alternative is the replacement of commutators by anticommutators in the Schwinger representation of the spins of the particles); we suggest why these might be unacceptable.

DOI
10.1088/0305-4470/33/24/101

Related papers

Quantum Indistinguishability: Spin-statistics without Relativity or Field Theory?

Michael Berry, Jonathan M. Robbins

We review the formulation of quantum mechanics for identical spinning particles with wavefunctions that are singlevalued when permuted configurations are identified. The identification requires the spins to be smoothly permuted along with position variables, so spin is represented in a position-dependent ‘transported basis’, rather than the usual fixed basis. The simplest transported basis, constructed in terms of spins represented as pairs of commuting harmonic oscillators, gives the correct connection between spin and statistics. More complicated constructions can give the wrong exchange sign. The theory is generalized to incorporate additional properties such as isospin, colour and strangeness. Some remarks about the relation between this approach and those based on relatitivity and/or field theory are given.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jul 23, 2017•0 citations

Indistinguishability for quantum particles: spin, statistics and the geometric phase

Michael Berry, Jonathan M. Robbins

The quantum mechanics of two identical particles with spin S in three dimensions is reformulated by employing not the usual fixed spin basis but a transported spin basis that exchanges the spins along with the positions. Such a basis, required to be smooth and parallel-transported, can be generated by an ‘exchange rotation’ operator resembling angular momentum. This is constructed from the four harmonic oscillators from which the two spins are made according to Schwinger’s scheme. It emerges automatically that the phase factor accompanying spin exchange with the transported basis is just the Pauli sign, that is (−1) 2 S . Singlevaluedness of the total wavefunction, involving the transported basis, then implies the correct relation between spin and statistics. The Pauli sign is a geometric phase factor of topological origin, associated with non-contractible circuits in the doubly connected (and non-orientable) configuration space of relative positions with identified antipodes. The theory extends to more than two particles.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Jul 23, 2017•7 citations

Indistinguishability for quantum particles: spin, statistics and the geometric phase

Michael Berry, Jonathan M. Robbins

The quantum mechanics of two identical particles with spin S in three dimensions is reformulated by employing not the usual fixed spin basis but a transported spin basis that exchanges the spins along with the positions. Such a basis, required to be smooth and parallel-transported, can be generated by an ‘exchange rotation’ operator resembling angular momentum. This is constructed from the four harmonic oscillators from which the two spins are made according to Schwinger's scheme. It emerges automatically that the phase factor accompanying spin exchange with the transported basis is just the Pauli sign, that is (−1)2S. Singlevaluedness of the total wavefunction, involving the transported basis, then implies the correct relation between spin and statistics. The Pauli sign is a geometric phase factor of topological origin, associated with non-contractible circuits in the doubly connected (and non-orientable) configuration space of relative positions with identified antipodes. The theory extends to more than two particles.

Proceedings of the Royal Society A Mathematical Physical and Engineering Sciences•Aug 8, 1997•120 citations

Quantum indistinguishability from general representations of SU(2n)

J. M. Harrison, J. M. Robbins

A treatment of the spin-statistics relation in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics due to Berry and Robbins [Proc. R. Soc. London Ser. A 453, 1771–1790 (1997)] is generalized within a group-theoretical framework. The construction of Berry and Robbins is reformulated in terms of certain locally flat vector bundles over n-particle configuration space. It is shown how families of such bundles can be constructed from irreducible representations of the group SU(2n). The construction of Berry and Robbins, which leads to a definite connection between spin and statistics (the physically correct connection), is shown to correspond to the completely symmetric representations. The spin-statistics connection is typically broken for general SU(2n) representations, which may admit, for a given value of spin, both Bose and Fermi statistics, as well as parastatistics. The determination of the allowed values of the spin and statistics reduces to the decomposition of certain zero-weight representations of a (generalized) Weyl group of SU(2n). A formula for this decomposition is obtained using the Littlewood–Richardson theorem for the decomposition of representations of U(m+n) into representations of U(m)×U(n).

arXiv:math-ph/0302037•Journal of Mathematical Physics•Mar 17, 2004•4 citations

Quantum indistinguishability: Spin-statistics without relativity or field theory?

Michael Berry

We review the formulation of quantum mechanics for identical spinning particles with wavefunctions that are singlevalued when permuted configurations are identified. The identification requires the spins to be smoothly permuted along with position variables, so spin is represented in a position-dependent ‘transported basis’, rather than the usual fixed basis. The simplest transported basis, constructed in terms of spins represented as pairs of commuting harmonic oscillators, gives the correct connection between spin and statistics. More complicated constructions can give the wrong exchange sign. The theory is generalized to incorporate additional properties such as isospin, color and strangeness. Some remarks about the relation between this approach and those based on relatitivity and/or field theory are given.

AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2000•8 citations

Quantum Indistiguishability: Spin Statistics without Relativity or Field Theory?

Michael Berry, Robbins, JM

•Jan 1, 2000•0 citations
Our earlier arguments (Berry M V and Robbins J M 1997 Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 453 1771-90) leading to the spin-statistics relation are summarized and then revisited. Constructions are described that satisfy all our previous requirements but lead to the wrong exchange sign (one such alternative is the replacement of commutators by anticommutators in the Schwinger representation of the spins of the particles); we suggest why these might be unacceptable.
We review the formulation of quantum mechanics for identical spinning particles with wavefunctions that are singlevalued when permuted configurations are identified. The identification requires the spins to be smoothly permuted along with position variables, so spin is represented in a position-dependent ‘transported basis’, rather than the usual fixed basis. The simplest transported basis, constructed in terms of spins represented as pairs of commuting harmonic oscillators, gives the correct connection between spin and statistics. More complicated constructions can give the wrong exchange sign. The theory is generalized to incorporate additional properties such as isospin, colour and strangeness. Some remarks about the relation between this approach and those based on relatitivity and/or field theory are given.
The quantum mechanics of two identical particles with spin S in three dimensions is reformulated by employing not the usual fixed spin basis but a transported spin basis that exchanges the spins along with the positions. Such a basis, required to be smooth and parallel-transported, can be generated by an ‘exchange rotation’ operator resembling angular momentum. This is constructed from the four harmonic oscillators from which the two spins are made according to Schwinger’s scheme. It emerges automatically that the phase factor accompanying spin exchange with the transported basis is just the Pauli sign, that is (−1) 2 S . Singlevaluedness of the total wavefunction, involving the transported basis, then implies the correct relation between spin and statistics. The Pauli sign is a geometric phase factor of topological origin, associated with non-contractible circuits in the doubly connected (and non-orientable) configuration space of relative positions with identified antipodes. The theory extends to more than two particles.
The quantum mechanics of two identical particles with spin S in three dimensions is reformulated by employing not the usual fixed spin basis but a transported spin basis that exchanges the spins along with the positions. Such a basis, required to be smooth and parallel-transported, can be generated by an ‘exchange rotation’ operator resembling angular momentum. This is constructed from the four harmonic oscillators from which the two spins are made according to Schwinger's scheme. It emerges automatically that the phase factor accompanying spin exchange with the transported basis is just the Pauli sign, that is (−1)2S. Singlevaluedness of the total wavefunction, involving the transported basis, then implies the correct relation between spin and statistics. The Pauli sign is a geometric phase factor of topological origin, associated with non-contractible circuits in the doubly connected (and non-orientable) configuration space of relative positions with identified antipodes. The theory extends to more than two particles.
A treatment of the spin-statistics relation in nonrelativistic quantum mechanics due to Berry and Robbins [Proc. R. Soc. London Ser. A 453, 1771–1790 (1997)] is generalized within a group-theoretical framework. The construction of Berry and Robbins is reformulated in terms of certain locally flat vector bundles over n-particle configuration space. It is shown how families of such bundles can be constructed from irreducible representations of the group SU(2n). The construction of Berry and Robbins, which leads to a definite connection between spin and statistics (the physically correct connection), is shown to correspond to the completely symmetric representations. The spin-statistics connection is typically broken for general SU(2n) representations, which may admit, for a given value of spin, both Bose and Fermi statistics, as well as parastatistics. The determination of the allowed values of the spin and statistics reduces to the decomposition of certain zero-weight representations of a (generalized) Weyl group of SU(2n). A formula for this decomposition is obtained using the Littlewood–Richardson theorem for the decomposition of representations of U(m+n) into representations of U(m)×U(n).
We review the formulation of quantum mechanics for identical spinning particles with wavefunctions that are singlevalued when permuted configurations are identified. The identification requires the spins to be smoothly permuted along with position variables, so spin is represented in a position-dependent ‘transported basis’, rather than the usual fixed basis. The simplest transported basis, constructed in terms of spins represented as pairs of commuting harmonic oscillators, gives the correct connection between spin and statistics. More complicated constructions can give the wrong exchange sign. The theory is generalized to incorporate additional properties such as isospin, color and strangeness. Some remarks about the relation between this approach and those based on relatitivity and/or field theory are given.