Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Statistical Mechanics of Coupled Bosons in the Heisenberg Representation

Robert H. Kraichnan

Published Nov 15, 1958• 6 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A system of bosons interacting by 2-body forces is treated in momentum space in the Heisenberg representation, assuming a statistically homogeneous and stationary state. The principle of weak statistical dependence of different momentum modes, previously applied to turbulence dynamics, is used to obtain an exact expansion expressing quadrilinear (2-body) time-displaced correlation functions of the second-quantized field variables in terms of bilinear time-displaced correlation functions and average impulse-response functions. The last-named functions are defined in terms of the exact Green's operator, for infinitesimal sources, of the nonlinear Heisenberg equations of motion. A set of coupled integral equations are then obtained which determine both the bilinear correlation functions and the response functions. By retaining in these equations only the lowest terms in the cited expansion, a theory is obtained which includes particle "self-energy" interactions with the medium of all orders. A modification of the theory is briefly outlined which includes, at finite temperatures, all the processes described at absolute zero by the Brueckner approximation and, in addition, 3-body effects, iterated to all orders, which are omitted in that approximation.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.112.1054

Related papers

Statistical Mechanics of Coupled Particles in the Schrödinger Representation

Robert H. Kraichnan

A perturbation treatment is presented for the operator $u(t)$ giving the evolution of the state vector of a system of $N$ particles coupled by 2-body forces. The total Hamiltonian is divided into a diagonal part ${H}_{0}$ and off-diagonal part ${H}_{1}$ in the representation with $N$-particle plane-wave states as basis. An effective pair-interaction operator ${\overline{H}}_{1}$ is defined which includes "vertex" corrections of all orders, and the off-diagonal part of $u$ is expressed exactly by an expansion which involves only ${\overline{H}}_{1}$ and the exact diagonal part of $u$. A closed set of equations determining ${\overline{H}}_{1}$ and the diagonal part of $u$ are obtained by retaining only the leading terms in the expansion. These equations include all the corrections included in the Brueckner approximation and, in addition, they contain 3-body effects, iterated to all orders, which are omitted in that approximation. No one-to-one correspondence between the eigenstates of ${H}_{0}$ and those of the total Hamiltonian is appealed to, and the ground state plays no special role. The connection with statistical mechanics follows the fact that the partition function is $\mathrm{Tr}[u(\ensuremath{-}\frac{i}{\mathrm{kT}})]$. The theory simplifies greatly for very large $N$.

Physical Review•Nov 15, 1958•3 citations

I. Exact relations among correlation functions of inherently nondynamic interacting systems

Stephen B. Haley

The standard basis operator (SBO) equation of motion is solved exactly for the class of interacting many-body Hamiltonians which can be constructed from a complete set of mutually orthogonal projection operators. This class includes the Ising model Hamiltonians. Two integration procedures are presented: (1) term by term integration over the poles of the SBO double-time temperature-dependent Green’s functions in the spectral representation; (2) direct integration of the time-dependent equation of motion of an SBO. An ensemble average expression relating correlation functions among systems in different energy states is derived. For the Ising model this expression relates correlation functions of spin clusters of different orders, and it is analogous to a relation derived from the master equation under equilibrium conditions.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•May 1, 1978•0 citations

Quantum Statistics of Interacting Particles; Thermodynamic Quantities and Pair Distribution Function

Shigeji Fujita, Ryogo Hirota

An alternative approach to the quantum statistics of interacting particles is proposed. It consists of calculating the equilibrium thermodynamical quantities of the many-body system via the pair distribution function with the assumption that the particles interact with each other only through pair central forces. The proposed approach has some advantage over the usual treatment via the partition function in that the pair distribution function is easier to deal with than the partition function in certain circumstances particularly when the collective motion description of the system is desirable. This is because only the pair distribution function can be expressed directly in terms of the collective interaction which is closely connected with collective elementary excitation, such as a plasmon in the electron gas and a phonon in the hard-sphere Boson gas. The equation of state as well as the internal energy are obtained in the form of integrals of the pair distribution function. The close analogy between the pair distribution function and the two-body propagator, which appears in the quantum field theory, makes it possible to analyze the former by the use of Feynman diagrams identical with those usually introduced for the latter. The collective interaction, which is defined by the sum of the direct and the indirect interactions, is introduced as a particular partial sum of the perturbation series of the pair distribution function. This is used in rewriting the pair distribution function in terms of the collective interaction.It is shown that, while the simple chain approximation to the collective interaction in the electron gas is responsible for the transfer of a plasmon, the same approximation to the collective pseudo-interaction in the hard-sphere Boson system has a relation similar to that of transfer of a phonon, both cases occuring at low temperatures. The explicit calculation of the pair distribution functions for these systems at the absolute zero temperature is carried out up to the first order in the collective interaction (simple chain approximation.) These results are used to calculate the ground-state energies. For the electron gas the energy thus obtained confirms Gell-Mann-Bruckner's calculation of the correlation energy. For the hard-sphere Bosons the calculated energy reproduces the result of Lee, Huang, and Yang. The extension of the calculation to the finite temperature case is also indicated. In particular the classical Debye-Huckel equation of state for the electron gas is briefly discussed.

Physical Review•Apr 1, 1960•20 citations

Stochastic Models for Many-Body Systems. II. Finite Systems and Statistical Nonequilibrium

Robert H. Kraichnan

In a preceding paper [J. Math. Phys. 3, 475 (1962)], some model Hamiltonians were proposed for quantum-mechanical many-body systems with pair forces. For infinite systems in thermal equilibrium, they led to temperature-domain propagator expansions which were formally summable and expressible by closed equations. These expansions were identical with infinite subclasses of terms from the propagator expansion for the true many-body problem. The two principal models corresponded to ring- and ladder-diagram summations from the true propagator expansion, augmented by infinite classes of self-energy corrections. The model Hamiltonians were called stochastic because they contained parameters whose phases were fixed by random choices. In the present paper, more general models are formulated which yield formally summable propagator expansions for finite systems. The analysis is extended to correlation and Green's functions defined for nonequilibrium ensembles. The nonequilibrium treatment is developed in the Heisenberg representation in such a way that unlinked diagrams do not arise. A basic convergence question associated with the formal closed equations for the model propagators and correlation functions is examined by means of finite-difference integration of the Heisenberg equations of motion. This procedure appears to converge independently of whether the perturbation expansions for the propagators and correlation functions converge. It yields substantial support for the validity of the formal closed model equations.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•May 1, 1962•19 citations

Nonequilibrium quantum fields: Closed-time-path effective action, Wigner function, and Boltzmann equation

Esteban Calzetta, B. L. Hu

This is the first of a series of papers which describe the functional-integral approach to the study of the statistical and kinetic properties of nonequilibrium quantum fields in flat and curved spacetimes. In this paper we treat a system of self-interacting bosons described by \ensuremath{\lambda}${\ensuremath{\varphi}}^{4}$ scalar fields in flat space. We adopt the closed-time-path (CTP or ``in-in'') functional formalism and use a two-particle irreducible (2PI) representation for the effective action. These formalisms allow for a full account of the dynamics of quantum fields, and put the correlation functions on an equal footing with the mean fields. By assuming a thermal distribution we recover the real-time finite-temperature theory as a special case. By requiring the CTP effective action to be stationary with respect to variations of the correlation functions we obtain an infinite set of coupled equations which is the quantum-field-theoretical generalization of the Bogoliubov-Born-Green-Kirkwood-Yvon (BBGKY) hierarchy. Truncation of this series leads to dissipative characteristics in the subsystem. In this context we discuss the nature of dissipation in interacting quantum fields.To one-loop order in a perturbative expansion of the CTP effective action, the 2PI formalism yields results equivalent to the leading 1/N expansion for an O(N)-symmetric scalar field. To higher-loop order we introduce a two-time approximation to separate the quantum-field effects of radiative correction and renormalization from the statistical-kinetic effects of collisions and relaxation. In the weak-coupling quasiuniform limit, the system of nonequilibrium quantum fields can subscribe to a kinetic theory description wherein the propagators are represented in terms of relativistic Wigner distribution functions. From a two-loop calculation we derive the Boltzmann equation for the distribution function and the gap equation for the effective mass of the quasiparticles. One can define an entropy function for the quantum gas of quasiparticles which satisfies the H theorem. We also calculate the limits to the validity of the binary collision approximation from a three-loop analysis. The theoretical framework established here can be generalized to nonconstant background fields and for curved spacetimes.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•May 15, 1988•548 citations

Green's-Function Formalism of the One-Dimensional Heisenberg Spin System

Jun Kondo, Yamaji K.

The one-dimensional Heisenberg model with S = 1/2 is treated with the use of the two-time Green's functions. The hierarchy of the equations of motion of the Green'f functions is decoupled at a stage one-step further than Tyablikov's decoupling. The thermal average of the spin component, ≪ Sz >, is set to zero, becaure the long-range order does not exist in one dimension. Instead, our Green's functions are expressed in terms of the correlation functions cn ≡4≪ S0zSnz >. The Green's function is essentially of the form representing undamped spin waves, whose spactrum depends on c1, c2 and one more parameter. They are determined by the requirement that c1 and c2 should be self-consistent and that c0 should be unity. The self-consistency equations have been solved analytically at high- and low-temperature limits, and also solved numerically in the whole range of the temperature. Thermodynamic quantities have been calculated using these solutions. It has turned out that the theory gives the correct high-temperature expansion for the thermodynamic quantities and the correlation functions. The latter is expressed by cn = (J / 4 kBT )n. In the case of ferromagnetic coupling, the correlation function cn at T = 0 is equal to 1/3 for all n's. This is what is expected from the correct ground state of the ferromagnetic Heisenberg system. The spin-wave spectrum at T = 0 also agrees with the correct one. At T ≪J/ kB, we find that the specific heat goes as T1/2 and the susceptibility goes as T-2. The gross feature of the temperature-dependence of the thermodynamic quantities agrees with Bonner and Fisher. In the case of the antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model, we find c1 = -0.55407 and c2 = 0.16100 at T = 0, which are fairly close to the exact values. The thermodynamic quantities are also in gross agreement with Bonner and Fisher.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Mar 1, 1972•243 citations
A system of bosons interacting by 2-body forces is treated in momentum space in the Heisenberg representation, assuming a statistically homogeneous and stationary state. The principle of weak statistical dependence of different momentum modes, previously applied to turbulence dynamics, is used to obtain an exact expansion expressing quadrilinear (2-body) time-displaced correlation functions of the second-quantized field variables in terms of bilinear time-displaced correlation functions and average impulse-response functions. The last-named functions are defined in terms of the exact Green's operator, for infinitesimal sources, of the nonlinear Heisenberg equations of motion. A set of coupled integral equations are then obtained which determine both the bilinear correlation functions and the response functions. By retaining in these equations only the lowest terms in the cited expansion, a theory is obtained which includes particle "self-energy" interactions with the medium of all orders. A modification of the theory is briefly outlined which includes, at finite temperatures, all the processes described at absolute zero by the Brueckner approximation and, in addition, 3-body effects, iterated to all orders, which are omitted in that approximation.
A perturbation treatment is presented for the operator u(t)u(t)u(t) giving the evolution of the state vector of a system of NNN particles coupled by 2-body forces. The total Hamiltonian is divided into a diagonal part H0{H}_{0}H0​ and off-diagonal part H1{H}_{1}H1​ in the representation with NNN-particle plane-wave states as basis. An effective pair-interaction operator H‾1{\overline{H}}_{1}H1​ is defined which includes "vertex" corrections of all orders, and the off-diagonal part of uuu is expressed exactly by an expansion which involves only H‾1{\overline{H}}_{1}H1​ and the exact diagonal part of uuu. A closed set of equations determining H‾1{\overline{H}}_{1}H1​ and the diagonal part of uuu are obtained by retaining only the leading terms in the expansion. These equations include all the corrections included in the Brueckner approximation and, in addition, they contain 3-body effects, iterated to all orders, which are omitted in that approximation. No one-to-one correspondence between the eigenstates of H0{H}_{0}H0​ and those of the total Hamiltonian is appealed to, and the ground state plays no special role. The connection with statistical mechanics follows the fact that the partition function is $\mathrm{Tr}[u(\ensuremath{-}\frac{i}{\mathrm{kT}})]$. The theory simplifies greatly for very large NNN.
The standard basis operator (SBO) equation of motion is solved exactly for the class of interacting many-body Hamiltonians which can be constructed from a complete set of mutually orthogonal projection operators. This class includes the Ising model Hamiltonians. Two integration procedures are presented: (1) term by term integration over the poles of the SBO double-time temperature-dependent Green’s functions in the spectral representation; (2) direct integration of the time-dependent equation of motion of an SBO. An ensemble average expression relating correlation functions among systems in different energy states is derived. For the Ising model this expression relates correlation functions of spin clusters of different orders, and it is analogous to a relation derived from the master equation under equilibrium conditions.
An alternative approach to the quantum statistics of interacting particles is proposed. It consists of calculating the equilibrium thermodynamical quantities of the many-body system via the pair distribution function with the assumption that the particles interact with each other only through pair central forces. The proposed approach has some advantage over the usual treatment via the partition function in that the pair distribution function is easier to deal with than the partition function in certain circumstances particularly when the collective motion description of the system is desirable. This is because only the pair distribution function can be expressed directly in terms of the collective interaction which is closely connected with collective elementary excitation, such as a plasmon in the electron gas and a phonon in the hard-sphere Boson gas. The equation of state as well as the internal energy are obtained in the form of integrals of the pair distribution function. The close analogy between the pair distribution function and the two-body propagator, which appears in the quantum field theory, makes it possible to analyze the former by the use of Feynman diagrams identical with those usually introduced for the latter. The collective interaction, which is defined by the sum of the direct and the indirect interactions, is introduced as a particular partial sum of the perturbation series of the pair distribution function. This is used in rewriting the pair distribution function in terms of the collective interaction.It is shown that, while the simple chain approximation to the collective interaction in the electron gas is responsible for the transfer of a plasmon, the same approximation to the collective pseudo-interaction in the hard-sphere Boson system has a relation similar to that of transfer of a phonon, both cases occuring at low temperatures. The explicit calculation of the pair distribution functions for these systems at the absolute zero temperature is carried out up to the first order in the collective interaction (simple chain approximation.) These results are used to calculate the ground-state energies. For the electron gas the energy thus obtained confirms Gell-Mann-Bruckner's calculation of the correlation energy. For the hard-sphere Bosons the calculated energy reproduces the result of Lee, Huang, and Yang. The extension of the calculation to the finite temperature case is also indicated. In particular the classical Debye-Huckel equation of state for the electron gas is briefly discussed.
In a preceding paper [J. Math. Phys. 3, 475 (1962)], some model Hamiltonians were proposed for quantum-mechanical many-body systems with pair forces. For infinite systems in thermal equilibrium, they led to temperature-domain propagator expansions which were formally summable and expressible by closed equations. These expansions were identical with infinite subclasses of terms from the propagator expansion for the true many-body problem. The two principal models corresponded to ring- and ladder-diagram summations from the true propagator expansion, augmented by infinite classes of self-energy corrections. The model Hamiltonians were called stochastic because they contained parameters whose phases were fixed by random choices. In the present paper, more general models are formulated which yield formally summable propagator expansions for finite systems. The analysis is extended to correlation and Green's functions defined for nonequilibrium ensembles. The nonequilibrium treatment is developed in the Heisenberg representation in such a way that unlinked diagrams do not arise. A basic convergence question associated with the formal closed equations for the model propagators and correlation functions is examined by means of finite-difference integration of the Heisenberg equations of motion. This procedure appears to converge independently of whether the perturbation expansions for the propagators and correlation functions converge. It yields substantial support for the validity of the formal closed model equations.
This is the first of a series of papers which describe the functional-integral approach to the study of the statistical and kinetic properties of nonequilibrium quantum fields in flat and curved spacetimes. In this paper we treat a system of self-interacting bosons described by \ensuremath{\lambda}${\ensuremath{\varphi}}^{4}$ scalar fields in flat space. We adopt the closed-time-path (CTP or ``in-in'') functional formalism and use a two-particle irreducible (2PI) representation for the effective action. These formalisms allow for a full account of the dynamics of quantum fields, and put the correlation functions on an equal footing with the mean fields. By assuming a thermal distribution we recover the real-time finite-temperature theory as a special case. By requiring the CTP effective action to be stationary with respect to variations of the correlation functions we obtain an infinite set of coupled equations which is the quantum-field-theoretical generalization of the Bogoliubov-Born-Green-Kirkwood-Yvon (BBGKY) hierarchy. Truncation of this series leads to dissipative characteristics in the subsystem. In this context we discuss the nature of dissipation in interacting quantum fields.To one-loop order in a perturbative expansion of the CTP effective action, the 2PI formalism yields results equivalent to the leading 1/N expansion for an O(N)-symmetric scalar field. To higher-loop order we introduce a two-time approximation to separate the quantum-field effects of radiative correction and renormalization from the statistical-kinetic effects of collisions and relaxation. In the weak-coupling quasiuniform limit, the system of nonequilibrium quantum fields can subscribe to a kinetic theory description wherein the propagators are represented in terms of relativistic Wigner distribution functions. From a two-loop calculation we derive the Boltzmann equation for the distribution function and the gap equation for the effective mass of the quasiparticles. One can define an entropy function for the quantum gas of quasiparticles which satisfies the H theorem. We also calculate the limits to the validity of the binary collision approximation from a three-loop analysis. The theoretical framework established here can be generalized to nonconstant background fields and for curved spacetimes.
The one-dimensional Heisenberg model with S = 1/2 is treated with the use of the two-time Green's functions. The hierarchy of the equations of motion of the Green'f functions is decoupled at a stage one-step further than Tyablikov's decoupling. The thermal average of the spin component, ≪ Sz >, is set to zero, becaure the long-range order does not exist in one dimension. Instead, our Green's functions are expressed in terms of the correlation functions cn ≡4≪ S0zSnz >. The Green's function is essentially of the form representing undamped spin waves, whose spactrum depends on c1, c2 and one more parameter. They are determined by the requirement that c1 and c2 should be self-consistent and that c0 should be unity. The self-consistency equations have been solved analytically at high- and low-temperature limits, and also solved numerically in the whole range of the temperature. Thermodynamic quantities have been calculated using these solutions. It has turned out that the theory gives the correct high-temperature expansion for the thermodynamic quantities and the correlation functions. The latter is expressed by cn = (J / 4 kBT )n. In the case of ferromagnetic coupling, the correlation function cn at T = 0 is equal to 1/3 for all n's. This is what is expected from the correct ground state of the ferromagnetic Heisenberg system. The spin-wave spectrum at T = 0 also agrees with the correct one. At T ≪J/ kB, we find that the specific heat goes as T1/2 and the susceptibility goes as T-2. The gross feature of the temperature-dependence of the thermodynamic quantities agrees with Bonner and Fisher. In the case of the antiferromagnetic Heisenberg model, we find c1 = -0.55407 and c2 = 0.16100 at T = 0, which are fairly close to the exact values. The thermodynamic quantities are also in gross agreement with Bonner and Fisher.