Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Comment on “Scheme for multistep photoionization of atoms”

Alexander A. Makarov, Vladilen S Letokhov

Published Oct 24, 2002• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

In a recent paper, Bo Liu and Xi-Jing Ning [Phys. Rev. A 64, 013401 (2001)] compared a multistep photoionization scheme where the resonant laser pulses act in consecutive order with one where the same laser pulses act simultaneously. Their conclusion is that the ``consecutive'' scheme is much more (several orders of magnitude) efficient than the ``simultaneous'' one, which they call traditional. We show, however, that optimum conditions for efficient photoionization with the simultaneous (or traditional) scheme are very different from those assumed by the authors. So the difference between two schemes, in terms of efficiency, is of much lower importance, if any, than that believed by the authors.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.66.047401

Related papers

Scheme for multistep resonance photoionization of atoms

Bo Liu, Xi‐Jing Ning

Traditional schemes for multistep resonance photoionization of atoms let every employed laser beam interact with the atoms simultaneously. In such a situation, analyses via time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation show that high ionization probability requires all the laser beams must be intense enough. In order to decrease laser intensity, we proposed a scheme that the laser beam used to pump the excited atoms (in a higher bound state) into an autoionization state does not interact with the atoms until all the population is transferred by the other lasers from a ground state to the bound state. As an interesting example, we examined three-step photoionization of ${}^{235}\mathrm{U}$ with our scheme, showing that the intensity of two laser beams can be lowered by two orders of magnitude without losing high ionization probability.

Physical Review A•May 30, 2001•6 citations

Comment on ‘Time-resolved resonant photoionization of He using a time-dependent Feshbach method with ultrashort laser pulses’

Cleanthis A. Nicolaides, Yannis Komninos, Th. Mercouris

We compare the contents of the recent paper by Granados-Castro and Sanz-Vicario (2013 J.Phys. B 46 055601) to our previously published work on the same problem (Mercouris, Komninos and Nicolaides 2007 Phys. Rev. A 75 013407; 2013 Phys. Rev. A 87 069905(E)).

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Jun 26, 2014•1 citation

Reply to comment on ‘Time-resolved resonant photoionization of He using a time-dependent Feshbach method with ultrashort laser pulses’

Carlos Mario Granados–Castro, José Luis Sanz‐Vicario

In this reply we amend the effect of misusing an analytical formula derived in 2007 Phys. Rev. A 75 013407, but containing a misprint subsequently corrected in a recently published erratum, 2013 Phys. Rev. A 87 069905(E). Two new corrected figures are included in this reply with the gradual formation of the resonance Fano profile for the lowest and third-lowest He 1P o resonant states. The comparison between our ab initio time-dependent Feshbach method and the analytical perturbative formula is rather good in the temporal domain for the time sequence shown during and after the laser pulse up to 50 fs, although still far from reaching the final asymptotic form. Other comments are also replied to. Finally, we emphasize that in the LabTalk published on 4 June 2013, we do not mention the inadequacy of any analytical formula whatsoever and the figure caption clearly refers to the asymptotic form of the Fano profile.

Journal of Physics B Atomic Molecular and Optical Physics•Jun 26, 2014•0 citations

Comment on “Effective excitation method of a three-level medium in a selective photoionization”

Gaurav Gupta, B. M. Suri

Analytical formulas of optimal detunings for efficient and selective excitation of a three-level atomic system derived by Choe et al. [Phys. Rev. A 52, 382 (1995)] predict the values of optimal detunings substantially different from the values mentioned in their paper.

Physical Review A•Jul 21, 2006•0 citations

Reply to “Comment on ‘Photoionization of helium atoms irradiated with intense vacuum ultraviolet free-electron laser light. Part II. Theoretical modeling of multiphoton and single-photon processes’ ”

Alonso Castro, Tim Laarmann, Joachim Schulz +2 more

We cannot agree with the Comment by Maquet et al. [Phys. Rev. A. 74, 027401 (2006)]. It seems that Maquet et al. are thinking in terms of classical fields. In our recent paper we have presented a study of the two-photon rate of He making use of quantized fields. This approach becomes a natural choice if we have in mind processes at high photon energy. In this description of the problem the squared vector potential $\mathbf{A}∙\mathbf{A}$ term is essential.

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 2006•4 citations

Photoexcitation and photoionization of alkali atoms

Xiao-Qiu Qi, Wang Feng, Dai Chang-Jian

The dynamical process of photoexcitation and photoionization of alkali atoms is studied with three-step laser pulses, focusing on the similarities and differences between Li and Cs atoms on their properties by making a comparison of them. Based on several excitation schemes, the present work not only establishes the rate equations of atom population for all related transition states, but also obtains the analytical solutions of photoexcitation and photoionization process. The mathematical solutions are simplified significantly by restricting the most general case to the several special cases, either designed or selected carefully, in order to highlight the main factors and obtain the physical insight underlying the complicated mathematical expressions. With self-programming, the possible impact of time configuration of laser pulses on the three-step laser excitation process of the photoexcitation and photoionization is calculated and studied systematically. Variation of the ionization efficiency with the laser parameters is investigated and discussed. With the same time configuration of laser pulses, the dependences of atom population for all the related transition states on the two different excitation paths are compared and analyzed, reflecting the impact of changing the atomic parameters. Under the similar excitation conditions, the differences of ionization efficiency between Li and Cs atoms are explored. Finally, based on the present study, several means for optimizing ionization efficiency are proposed.

Acta Physica Sinica•Jan 1, 2015•6 citations
In a recent paper, Bo Liu and Xi-Jing Ning [Phys. Rev. A 64, 013401 (2001)] compared a multistep photoionization scheme where the resonant laser pulses act in consecutive order with one where the same laser pulses act simultaneously. Their conclusion is that the consecutive'' scheme is much more (several orders of magnitude) efficient than the simultaneous'' one, which they call traditional. We show, however, that optimum conditions for efficient photoionization with the simultaneous (or traditional) scheme are very different from those assumed by the authors. So the difference between two schemes, in terms of efficiency, is of much lower importance, if any, than that believed by the authors.
Traditional schemes for multistep resonance photoionization of atoms let every employed laser beam interact with the atoms simultaneously. In such a situation, analyses via time-dependent Schr\"odinger equation show that high ionization probability requires all the laser beams must be intense enough. In order to decrease laser intensity, we proposed a scheme that the laser beam used to pump the excited atoms (in a higher bound state) into an autoionization state does not interact with the atoms until all the population is transferred by the other lasers from a ground state to the bound state. As an interesting example, we examined three-step photoionization of 235U{}^{235}\mathrm{U}235U with our scheme, showing that the intensity of two laser beams can be lowered by two orders of magnitude without losing high ionization probability.
In this reply we amend the effect of misusing an analytical formula derived in 2007 Phys. Rev. A 75 013407, but containing a misprint subsequently corrected in a recently published erratum, 2013 Phys. Rev. A 87 069905(E). Two new corrected figures are included in this reply with the gradual formation of the resonance Fano profile for the lowest and third-lowest He 1P o resonant states. The comparison between our ab initio time-dependent Feshbach method and the analytical perturbative formula is rather good in the temporal domain for the time sequence shown during and after the laser pulse up to 50 fs, although still far from reaching the final asymptotic form. Other comments are also replied to. Finally, we emphasize that in the LabTalk published on 4 June 2013, we do not mention the inadequacy of any analytical formula whatsoever and the figure caption clearly refers to the asymptotic form of the Fano profile.
We cannot agree with the Comment by Maquet et al. [Phys. Rev. A. 74, 027401 (2006)]. It seems that Maquet et al. are thinking in terms of classical fields. In our recent paper we have presented a study of the two-photon rate of He making use of quantized fields. This approach becomes a natural choice if we have in mind processes at high photon energy. In this description of the problem the squared vector potential A∙A\mathbf{A}∙\mathbf{A}A∙A term is essential.
The dynamical process of photoexcitation and photoionization of alkali atoms is studied with three-step laser pulses, focusing on the similarities and differences between Li and Cs atoms on their properties by making a comparison of them. Based on several excitation schemes, the present work not only establishes the rate equations of atom population for all related transition states, but also obtains the analytical solutions of photoexcitation and photoionization process. The mathematical solutions are simplified significantly by restricting the most general case to the several special cases, either designed or selected carefully, in order to highlight the main factors and obtain the physical insight underlying the complicated mathematical expressions. With self-programming, the possible impact of time configuration of laser pulses on the three-step laser excitation process of the photoexcitation and photoionization is calculated and studied systematically. Variation of the ionization efficiency with the laser parameters is investigated and discussed. With the same time configuration of laser pulses, the dependences of atom population for all the related transition states on the two different excitation paths are compared and analyzed, reflecting the impact of changing the atomic parameters. Under the similar excitation conditions, the differences of ionization efficiency between Li and Cs atoms are explored. Finally, based on the present study, several means for optimizing ionization efficiency are proposed.