If a classical system has infinitely many degrees of freedom, its Hamiltonian quantization need not be unique up to unitary equivalence. I sketch different approaches (Hilbert space and algebraic) to understanding the content of quantum theories in light of this non-uniqueness, and suggest that neither approach suffices to support explanatory aspirations encountered in the thermodynamic limit of quantum statistical mechanics.
If a classical system has infinitely many degrees of freedom, its Hamiltonian quantization need not be unique up to unitary equivalence. I sketch different approaches (Hilbert space and algebraic) to understanding the content of quantum theories in light of this non-uniqueness, and suggest that neither approach suffices to support explanatory aspirations encountered in the thermodynamic limit of quantum statistical mechanics.
Quantum systems with infinite degrees of freedom exhibit properties, like relaxation to equilibrium, phase-transitions and the existence of inequivalent representations of the CAR and CCR , that can satisfactorily be dealt with by means of the methods and techniques of algebraic quantum statistical mechanics [80, 81, 130]. The point of departure from standard quantum mechanics, is that in an infinite dimensional context one is usually provided with the algebraic properties of the relevant observables, but, in general, not with an a priori given representation on a Hilbert space; the latter rather depends on to the physical properties of the systems under consideration [324, 342, 343].
There has been much debate about how the semantic content of quantum theories with infinitely many degrees of freedom ought to be understood. This article focuses instead on the epistemological status of the limit of infinite degrees of freedom. Do we have strong grounds to believe that the actual world is an infinite quantum system? I consider two types of argument for thinking that we do: indispensability arguments, which appeal to the role that unitarily inequivalent Hilbert space representations play in accounting for physical phenomena like spontaneous symmetry breaking, and what I call extrapolation arguments, which support the physical significance of the limit of infinite degrees of freedom by pointing to infinite volume cosmological models. Neither of these strategies turns out to be conclusive as they stand, leaving the relevance of novel features of infinite quantum systems to real-world physics murky. I go on to discuss ways of motivating foundational work on infinite quantum systems that do not turn on the representational veracity of these features, and point out that when it comes to the question of the epistemological status of unitarily inequivalent Hilbert space representations, other sources of non-uniqueness than the limit of infinite degrees of freedom must also be considered.
Philosophical debate on the measurement problem of quantum mechanics has, for the most part, been confined to the non-relativistic version of the theory. Quantizing quantum field theory, or making quantum mechanics relativistic, yields a conceptual framework capable of dealing with the creation and annihilation of an indefinite number of particles in interaction with fields, i.e. quantum systems with an infinite number of degrees of freedom. I want to show that a solution to the standard measurement problem is available if we exploit the properties of the infinite quantum models available in this broader conceptual framework. There is a qualitative difference between quantum systems with an infinite number of degrees of freedom and quantum systems with a finite number of degrees of freedom. In the infinite case, there exist many unitarily inequivalent irreducible Hilbert space representations of the algebra of observables of the system. In the finite case, there is only one such representation.
This chapter presents three reasons to take quantum statistical mechanics to the thermodynamic limit, where the number of systems considered becomes infinite, in the form of three phenomena that can't be modeled short of the thermodynamic limit: ergodicity, phase structure, and broken symmetry. Focusing on phase structure, exemplified by ferromagnetism, the chapter documents a promising model of the phenomenon that makes use of unitarily inequivalent representations in a way rigid interpretations of QM∞, such as Hilbert Space Conservatism and Algebraic Imperialism, can't endorse. Taking a virtue of interpretation to be its capacity to sustain the explanatory aspirations of the theory interpreted, the chapter scores this as a strike against rigid interpretations.
One classical theory, as determined by an equation of motion or set of classical trajectories, can correspond to many unitarily {\em in}equivalent quantum theories upon canonical quantization. This arises from a remarkable ambiguity, not previously investigated, in the construction of the classical (and hence the quantized) Hamiltonian or Lagrangian. This ambiguity is illustrated for systems with one degree of freedom: An arbitrary function of the constants of motion can be introduced into this construction. For example, the nonrelativistic and relativistic free particles follow identical classical trajectories, but the Hamiltonians or Lagrangians, and the canonically quantized versions of these descriptions, are inequivalent. Inequivalent descriptions of other systems, such as the harmonic oscillator, are also readily obtained.
This thesis is an examination of the Algebraic Approach to Quantum Mechanics and its use in the description of infinite Quantum systems.This approach is based on the postulate that it is possible to set up a correspondence between Quantum systems and the mathematical theory of C*algebras.In Chapter 1 the theory of C*aIgebras and their representations is discussed.The main result isthe G.N.S. construction.In Chapter 2 the methods developed in Chapter 1 are applied to Quantum spin sytems.The C*alebra corresponding to a single spin is constructed and analyzed, and the G.N.S. representation for the state corresponding to a canonical ensemble with definite temperature is constructed.The discussion is then generalized to a two spin system, a multi spin system, and finally to a system consisting of an infinite number of spins.It is shown that the G.N.S. representations corresponding to different temperatures are unitarily equivalent for the finite system, while for the infinite system these representations become unitarily inequivalent.This example illustrates that classical variables, in this case the temperature, arise in quantum systems as labels that distinguish between different inequivalent representations of the Quantum algebra in the case of inifinitely many degrees of freedom.In Chapter 3 the algebraic description of a non-interactihg Bose gas is examined.The C.C.R. algebra is constructed.Methods developed by Araki and Woods are used to construct the state of the infinite Bose gas that has density p and in 0 which all particles have zero momentum.The representation constructed by Araki andWoods is shown to be the G.N.S. representation for this state.It is shown that for the infinite gas the GN.S. representations corresponding to different densities are unitarily inequivalent.Again a classical variable, the density in this case, arises as a label that distinguishes the different inequivalent representations.