Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

Reply to “Comment on ‘A quantum-classical bracket that satisfies the Jacobi identity’ ” [J. Chem. Phys. 124, 201104 (2006)]

Oleg V. Prezhdo

Published Feb 6, 2007• 4 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The argument made in the cited Comment is based on a calculation that was not intended in the original paper. Starting from a fully quantum expression, application of the ℏ→0 limit after every bracket calculation as stated in the paper retains consistent orders of ℏ and does obey the Jacobi identity.
DOI
10.1063/1.2431651

Related papers

Reply to the Comment on ‘The correspondence between quantum and classical mechanics: An experimental demonstration of the smooth transition between the two regimes’ [Chem. Phys. Lett. 402 (2005) 519]

Anthony J. Horsewill

Chemical Physics Letters•Nov 29, 2006•4 citations

Comment on “Equivalence of two approaches for quantum-classical hybrid systems” [J. Chem. Phys. 128, 204104 (2008)]

V. I. Gerasimenko

We discuss the links between consistent and approximate descriptions of the quantum-classical systems, i.e., systems composed of two interacting subsystems, one of which behaves almost classically while the other requires a quantum description.

arXiv:0909.4942•The Journal of Chemical Physics•Sep 28, 2009•2 citations

A quantum-classical bracket that satisfies the Jacobi identity

Oleg V. Prezhdo

A quantum-classical bracket is proposed and is shown to satisfy the Jacobi identity, in contrast to previous definitions that obey this property only up to higher order terms in the Planck constant variant Planck's over 2pi. The Jacobi identity is required of a true Lie bracket and ensures that the Lie bracket of constants of motion is also a constant of motion. An explicit calculation of the Jacobi identity highlights the difference between the proposed and traditional definitions. A further example illustrates that the proposed bracket generates a more consistent quantum-classical dynamics than the traditional bracket. The traditional quantum-classical dynamics in the Henon-Heiles system diverges due to higher order variant Planck's over 2pi terms. The divergence is eliminated with the proposed bracket.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•May 22, 2006•33 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘Association between quantum paradoxes based on weak values and a realistic interpretation of quantum measurements' ”

Alice M. Aredes, Pablo L. Saldanha

Seoane et al. [preceding Comment, Phys. Rev. A 111, 066201 (2025)] criticized our work [Phys. Rev. A 109, 022238 (2024)], saying that our argument that realistic interpretations of weak values lead to inconsistencies is not valid for all weak values and quantum theories. This is true. We never intended that the arguments we presented would be valid for all weak values. We believe it is clearly stated in our work that we were dealing only with the weak values related to the quantum paradoxes cited in our paper. Seoane et al. also said in their Comment that the ``general argument'' we present in our paper is formally incorrect. However, this criticism is related to the interpretation they give to the expression ``equivalent,'' which is different from the one we use. In this sense, the presented criticisms are a matter of semantics, not of physics.

Physical Review A•Jun 2, 2025•1 citation

Response to “Comment on ‘Equivalence of two approaches for quantum-classical hybrid systems’ ” [J. Chem. Phys. 131, 127101 (2009)]

Fei Zhan, Yuan Lin, Biao Wu

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Sep 28, 2009•0 citations

Bohr’s molecular model and the melding of classical and quantum mechanics

Anatoly A. Svidzinsky, Marlan O. Scully, Dudley R. Herschbach

Svidzinsky, Scully, and Herschbach reply: We agree with M. Y. Amusia that a statement we made about the infinite dimension limit is “lacking in rigor.” It was intended simply to provide heuristic insight into why, for a wide variety of problems, the large-D limit has proven to be a useful starting approximation to obtain results for D = 3.Amusia’s other concerns are answered in a 1975 paper on a D-scaling treatment of helium by David Herrick and Frank Stillinger.11. D. R. Herrick, F. H. Stillinger, Phys. Rev. A 11, 42 (1975). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.11.42 They gave a rigorous derivation of the D-dimensional hydrogen atom Hamiltonian, shown as equation 1 in Amusia’s letter. That solution applies for D ≥ 2, as implied in the figure included in box 1 of our article. Herrick and Stillinger also showed that for the correct D → 1 limit, the Z/r term becomes a δ-function. In D-scaling, contrary to Amusia’s assumption, the D = 3 form of Coulomb’s law can be used for dimensional continuation to the large-D limit. The D-dependent similarity transformation affects the Laplacian, not the potential energy. Both theory and application are amply presented in references given in our article (particularly references 8–11). D-scaling, using just elementary algebra, has attained correlation energies for multielectron atoms with accuracy comparable to or better than conventional electronic calculations.22. See, for example, S. Kais, R. Bleil, J. Chem. Phys. 102, 7472 (1995); https://doi.org/10.1063/1.469059D. K. Watson, D. Z. Goodson, Phys. Rev. A 51, R5 (1995), and references therein. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.51.R5The papers of Leonard Mlodinow33. See D. R. Herschbach, J. Chem. Phys. 84, 838 (1986), for analysis of the papers cited in reference 1 of Mlodinow’s letter. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.450584 and several other authors, especially the earlier paper by Herrick and Stillinger,11. D. R. Herrick, F. H. Stillinger, Phys. Rev. A 11, 42 (1975). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.11.42 fostered the development of D-scaling for electronic structure. Since the kinship of Bohr’s model to dimensional scaling was not recognized until 2005, we did not dwell on that history, other than citing the tutorial article by Edward Witten. The treatment of H2 that Mlodinow cites in the second part of his reference 3 is a deliberately drastic approximation and gives less than 40% of the bond dissociation energy.As emphasized by Petar Grujic, the bold, perplexing enterprise by Niels Bohr motivated much further work melding classical and quantum mechanics. We note that D-scaling has a distinctive character. It might aptly be termed “semiquantum” rather than semiclassical. Although in the large-D limit the equations become classical, quantum mechanics is hidden in the D-dependent units adopted for distance and energy. At that limit, electrons take fixed positions in the D-scaled space and the first-order correction in (1/D) has them execute harmonic vibrations about those positions. In the prequantum era, such behavior was postulated by Gilbert Lewis and Irving Langmuir,44. P. Coffey, Cathedrals of Science: The Personalities and Rivalries That Made Modern Chemistry, Oxford U. Press, New York (2008), chap. 5, esp. p. 139. motivated by chemical arguments but disdained by physicists and considered incompatible with the Bohr model.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. D. R. Herrick, F. H. Stillinger, Phys. Rev. A 11, 42 (1975). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.11.42, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. See, for example, S. Kais, R. Bleil, J. Chem. Phys. 102, 7472 (1995); https://doi.org/10.1063/1.469059, Google ScholarCrossref, ISID. K. Watson, D. Z. Goodson, Phys. Rev. A 51, R5 (1995), and references therein. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.51.R5, , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI3. See D. R. Herschbach, J. Chem. Phys. 84, 838 (1986), for analysis of the papers cited in reference 1 of Mlodinow’s letter. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.450584, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI4. P. Coffey, Cathedrals of Science: The Personalities and Rivalries That Made Modern Chemistry, Oxford U. Press, New York (2008), chap. 5, esp. p. 139. Google Scholar© 2014 American Institute of Physics.

Physics Today•Aug 1, 2014•2 citations
A quantum-classical bracket is proposed and is shown to satisfy the Jacobi identity, in contrast to previous definitions that obey this property only up to higher order terms in the Planck constant variant Planck's over 2pi. The Jacobi identity is required of a true Lie bracket and ensures that the Lie bracket of constants of motion is also a constant of motion. An explicit calculation of the Jacobi identity highlights the difference between the proposed and traditional definitions. A further example illustrates that the proposed bracket generates a more consistent quantum-classical dynamics than the traditional bracket. The traditional quantum-classical dynamics in the Henon-Heiles system diverges due to higher order variant Planck's over 2pi terms. The divergence is eliminated with the proposed bracket.
Seoane et al. [preceding Comment, Phys. Rev. A 111, 066201 (2025)] criticized our work [Phys. Rev. A 109, 022238 (2024)], saying that our argument that realistic interpretations of weak values lead to inconsistencies is not valid for all weak values and quantum theories. This is true. We never intended that the arguments we presented would be valid for all weak values. We believe it is clearly stated in our work that we were dealing only with the weak values related to the quantum paradoxes cited in our paper. Seoane et al. also said in their Comment that the ``general argument'' we present in our paper is formally incorrect. However, this criticism is related to the interpretation they give to the expression ``equivalent,'' which is different from the one we use. In this sense, the presented criticisms are a matter of semantics, not of physics.
Svidzinsky, Scully, and Herschbach reply: We agree with M. Y. Amusia that a statement we made about the infinite dimension limit is “lacking in rigor.” It was intended simply to provide heuristic insight into why, for a wide variety of problems, the large-D limit has proven to be a useful starting approximation to obtain results for D = 3.Amusia’s other concerns are answered in a 1975 paper on a D-scaling treatment of helium by David Herrick and Frank Stillinger.11. D. R. Herrick, F. H. Stillinger, Phys. Rev. A 11, 42 (1975). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.11.42 They gave a rigorous derivation of the D-dimensional hydrogen atom Hamiltonian, shown as equation 1 in Amusia’s letter. That solution applies for D ≥ 2, as implied in the figure included in box 1 of our article. Herrick and Stillinger also showed that for the correct D → 1 limit, the Z/r term becomes a δ-function. In D-scaling, contrary to Amusia’s assumption, the D = 3 form of Coulomb’s law can be used for dimensional continuation to the large-D limit. The D-dependent similarity transformation affects the Laplacian, not the potential energy. Both theory and application are amply presented in references given in our article (particularly references 8–11). D-scaling, using just elementary algebra, has attained correlation energies for multielectron atoms with accuracy comparable to or better than conventional electronic calculations.22. See, for example, S. Kais, R. Bleil, J. Chem. Phys. 102, 7472 (1995); https://doi.org/10.1063/1.469059D. K. Watson, D. Z. Goodson, Phys. Rev. A 51, R5 (1995), and references therein. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.51.R5The papers of Leonard Mlodinow33. See D. R. Herschbach, J. Chem. Phys. 84, 838 (1986), for analysis of the papers cited in reference 1 of Mlodinow’s letter. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.450584 and several other authors, especially the earlier paper by Herrick and Stillinger,11. D. R. Herrick, F. H. Stillinger, Phys. Rev. A 11, 42 (1975). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.11.42 fostered the development of D-scaling for electronic structure. Since the kinship of Bohr’s model to dimensional scaling was not recognized until 2005, we did not dwell on that history, other than citing the tutorial article by Edward Witten. The treatment of H2 that Mlodinow cites in the second part of his reference 3 is a deliberately drastic approximation and gives less than 40% of the bond dissociation energy.As emphasized by Petar Grujic, the bold, perplexing enterprise by Niels Bohr motivated much further work melding classical and quantum mechanics. We note that D-scaling has a distinctive character. It might aptly be termed “semiquantum” rather than semiclassical. Although in the large-D limit the equations become classical, quantum mechanics is hidden in the D-dependent units adopted for distance and energy. At that limit, electrons take fixed positions in the D-scaled space and the first-order correction in (1/D) has them execute harmonic vibrations about those positions. In the prequantum era, such behavior was postulated by Gilbert Lewis and Irving Langmuir,44. P. Coffey, Cathedrals of Science: The Personalities and Rivalries That Made Modern Chemistry, Oxford U. Press, New York (2008), chap. 5, esp. p. 139. motivated by chemical arguments but disdained by physicists and considered incompatible with the Bohr model.REFERENCESSection:ChooseTop of pageREFERENCES <<CITING ARTICLES1. D. R. Herrick, F. H. Stillinger, Phys. Rev. A 11, 42 (1975). https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.11.42, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI2. See, for example, S. Kais, R. Bleil, J. Chem. Phys. 102, 7472 (1995); https://doi.org/10.1063/1.469059, Google ScholarCrossref, ISID. K. Watson, D. Z. Goodson, Phys. Rev. A 51, R5 (1995), and references therein. https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.51.R5, , Google ScholarCrossref, ISI3. See D. R. Herschbach, J. Chem. Phys. 84, 838 (1986), for analysis of the papers cited in reference 1 of Mlodinow’s letter. https://doi.org/10.1063/1.450584, Google ScholarCrossref, ISI4. P. Coffey, Cathedrals of Science: The Personalities and Rivalries That Made Modern Chemistry, Oxford U. Press, New York (2008), chap. 5, esp. p. 139. Google Scholar© 2014 American Institute of Physics.