Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Chemical Physics

Investigation of the dynamics of two coupled oscillators with mixed quantum-classical methods

Jingrui Li, Clemens Woywod, Valérie Vallet, Christoph Meier

Published May 11, 2006• 6 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The dynamics of two coupled oscillators can become quite complex if anharmonic potential energy functions are employed. This type of system therefore represents a good model for an investigation of the performance of mixed quantum-classical methods. In this work, the motion of two coupled particles with a mass ratio of one to ten is studied with three different mixed quantum-classical methods in the presence of anharmonic potential terms for a comparison with exact quantum mechanical calculations. The mixed quantum-classical approaches include the multitrajectory Ehrenfest, the mixed quantum-classical Bohmian (MQCB), and the so-called coupled Schrödinger equations (CSE) formalisms. The analysis shows that while the description of a weakly anharmonic system by the Ehrenfest and MQCB schemes is accurate if proper sampling techniques are applied, both approximations break down rapidly if the anharmonic terms are increased. The performance of the simple CSE prescription, which corresponds to a reduction of the full two-dimensional wave function to two one-dimensional wave functions representing two quantum oscillators coupled via the potential energy in a classical fashion, decreases if the width of the initial wave packet is enlarged. The dependence of the CSE method on the diffuseness of the initial wave packet is therefore opposite to that of the MQCB method, which is more accurate for wide wave packets. Overall, the multitrajectory Ehrenfest ansatz is found to be most successful in reproducing the exact quantum results.

DOI
10.1063/1.2196408

Related papers

Mixing quantum and classical dynamics using Bohmian trajectories

Etienne Gindensperger, C. Meier, Juan Alberto Beswick

A novel time-dependent hybrid quantum/classical propagation scheme based on Bohmian quantum trajectories is presented. The quantum subsystem is described by a wave packet depending on the quantum variables x and, via the total potential energy of the system, parametrically on the classical trajectories X(t). The wave packet is used to calculate de Broglie–Bohm quantum trajectories x(t) which are used to calculate the force acting on the classical variables. Quantum corrections of the classical equation of motion are also included. The method is applied to a simple case of two coupled oscillators. Comparison between exact quantum and approximate results demonstrates that these MQCB (Mixed Quantum/Classical Bohmian) trajectories provide a good description of the energy exchange between the two oscillators.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Dec 1, 2000•130 citations

Quantum-classical dynamics including continuum states using quantum trajectories

Etienne Gindensperger, C. Meier, Juan Alberto Beswick

We apply the MQCB (mixed quantum/classical mechanics based on Bohmian trajectories) [E. Gindensperger, C. Meier, and J. A. Beswick, J. Chem. Phys. 113, 9369 (2000)] to the case where the quantum degree of freedom contains both bound and continuum states. The quantum degree of freedom is treated by a wave packet that is propagated on a spatial grid with a Hamiltonian that depends parametrically on the classical degrees of freedom, while the classical degrees of freedom themselves are coupled to the wave function via quantum trajectories. The method is applied to a simple model of a light particle colliding with a heavy (classical) particle absorbed on a surface, which has been used by other authors to develop methods to combine quantum degrees of freedom including continuum states with classical mechanics. The results are compared to the Ehrenfest mean-field method as well as to full quantum results.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Jan 1, 2002•42 citations

Nonadiabatic dynamics via the classical limit Schrödinger equation

John C. Burant, John C. Tully

The coupled Schrödinger equations that describe nonadiabatic dynamics are recast using the Bohm formulation of quantum mechanics. The resulting coupled Bohm equations are solved numerically for two scattering models, giving results that are essentially identical to wave-packet solution of the original coupled Schrödinger equations. The classical limit of the set of coupled Bohm equations is then described, producing a mixed quantum-classical theory incorporating classical-like motion on each potential energy surface accompanied by quantum transitions between the quantum states. Numerical tests of the mixed quantum-classical method are in excellent agreement with the accurate full-quantum results for the model problems. The method is contrasted with the related surface-hopping approach. It is shown that computing the dynamics of a distribution of classical particles is more consistent and more accurate than computing the motion of independent point particles as with surface hopping.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Apr 8, 2000•103 citations

On the Classical Schrödinger Equation

Albert Benseny, David Tena, Xavier Oriols

In this paper, the classical Schrödinger equation (CSE), which allows the study of classical dynamics in terms of wave functions, is analyzed theoretically and numerically. First, departing from classical (Newtonian) mechanics, and assuming an additional single-valued condition for the Hamilton’s principal function, the CSE is obtained. This additional assumption implies inherent non-classical features on the description of the dynamics obtained from the CSE: the trajectories do not cross in the configuration space. Second, departing from Bohmian mechanics and invoking the quantum-to-classical transition, the CSE is obtained in a natural way for the center of mass of a quantum system with a large number of identical particles. This quantum development imposes the condition of dealing with a narrow wave packet, which implicitly avoids the non-classical features mentioned above. We illustrate all the above points with numerical simulations of the classical and quantum Schrödinger equations for different systems.

arXiv:1607.00168•Fluctuation and Noise Letters•Sep 1, 2016•17 citations

Variational and coupled-cluster calculations of the spectra of anharmonic oscillators

R. F. Bishop, M. F. Flynn

Using the general anharmonic oscillator as a case study, we examine the coupled-cluster method (CCM) in some detail. Emphasis is specially placed on the accuracy of the standard ground-state energy calculation and the excitation spectrum as derived via the Emrich ansatz. We are particularly interested in problems that can arise from large differences between the exact wave function and its model counterpart that forms the starting point of the CCM. To this end we begin with a variational Hartree approximation applied to three particular anharmonic-oscillator Hamiltonians that contain, respectively, pure quartic, equally weighted cubic and quartic, and double-well perturbations. These are chosen to provide increasingly stringent tests for the CCM in the above sense. Considerable attention is paid to the variational description of the double-well case, where the various possible solutions to the Hartree equations are considered and a further calculation on the energy-level splitting is performed. The CCM is then used to improve systematically upon our chosen starting point and is shown, particularly for the ground state, both to produce extremely accurate results and to be rather resilient to even gross deficiencies in the starting wave function. The main problem is the double-well system, where the CCM shows its lack of intrinsic inbuilt tunneling mechanisms via the absence of level splitting. Even here the CCM still produces very accurate average energies for very deep wells. While clearly needing some modification in such extreme cases, the CCM is shown to be quite adaptable and robust with regard to inaccurate starting wave functions.

Physical Review A•Sep 1, 1988•52 citations

Short time dynamics of harmonic oscillator coherent states in anharmonic systems. I. One-dimensional motion

Jürgen Brickmann

The dynamics of an initially excital Gaussian wave packet (harmonic oscillator coherent state, HOCS) in a general one-dimensional anharmonic system is studied analytically with the aid of a second quantization formalism for times shorter than a classical oscillation period. The initial state population probability PQ(t), its classical counterpart PC(t), and the overlap probability PQC(t) between a time evolved wave packet and a classically moving Gaussian with stationary shape are calculated in order to analyze the spreading of the wave packet. It was found that, in general, PQ(t) and PC(t) agree very well if the potential energy function has no strongly changing low order derivatives. This agreement is held even if the wave packet spreads drastically within the time scale considered as can be demonstrated by analyzing PQC(t). The analytical expressions for PQ(t), PC(t), and PQC(t) are applied to a dissociative third-order oscillator and a strongly anharmonic fourth-order oscillator. While for a harmonic system, the initial decay time of PQ(t) and PC(t) (which are identical in this case) are only dependent on the energy expectation value 〈H〉 with respect to the initial HOCS, differences up to an order of magnitude occur for HOCS with the same energy in the model systems.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Feb 15, 1983•22 citations
The dynamics of two coupled oscillators can become quite complex if anharmonic potential energy functions are employed. This type of system therefore represents a good model for an investigation of the performance of mixed quantum-classical methods. In this work, the motion of two coupled particles with a mass ratio of one to ten is studied with three different mixed quantum-classical methods in the presence of anharmonic potential terms for a comparison with exact quantum mechanical calculations. The mixed quantum-classical approaches include the multitrajectory Ehrenfest, the mixed quantum-classical Bohmian (MQCB), and the so-called coupled Schrödinger equations (CSE) formalisms. The analysis shows that while the description of a weakly anharmonic system by the Ehrenfest and MQCB schemes is accurate if proper sampling techniques are applied, both approximations break down rapidly if the anharmonic terms are increased. The performance of the simple CSE prescription, which corresponds to a reduction of the full two-dimensional wave function to two one-dimensional wave functions representing two quantum oscillators coupled via the potential energy in a classical fashion, decreases if the width of the initial wave packet is enlarged. The dependence of the CSE method on the diffuseness of the initial wave packet is therefore opposite to that of the MQCB method, which is more accurate for wide wave packets. Overall, the multitrajectory Ehrenfest ansatz is found to be most successful in reproducing the exact quantum results.
A novel time-dependent hybrid quantum/classical propagation scheme based on Bohmian quantum trajectories is presented. The quantum subsystem is described by a wave packet depending on the quantum variables x and, via the total potential energy of the system, parametrically on the classical trajectories X(t). The wave packet is used to calculate de Broglie–Bohm quantum trajectories x(t) which are used to calculate the force acting on the classical variables. Quantum corrections of the classical equation of motion are also included. The method is applied to a simple case of two coupled oscillators. Comparison between exact quantum and approximate results demonstrates that these MQCB (Mixed Quantum/Classical Bohmian) trajectories provide a good description of the energy exchange between the two oscillators.
We apply the MQCB (mixed quantum/classical mechanics based on Bohmian trajectories) [E. Gindensperger, C. Meier, and J. A. Beswick, J. Chem. Phys. 113, 9369 (2000)] to the case where the quantum degree of freedom contains both bound and continuum states. The quantum degree of freedom is treated by a wave packet that is propagated on a spatial grid with a Hamiltonian that depends parametrically on the classical degrees of freedom, while the classical degrees of freedom themselves are coupled to the wave function via quantum trajectories. The method is applied to a simple model of a light particle colliding with a heavy (classical) particle absorbed on a surface, which has been used by other authors to develop methods to combine quantum degrees of freedom including continuum states with classical mechanics. The results are compared to the Ehrenfest mean-field method as well as to full quantum results.
The coupled Schrödinger equations that describe nonadiabatic dynamics are recast using the Bohm formulation of quantum mechanics. The resulting coupled Bohm equations are solved numerically for two scattering models, giving results that are essentially identical to wave-packet solution of the original coupled Schrödinger equations. The classical limit of the set of coupled Bohm equations is then described, producing a mixed quantum-classical theory incorporating classical-like motion on each potential energy surface accompanied by quantum transitions between the quantum states. Numerical tests of the mixed quantum-classical method are in excellent agreement with the accurate full-quantum results for the model problems. The method is contrasted with the related surface-hopping approach. It is shown that computing the dynamics of a distribution of classical particles is more consistent and more accurate than computing the motion of independent point particles as with surface hopping.
In this paper, the classical Schrödinger equation (CSE), which allows the study of classical dynamics in terms of wave functions, is analyzed theoretically and numerically. First, departing from classical (Newtonian) mechanics, and assuming an additional single-valued condition for the Hamilton’s principal function, the CSE is obtained. This additional assumption implies inherent non-classical features on the description of the dynamics obtained from the CSE: the trajectories do not cross in the configuration space. Second, departing from Bohmian mechanics and invoking the quantum-to-classical transition, the CSE is obtained in a natural way for the center of mass of a quantum system with a large number of identical particles. This quantum development imposes the condition of dealing with a narrow wave packet, which implicitly avoids the non-classical features mentioned above. We illustrate all the above points with numerical simulations of the classical and quantum Schrödinger equations for different systems.
Using the general anharmonic oscillator as a case study, we examine the coupled-cluster method (CCM) in some detail. Emphasis is specially placed on the accuracy of the standard ground-state energy calculation and the excitation spectrum as derived via the Emrich ansatz. We are particularly interested in problems that can arise from large differences between the exact wave function and its model counterpart that forms the starting point of the CCM. To this end we begin with a variational Hartree approximation applied to three particular anharmonic-oscillator Hamiltonians that contain, respectively, pure quartic, equally weighted cubic and quartic, and double-well perturbations. These are chosen to provide increasingly stringent tests for the CCM in the above sense. Considerable attention is paid to the variational description of the double-well case, where the various possible solutions to the Hartree equations are considered and a further calculation on the energy-level splitting is performed. The CCM is then used to improve systematically upon our chosen starting point and is shown, particularly for the ground state, both to produce extremely accurate results and to be rather resilient to even gross deficiencies in the starting wave function. The main problem is the double-well system, where the CCM shows its lack of intrinsic inbuilt tunneling mechanisms via the absence of level splitting. Even here the CCM still produces very accurate average energies for very deep wells. While clearly needing some modification in such extreme cases, the CCM is shown to be quite adaptable and robust with regard to inaccurate starting wave functions.
The dynamics of an initially excital Gaussian wave packet (harmonic oscillator coherent state, HOCS) in a general one-dimensional anharmonic system is studied analytically with the aid of a second quantization formalism for times shorter than a classical oscillation period. The initial state population probability PQ(t), its classical counterpart PC(t), and the overlap probability PQC(t) between a time evolved wave packet and a classically moving Gaussian with stationary shape are calculated in order to analyze the spreading of the wave packet. It was found that, in general, PQ(t) and PC(t) agree very well if the potential energy function has no strongly changing low order derivatives. This agreement is held even if the wave packet spreads drastically within the time scale considered as can be demonstrated by analyzing PQC(t). The analytical expressions for PQ(t), PC(t), and PQC(t) are applied to a dissociative third-order oscillator and a strongly anharmonic fourth-order oscillator. While for a harmonic system, the initial decay time of PQ(t) and PC(t) (which are identical in this case) are only dependent on the energy expectation value 〈H〉 with respect to the initial HOCS, differences up to an order of magnitude occur for HOCS with the same energy in the model systems.