Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry

Effective description of the dissipative interaction between simple model-systems and their environment

Dieter Schuch

Published Jan 1, 1999• 30 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Chemical reactions are generally connected with energy transfer between reactands and their environment. There are different ways of taking this environment into account. The traditional system-plus-reservoir (S+R) approach couples the relevant system to a large number of environmental degrees of freedom, represented, e.g., by harmonic oscillators. However, this has the disadvantage—from a computational point of view—that a system of many coupled differential equations has to be solved due to the large number of degrees of freedom of the reservoir. The number of degrees of freedom can be drastically reduced if an effective description of the interaction between system and reservoir is applied. On the quantum mechanical level, the effect of the environment can be included, e.g., by the use of explicitly time-dependent Hamiltonians or nonlinear additions to the Schrödinger equation (SE). An advantage of the former method is the preservation of the canonical formalism and the linearity of the theory as well as the fact that its operators can be derived directly from the S+R approach. Therefore, it seems to be even more of a paradox that this method apparently violates the uncertainty principle. This violation does not occur in the nonlinear approaches but the nonlinearity seems, at first sight, to be problematic. However, it can be shown that a particular logarithmic nonlinear SE is equivalent to the approach using the time-dependent Hamiltonian and can be transformed into this. The fact that this transformation is nonunitary provides the key for the solution of the paradox and also allows one to show the equivalence of all three of the above-mentioned approaches. In investigating the classical counterpart, a noncanonical transformation is used between the dissipative physical level and the canonical formal level, which makes it even possible to transform the physical interacting system into a formal isolated system that can be treated in the conventional way. As a result, the effect of the interaction with the environment can be taken into account classically by noncanonical transformations and quantum mechanically by nonunitary transformations. ©1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Int J Quant Chem 72: 537–547, 1999

DOI
10.1002/(sici)1097-461x(1999)72:6<537::aid-qua1>3.0.co;2-q

Related papers

Nonunitary connection between explicitly time-dependent and nonlinear approachesfor the description of dissipative quantum systems

Dieter Schuch

Caldirola [Nuovo Cimento 18, 393 (1941)] and Kanai's [Prog. Theor. Phys. 3, 440 (1948)] time-dependent approach for dissipative systems can be traced back to the conventional system-plus-reservoir approach; however, it apparently violates the uncertainty principle. This discrepancy can be avoided by considering a consistent transition between the Caldirola-Kanai formalism and a logarithmic nonlinear Schr\"odinger equation that requires not only a transformation of the operators, but also a nonunitary transformation of the wave function. This procedure also shows the equivalence of three at first sight incompatible approaches to describe dissipative quantum systems.

Physical Review A•Feb 1, 1997•68 citations

Time-Dependent Approaches to Open Quantum Systems

Masaaki Tokieda, K. Hagino

Couplings of a system to other degrees of freedom (that is, environmental degrees of freedom) lead to energy dissipation when the number of environmental degrees of freedom is large enough. Here we discuss quantal treatments for such energy dissipation. To this end, we discuss two different time-dependent methods. One is to introduce an effective time-dependent Hamiltonian, which leads to a classical equation of motion as a relationship among expectation values of quantum operators. We apply this method to a heavy-ion fusion reaction and discuss the role of dissipation on the penetrability of the Coulomb barrier. The other method is to start with a Hamiltonian with environmental degrees of freedom and derive an equation which the system degree of freedom obeys. For this, we present a new efficient method to solve coupled-channels equations, which can be easily applied even when the dimension of the coupled-channels equations is huge.

arXiv:1911.08026•Frontiers in Physics•Feb 7, 2020•7 citations

Complex Riccati equations as a link between different approaches for the description of dissipative and irreversible systems

Dieter Schuch

Quantum mechanics is essentially described in terms of complex quantities like wave functions. The interesting point is that phase and amplitude of the complex wave function are not independent of each other, but coupled by some kind of conservation law. This coupling exists in time-independent quantum mechanics and has a counterpart in its time-dependent form. It can be traced back to a reformulation of quantum mechanics in terms of nonlinear real Ermakov equations or equivalent complex nonlinear Riccati equations, where the quadratic term in the latter equation explains the origin of the phase-amplitude coupling. Since realistic physical systems are always in contact with some kind of environment this aspect is also taken into account. In this context, different approaches for describing open quantum systems, particularly effective ones, are discussed and compared. Certain kinds of nonlinear modifications of the Schrödinger equation are discussed as well as their interrelations and their relations to linear approaches via non-unitary transformations. The modifications of the aforementioned Ermakov and Riccati equations when environmental effects are included can be determined in the time-dependent case. From formal similarities conclusions can be drawn how the equations of time-independent quantum mechanics can be modified to also incluce the enviromental aspects.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Aug 24, 2012•10 citations

Connections between ’t Hooft’s beables and canonical descriptions of dissipative systems

Dieter Schuch, Massimo Blasone

According to a proposal by 't Hooft, information loss introduced by constraints in certain classical dissipative systems may lead to quantization. This scheme can be realized within the Bateman model of two coupled oscillators, one damped and one accelerated. In this paper we analyze the links of this approach to effective Hamiltonians where the environmental degrees of freedom do not appear explicitly but their effect leads to the same friction force appearing in the Bateman model. In particular, it is shown that by imposing constraints, the Bateman Hamiltonian can be transformed into an effective one expressed in expanding coordinates. This one can be transformed via a canonical transformation into Caldirola and Kanai's effective Hamiltonian that can be linked to the conventional system-plus-reservoir approach, for example, in a form used by Caldeira and Leggett.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Aug 1, 2017•5 citations

Quantization of the linearly damped harmonic oscillator

H. Dekker

A previously developed novel theory for the formal canonical quantization of classically dissipating systems will be the starting point for a detailed discussion of the quantum statistical aspects of the simple linearly damped harmonic oscillator. The formalism essentially involves complex classical canonical coordinates and momenta, and thus quite naturally leads to the possibility of creation and annihilation operators. Furthermore, the occurrence of quantal noise operators appears to be of principal importance for the conservation of the fundamental commutator in the course of time, as will be expressed in a simple fluctuation-dissipation relation. Making a canonical transformation back to the real, Cartesian Hermitian position and momentum an "effective" Hermitian Hamiltonian will be derived, with which a transformation is made from the Heisenberg frame to the Schr\"odinger frame where the density operator equation will be computed. This will make it obvious that no proper Schr\"odinger equation exists for the dissipative subsystem on its own, thus reflecting an incomplete knowledge. The master equation will then be translated into its Wigner representation. The intimate connection between the diffusion coefficients in the resulting Fokker-Planck equation and the uncertainty relation will be demonstrated in a clear fashion.

Physical Review A•Nov 1, 1977•163 citations

Generalization of the Schrödinger Equation for Open Systems Based on the Quantum-Statistical Approach

Konstantin G. Zloshchastiev

Within the framework of the quantum-statistical approach, utilizing both non-Hermitian Hamiltonian and Lindblad’s jump operators, one can derive various generalizations of the von Neumann equation for reduced density operators, also known as hybrid master equations. If one considers the evolution of pure states only, i.e., disregarding the coherence between states and spontaneous transitions from pure to mixed states, then one can resort to quantum-mechanical equations of the Schrödinger type. We derive them from the hybrid master equations and study their main properties, which indicate that our equations have a larger range of applicability compared to other generalized Schrödinger equations proposed hitherto. Among other features, they can describe not only systems which remain in the stationary eigenstates of the Hamiltonian as time passes, but also those which evolve from those eigenstates. As an example, we consider a simple but important model, a quantum harmonic oscillator driven by both Hamiltonian and non-Hamiltonian terms, and derive its classical limit, which turns out to be the damped harmonic oscillator. Using this model, we demonstrate that the effects of dissipative environments of different types can cancel each other, thus resulting in an effectively dissipation-free classical system. Another discussed phenomenon is whether a non-trivial quantum system can reduce to a classical system in free motion, i.e., without experiencing any classical Newtonian forces. This uncovers a large class of quantum-mechanical non-Hamiltonian systems whose dynamics are not determined by conventional mechanics’ potentials and forces, but rather come about through quantum statistical effects caused by the system’s environment.

Universe•Jan 12, 2024•8 citations
Chemical reactions are generally connected with energy transfer between reactands and their environment. There are different ways of taking this environment into account. The traditional system-plus-reservoir (S+R) approach couples the relevant system to a large number of environmental degrees of freedom, represented, e.g., by harmonic oscillators. However, this has the disadvantage—from a computational point of view—that a system of many coupled differential equations has to be solved due to the large number of degrees of freedom of the reservoir. The number of degrees of freedom can be drastically reduced if an effective description of the interaction between system and reservoir is applied. On the quantum mechanical level, the effect of the environment can be included, e.g., by the use of explicitly time-dependent Hamiltonians or nonlinear additions to the Schrödinger equation (SE). An advantage of the former method is the preservation of the canonical formalism and the linearity of the theory as well as the fact that its operators can be derived directly from the S+R approach. Therefore, it seems to be even more of a paradox that this method apparently violates the uncertainty principle. This violation does not occur in the nonlinear approaches but the nonlinearity seems, at first sight, to be problematic. However, it can be shown that a particular logarithmic nonlinear SE is equivalent to the approach using the time-dependent Hamiltonian and can be transformed into this. The fact that this transformation is nonunitary provides the key for the solution of the paradox and also allows one to show the equivalence of all three of the above-mentioned approaches. In investigating the classical counterpart, a noncanonical transformation is used between the dissipative physical level and the canonical formal level, which makes it even possible to transform the physical interacting system into a formal isolated system that can be treated in the conventional way. As a result, the effect of the interaction with the environment can be taken into account classically by noncanonical transformations and quantum mechanically by nonunitary transformations. ©1999 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Int J Quant Chem 72: 537–547, 1999
Caldirola [Nuovo Cimento 18, 393 (1941)] and Kanai's [Prog. Theor. Phys. 3, 440 (1948)] time-dependent approach for dissipative systems can be traced back to the conventional system-plus-reservoir approach; however, it apparently violates the uncertainty principle. This discrepancy can be avoided by considering a consistent transition between the Caldirola-Kanai formalism and a logarithmic nonlinear Schr\"odinger equation that requires not only a transformation of the operators, but also a nonunitary transformation of the wave function. This procedure also shows the equivalence of three at first sight incompatible approaches to describe dissipative quantum systems.
Couplings of a system to other degrees of freedom (that is, environmental degrees of freedom) lead to energy dissipation when the number of environmental degrees of freedom is large enough. Here we discuss quantal treatments for such energy dissipation. To this end, we discuss two different time-dependent methods. One is to introduce an effective time-dependent Hamiltonian, which leads to a classical equation of motion as a relationship among expectation values of quantum operators. We apply this method to a heavy-ion fusion reaction and discuss the role of dissipation on the penetrability of the Coulomb barrier. The other method is to start with a Hamiltonian with environmental degrees of freedom and derive an equation which the system degree of freedom obeys. For this, we present a new efficient method to solve coupled-channels equations, which can be easily applied even when the dimension of the coupled-channels equations is huge.
Quantum mechanics is essentially described in terms of complex quantities like wave functions. The interesting point is that phase and amplitude of the complex wave function are not independent of each other, but coupled by some kind of conservation law. This coupling exists in time-independent quantum mechanics and has a counterpart in its time-dependent form. It can be traced back to a reformulation of quantum mechanics in terms of nonlinear real Ermakov equations or equivalent complex nonlinear Riccati equations, where the quadratic term in the latter equation explains the origin of the phase-amplitude coupling. Since realistic physical systems are always in contact with some kind of environment this aspect is also taken into account. In this context, different approaches for describing open quantum systems, particularly effective ones, are discussed and compared. Certain kinds of nonlinear modifications of the Schrödinger equation are discussed as well as their interrelations and their relations to linear approaches via non-unitary transformations. The modifications of the aforementioned Ermakov and Riccati equations when environmental effects are included can be determined in the time-dependent case. From formal similarities conclusions can be drawn how the equations of time-independent quantum mechanics can be modified to also incluce the enviromental aspects.
According to a proposal by 't Hooft, information loss introduced by constraints in certain classical dissipative systems may lead to quantization. This scheme can be realized within the Bateman model of two coupled oscillators, one damped and one accelerated. In this paper we analyze the links of this approach to effective Hamiltonians where the environmental degrees of freedom do not appear explicitly but their effect leads to the same friction force appearing in the Bateman model. In particular, it is shown that by imposing constraints, the Bateman Hamiltonian can be transformed into an effective one expressed in expanding coordinates. This one can be transformed via a canonical transformation into Caldirola and Kanai's effective Hamiltonian that can be linked to the conventional system-plus-reservoir approach, for example, in a form used by Caldeira and Leggett.
A previously developed novel theory for the formal canonical quantization of classically dissipating systems will be the starting point for a detailed discussion of the quantum statistical aspects of the simple linearly damped harmonic oscillator. The formalism essentially involves complex classical canonical coordinates and momenta, and thus quite naturally leads to the possibility of creation and annihilation operators. Furthermore, the occurrence of quantal noise operators appears to be of principal importance for the conservation of the fundamental commutator in the course of time, as will be expressed in a simple fluctuation-dissipation relation. Making a canonical transformation back to the real, Cartesian Hermitian position and momentum an "effective" Hermitian Hamiltonian will be derived, with which a transformation is made from the Heisenberg frame to the Schr\"odinger frame where the density operator equation will be computed. This will make it obvious that no proper Schr\"odinger equation exists for the dissipative subsystem on its own, thus reflecting an incomplete knowledge. The master equation will then be translated into its Wigner representation. The intimate connection between the diffusion coefficients in the resulting Fokker-Planck equation and the uncertainty relation will be demonstrated in a clear fashion.
Within the framework of the quantum-statistical approach, utilizing both non-Hermitian Hamiltonian and Lindblad’s jump operators, one can derive various generalizations of the von Neumann equation for reduced density operators, also known as hybrid master equations. If one considers the evolution of pure states only, i.e., disregarding the coherence between states and spontaneous transitions from pure to mixed states, then one can resort to quantum-mechanical equations of the Schrödinger type. We derive them from the hybrid master equations and study their main properties, which indicate that our equations have a larger range of applicability compared to other generalized Schrödinger equations proposed hitherto. Among other features, they can describe not only systems which remain in the stationary eigenstates of the Hamiltonian as time passes, but also those which evolve from those eigenstates. As an example, we consider a simple but important model, a quantum harmonic oscillator driven by both Hamiltonian and non-Hamiltonian terms, and derive its classical limit, which turns out to be the damped harmonic oscillator. Using this model, we demonstrate that the effects of dissipative environments of different types can cancel each other, thus resulting in an effectively dissipation-free classical system. Another discussed phenomenon is whether a non-trivial quantum system can reduce to a classical system in free motion, i.e., without experiencing any classical Newtonian forces. This uncovers a large class of quantum-mechanical non-Hamiltonian systems whose dynamics are not determined by conventional mechanics’ potentials and forces, but rather come about through quantum statistical effects caused by the system’s environment.