Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Minimal irreversible quantum mechanics: The mixed states and the diagonal singularity

Roberto Laura, Mario A Castagnino

Published Jun 1, 1998• 47 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A formalism for minimal irreversible quantum mechanics is extended from pure states to mixed states. In the latter case the problem of their diagonal singularity is explained and solved. In addition to the pure and mixed states of the usual approach, more general states are obtained. The Friedrichs model is studied. Decoherence is found and decoherence characteristic times are computed.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.57.4140

Related papers

Minimal irreversible quantum mechanics: Pure-state formalism

Mario A Castagnino, Roberto Laura

It is demonstrated that, making minimal changes in ordinary quantum mechanics, a reasonable irreversible quantum mechanics can be obtained. This theory has a more general spectral decomposition, with eigenvectors corresponding to unstable states that vanish when $t\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}.$ These Gamov vectors have zero norm, in such a way that the norm and the energy of the physical states remain constant. The evolution operator has no inverse, showing that we are really dealing with a time-asymmetric theory. Using the Friedrichs model, reasonable physical results are obtained, e.g., the remnant of an unstable decaying state reappears, in the continuous spectrum of the model, with its primitive energy.

arXiv:quant-ph/9612041•Physical Review A•Jul 1, 1997•55 citations

Stochastic mechanics of mixed states

Marc-Thierry Jaekel, D. Pignon

Nelson's stochastic interpretation of quantum mechanics is extended from the case of pure states to that of mixed states. It is shown that a pure probabilistic formalism, which applies the Newton-Nelson law to the initial position and velocity distributions, does not reproduce the time evolution predicted by quantum mechanics. In order to recover the latter, a new notion must be introduced, that of pure quantum states, over which the mixture has to be decomposed, and which then satisfy the Newton-Nelson law independently.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jan 11, 1984•7 citations

Single Subdynamics for the Friedrichs Model

Michel De Haan, Claude D. George

The compatibility of irreversibility, as expressed by the second law of thermodynamics, with ordinary quantum mechanics requires an extension of the latter. Such an extension of a reversible formalism is made possible by the presence of self-energy processes (already found in quantum electrodynamics), which allows for the widening of the dynamics through the introduction of specific additional variables leading to the recognition of such processes. A projection technique modeled on that introduced long ago by the Brussels group defines a subdynamics that is shown to contain the starting formulation in its entirety. (It corresponds to a restricted class of initial conditions, namely the reversible ones.) A new kinetic description is obtained in which, e.g., collision processes for privileged components arise from the original interaction. This method is applied successively to various models, and we focus in this paper on the possible presence of temporal behaviour excluded in ordinary quantum mechanics. Among the differences between this framework and that of ordinary quantum mechanics, the possibility appears for the purely exponential decay of a particle, while ordinary quantum mechanics requires long time tails associated with the finite lower bound in the spectrum of the Hamiltonian.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Jun 1, 2003•7 citations

Irreversibility and Quantum Measurement

Julio R. Gea-Banacloche

The role played by irreversible processes, at the microscopic scale, in several examples of quantum measurements is studied within a "minimally realist" interpretation of the quantum formalism introduced in a recent publication. The analysis extends and confirms the basic results of the earlier work: separation of the collapse and amplification phases of the measurement, and decoherence and collapse happening already as a consequence of irreversible microscopic processes at the level of the "probe" itself (typically an atom in the examples considered). Additionally, the proposed interpretation of the formalism is shown to be consistent with previous interpretations, and a case for true irreversibility in physics is argued in some detail.

Entropy•Sep 12, 2026•0 citations

Unitary Evolution between Pure and Mixed States

Benni Reznik

We propose an extended quantum mechanical formalism that is based on a wave operator $\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\varrho}}$, which is related to the ordinary density matrix via $\ensuremath{\rho}\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\varrho}}{\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\varrho}}}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}$. This formalism allows a (generalized) unitary evolution between pure and mixed states. It also preserves much of the connection between symmetries and conservation laws. The new formalism is illustrated for the case of a two-level system.

arXiv:quant-ph/9504019•Physical Review Letters•Feb 19, 1996•22 citations

Decoherence, irreversibility, and selection by decoherence of exclusive quantum states with definite probabilities

Roland L. Omnes

The problem investigated in this paper is einselection, i.e., the selection of mutually exclusive quantum states with definite probabilities through decoherence. Its study is based on a theory of decoherence resulting from the projection method in the quantum theory of irreversible processes, which is general enough for giving reliable predictions. This approach leads to a definition (or redefinition) of the coupling with the environment involving only fluctuations. The range of application of perturbation calculus is then wide, resulting in a rather general master equation. Two distinct cases of decoherence are then found: (i) a ``degenerate'' case (already encountered with solvable models) where decoherence amounts essentially to approximate diagonalization; (ii) a general case where the einselected states are essentially classical. They are mixed states. Their density operators are proportional to microlocal projection operators (or ``quasiprojectors'') that were previously introduced in the quantum expression of classical properties. It is found at various places that the main limitation in our understanding of decoherence is the lack of a systematic method for constructing collective observables.

arXiv:quant-ph/0304100•Physical Review A•May 8, 2002•65 citations
A formalism for minimal irreversible quantum mechanics is extended from pure states to mixed states. In the latter case the problem of their diagonal singularity is explained and solved. In addition to the pure and mixed states of the usual approach, more general states are obtained. The Friedrichs model is studied. Decoherence is found and decoherence characteristic times are computed.
It is demonstrated that, making minimal changes in ordinary quantum mechanics, a reasonable irreversible quantum mechanics can be obtained. This theory has a more general spectral decomposition, with eigenvectors corresponding to unstable states that vanish when $t\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}.$ These Gamov vectors have zero norm, in such a way that the norm and the energy of the physical states remain constant. The evolution operator has no inverse, showing that we are really dealing with a time-asymmetric theory. Using the Friedrichs model, reasonable physical results are obtained, e.g., the remnant of an unstable decaying state reappears, in the continuous spectrum of the model, with its primitive energy.
Nelson's stochastic interpretation of quantum mechanics is extended from the case of pure states to that of mixed states. It is shown that a pure probabilistic formalism, which applies the Newton-Nelson law to the initial position and velocity distributions, does not reproduce the time evolution predicted by quantum mechanics. In order to recover the latter, a new notion must be introduced, that of pure quantum states, over which the mixture has to be decomposed, and which then satisfy the Newton-Nelson law independently.
The compatibility of irreversibility, as expressed by the second law of thermodynamics, with ordinary quantum mechanics requires an extension of the latter. Such an extension of a reversible formalism is made possible by the presence of self-energy processes (already found in quantum electrodynamics), which allows for the widening of the dynamics through the introduction of specific additional variables leading to the recognition of such processes. A projection technique modeled on that introduced long ago by the Brussels group defines a subdynamics that is shown to contain the starting formulation in its entirety. (It corresponds to a restricted class of initial conditions, namely the reversible ones.) A new kinetic description is obtained in which, e.g., collision processes for privileged components arise from the original interaction. This method is applied successively to various models, and we focus in this paper on the possible presence of temporal behaviour excluded in ordinary quantum mechanics. Among the differences between this framework and that of ordinary quantum mechanics, the possibility appears for the purely exponential decay of a particle, while ordinary quantum mechanics requires long time tails associated with the finite lower bound in the spectrum of the Hamiltonian.
The role played by irreversible processes, at the microscopic scale, in several examples of quantum measurements is studied within a "minimally realist" interpretation of the quantum formalism introduced in a recent publication. The analysis extends and confirms the basic results of the earlier work: separation of the collapse and amplification phases of the measurement, and decoherence and collapse happening already as a consequence of irreversible microscopic processes at the level of the "probe" itself (typically an atom in the examples considered). Additionally, the proposed interpretation of the formalism is shown to be consistent with previous interpretations, and a case for true irreversibility in physics is argued in some detail.
We propose an extended quantum mechanical formalism that is based on a wave operator $\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\varrho}}$, which is related to the ordinary density matrix via $\ensuremath{\rho}\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}=\phantom{\rule{0ex}{0ex}}\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\varrho}}{\stackrel{^}{\ensuremath{\varrho}}}^{\ifmmode\dagger\else\textdagger\fi{}}$. This formalism allows a (generalized) unitary evolution between pure and mixed states. It also preserves much of the connection between symmetries and conservation laws. The new formalism is illustrated for the case of a two-level system.
The problem investigated in this paper is einselection, i.e., the selection of mutually exclusive quantum states with definite probabilities through decoherence. Its study is based on a theory of decoherence resulting from the projection method in the quantum theory of irreversible processes, which is general enough for giving reliable predictions. This approach leads to a definition (or redefinition) of the coupling with the environment involving only fluctuations. The range of application of perturbation calculus is then wide, resulting in a rather general master equation. Two distinct cases of decoherence are then found: (i) a ``degenerate'' case (already encountered with solvable models) where decoherence amounts essentially to approximate diagonalization; (ii) a general case where the einselected states are essentially classical. They are mixed states. Their density operators are proportional to microlocal projection operators (or ``quasiprojectors'') that were previously introduced in the quantum expression of classical properties. It is found at various places that the main limitation in our understanding of decoherence is the lack of a systematic method for constructing collective observables.