Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Quantized Energy Distributions for the Harmonic Oscillator

Bayard Rankin

Published Jan 28, 1966• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

An earlier study of quantum-mechanical time has suggested that, from the quantum-theoretic point of view, time is a random variable. The present work explores how such a description of time can be used to bring greater detail into the analysis of the one-dimensional harmonic oscillator. Specifically, the classical equations for harmonic motion are used as a point transformation between phase space and time-energy space, permitting probability distributions in the two spaces to be different representations of the same thing. The familiar energy-quantization hypothesis is supplemented with the hypothesis that quantized energy values are means (averages) of energy distributions characteristic of each energy state. With the probability distribution of time determined from the previously cited study, the desired quantized energy distributions follow from the requirements: (1) that they should be normalized, non-negative, and with means equal to the quantized energy values; (2) that the equivalent representation of distribution in position-momentum space should have marginal densities that are proportional (except near the origin) to the densities in position and momentum, ${|\ensuremath{\phi}(q)|}^{2}$ and ${|\ensuremath{\psi}(p)|}^{2}$, which are postulated in quantum theory. Requirement (2) is a weakening of the Born postulate. In the time-energy space, the probability distributions exclude energies smaller than the mode (energy value with maximum probability). In position-momentum space this exclusion requirement becomes the dynamical restriction: $\frac{{q}^{2}m{\ensuremath{\omega}}^{2}}{2}+\frac{{p}^{2}}{2m}\ensuremath{\ge}\frac{{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{n}\ensuremath{\hbar}\ensuremath{\omega}}{2}$, where, for the first three energy states, ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{0}=0$, ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{1}=\frac{3}{2}$, ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{2}=2+\ensuremath{\surd}\frac{3}{2}$. In general terms it is thus shown that the quantized harmonic oscillator can be described as a statistical ensemble of classical oscillators. Some comparisons with work on phase-space formulations of quantum mechanics (especially with the work of Wigner) are made and some aspects of the theory that should submit to experimental verification are pointed out.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.141.1223

Related papers

Study about Forced Harmonic Oscillator in the Space (x, v)

Gustavo V. López, Omar J. P. Bravo

The time-dependent Schrödinger equation is a cornerstone of quantum physics and governs all phenomena of the microscopic world. However, despite its importance, its origin is still not widely appreciated and properly understood. The quantization of the forced harmonic oscillator is studied with the quantum variable (\(\mathit{x}\) , \(\hat{v}\)) , with the commutation relation [\(\mathit{x}\) , \(\hat{v}\)] = \(\mathit{i}\hbar\)/\(\mathit{m}\) , and using a Schrödinger’s like equation on these variable, and associating a linear operator to a constant of motion \(\mathit{K}\)(\(\mathit{x, v, t}\)) of the classical system, The comparison with the quantization in the space (\(\mathit{x, p}\)) is done with the usual Schrödinger’s equation for the Hamiltonian \(\mathit{H}\)(\(\mathit{x, p, t}\)), and with the commutation relation [\(\mathit{x}\) , \(\hat{p}\)] = \(\mathit{i}\hbar\). It is found that for the non-resonant case, both forms of quantization bring about the same result. The difference means that the H-approach case brings about more complex behavior in the quantum dynamics than the K-approach case, and that the H-approach case losses more information than the K-approach case.However, for the resonant case, both forms of quantization are different, and the probability for the system to be in the exited state for the (\(\mathit{x}\) , \(\hat{v}\)) quantization has fewer oscillations than the (\(\mathit{x}\) , \(\hat{p}\)) quantization, the average energy of the system is higher in (\(\mathit{x}\) , \(\hat{p}\)) quantization than on the (\(\mathit{x}\) , \(\hat{v}\)) quantization, and the Boltzmann- Shannon entropy on the (\(\mathit{x}\) , \(\hat{p}\)) quantization is higher than on the (\(\mathit{x}\) , \(\hat{v}\)) quantization. The parameter does not appear to be suitable for experimental measurement because the variation in the average value of the energy is quite modest. Entropy is a nice parameter to investigate experimentally because it differs significantly.

Book Publisher International (a part of SCIENCEDOMAIN International)•Sep 1, 2023•1 citation

Quantization of the 1-D Forced Harmonic Oscillator in the Space (x, v)

Gustavo V. López, Omar J. P. Bravo

The quantization of the forced harmonic oscillator is studied with the quantum variable (x, v∧), with the commutation relation , and using a Schrödinger’s like equation on these variable, and associating a linear operator to a constant of motion K (x, v, t) of the classical system, The comparison with the quantization in the space (x, p) is done with the usual Schrödinger’s equation for the Hamiltonian H(x, p, t), and with the commutation relation . It is found that for the non-resonant case, both forms of quantization bring about the same result. However, for the resonant case, both forms of quantization are different, and the probability for the system to be in the exited state for the (x, v∧) quantization has fewer oscillations than the (x, p∧) quantization, the average energy of the system is higher in (x, p∧) quantization than on the (x, v∧) quantization, and the Boltzmann-Shannon entropy on the (x, p∧) quantization is higher than on the (x, v∧) quantization.

arXiv:2005.00344•Journal of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 2021•1 citation

Path distributions for describing eigenstates of the harmonic oscillator and other 1-dimensional problems

Randall M. Feenstra

The manner in which probability amplitudes of paths sum up to form wave functions of a harmonic oscillator, as well as other, simple 1-dimensional problems, is described. Using known, closed-form, path-based propagators for each problem, an integral expression is written that describes the wave function. This expression conventionally takes the form of an integral over initial locations of a particle, but it is re-expressed here in terms of a characteristic momentum associated with motion between the endpoints of a path. In this manner, the resulting expression can be analyzed using a generalization of stationary-phase analysis, leading to distributions of paths that exactly describe each eigenstate. These distributions are valid for all travel times, but when evaluated for long times they turn out to be real, non-negative functions of the characteristic momentum. For the harmonic oscillator in particular, a somewhat broad distribution is found, peaked at value of momentum that corresponds to a classical energy which in turn equals the energy eigenvalue for the state being described.

arXiv:2306.11155•Jun 19, 2023•1 citation

The quantum harmonic oscillator revisited: A new look from stochastic electrodynamics

Luis de la Peña, Ana María Cetto

We apply the theory of stochastic electrodynamics to the study of the (nonrelativistic) harmonic oscillator by using the Fokker–Planck method. It is demonstrated that the equilibrium distribution in phase space is exactly equal to that given by quantum statistical mechanics, i.e., the corresponding Wigner distribution, and that analysis of this distribution by means of a decomposition in terms of canonical densities leads automatically to the usual description of quantum mechanics in terms of excited states. All fundamental equations of quantum mechanics are recovered as aprproximations to zero order in the radiation terms; the first-order terms lead to the radiative corrections predicted by quantum electrodynamics, namely, the decay of states and the Lamb shift of the energy levels. The necessary differences between both treatments of the oscillator and their implications are briefly discussed.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Mar 1, 1979•47 citations

The quantized harmonic vibrator and its classical features

Alfred Brian Pippard

By the time a student of physics is ready to tackle quantum mechanics he has become familiar with the classical harmonic vibrator through many examples, and knows the crucial role it played in the development of Planck's ideas. It is natural then to concentrate on the mathematical aspects of the harmonic oscillator equation in quantum mechanics, the solution of Schrödinger's equation, normalization of the wave-function, calculation of mean values and of matrix elements, leaving the physics to look after itself. At a more advanced level the harmonic vibrator provides the entry into field theories, second quantization etc., and as a general rule it tends to be viewed more as a vehicle for instruction in more interesting matters than as a physical system having its own considerable interest and importance. Here we shall seek to redress the balance and study the vibrator as a thing in itself, without losing sight of the variety of physical problems to which the results can be applied. One especially important set of applications, however, will get little attention at this stage – the vibrations of compound bodies and of extended physical systems provide such wealth of interest as to justify a volume to themselves; and it is to such matters that the whole of the third part of this work will be devoted. As soon as one begins to contemplate the harmonic vibrator one becomes aware of the exceptional nature of its behaviour, in that it conforms more closely than any other system to the classical rules.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•Nov 16, 1989•0 citations

Wave Mechanics in Classical Phase Space, Brownian Motion, and Quantum Theory

Giacomo Della Riccia, Norbert Wiener

A wave dynamics of fields φ(p, q; t) ∈ L2(Γ) over the phase space Γ(p, q) of a classical system 𝒮 is derived from the Liouville theorem. We define the energy contained in a given field φ(p, q; t). We show that for a special class of fields, selected on physical grounds, the energy spectrum is given by a time-independent Schrödinger equation. This allows us to associate with 𝒮 an ordinary quantum system Q such that the values of the quantized energy coincide for the fields in the phase space of 𝒮 and for Q. Then we make use of Wiener's stochastic integral based on the theory of Brownian motion to derive probabilities which are the same as those one would obtain through Born's statistical postulate of quantum theory. From this it follows that we can regard normalized fields φ(p, q; t) as ``probability amplitudes'' leading to a probability density function ρ(p, q; t) = φφ* in the sense of Gibbs' statistical mechanics. Our work therefore appears as a bridge between a statistical theory (in the sense of Gibbs) of a mechanical system 𝒮 and the usual quantum theory of the related quantum system Q.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Aug 1, 1966•44 citations
An earlier study of quantum-mechanical time has suggested that, from the quantum-theoretic point of view, time is a random variable. The present work explores how such a description of time can be used to bring greater detail into the analysis of the one-dimensional harmonic oscillator. Specifically, the classical equations for harmonic motion are used as a point transformation between phase space and time-energy space, permitting probability distributions in the two spaces to be different representations of the same thing. The familiar energy-quantization hypothesis is supplemented with the hypothesis that quantized energy values are means (averages) of energy distributions characteristic of each energy state. With the probability distribution of time determined from the previously cited study, the desired quantized energy distributions follow from the requirements: (1) that they should be normalized, non-negative, and with means equal to the quantized energy values; (2) that the equivalent representation of distribution in position-momentum space should have marginal densities that are proportional (except near the origin) to the densities in position and momentum, ∣\ensuremathϕ(q)∣2{|\ensuremath{\phi}(q)|}^{2}∣\ensuremathϕ(q)∣2 and ∣\ensuremathψ(p)∣2{|\ensuremath{\psi}(p)|}^{2}∣\ensuremathψ(p)∣2, which are postulated in quantum theory. Requirement (2) is a weakening of the Born postulate. In the time-energy space, the probability distributions exclude energies smaller than the mode (energy value with maximum probability). In position-momentum space this exclusion requirement becomes the dynamical restriction: q2m\ensuremathω22+p22m\ensuremath≥\ensuremathΛn\ensuremathℏ\ensuremathω2\frac{{q}^{2}m{\ensuremath{\omega}}^{2}}{2}+\frac{{p}^{2}}{2m}\ensuremath{\ge}\frac{{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{n}\ensuremath{\hbar}\ensuremath{\omega}}{2}2q2m\ensuremathω2​+2mp2​\ensuremath≥2\ensuremathΛn​\ensuremathℏ\ensuremathω​, where, for the first three energy states, \ensuremathΛ0=0{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{0}=0\ensuremathΛ0​=0, \ensuremathΛ1=32{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{1}=\frac{3}{2}\ensuremathΛ1​=23​, \ensuremathΛ2=2+\ensuremath√32{\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{2}=2+\ensuremath{\surd}\frac{3}{2}\ensuremathΛ2​=2+\ensuremath√23​. In general terms it is thus shown that the quantized harmonic oscillator can be described as a statistical ensemble of classical oscillators. Some comparisons with work on phase-space formulations of quantum mechanics (especially with the work of Wigner) are made and some aspects of the theory that should submit to experimental verification are pointed out.
The time-dependent Schrödinger equation is a cornerstone of quantum physics and governs all phenomena of the microscopic world. However, despite its importance, its origin is still not widely appreciated and properly understood. The quantization of the forced harmonic oscillator is studied with the quantum variable (x\mathit{x}x , v^\hat{v}v^) , with the commutation relation [x\mathit{x}x , v^\hat{v}v^] = iℏ\mathit{i}\hbariℏ/m\mathit{m}m , and using a Schrödinger’s like equation on these variable, and associating a linear operator to a constant of motion K\mathit{K}K(x,v,t\mathit{x, v, t}x,v,t) of the classical system, The comparison with the quantization in the space (x,p\mathit{x, p}x,p) is done with the usual Schrödinger’s equation for the Hamiltonian H\mathit{H}H(x,p,t\mathit{x, p, t}x,p,t), and with the commutation relation [x\mathit{x}x , p^\hat{p}p^​] = iℏ\mathit{i}\hbariℏ. It is found that for the non-resonant case, both forms of quantization bring about the same result. The difference means that the H-approach case brings about more complex behavior in the quantum dynamics than the K-approach case, and that the H-approach case losses more information than the K-approach case.However, for the resonant case, both forms of quantization are different, and the probability for the system to be in the exited state for the (x\mathit{x}x , v^\hat{v}v^) quantization has fewer oscillations than the (x\mathit{x}x , p^\hat{p}p^​) quantization, the average energy of the system is higher in (x\mathit{x}x , p^\hat{p}p^​) quantization than on the (x\mathit{x}x , v^\hat{v}v^) quantization, and the Boltzmann- Shannon entropy on the (x\mathit{x}x , p^\hat{p}p^​) quantization is higher than on the (x\mathit{x}x , v^\hat{v}v^) quantization. The parameter does not appear to be suitable for experimental measurement because the variation in the average value of the energy is quite modest. Entropy is a nice parameter to investigate experimentally because it differs significantly.
The quantization of the forced harmonic oscillator is studied with the quantum variable (x, v∧), with the commutation relation , and using a Schrödinger’s like equation on these variable, and associating a linear operator to a constant of motion K (x, v, t) of the classical system, The comparison with the quantization in the space (x, p) is done with the usual Schrödinger’s equation for the Hamiltonian H(x, p, t), and with the commutation relation . It is found that for the non-resonant case, both forms of quantization bring about the same result. However, for the resonant case, both forms of quantization are different, and the probability for the system to be in the exited state for the (x, v∧) quantization has fewer oscillations than the (x, p∧) quantization, the average energy of the system is higher in (x, p∧) quantization than on the (x, v∧) quantization, and the Boltzmann-Shannon entropy on the (x, p∧) quantization is higher than on the (x, v∧) quantization.
The manner in which probability amplitudes of paths sum up to form wave functions of a harmonic oscillator, as well as other, simple 1-dimensional problems, is described. Using known, closed-form, path-based propagators for each problem, an integral expression is written that describes the wave function. This expression conventionally takes the form of an integral over initial locations of a particle, but it is re-expressed here in terms of a characteristic momentum associated with motion between the endpoints of a path. In this manner, the resulting expression can be analyzed using a generalization of stationary-phase analysis, leading to distributions of paths that exactly describe each eigenstate. These distributions are valid for all travel times, but when evaluated for long times they turn out to be real, non-negative functions of the characteristic momentum. For the harmonic oscillator in particular, a somewhat broad distribution is found, peaked at value of momentum that corresponds to a classical energy which in turn equals the energy eigenvalue for the state being described.
We apply the theory of stochastic electrodynamics to the study of the (nonrelativistic) harmonic oscillator by using the Fokker–Planck method. It is demonstrated that the equilibrium distribution in phase space is exactly equal to that given by quantum statistical mechanics, i.e., the corresponding Wigner distribution, and that analysis of this distribution by means of a decomposition in terms of canonical densities leads automatically to the usual description of quantum mechanics in terms of excited states. All fundamental equations of quantum mechanics are recovered as aprproximations to zero order in the radiation terms; the first-order terms lead to the radiative corrections predicted by quantum electrodynamics, namely, the decay of states and the Lamb shift of the energy levels. The necessary differences between both treatments of the oscillator and their implications are briefly discussed.
By the time a student of physics is ready to tackle quantum mechanics he has become familiar with the classical harmonic vibrator through many examples, and knows the crucial role it played in the development of Planck's ideas. It is natural then to concentrate on the mathematical aspects of the harmonic oscillator equation in quantum mechanics, the solution of Schrödinger's equation, normalization of the wave-function, calculation of mean values and of matrix elements, leaving the physics to look after itself. At a more advanced level the harmonic vibrator provides the entry into field theories, second quantization etc., and as a general rule it tends to be viewed more as a vehicle for instruction in more interesting matters than as a physical system having its own considerable interest and importance. Here we shall seek to redress the balance and study the vibrator as a thing in itself, without losing sight of the variety of physical problems to which the results can be applied. One especially important set of applications, however, will get little attention at this stage – the vibrations of compound bodies and of extended physical systems provide such wealth of interest as to justify a volume to themselves; and it is to such matters that the whole of the third part of this work will be devoted. As soon as one begins to contemplate the harmonic vibrator one becomes aware of the exceptional nature of its behaviour, in that it conforms more closely than any other system to the classical rules.
A wave dynamics of fields φ(p, q; t) ∈ L2(Γ) over the phase space Γ(p, q) of a classical system 𝒮 is derived from the Liouville theorem. We define the energy contained in a given field φ(p, q; t). We show that for a special class of fields, selected on physical grounds, the energy spectrum is given by a time-independent Schrödinger equation. This allows us to associate with 𝒮 an ordinary quantum system Q such that the values of the quantized energy coincide for the fields in the phase space of 𝒮 and for Q. Then we make use of Wiener's stochastic integral based on the theory of Brownian motion to derive probabilities which are the same as those one would obtain through Born's statistical postulate of quantum theory. From this it follows that we can regard normalized fields φ(p, q; t) as ``probability amplitudes'' leading to a probability density function ρ(p, q; t) = φφ* in the sense of Gibbs' statistical mechanics. Our work therefore appears as a bridge between a statistical theory (in the sense of Gibbs) of a mechanical system 𝒮 and the usual quantum theory of the related quantum system Q.