Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

European Journal of Physics

Constraints in quantum mechanics

R. C. T. da Costa

Published Oct 1, 1986• 6 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The motion of a particle bounded to a plane curve C is discussed in detail from the point of view of quantum mechanics, considering a sequence of increasingly stronger potentials which limit the motion of the particle to an infinitely thin neighbourhood of C. This procedure gives a well defined result provided that one takes some simple precautions (explained in the text) in the choice of the constraining potentials. The result obtained in this way presents an interesting property which has no classical analogue: in its motion along the curve the particle 'sees' a longitudinal potential which is a function of the curvature. The consequences of this result, as well as some further information about more complex situations, are presented using the simplest language and a minimum of mathematical sophistication in order to render this paper legible and useful to both teachers and students.

DOI
10.1088/0143-0807/7/4/010

Related papers

Quantum mechanics of a constrained particle

R. C. T. da Costa

The motion of a particle rigidly bounded to a surface is discussed, considering the Schr\"odinger equation of a free particle constrained to move, by the action of an external potential, in an infinitely thin sheet of the ordinary three-dimensional space. Contrary to what seems to be the general belief expressed in the literature, this limiting process gives a perfectly well-defined result, provided that we take some simple precautions in the definition of the potentials and wave functions. It can then be shown that the wave function splits into two parts: the normal part, which contains the infinite energies required by the uncertainty principle, and a tangent part which contains "surface potentials" depending both on the Gaussian and mean curvatures. An immediate consequence of these results is the existence of different quantum mechanical properties for two isometric surfaces, as can be seen from the bound state which appears along the edge of a folded (but not stretched) plane. The fact that this surface potential is not a bending invariant (cannot be expressed as a function of the components of the metric tensor and their derivatives) is also interesting from the more general point of view of the quantum mechanics in curved spaces, since it can never be obtained from the classical Lagrangian of an a priori constrained particle without substantial modifications in the usual quantization procedures. Similar calculations are also presented for the case of a particle bounded to a curve. The properties of the constraining spatial potential, necessary to a meaningful limiting process, are discussed in some detail, and, as expected, the resulting Schr\"odinger equation contains a "linear potential" which is a function of the curvature.

Physical Review A•Apr 1, 1981•589 citations

Constraints in quantum mechanics

R. C. T. da Costa

We discuss the introduction of constraints in a system of n noninteracting particles which obey the laws of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics. In this paper the particles are first thought of as being unconstrained (described by the $3n$ Cartesian coordinates of a flat space $R$), but subject to an external potential $V$ which, in a certian suitable limit, forces the system to remain in a curved subspace $V$ of $R$. This idea was already employed in a previous work where we have discussed the motion of one constrained particle. It was then shown that in order to obtain a meaningful result the particle wave function should be "uniformly compressed" into a surface (or curve), avoiding, in this way, the tangential forces which correspond to the dissipative constraints of classical mechanics. The resulting Schr\"odinger equation could then be separated in such a way that the part which contained the surface (or curve) variables was independent of the potential $V$ employed in the constraining process. In the present paper we show that this procedure cannot be carried out for all subspaces $V$ of $R$ in the case of a many-particle system, unless $V$ satisfies a certain geometrical condition. The many-particle Schr\"odinger equation (as was already the case of the one-particle systems) contains, besides the kinetic energy term, potentials which are not bending invariants, that is, cannot be obtained from the metric tensor ${g}_{\mathrm{ij}}$ of $V$ or its derivatives. This gives rise to different Schr\"odinger equations for isometric subspaces, in striking contrast with the usual quantization procedures which start from the classical Lagrangian of the constrained system.

Physical Review A•Jun 1, 1982•144 citations

Quantum Mechanics of a Particle on a Curved Surface: Comparison of Three Different Approaches

Mitsuhiro Ikegami, Yasutaka Nagaoka, Shuji Takagi +1 more

When quantum mechanical motion of a particle constrained to a curved surface in the Euclidean space is considered, three different approaches may be adopted to describe the system. One is the confining approach which enforces a particle to stay in the surface by a physical confining potential. Both of the others follow Dirac's general prescription to treat a constrained system, but employ different constraints, namely the usual and the conservative constraints, respectively. The three approaches lead to results which do not in general agree with each other, though they give the same classical equation of motion. It is emphasized that the arbitrariness in the ordering of operators cannot be avoided when the latter two approaches are adopted. In the approach with the conservative constraint, however, there is a physical ordering, which leads to the result in agreement with that of the confining approach. We interpret these discrepancy and agreement in simple physical terms.

Progress of Theoretical Physics•Aug 1, 1992•59 citations

Wave Functions in the Neighborhood of a Toroidal Surface; Hard vs. Soft Constraint

M. Encinosa, Lonnie Mott, Babak Etemadi

The curvature potential arising from confining a particle initially in three-dimensional space onto a curved surface is normally derived in the hard constraint q → 0 limit, with q the degree of freedom normal to the surface. In this work the hard constraint is relaxed, and eigenvalues and wave functions are numerically determined for a particle confined to a thin layer in the neighborhood of a toroidal surface. The hard constraint and finite layer (or soft constraint) quantities are comparable, but both differ markedly from those of the corresponding two dimensional system, indicating that the curvature potential continues to influence the dynamics when the particle is confined to a finite layer. This effect is potentially of consequence to the modelling of curved nanostructures.

arXiv:quant-ph/0409141•Physica Scripta•Jan 1, 2005•17 citations

Notes on the quantum mechanics of particles constrained to curved surfaces

Benjamin Bernard, L. C. Lew Yan Voon

In the course of one's studies, it may be desired to approximate a particle constrained to a curved surface, such as a sheet of graphene or a fullerene, but without modelling the lattice of Coulomb potentials. This can be done using the machinery of differential geometry to formulate a Schr?dinger equation for a particle constrained so by applying an infinitely narrow infinite square well potential normal to the surface. The purpose of this paper is to clarify two mistakes that might be made when attempting to formulate this equation. These mistakes are: (1) incorrectly assuming that the Laplacian of the surface is the same as the Laplacian of the space, with the constrained term removed; and (2) neglecting to include the effective potential energy due to the curvature of the surface. It is also noted that the constrained approach produces results that, if the resulting Schr?dinger equation is separable, will produce one constant of separation instead of the traditional two. The emergence of the second quantum number is demonstrated and, hence, the apparent inconsistency is resolved. The prolate spheroid is given as a non-trivial example because it highlights the issues presented.

European Journal of Physics•Jul 26, 2013•7 citations

Curvature-induced bound states in quantum wires

Tim Bergmann, Benjamin Schwager, Jamal Berakdar

A classical particle under spatial constraints is strictly confined to live on a specific space manifold or path, but this assumption is incompatible with the zero-point fluctuations of a quantum particle. One way to describe quantum mechanics under constraints is the confinement potential approach (CPA). For a non-relativistic particle, the CPA maps the problem onto the solution of a Schrödinger-type equation in an isometrically embedded Riemannian submanifold of Euclidean space while the motion along orthogonal directions are decoupled and spatially confined. This approach respects quantum uncertainty, and one of its key results is the appearance of geometry- and metric-induced potentials that affect the stationary states and the dynamics of the particle. For particles constrained to different spaces, such as structures hosting sharp bents, vertices, wedges, conical apices, tips, or self-intersections, a formalism beyond the CPA is needed. Here, a step towards a CPA extension for irregular spaces is presented. After classifying the possible geometric irregularities concerning the CPA formalism, the presentation is focused on a sharply bent quantum wire modeled as an embedded curve with singular (but absolute integrable) curvature. For a subclass fulfilling the additional requirement that the geometric potential is a distribution of first order, a solution scheme for the confined Schrödinger equation is presented based on singular Sturm-Liouville theory and operator theoretic methods. The analytical considerations and numerical simulations evidence the existence of curvature-induced bound states with non-differentiable wave functions localized around the singular point, with an extension well beyond the singularity. Furthermore, a multitude of scattering states appear that may affect the transport and optical properties of the system.

quant-pharXiv:2604.01856•Physical Review Research•Apr 3, 2026•2 citations
The motion of a particle bounded to a plane curve C is discussed in detail from the point of view of quantum mechanics, considering a sequence of increasingly stronger potentials which limit the motion of the particle to an infinitely thin neighbourhood of C. This procedure gives a well defined result provided that one takes some simple precautions (explained in the text) in the choice of the constraining potentials. The result obtained in this way presents an interesting property which has no classical analogue: in its motion along the curve the particle 'sees' a longitudinal potential which is a function of the curvature. The consequences of this result, as well as some further information about more complex situations, are presented using the simplest language and a minimum of mathematical sophistication in order to render this paper legible and useful to both teachers and students.
The motion of a particle rigidly bounded to a surface is discussed, considering the Schr\"odinger equation of a free particle constrained to move, by the action of an external potential, in an infinitely thin sheet of the ordinary three-dimensional space. Contrary to what seems to be the general belief expressed in the literature, this limiting process gives a perfectly well-defined result, provided that we take some simple precautions in the definition of the potentials and wave functions. It can then be shown that the wave function splits into two parts: the normal part, which contains the infinite energies required by the uncertainty principle, and a tangent part which contains "surface potentials" depending both on the Gaussian and mean curvatures. An immediate consequence of these results is the existence of different quantum mechanical properties for two isometric surfaces, as can be seen from the bound state which appears along the edge of a folded (but not stretched) plane. The fact that this surface potential is not a bending invariant (cannot be expressed as a function of the components of the metric tensor and their derivatives) is also interesting from the more general point of view of the quantum mechanics in curved spaces, since it can never be obtained from the classical Lagrangian of an a priori constrained particle without substantial modifications in the usual quantization procedures. Similar calculations are also presented for the case of a particle bounded to a curve. The properties of the constraining spatial potential, necessary to a meaningful limiting process, are discussed in some detail, and, as expected, the resulting Schr\"odinger equation contains a "linear potential" which is a function of the curvature.
We discuss the introduction of constraints in a system of n noninteracting particles which obey the laws of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics. In this paper the particles are first thought of as being unconstrained (described by the 3n3n3n Cartesian coordinates of a flat space RRR), but subject to an external potential VVV which, in a certian suitable limit, forces the system to remain in a curved subspace VVV of RRR. This idea was already employed in a previous work where we have discussed the motion of one constrained particle. It was then shown that in order to obtain a meaningful result the particle wave function should be "uniformly compressed" into a surface (or curve), avoiding, in this way, the tangential forces which correspond to the dissipative constraints of classical mechanics. The resulting Schr\"odinger equation could then be separated in such a way that the part which contained the surface (or curve) variables was independent of the potential VVV employed in the constraining process. In the present paper we show that this procedure cannot be carried out for all subspaces VVV of RRR in the case of a many-particle system, unless VVV satisfies a certain geometrical condition. The many-particle Schr\"odinger equation (as was already the case of the one-particle systems) contains, besides the kinetic energy term, potentials which are not bending invariants, that is, cannot be obtained from the metric tensor gij{g}_{\mathrm{ij}}gij​ of VVV or its derivatives. This gives rise to different Schr\"odinger equations for isometric subspaces, in striking contrast with the usual quantization procedures which start from the classical Lagrangian of the constrained system.
When quantum mechanical motion of a particle constrained to a curved surface in the Euclidean space is considered, three different approaches may be adopted to describe the system. One is the confining approach which enforces a particle to stay in the surface by a physical confining potential. Both of the others follow Dirac's general prescription to treat a constrained system, but employ different constraints, namely the usual and the conservative constraints, respectively. The three approaches lead to results which do not in general agree with each other, though they give the same classical equation of motion. It is emphasized that the arbitrariness in the ordering of operators cannot be avoided when the latter two approaches are adopted. In the approach with the conservative constraint, however, there is a physical ordering, which leads to the result in agreement with that of the confining approach. We interpret these discrepancy and agreement in simple physical terms.
The curvature potential arising from confining a particle initially in three-dimensional space onto a curved surface is normally derived in the hard constraint q → 0 limit, with q the degree of freedom normal to the surface. In this work the hard constraint is relaxed, and eigenvalues and wave functions are numerically determined for a particle confined to a thin layer in the neighborhood of a toroidal surface. The hard constraint and finite layer (or soft constraint) quantities are comparable, but both differ markedly from those of the corresponding two dimensional system, indicating that the curvature potential continues to influence the dynamics when the particle is confined to a finite layer. This effect is potentially of consequence to the modelling of curved nanostructures.
In the course of one's studies, it may be desired to approximate a particle constrained to a curved surface, such as a sheet of graphene or a fullerene, but without modelling the lattice of Coulomb potentials. This can be done using the machinery of differential geometry to formulate a Schr?dinger equation for a particle constrained so by applying an infinitely narrow infinite square well potential normal to the surface. The purpose of this paper is to clarify two mistakes that might be made when attempting to formulate this equation. These mistakes are: (1) incorrectly assuming that the Laplacian of the surface is the same as the Laplacian of the space, with the constrained term removed; and (2) neglecting to include the effective potential energy due to the curvature of the surface. It is also noted that the constrained approach produces results that, if the resulting Schr?dinger equation is separable, will produce one constant of separation instead of the traditional two. The emergence of the second quantum number is demonstrated and, hence, the apparent inconsistency is resolved. The prolate spheroid is given as a non-trivial example because it highlights the issues presented.
A classical particle under spatial constraints is strictly confined to live on a specific space manifold or path, but this assumption is incompatible with the zero-point fluctuations of a quantum particle. One way to describe quantum mechanics under constraints is the confinement potential approach (CPA). For a non-relativistic particle, the CPA maps the problem onto the solution of a Schrödinger-type equation in an isometrically embedded Riemannian submanifold of Euclidean space while the motion along orthogonal directions are decoupled and spatially confined. This approach respects quantum uncertainty, and one of its key results is the appearance of geometry- and metric-induced potentials that affect the stationary states and the dynamics of the particle. For particles constrained to different spaces, such as structures hosting sharp bents, vertices, wedges, conical apices, tips, or self-intersections, a formalism beyond the CPA is needed. Here, a step towards a CPA extension for irregular spaces is presented. After classifying the possible geometric irregularities concerning the CPA formalism, the presentation is focused on a sharply bent quantum wire modeled as an embedded curve with singular (but absolute integrable) curvature. For a subclass fulfilling the additional requirement that the geometric potential is a distribution of first order, a solution scheme for the confined Schrödinger equation is presented based on singular Sturm-Liouville theory and operator theoretic methods. The analytical considerations and numerical simulations evidence the existence of curvature-induced bound states with non-differentiable wave functions localized around the singular point, with an extension well beyond the singularity. Furthermore, a multitude of scattering states appear that may affect the transport and optical properties of the system.