Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Single-Particle Energies in the Many-Fermion System

D. J. Thouless

Published Jun 15, 1959• 15 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We have examined the ground state of the many-fermion system, using perturbation theory, with particular attention to Brueckner's method. A study of the single-particle propagators in the ground state of the system sheds some light on the relation between the single-particle energies used, for example, in the optical model of nuclear reactions, and Brucekner's self-consistent energies. This leads naturally to the use of a renormalization factor to allow for propagation off the energy shell. It is possible to formulate the perturbation theory entirely in terms of graphs with no fermion self-energy parts, and this method is used to examine the approximations used for this problem, and to relate more closely the calculations of the ground-state energy and of other properties of the ground state.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.114.1383

Related papers

Variational Methods and the Nuclear Many-Body Problem

R. Brout

The general form of the energy of the ground state of a many-fermion system is shown to be exactly of the form proposed by Brueckner and Bethe, without approximation. In a variational treatment, if the trial wave function is picked containing only pair correlations, together with all possible unlinked pairs, it is described by a two-body excitation matrix $〈{m}_{1}{m}_{2}|A|{p}_{1}{p}_{2}〉$. Variation of this matrix in the Ritz-Rayleigh principle yields a set of integral equations of the scattering type for the matrix $A$. Hole-state energies are given self-consistently in terms of the matrix $A$, but particle-state energies are Hartree-Fock energies. This may be corrected for by widely enlarging the class of terms admitted into the wave function. If the approximation is then made of omitting a class of terms, defined as cross-linked clusters in $〈\ensuremath{\psi}|H|\ensuremath{\psi}〉$, the particle-state energies are easily renormalized. Variation then leads to an infinite hierarchy of integral equations.

Physical Review•Sep 1, 1958•22 citations

Analytic Properties of Single-Particle Propagators for Many-Fermion Systems

J. M. Luttinger

Certain general properties of single-particle propagators for a system of interacting fermions are derived. In addition, the properties of the proper self-energy part ${G}_{k}(\ensuremath{\zeta})$ which were used in previous work on the ground-state energy and on the Fermi surface are established. In particular, the fact that to all orders of perturbation theory in the interaction, $\mathrm{Im} {G}_{k}(x\ensuremath{-}i{0}^{+})$ behaves like ${C}_{k}{(x\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\mu})}^{2}$ (${C}_{k}>0$) for $x$ very near $\ensuremath{\mu}$, is proved.

Physical Review•Feb 15, 1961•359 citations

Perturbation Theory for an Infinite Medium of Fermions. II

Abraham Klein

New forms of the linked cluster expansion for the ground-state energy of a normal spherical system are given in terms of the exact single-particle propagator and of the associated self-energy operator. These forms are shown to be stationary with respect to variations of the latter quantities. A new concise proof of the Hugenholtz-Van Hove theorem on single-particle energies is then possible. The variational principle also explains the insensitivity of recent binding energy calculations to the choice of single-particle energies. It is shown how all results may be extended to systems with anisotropic features.

Physical Review•Feb 15, 1961•99 citations

Ground-State Energy of a Many-Fermion System. II

J. M. Luttinger, John Ward

The perturbation series for the ground-state energy of a many-fermion system is investigated to arbitrary order for the "isotropic" case. This is the case of over-all spherical symmetry, both in the interaction and in the unperturbed single particle energies. It is shown that for spin one-half fermions the Brueckner-Goldstone perturbation series is valid to all orders in the perturbation. For spins greater than one-half it is in general incorrect even in the isotropic case, unless the interactions are spin independent.The discussion to arbitrary order in the interaction is carried out by means of a Feynman-like propagator formalism, which is developed in detail.

Physical Review•Jun 1, 1960•1,712 citations

Λ10 Approximation for Self-Bound Many-Fermion Systems

Robert D. Puff, A.S. Reiner, L. Wilets

We investigate several approximations for self-bound many-fermion systems, each of which employs the Green's-function formalism together with a suitable factorization to close the otherwise infinite hierarchy of coupled integral equations. The particular approximations, which attempt to include the important two-body correlations for short-range forces, differ in the choice of propagator $\ensuremath{\Lambda}$ for two-particle intermediate states in the $T$ matrix used to calculate the two-body correlation function. The advantages and shortcomings of the choice ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{00}\ensuremath{\sim}{{G}_{1}}^{0}{{G}_{1}}^{0}$ have been noted previously and are not treated here. We show that the choice ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{10}\ensuremath{\sim}{{G}_{1}}^{0}{G}_{1}$, which appears in a "natural" factorization, is formulated in a manner which preserves much of the simplicity of the ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{00}$ approximation. (Numerical calculations using the ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{10}$ approximation are presented by Foster in the following paper.) The ground-state energies for three $\ensuremath{\Lambda}$ approximations (${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{00}$, ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{10}$, and ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{11}\ensuremath{\sim}{G}_{1}{G}_{1}$) are expanded through third order in the interaction strength to facilitate comparison with each other and with the Brueckner-Goldstone series. Numerical comparison of these third-order contributions for a square-well potential is presented. ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{10}$ is in dramatically closer agreement with the full perturbation theory (for ${{k}_{F}}^{0}c\ensuremath{\lesssim}1$) than are the other $\ensuremath{\Lambda}$ approximations or Brueckner theory.

Physical Review•Sep 23, 1966•23 citations

Ground-State Energy of a Many-Fermion System

Walter Kohn, J. M. Luttinger

This paper contains a critique of the Brueckner-Goldstone perturbation series for the ground-state energy of an interacting gas of fermions. We have calculated this energy by first constructing the grand partition function at finite temperature, and then carefully taking the limit as $T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$. In general this leads to a series which differs from that of Brueckner and Goldstone. An exception is the case where both the unperturbed single-particle energy as well as the interaction potential have spherical symmetry. Reasons for the breakdown of the Brueckner-Goldstone formalism are briefly discussed.

Physical Review•Apr 1, 1960•292 citations
We have examined the ground state of the many-fermion system, using perturbation theory, with particular attention to Brueckner's method. A study of the single-particle propagators in the ground state of the system sheds some light on the relation between the single-particle energies used, for example, in the optical model of nuclear reactions, and Brucekner's self-consistent energies. This leads naturally to the use of a renormalization factor to allow for propagation off the energy shell. It is possible to formulate the perturbation theory entirely in terms of graphs with no fermion self-energy parts, and this method is used to examine the approximations used for this problem, and to relate more closely the calculations of the ground-state energy and of other properties of the ground state.
The general form of the energy of the ground state of a many-fermion system is shown to be exactly of the form proposed by Brueckner and Bethe, without approximation. In a variational treatment, if the trial wave function is picked containing only pair correlations, together with all possible unlinked pairs, it is described by a two-body excitation matrix 〈m1m2∣A∣p1p2〉〈{m}_{1}{m}_{2}|A|{p}_{1}{p}_{2}〉〈m1​m2​∣A∣p1​p2​〉. Variation of this matrix in the Ritz-Rayleigh principle yields a set of integral equations of the scattering type for the matrix AAA. Hole-state energies are given self-consistently in terms of the matrix AAA, but particle-state energies are Hartree-Fock energies. This may be corrected for by widely enlarging the class of terms admitted into the wave function. If the approximation is then made of omitting a class of terms, defined as cross-linked clusters in $〈\ensuremath{\psi}|H|\ensuremath{\psi}〉$, the particle-state energies are easily renormalized. Variation then leads to an infinite hierarchy of integral equations.
Certain general properties of single-particle propagators for a system of interacting fermions are derived. In addition, the properties of the proper self-energy part ${G}_{k}(\ensuremath{\zeta})$ which were used in previous work on the ground-state energy and on the Fermi surface are established. In particular, the fact that to all orders of perturbation theory in the interaction, $\mathrm{Im} {G}_{k}(x\ensuremath{-}i{0}^{+})$ behaves like ${C}_{k}{(x\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\mu})}^{2}$ (Ck>0{C}_{k}>0Ck​>0) for xxx very near $\ensuremath{\mu}$, is proved.
New forms of the linked cluster expansion for the ground-state energy of a normal spherical system are given in terms of the exact single-particle propagator and of the associated self-energy operator. These forms are shown to be stationary with respect to variations of the latter quantities. A new concise proof of the Hugenholtz-Van Hove theorem on single-particle energies is then possible. The variational principle also explains the insensitivity of recent binding energy calculations to the choice of single-particle energies. It is shown how all results may be extended to systems with anisotropic features.
The perturbation series for the ground-state energy of a many-fermion system is investigated to arbitrary order for the "isotropic" case. This is the case of over-all spherical symmetry, both in the interaction and in the unperturbed single particle energies. It is shown that for spin one-half fermions the Brueckner-Goldstone perturbation series is valid to all orders in the perturbation. For spins greater than one-half it is in general incorrect even in the isotropic case, unless the interactions are spin independent.The discussion to arbitrary order in the interaction is carried out by means of a Feynman-like propagator formalism, which is developed in detail.
We investigate several approximations for self-bound many-fermion systems, each of which employs the Green's-function formalism together with a suitable factorization to close the otherwise infinite hierarchy of coupled integral equations. The particular approximations, which attempt to include the important two-body correlations for short-range forces, differ in the choice of propagator $\ensuremath{\Lambda}$ for two-particle intermediate states in the TTT matrix used to calculate the two-body correlation function. The advantages and shortcomings of the choice ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{00}\ensuremath{\sim}{{G}_{1}}^{0}{{G}_{1}}^{0}$ have been noted previously and are not treated here. We show that the choice ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{10}\ensuremath{\sim}{{G}_{1}}^{0}{G}_{1}$, which appears in a "natural" factorization, is formulated in a manner which preserves much of the simplicity of the ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{00}$ approximation. (Numerical calculations using the ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{10}$ approximation are presented by Foster in the following paper.) The ground-state energies for three $\ensuremath{\Lambda}$ approximations (${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{00}$, ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{10}$, and ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{11}\ensuremath{\sim}{G}_{1}{G}_{1}$) are expanded through third order in the interaction strength to facilitate comparison with each other and with the Brueckner-Goldstone series. Numerical comparison of these third-order contributions for a square-well potential is presented. ${\ensuremath{\Lambda}}_{10}$ is in dramatically closer agreement with the full perturbation theory (for ${{k}_{F}}^{0}c\ensuremath{\lesssim}1$) than are the other $\ensuremath{\Lambda}$ approximations or Brueckner theory.
This paper contains a critique of the Brueckner-Goldstone perturbation series for the ground-state energy of an interacting gas of fermions. We have calculated this energy by first constructing the grand partition function at finite temperature, and then carefully taking the limit as $T\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$. In general this leads to a series which differs from that of Brueckner and Goldstone. An exception is the case where both the unperturbed single-particle energy as well as the interaction potential have spherical symmetry. Reasons for the breakdown of the Brueckner-Goldstone formalism are briefly discussed.