Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

Remarks Concerning Reciprocity in Quantum Mechanics

D. E. Bilhorn, Leslie L. Foldy, Roy M. Thaler, William Tobocman, V. A. Madsen

Published Apr 1, 1964• 31 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A new derivation of the reciprocity theorem is given. The general invariance property of the Hamiltonian which leads to symmetry of the Green's function for a quantum mechanical system is exhibited. It is found that reciprocity does not necessarily imply Hermiticity of the Hamiltonian, so that the ``complex optical model potential,'' for example, satisfies the reciprocity relations. The concept of reciprocity is then generalized to include a somewhat wider class of symmetry properties. Some properties of antiunitary transformations are discussed.

DOI
10.1063/1.1704136

Related papers

Gauge invariance and reciprocity in quantum mechanics

P. T. Leung, K. Young

Reciprocity in wave propagation usually refers to the symmetry of the Green's function under the interchange of the source and the observer coordinates, but this condition is not gauge invariant in quantum mechanics, a problem that is particularly significant in the presence of a vector potential. Several possible alternative criteria are given and analyzed with reference to different examples with nonzero magnetic fields and/or vector potentials, including the case of a multiply connected spatial domain. It is shown that the appropriate reciprocity criterion allows for specific phase factors separable into functions of the source and observer coordinates and that this condition is robust with respect to the addition of any scalar potential. In the Aharonov-Bohm effect, reciprocity beyond monoenergetic experiments holds only because of subsidiary conditions satisfied in actual experiments: the test charge is in units of $e$ and the flux is produced by a condensate of particles with charge $2e$.

Physical Review A•Mar 8, 2010•10 citations

Symmetries and Invariants for Non-Hermitian Hamiltonians

Miguel Angel Otero Simón, Álvaro Buendía, Juan Gonzalo Muga

We discuss Hamiltonian symmetries and invariants for quantum systems driven by non-Hermitian Hamiltonians. For time-independent Hermitian Hamiltonians, a unitary or antiunitary transformation AHA† that leaves the Hamiltonian H unchanged represents a symmetry of the Hamiltonian, which implies the commutativity [H,A]=0 and, if A is linear and time-independent, a conservation law, namely the invariance of expectation values of A. For non-Hermitian Hamiltonians, H† comes into play as a distinct operator that complements H in generalized unitarity relations. The above description of symmetries has to be extended to include also A-pseudohermiticity relations of the form AH=H†A. A superoperator formulation of Hamiltonian symmetries is provided and exemplified for Hamiltonians of a particle moving in one-dimension considering the set of A operators that form Klein’s 4-group: parity, time-reversal, parity&time-reversal, and unity. The link between symmetry and conservation laws is discussed and shown to be richer and subtler for non-Hermitian than for Hermitian Hamiltonians.

arXiv:1805.04968•Mathematics•Jun 27, 2018•20 citations

General validity of reciprocity in quantum mechanics

Huai-Yi Xie, P. T. Leung, Din Ping Tsai

The concept of reciprocity symmetry for matter-wave propagation is established for nonrelativistic quantum mechanics with previous results in the literature extended to include nonlocal interactions. Examples are given for cases with both local and nonlocal potentials, where we show in particular that reciprocity can be violated for the motion of a charged particle in an external electromagnetic field. In addition, this symmetry is applied to interpret a recent analysis [Phys. Rev. A 64, 042716 (2001)] on the symmetry of transmission through one-dimensional complex potentials, with the emphasis that the validity of reciprocity can go beyond that of time-reversal symmetry, such as in the presence of absorption in which the latter symmetry breaks down.

Physical Review A•Dec 15, 2008•9 citations

Constraints on the reciprocal propagation of a quantum particle through a one-dimensional localized complex potential

Ethan Knox, P. T. Leung

In the propagation of an electron through a one-dimensional asymmetric complex potential, it is known that while the conventional Green function reciprocity symmetry will ensure transmission to be symmetric between a “left-incident” and a “right-incident” beam, no such symmetry exists for the case of reflection. Here we derive generalized reciprocity relations for both the amplitude and phase of the reflected waves as constraints on the left- and right-incident beams, in complete analogy to what was established in optics. We further provide illustrations of these relations via direct analytical calculations in the case of a real potential, and via numerical studies in the case of a complex potential.

Canadian Journal of Physics•Jan 22, 2013•0 citations

Symmetries

This chapter is concerned with a discussion of symmetries in quantum many-body systems. After a general introduction to symmetries, invariances and conservation laws (Sec. 2.1), we consider a number of standard symmetry transformations: geometric space transformations (e.g. parity or space rotation), time translation, Galilean transformation, time-reversal and U(1) transformation (Sec. 2.2). In Sec. 2.3, we briefly review Noether’s theorem in classical field theory and show how the invariance of a quantum system in a symmetry transformation implies a set of relations, known as Ward identities, which must be satisfied by the Green functions or the 1PI/2PI vertices.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC (EUROPE) eBooks•Aug 1, 2023•0 citations

Generalized Wigner theorem for noninvertible symmetries

Gerardo Ortíz, Chinmay Giridhar, Philipp Vojta +2 more

We establish the conditions under which a conservation law associated with a non-invertible operator may be realized as a symmetry in quantum physics. As established by Wigner, all quantum symmetries must be represented by either unitary or antiunitary transformations. Relinquishing an implicit assumption of invertibility, we demonstrate that the fundamental invariance of quantum transition probabilities under the application of symmetries mandates that all non-invertible symmetries may only correspond to {\it projective} unitary or antiunitary transformations, i.e., {\it partial isometries}. This extends the notion of physical states beyond conventional rays in Hilbert space to equivalence classes in an {\it extended, gauged Hilbert space}, thereby broadening the traditional understanding of symmetry transformations in quantum theory. Our generalized theorem applies irrespective of the origin of the (non)invertible symmetry, holds in arbitrary spatial dimensions, and is independent of the Hamiltonian or action. We explore its physical consequences and, using simple model systems, illustrate how the distinction between invertible and non-invertible symmetries can sometimes be tied to the choice of boundary conditions.

arXiv:2509.25327•Physical review. B./Physical review. B•Mar 12, 2026•5 citations
A new derivation of the reciprocity theorem is given. The general invariance property of the Hamiltonian which leads to symmetry of the Green's function for a quantum mechanical system is exhibited. It is found that reciprocity does not necessarily imply Hermiticity of the Hamiltonian, so that the ``complex optical model potential,'' for example, satisfies the reciprocity relations. The concept of reciprocity is then generalized to include a somewhat wider class of symmetry properties. Some properties of antiunitary transformations are discussed.
Reciprocity in wave propagation usually refers to the symmetry of the Green's function under the interchange of the source and the observer coordinates, but this condition is not gauge invariant in quantum mechanics, a problem that is particularly significant in the presence of a vector potential. Several possible alternative criteria are given and analyzed with reference to different examples with nonzero magnetic fields and/or vector potentials, including the case of a multiply connected spatial domain. It is shown that the appropriate reciprocity criterion allows for specific phase factors separable into functions of the source and observer coordinates and that this condition is robust with respect to the addition of any scalar potential. In the Aharonov-Bohm effect, reciprocity beyond monoenergetic experiments holds only because of subsidiary conditions satisfied in actual experiments: the test charge is in units of eee and the flux is produced by a condensate of particles with charge 2e2e2e.
We discuss Hamiltonian symmetries and invariants for quantum systems driven by non-Hermitian Hamiltonians. For time-independent Hermitian Hamiltonians, a unitary or antiunitary transformation AHA† that leaves the Hamiltonian H unchanged represents a symmetry of the Hamiltonian, which implies the commutativity [H,A]=0 and, if A is linear and time-independent, a conservation law, namely the invariance of expectation values of A. For non-Hermitian Hamiltonians, H† comes into play as a distinct operator that complements H in generalized unitarity relations. The above description of symmetries has to be extended to include also A-pseudohermiticity relations of the form AH=H†A. A superoperator formulation of Hamiltonian symmetries is provided and exemplified for Hamiltonians of a particle moving in one-dimension considering the set of A operators that form Klein’s 4-group: parity, time-reversal, parity&time-reversal, and unity. The link between symmetry and conservation laws is discussed and shown to be richer and subtler for non-Hermitian than for Hermitian Hamiltonians.
The concept of reciprocity symmetry for matter-wave propagation is established for nonrelativistic quantum mechanics with previous results in the literature extended to include nonlocal interactions. Examples are given for cases with both local and nonlocal potentials, where we show in particular that reciprocity can be violated for the motion of a charged particle in an external electromagnetic field. In addition, this symmetry is applied to interpret a recent analysis [Phys. Rev. A 64, 042716 (2001)] on the symmetry of transmission through one-dimensional complex potentials, with the emphasis that the validity of reciprocity can go beyond that of time-reversal symmetry, such as in the presence of absorption in which the latter symmetry breaks down.
In the propagation of an electron through a one-dimensional asymmetric complex potential, it is known that while the conventional Green function reciprocity symmetry will ensure transmission to be symmetric between a “left-incident” and a “right-incident” beam, no such symmetry exists for the case of reflection. Here we derive generalized reciprocity relations for both the amplitude and phase of the reflected waves as constraints on the left- and right-incident beams, in complete analogy to what was established in optics. We further provide illustrations of these relations via direct analytical calculations in the case of a real potential, and via numerical studies in the case of a complex potential.
This chapter is concerned with a discussion of symmetries in quantum many-body systems. After a general introduction to symmetries, invariances and conservation laws (Sec. 2.1), we consider a number of standard symmetry transformations: geometric space transformations (e.g. parity or space rotation), time translation, Galilean transformation, time-reversal and U(1) transformation (Sec. 2.2). In Sec. 2.3, we briefly review Noether’s theorem in classical field theory and show how the invariance of a quantum system in a symmetry transformation implies a set of relations, known as Ward identities, which must be satisfied by the Green functions or the 1PI/2PI vertices.
We establish the conditions under which a conservation law associated with a non-invertible operator may be realized as a symmetry in quantum physics. As established by Wigner, all quantum symmetries must be represented by either unitary or antiunitary transformations. Relinquishing an implicit assumption of invertibility, we demonstrate that the fundamental invariance of quantum transition probabilities under the application of symmetries mandates that all non-invertible symmetries may only correspond to {\it projective} unitary or antiunitary transformations, i.e., {\it partial isometries}. This extends the notion of physical states beyond conventional rays in Hilbert space to equivalence classes in an {\it extended, gauged Hilbert space}, thereby broadening the traditional understanding of symmetry transformations in quantum theory. Our generalized theorem applies irrespective of the origin of the (non)invertible symmetry, holds in arbitrary spatial dimensions, and is independent of the Hamiltonian or action. We explore its physical consequences and, using simple model systems, illustrate how the distinction between invertible and non-invertible symmetries can sometimes be tied to the choice of boundary conditions.