Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical review. B, Condensed matter

Thermodynamics of interacting many-level systems from random-phase-approximation Green's functions

Stephen B. Haley

Published Jan 1, 1978• 22 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Standard-basis-operator (SBO) Green's function equations of motion are developed in the random-phase approximation (RPA) for a general Hamiltonian characterizing interacting systems having discrete energy levels. It is shown that the RPA equations have the same algebraic structure as the chain-diagram equations in the perturbation theory of SBO Green's functions. The earlier problems of redundancy and failure to satisfy the monotopic restrictions in the calculation of autocorrelation functions are resolved. Ratios of RPA autocorrelation functions can always be determined from commutator equations from which thermal average energy-level occupation probabilities ${P}_{\ensuremath{\beta}}$ associated with state $|\ensuremath{\beta}〉$ are obtained. Using the properties of the SBO, a very simple derivation of an explicit formula for ${P}_{\ensuremath{\beta}}$ is given for an important class of Hamiltonians, which includes the Hubbard $s$-band model and the Heisenberg ferromagnet. This derivation completely avoids the use of complicated methods such as the moment generator used to solve equations coupling average moments of the spin operator ${\stackrel{^}{S}}_{Z}$ in ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic systems.

DOI
10.1103/physrevb.17.337

Related papers

I. Exact relations among correlation functions of inherently nondynamic interacting systems

Stephen B. Haley

The standard basis operator (SBO) equation of motion is solved exactly for the class of interacting many-body Hamiltonians which can be constructed from a complete set of mutually orthogonal projection operators. This class includes the Ising model Hamiltonians. Two integration procedures are presented: (1) term by term integration over the poles of the SBO double-time temperature-dependent Green’s functions in the spectral representation; (2) direct integration of the time-dependent equation of motion of an SBO. An ensemble average expression relating correlation functions among systems in different energy states is derived. For the Ising model this expression relates correlation functions of spin clusters of different orders, and it is analogous to a relation derived from the master equation under equilibrium conditions.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•May 1, 1978•0 citations

Self-consistent generalized random-phase approximation for spin systems

Edward B. Brown

A generalized random-phase approximation (RPA) for decoupling the double-time Green's functions (DTGF) equations of motion of spin systems is developed. The decoupling parameters are chosen by fixing the moments of both the commutator and anticommutator decoupled spectral functions, thus establishing a well-defined relationship between the approximation scheme and the fundamental properties of DTGF. It is shown that the standard RPA must be supplemented by a condition on correlations to provide a well-defined, complete approximation scheme. The procedure is demonstrated by application to the fully anisotropic S=1/2 Heisenberg model in a field.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1990•3 citations

Generalized Many-Body Perturbation Theory for the Electron Correlation Energy: Multireference Random Phase Approximation via Diagrammatic Resummation

Yuqi Wang, Wei‐Hai Fang, Zhendong Li

Many-body perturbation theory (MBPT) based on Green’s functions and Feynman diagrams provides a fundamental theoretical framework for various ab initio computational approaches in molecular and materials science, including the random phase approximation (RPA) and GW approximation. Unfortunately, this perturbation expansion often fails in systems with strong multireference characters. Extending diagrammatic MBPT to the multireference case is highly nontrivial and remains largely unexplored, primarily due to the breakdown of Wick’s theorem. In this work, we develop a diagrammatic multireference generalization of MBPT for computing correlation energies of strongly correlated systems, by using the cumulant expansion of many-body Green’s functions in place of Wick’s theorem. This theoretical framework bridges the gap between MBPT in condensed matter physics and multireference perturbation theories (MRPT) in quantum chemistry, which had been almost exclusively formulated within time-independent wave function frameworks prior to this work. Our formulation enables the explicit incorporation of strong correlation effects from the outset as in MRPT, while treating residual weak interactions through a generalized diagrammatic perturbation expansion as in MBPT. As a concrete demonstration, we formulate a multireference (MR) extension of the standard single-reference (SR) RPA by systematically resumming generalized ring diagrams, which naturally leads to a unified set of equations applicable to both SR and MR cases. Benchmark calculations on prototypical molecular systems reveal that MR-RPA successfully resolves the well-known failure of SR-RPA in strongly correlated systems. This theoretical advancement paves the way for advancing ab initio computational methods through diagrammatic resummation techniques in future.

arXiv:2410.22990•The Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters•Mar 18, 2025•10 citations

Dyson equation approach to many-body Green’s functions and self-consistent RPA: Application to the Hubbard model

Steffen Schäfer, Peter Schuck

An approach for particle-hole correlation functions, based on the so-called self-consistent random-phase approximation is developed. This leads to a fully self-consistent RPA-like theory that satisfies the $f$-sum rule and several other theorems. As a first step, a simpler self-consistent approach, the renormalized RPA, is solved numerically in the one-dimensional Hubbard model. The charge and the longitudinal spin susceptibility, the momentum distribution, and several ground-state properties are calculated and compared with the exact results. Especially at half-filling, our approach provides quite promising results and matches the exact behavior apart from a general prefactor. The strong-coupling limit of our approach can be described analytically.

arXiv:cond-mat/9804011•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jan 15, 1999•25 citations

Self-consistent random-phase approximation at finite temperature within the Richardson model

Nguyen Dinh Dang, K. Tanabe

The self-consistent random-phase approximation (SCRPA) is extended to nonzero temperature. Within the SCRPA, the collective dynamics of nucleon pairs is built on the occupation numbers that deviate from the Fermi-Dirac distribution as a result of temperature-dependent correlations beyond the RPA. The equations for single-particle occupation numbers are derived using the method of the double-time Green's functions. The approach is applied to the Richardson model of pairing. The results of numerical calculations for energies of states and occupation numbers, as well as for the thermodynamic quantities such as the excitation energy and heat capacity of the system, are compared with those obtained within the conventional RPA and the perturbative thermal SCRPA and with the exact results. We find that, overall, the SCRPA offers a better agreement with the exact results.

Physical Review C•Sep 25, 2006•2 citations

Equations-of-Motion Method and the Extended Shell Model

DAVID J. ROWE

This paper presents the equations-of-motion method as a useful and flexible tool in the study of nuclear spectroscopy. It is partly a review, but also it introduces a new and much more powerful equations-of-motion technique which supercedes the older linearization methods. The older methods worked with operator equations. To obtain closed expressions they had to be linearized in a rather arbitrary manner. The present approach works with the ground-state expectation of operator equations and thereby avoids all problems of linearization. Thus, like the Green's function method, the equations-of-motion method becomes potentially exact. It has many advantages over Green's function methods, however, among which are its greater compactness, simplicity, and the physical insight it yields.The method is first applied to rederive the random phase approximation (RPA) and the quasi-particle RPA (QRPA) and to show precisely what terms they neglect. It is demonstrated that some of these terms have coherent phases. A higher RPA and QRPA are then derived to include these terms. The corrections have some interesting effects: notably, there is a reduction of the effective interaction strength and a stabilization of the nucleus against sudden phase transitions. The equations-of-motion method is also used to generalize, in a very simple and natural way, the Hartree-Fock (HF) and Hartree-Bogolyubov (HB) concepts of independent particles and quasi-particles to nonsimple ground states.The equations-of-motion method is presented as a simple extension of the shell model to the treatment of excitationg of a correlated ground state. By concentrating on the quantities of direct physical interest, the complexity of workins with correlated wavefunctions is avoided.

Reviews of Modern Physics•Jan 1, 1968•1,131 citations
Standard-basis-operator (SBO) Green's function equations of motion are developed in the random-phase approximation (RPA) for a general Hamiltonian characterizing interacting systems having discrete energy levels. It is shown that the RPA equations have the same algebraic structure as the chain-diagram equations in the perturbation theory of SBO Green's functions. The earlier problems of redundancy and failure to satisfy the monotopic restrictions in the calculation of autocorrelation functions are resolved. Ratios of RPA autocorrelation functions can always be determined from commutator equations from which thermal average energy-level occupation probabilities P\ensuremathβ{P}_{\ensuremath{\beta}}P\ensuremathβ​ associated with state ∣\ensuremathβ〉|\ensuremath{\beta}〉∣\ensuremathβ〉 are obtained. Using the properties of the SBO, a very simple derivation of an explicit formula for P\ensuremathβ{P}_{\ensuremath{\beta}}P\ensuremathβ​ is given for an important class of Hamiltonians, which includes the Hubbard sss-band model and the Heisenberg ferromagnet. This derivation completely avoids the use of complicated methods such as the moment generator used to solve equations coupling average moments of the spin operator {\stackrel{^}{S}}_{Z} in ferromagnetic and antiferromagnetic systems.
The standard basis operator (SBO) equation of motion is solved exactly for the class of interacting many-body Hamiltonians which can be constructed from a complete set of mutually orthogonal projection operators. This class includes the Ising model Hamiltonians. Two integration procedures are presented: (1) term by term integration over the poles of the SBO double-time temperature-dependent Green’s functions in the spectral representation; (2) direct integration of the time-dependent equation of motion of an SBO. An ensemble average expression relating correlation functions among systems in different energy states is derived. For the Ising model this expression relates correlation functions of spin clusters of different orders, and it is analogous to a relation derived from the master equation under equilibrium conditions.
A generalized random-phase approximation (RPA) for decoupling the double-time Green's functions (DTGF) equations of motion of spin systems is developed. The decoupling parameters are chosen by fixing the moments of both the commutator and anticommutator decoupled spectral functions, thus establishing a well-defined relationship between the approximation scheme and the fundamental properties of DTGF. It is shown that the standard RPA must be supplemented by a condition on correlations to provide a well-defined, complete approximation scheme. The procedure is demonstrated by application to the fully anisotropic S=1/2 Heisenberg model in a field.
Many-body perturbation theory (MBPT) based on Green’s functions and Feynman diagrams provides a fundamental theoretical framework for various ab initio computational approaches in molecular and materials science, including the random phase approximation (RPA) and GW approximation. Unfortunately, this perturbation expansion often fails in systems with strong multireference characters. Extending diagrammatic MBPT to the multireference case is highly nontrivial and remains largely unexplored, primarily due to the breakdown of Wick’s theorem. In this work, we develop a diagrammatic multireference generalization of MBPT for computing correlation energies of strongly correlated systems, by using the cumulant expansion of many-body Green’s functions in place of Wick’s theorem. This theoretical framework bridges the gap between MBPT in condensed matter physics and multireference perturbation theories (MRPT) in quantum chemistry, which had been almost exclusively formulated within time-independent wave function frameworks prior to this work. Our formulation enables the explicit incorporation of strong correlation effects from the outset as in MRPT, while treating residual weak interactions through a generalized diagrammatic perturbation expansion as in MBPT. As a concrete demonstration, we formulate a multireference (MR) extension of the standard single-reference (SR) RPA by systematically resumming generalized ring diagrams, which naturally leads to a unified set of equations applicable to both SR and MR cases. Benchmark calculations on prototypical molecular systems reveal that MR-RPA successfully resolves the well-known failure of SR-RPA in strongly correlated systems. This theoretical advancement paves the way for advancing ab initio computational methods through diagrammatic resummation techniques in future.
An approach for particle-hole correlation functions, based on the so-called self-consistent random-phase approximation is developed. This leads to a fully self-consistent RPA-like theory that satisfies the fff-sum rule and several other theorems. As a first step, a simpler self-consistent approach, the renormalized RPA, is solved numerically in the one-dimensional Hubbard model. The charge and the longitudinal spin susceptibility, the momentum distribution, and several ground-state properties are calculated and compared with the exact results. Especially at half-filling, our approach provides quite promising results and matches the exact behavior apart from a general prefactor. The strong-coupling limit of our approach can be described analytically.
The self-consistent random-phase approximation (SCRPA) is extended to nonzero temperature. Within the SCRPA, the collective dynamics of nucleon pairs is built on the occupation numbers that deviate from the Fermi-Dirac distribution as a result of temperature-dependent correlations beyond the RPA. The equations for single-particle occupation numbers are derived using the method of the double-time Green's functions. The approach is applied to the Richardson model of pairing. The results of numerical calculations for energies of states and occupation numbers, as well as for the thermodynamic quantities such as the excitation energy and heat capacity of the system, are compared with those obtained within the conventional RPA and the perturbative thermal SCRPA and with the exact results. We find that, overall, the SCRPA offers a better agreement with the exact results.
This paper presents the equations-of-motion method as a useful and flexible tool in the study of nuclear spectroscopy. It is partly a review, but also it introduces a new and much more powerful equations-of-motion technique which supercedes the older linearization methods. The older methods worked with operator equations. To obtain closed expressions they had to be linearized in a rather arbitrary manner. The present approach works with the ground-state expectation of operator equations and thereby avoids all problems of linearization. Thus, like the Green's function method, the equations-of-motion method becomes potentially exact. It has many advantages over Green's function methods, however, among which are its greater compactness, simplicity, and the physical insight it yields.The method is first applied to rederive the random phase approximation (RPA) and the quasi-particle RPA (QRPA) and to show precisely what terms they neglect. It is demonstrated that some of these terms have coherent phases. A higher RPA and QRPA are then derived to include these terms. The corrections have some interesting effects: notably, there is a reduction of the effective interaction strength and a stabilization of the nucleus against sudden phase transitions. The equations-of-motion method is also used to generalize, in a very simple and natural way, the Hartree-Fock (HF) and Hartree-Bogolyubov (HB) concepts of independent particles and quasi-particles to nonsimple ground states.The equations-of-motion method is presented as a simple extension of the shell model to the treatment of excitationg of a correlated ground state. By concentrating on the quantities of direct physical interest, the complexity of workins with correlated wavefunctions is avoided.