Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Studies in the Philosophy of Science

Time as non‐observational knowledge: How to straighten outΔEΔt≥h

Constantin Antonopoulos

Published Jul 1, 1997• 2 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The Energy‐Time Uncertainty (ETU) has always been a problem‐ridden relation, its problems stemming uniquely from the perplexing question of how to understand this mysterious Δt. On the face of it (and, indeed, far deeper than that), we always know what time it is. Few theorists were ignorant of the fact that time in quantum mechanics is exogenously defined, in no ways intrinsically related to the system. Time in quantum theory is an independent parameter, which simply means independently known. In the early 1960s Aharonov (1961–64) and Bohm (1961–64) mounted a spirited attack against the ETU, which sealed its fate to the present date. By emphasising that time is always “well‐defined” in quantum theory, they were led to the conclusion that no ETU should exist, a view shared by many in the 1990s, if Busch (1990) is to be believed. In a similar vein, I emphasize that (a) physical systems occupy a particular energy state at a particular instant of time, if at all; (b) even in absence of all time‐measuring instruments, it is still trivially warranted that one can measure a system's energy as accurately as one pleases, and simply announce “The system's energy is exactly E NOW!”, a possibility which no quantum mechanics of any sort, or any physical theory whatsoever, can afford to tamper with or change, except circularly. One never loses one's own perception of time, when one measures the energy, a fact which no measurement conceivable can interfere with or affect. Both (a) and (b) uniquely entail that energy and time are compatible, if not indeed intimately interconnected, contrary to what the relevant uncertainty seems to affirm. In response to Aharonov's and Bohm's initial problem, I reinterpret ΔEΔt ≥ h, as directly derived from authentic quantum principles, without however having to assume a direct incompatibility between its related concepts, attributing their complementarity to conditions other than ordinarily assumed.

DOI
10.1080/02698599708573561

Related papers

The uncertainty relation between energy and time of measurement

Yurii I. Vorontsov

Contrary to a wide-spread impression, the possibility of measuring an energy in a finite time without changing its initial value (E' =E0) is not in contradiction with the principles of quantum mechanics. The relation Δ(E'-E0)Δt≥ holds only in the case when the energy of interaction between the quantum system in question and the apparatus is a function of a coordinate of the system. The condition for a nonperturbing energy measurement is that the interaction energy H1, of the system and the apparatus depend on the energy operator E and that the operators Ĥ and E commute. It is also possible to have a nonperturbing measurement in which the error in measuring the energy is so small that ΔE/Δt. Measurement of the energy of a given system is accompanied by an increase in the uncertainty Δe of the energy of the apparatus. The error ΔE in the measurement of the system's energy and the perturbation Δeof the energy of the apparatus are connected by the relations (ΔE + Δe) Δt≥ and ΔE Δe≥(/2Δt)2.

Soviet Physics Uspekhi•Feb 28, 1981•17 citations

Time in the Quantum Theory and the Uncertainty Relation for Time and Energy

Yakir Aharonov, David Böhm

Because time does not appear in Schr\"odinger's equation as an operator but only as a parameter, the time-energy uncertainty relation must be formulated in a special way. This problem has in fact been studied by many authors and we give a summary of their treatments. We then criticize the main conclusion of these treatments; viz., that in a measurement of energy carried out in a time interval, $\ensuremath{\Delta}t$, there must be a minimum uncertainty in the transfer of energy to the observed system, given by $\ensuremath{\Delta}({E}^{\ensuremath{'}}\ensuremath{-}E)>~\frac{h}{\ensuremath{\Delta}t}$. We show that this conclusion is erroneous in two respects. First, it is not consistent with the general principles of the quantum theory, which require that all uncertainty relations be expressible in terms of the mathematical formalism, i.e., by means of operators, wave functions, etc. Secondly, the examples of measurement processes that were used to derive the above uncertainty relation are not general enough. We then develop a systematic presentation of our own point of view, with regard to the role of time in the quantum theory, and give a concrete example of a measurement process not satisfying the above uncertainty relation.

Physical Review•Jun 1, 1961•476 citations

1 The Time–Energy Uncertainty Relation

Paul Busch

The time energy uncertainty relation has been a controversial issue since the advent of quantum theory, with respect to appropriate formalisation, validity and possible meanings. A comprehensive account of the development of this subject up to the 1980s is provided by a combination of the reviews of Jammer (1974), Bauer and Mello (1978), and Busch (1990). More recent reviews are concerned with different specific aspects of the subject. The purpose of this chapter is to show that different types of time energy uncertainty relation can indeed be deduced in specific contexts, but that there is no unique universal relation that could stand on equal footing with the position-momentum uncertainty relation. To this end, we will survey the various formulations of a time energy uncertainty relation, with a brief assessment of their validity, and along the way we will indicate some new developments that emerged since the 1990s.

•May 11, 2001•81 citations

Quantum properties that are extended in time

Jeff Tollaksen

This paper focuses on "time-extended" properties that quantum mechanics represents as existing at a given moment, but which cannot be measured at a given moment. Several examples are presented in which the energy cannot be measured in a short time. The essence of these examples is an attempt to measure the momenta (or the energy) of an ideal quantum clock by having an interaction that lasts only a short time, where this short time is defined with respect to the internal time which is conjugate to this momenta. However, this momenta and this time cannot both be definite at once, even though quantum mechanics claims that a definite energy should be definite at a definite time. However, the momenta can be definite at a definite external parameter time, rather than this internal time. From the internal perspective, however, it is shown that the energy cannot be defined at a given internal time and therefore, this aspect of "time-extension" is completely quantum in origin, unlike the classical aspect of "energy is frequency." An additional consequence of time extended properties is that the connection between the internal time before and after the energy measurement is made uncertain. This suggests that the complementarity between energy and time is deeper than the notion that precise measurements of energy take a long time. Going beyond the "negative" statements about what cannot be measured (which characterize most of the discussions of the energy-time uncertainty relation), a positive aspect of ΔEΔt > 1 is demonstrated in a closed system based on causality. In this example, if one were to argue that energy really existed at a definite moment in time, then causality could be called into question. The standard understanding of the relationship between energy and time is that if the energy is conserved then we can calculate what the energy is at any point in time and thus we should be able to speak about energy as actually existing at that definite moment in time. This section challenges that assertion and is motivated by the question: "is there an example in physics of a property that the formalism tells us exists at a given moment, but which cannot be checked at a given time?"

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•Apr 27, 2007•4 citations

On Entropic Uncertainty Relations for Measurements of Energy and Its “Complement”

Alexey E. Rastegin

Abstract Heisenberg's uncertainty principle in application to energy and time is a powerful heuristics. This statement plays an important role in foundations of quantum theory and statistical physics. If some state exists for a finite interval of time, then it cannot have a completely definite value of energy. It is well known that the case of energy and time principally differs from more familiar examples of two non‐commuting observables. Since quantum theory was originated, many approaches to energy–time uncertainties have been proposed. Entropic way to formulate the uncertainty principle is currently the subject of active researches. Using the Pegg concept of complementarity of the Hamiltonian, uncertainty relations of the “energy–time” type are obtained in terms of Rényi and Tsallis entropies. Although this concept is somehow restricted in scope, derived relations can be applied to systems typically used in quantum information processing. Both the state‐dependent and state‐independent formulations are of interest. Some of the derived state‐independent bounds are similar to the results obtained within a more general approach on the basis of sandwiched relative entropies. The developed method allows us to address the case of detection inefficiencies.

arXiv:1807.11413•Annalen der Physik•Feb 10, 2019•8 citations

Exploring the implications of the uncertainty relationships in quantum mechanics

Huai‐Yu Wang

Heisenberg guessed, after he established the matrix quantum mechanics, that the non-commutativity of the matrices of position and momentum implied that the position and momentum of a particle could not be precisely simultaneously determined. He consequently conjectured that time and energy should also have a similar relationship. Soon after, Robertson derived an inequality concerning the space coordinate and momentum, which was thought to be the mathematical expression of the uncertainty relation guessed by Heisenberg. Since then, people have tried various devices to prove the correctness of these two relations. However, no one conducted a careful analysis of Heisenberg’s primary paper. In this work, we point out some serious problems in Heisenberg’s paper and the literature talking about the uncertainty relationships: the physical concepts involved in the uncertainty relations are not clear; one physical concept had more than one explanation, i.e., switching concepts; there has never been measurement experiment to support the relations. The conclusions are that the so-called coordinate–momentum uncertainty relation has never been related to actual measurement and there does not exist a time–energy uncertainty relation.

Frontiers in Physics•Dec 8, 2022•4 citations
The Energy‐Time Uncertainty (ETU) has always been a problem‐ridden relation, its problems stemming uniquely from the perplexing question of how to understand this mysterious Δt. On the face of it (and, indeed, far deeper than that), we always know what time it is. Few theorists were ignorant of the fact that time in quantum mechanics is exogenously defined, in no ways intrinsically related to the system. Time in quantum theory is an independent parameter, which simply means independently known. In the early 1960s Aharonov (1961–64) and Bohm (1961–64) mounted a spirited attack against the ETU, which sealed its fate to the present date. By emphasising that time is always “well‐defined” in quantum theory, they were led to the conclusion that no ETU should exist, a view shared by many in the 1990s, if Busch (1990) is to be believed. In a similar vein, I emphasize that (a) physical systems occupy a particular energy state at a particular instant of time, if at all; (b) even in absence of all time‐measuring instruments, it is still trivially warranted that one can measure a system's energy as accurately as one pleases, and simply announce “The system's energy is exactly E NOW!”, a possibility which no quantum mechanics of any sort, or any physical theory whatsoever, can afford to tamper with or change, except circularly. One never loses one's own perception of time, when one measures the energy, a fact which no measurement conceivable can interfere with or affect. Both (a) and (b) uniquely entail that energy and time are compatible, if not indeed intimately interconnected, contrary to what the relevant uncertainty seems to affirm. In response to Aharonov's and Bohm's initial problem, I reinterpret ΔEΔt ≥ h, as directly derived from authentic quantum principles, without however having to assume a direct incompatibility between its related concepts, attributing their complementarity to conditions other than ordinarily assumed.
Contrary to a wide-spread impression, the possibility of measuring an energy in a finite time without changing its initial value (E' =E0) is not in contradiction with the principles of quantum mechanics. The relation Δ(E'-E0)Δt≥ holds only in the case when the energy of interaction between the quantum system in question and the apparatus is a function of a coordinate of the system. The condition for a nonperturbing energy measurement is that the interaction energy H1, of the system and the apparatus depend on the energy operator E and that the operators Ĥ and E commute. It is also possible to have a nonperturbing measurement in which the error in measuring the energy is so small that ΔE/Δt. Measurement of the energy of a given system is accompanied by an increase in the uncertainty Δe of the energy of the apparatus. The error ΔE in the measurement of the system's energy and the perturbation Δeof the energy of the apparatus are connected by the relations (ΔE + Δe) Δt≥ and ΔE Δe≥(/2Δt)2.
Because time does not appear in Schr\"odinger's equation as an operator but only as a parameter, the time-energy uncertainty relation must be formulated in a special way. This problem has in fact been studied by many authors and we give a summary of their treatments. We then criticize the main conclusion of these treatments; viz., that in a measurement of energy carried out in a time interval, $\ensuremath{\Delta}t$, there must be a minimum uncertainty in the transfer of energy to the observed system, given by $\ensuremath{\Delta}({E}^{\ensuremath{'}}\ensuremath{-}E)>~\frac{h}{\ensuremath{\Delta}t}$. We show that this conclusion is erroneous in two respects. First, it is not consistent with the general principles of the quantum theory, which require that all uncertainty relations be expressible in terms of the mathematical formalism, i.e., by means of operators, wave functions, etc. Secondly, the examples of measurement processes that were used to derive the above uncertainty relation are not general enough. We then develop a systematic presentation of our own point of view, with regard to the role of time in the quantum theory, and give a concrete example of a measurement process not satisfying the above uncertainty relation.
The time energy uncertainty relation has been a controversial issue since the advent of quantum theory, with respect to appropriate formalisation, validity and possible meanings. A comprehensive account of the development of this subject up to the 1980s is provided by a combination of the reviews of Jammer (1974), Bauer and Mello (1978), and Busch (1990). More recent reviews are concerned with different specific aspects of the subject. The purpose of this chapter is to show that different types of time energy uncertainty relation can indeed be deduced in specific contexts, but that there is no unique universal relation that could stand on equal footing with the position-momentum uncertainty relation. To this end, we will survey the various formulations of a time energy uncertainty relation, with a brief assessment of their validity, and along the way we will indicate some new developments that emerged since the 1990s.
This paper focuses on "time-extended" properties that quantum mechanics represents as existing at a given moment, but which cannot be measured at a given moment. Several examples are presented in which the energy cannot be measured in a short time. The essence of these examples is an attempt to measure the momenta (or the energy) of an ideal quantum clock by having an interaction that lasts only a short time, where this short time is defined with respect to the internal time which is conjugate to this momenta. However, this momenta and this time cannot both be definite at once, even though quantum mechanics claims that a definite energy should be definite at a definite time. However, the momenta can be definite at a definite external parameter time, rather than this internal time. From the internal perspective, however, it is shown that the energy cannot be defined at a given internal time and therefore, this aspect of "time-extension" is completely quantum in origin, unlike the classical aspect of "energy is frequency." An additional consequence of time extended properties is that the connection between the internal time before and after the energy measurement is made uncertain. This suggests that the complementarity between energy and time is deeper than the notion that precise measurements of energy take a long time. Going beyond the "negative" statements about what cannot be measured (which characterize most of the discussions of the energy-time uncertainty relation), a positive aspect of ΔEΔt > 1 is demonstrated in a closed system based on causality. In this example, if one were to argue that energy really existed at a definite moment in time, then causality could be called into question. The standard understanding of the relationship between energy and time is that if the energy is conserved then we can calculate what the energy is at any point in time and thus we should be able to speak about energy as actually existing at that definite moment in time. This section challenges that assertion and is motivated by the question: "is there an example in physics of a property that the formalism tells us exists at a given moment, but which cannot be checked at a given time?"
Abstract Heisenberg's uncertainty principle in application to energy and time is a powerful heuristics. This statement plays an important role in foundations of quantum theory and statistical physics. If some state exists for a finite interval of time, then it cannot have a completely definite value of energy. It is well known that the case of energy and time principally differs from more familiar examples of two non‐commuting observables. Since quantum theory was originated, many approaches to energy–time uncertainties have been proposed. Entropic way to formulate the uncertainty principle is currently the subject of active researches. Using the Pegg concept of complementarity of the Hamiltonian, uncertainty relations of the “energy–time” type are obtained in terms of Rényi and Tsallis entropies. Although this concept is somehow restricted in scope, derived relations can be applied to systems typically used in quantum information processing. Both the state‐dependent and state‐independent formulations are of interest. Some of the derived state‐independent bounds are similar to the results obtained within a more general approach on the basis of sandwiched relative entropies. The developed method allows us to address the case of detection inefficiencies.
Heisenberg guessed, after he established the matrix quantum mechanics, that the non-commutativity of the matrices of position and momentum implied that the position and momentum of a particle could not be precisely simultaneously determined. He consequently conjectured that time and energy should also have a similar relationship. Soon after, Robertson derived an inequality concerning the space coordinate and momentum, which was thought to be the mathematical expression of the uncertainty relation guessed by Heisenberg. Since then, people have tried various devices to prove the correctness of these two relations. However, no one conducted a careful analysis of Heisenberg’s primary paper. In this work, we point out some serious problems in Heisenberg’s paper and the literature talking about the uncertainty relationships: the physical concepts involved in the uncertainty relations are not clear; one physical concept had more than one explanation, i.e., switching concepts; there has never been measurement experiment to support the relations. The conclusions are that the so-called coordinate–momentum uncertainty relation has never been related to actual measurement and there does not exist a time–energy uncertainty relation.