Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

The photon picture of radiation transport

J. Rosato

Published Jul 14, 2010• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The photon picture of radiation transport is examined. Because the photon has no mass and spin one, a position operator for a photon particle cannot be defined properly. This lack leads to ambiguity if the radiative transfer equation is associated with a quantum transport equation for photons. The issue of photon nonlocalizability is discussed and illustrated through a wavefunction-based approach. It is next shown that the phase space formalism due to Wigner provides a suitable framework for a proper derivation of a photon transport equation from first principles.

DOI
10.1119/1.3377132

Related papers

Radiative Transfer and Atom Transport

Carsten Henkel

The report deals with classical and quantum descriptions of particles that interact with smooth random potentials, for example ultracold atoms in the dipole potential of an optical speckle pattern. In addition, a discussion of the link between Radiative Transfer theory and the underlying coherence theory of wave optics is presented. The Radiative Transfer Equation is shown to emerge as a limiting case of the Bethe-Salpeter Equation, and some next-order corrections are discussed.

arXiv:physics/0505023•May 3, 2005•5 citations

Photon wave mechanics and position eigenvectors

Margaret Hawton

One and two photon wave functions are derived by projecting the quantum state vector onto simultaneous eigenvectors of the number operator and a recently constructed photon position operator [Phys. Rev. A 59, 954 (1999)] that couples spin and orbital angular momentum. While only the Landau-Peierls wave function defines a positive definite photon density, a similarity transformation to a biorthogonal field-potential pair of positive frequency solutions of Maxwell's equations preserves eigenvalues and expectation values. We show that this real space description of photons is compatible with all of the usual rules of quantum mechanics and provides a framework for understanding the relationships amongst different forms of the photon wave function in the literature. It also gives a quantum picture of the optical angular momentum of beams that applies to both one photon and coherent states. According to the rules of quantum mechanics, this wave function gives the probability to count a photon at any position in space.

arXiv:0705.3196•Physical Review A•Jun 15, 2007•37 citations

Localization of relativistic particles

Roland L. Omnes

In order to discuss localization experiments and also to extend the consistent history interpretation of quantum mechanics to relativistic properties, the techniques introduced in a previous paper [J. Math. Phys. 38, 697 (1997)] are applied to the localization of a photon in a given region of space. An essential requirement is to exclude arbitrarily large wavelengths. The method is valid for a particle with any mass and spin. Though there is no proper position operator for a photon, one never needs one in practice. Causality is valid up to exponentially small corrections.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Feb 1, 1997•10 citations

V Photon Wave Function

Iwo Białynicki‐Birula

This chapter describes the photon wave function, and explains the basic properties of a well-defined mathematical object—a six-component function of space-time variables—that describes the quantum state of the photon. The most essential property that does not hold for the photon wave function is that the argument of the wave function cannot be directly associated with the position operator of the photon. The position operator for the photon simply does not exist. However, one should remember that for massive particles also, the true position operator exists only in the nonrelativistic approximation. The concept of localization associated with the Newton-Wigner position operator is not relativistically invariant. The photon wave function is not restricted to the wave mechanics of photons. The same wave functions also appear as mode functions in the expansion of the electromagnetic field operators.

Progress in optics•Jan 1, 1996•250 citations

Space-Time Position Operators

Arthur A. Broyles

A formalism is presented giving the development of $\ensuremath{\psi}(\overline{x})$ in time with the interpretation that $\ensuremath{\psi}(\overline{x})$ is the probability amplitude for observing an event at a space-time point $\overline{x}$. No properties other than the four space-time coordinates are associated with an event. A Hilbert space is defined in which $\ensuremath{\psi}(\overline{x})$ is the result of a scalar product. The space-time position operators defined in this Hilbert space have no association with particle properties, such as mass. These operators cannot be defined in the Hilbert space spanned by solutions of a Schr\"odinger equation, since the operators lead out of the Hilbert subspace belonging to a given mass. It is shown that state vectors in Hilbert space that are eigenvectors of ${P}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}{P}^{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ produce position amplitudes satisfying the Klein-Gordon equation. The relation between this Hilbert space and the one introduced by Dirac is discussed. Spin is not considered.

Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D. Particles and fields•Feb 15, 1970•22 citations

A Photon Viewed from Wigner Phase Space

Holger Mack, Wolfgang P. Schleich

We present a brief history of the photon and summarize the canonical procedure to quantize the radiation field. Our answer to the question what is a photon?. springs from the Wigner representation of quantum mechanics as applied to a single photon number state.

Optical science and engineering•Jul 25, 2008•3 citations
The photon picture of radiation transport is examined. Because the photon has no mass and spin one, a position operator for a photon particle cannot be defined properly. This lack leads to ambiguity if the radiative transfer equation is associated with a quantum transport equation for photons. The issue of photon nonlocalizability is discussed and illustrated through a wavefunction-based approach. It is next shown that the phase space formalism due to Wigner provides a suitable framework for a proper derivation of a photon transport equation from first principles.
One and two photon wave functions are derived by projecting the quantum state vector onto simultaneous eigenvectors of the number operator and a recently constructed photon position operator [Phys. Rev. A 59, 954 (1999)] that couples spin and orbital angular momentum. While only the Landau-Peierls wave function defines a positive definite photon density, a similarity transformation to a biorthogonal field-potential pair of positive frequency solutions of Maxwell's equations preserves eigenvalues and expectation values. We show that this real space description of photons is compatible with all of the usual rules of quantum mechanics and provides a framework for understanding the relationships amongst different forms of the photon wave function in the literature. It also gives a quantum picture of the optical angular momentum of beams that applies to both one photon and coherent states. According to the rules of quantum mechanics, this wave function gives the probability to count a photon at any position in space.
In order to discuss localization experiments and also to extend the consistent history interpretation of quantum mechanics to relativistic properties, the techniques introduced in a previous paper [J. Math. Phys. 38, 697 (1997)] are applied to the localization of a photon in a given region of space. An essential requirement is to exclude arbitrarily large wavelengths. The method is valid for a particle with any mass and spin. Though there is no proper position operator for a photon, one never needs one in practice. Causality is valid up to exponentially small corrections.
This chapter describes the photon wave function, and explains the basic properties of a well-defined mathematical object—a six-component function of space-time variables—that describes the quantum state of the photon. The most essential property that does not hold for the photon wave function is that the argument of the wave function cannot be directly associated with the position operator of the photon. The position operator for the photon simply does not exist. However, one should remember that for massive particles also, the true position operator exists only in the nonrelativistic approximation. The concept of localization associated with the Newton-Wigner position operator is not relativistically invariant. The photon wave function is not restricted to the wave mechanics of photons. The same wave functions also appear as mode functions in the expansion of the electromagnetic field operators.
A formalism is presented giving the development of $\ensuremath{\psi}(\overline{x})$ in time with the interpretation that $\ensuremath{\psi}(\overline{x})$ is the probability amplitude for observing an event at a space-time point x‾\overline{x}x. No properties other than the four space-time coordinates are associated with an event. A Hilbert space is defined in which $\ensuremath{\psi}(\overline{x})$ is the result of a scalar product. The space-time position operators defined in this Hilbert space have no association with particle properties, such as mass. These operators cannot be defined in the Hilbert space spanned by solutions of a Schr\"odinger equation, since the operators lead out of the Hilbert subspace belonging to a given mass. It is shown that state vectors in Hilbert space that are eigenvectors of ${P}_{\ensuremath{\mu}}{P}^{\ensuremath{\mu}}$ produce position amplitudes satisfying the Klein-Gordon equation. The relation between this Hilbert space and the one introduced by Dirac is discussed. Spin is not considered.