Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Critical analysis of the empirical tests of local hidden-variable theories

Emilio Santos

Published Oct 1, 1992• 137 citations
Publisher

Abstract

A local hidden-variable model is exhibited for the experiments by Aspect, Grangier, and Roger [Phys. Rev. Lett. 47, 460 (1981); 49, 91 (1982)] and Aspect, Dalibard, and Roger [Phys. Rev. Lett. 49, 1804 (1982)] measuring polarization correlation of optical-photon pairs. The model agrees with quantum-mechanical predictions for all measurable quantities even with ideal polarizers and detectors, and emphasizes the need of a high degree of directional correlation, besides the correlation of spin (or polarization or other quantities), in any test of locality. It is proved that homogeneous inequalities, involving only coincidence detection rates, cannot discriminate between quantum mechanics and local theories, which invalidates all previously used empirical tests. The role of supplementary assumptions, like the so-called no enhancement, for the derivation of Bell's inequalities is discussed. Finally it is conjectured that quantum mechanics might be compatible with local realism, if we assume that not all self-adjoint operators represent observables and not all density operators represent states.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.46.3646

Related papers

Optical test of local hidden-variable theories with two-channel polarizers

M. Ardehali

An inequality is deduced from local realism and a supplementary assumption. This inequality is violated by the predictions of quantum mechanics for experiments with low-efficiency detectors.Received 19 August 1993DOI:https://doi.org/10.1103/PhysRevA.49.R3143©1994 American Physical Society

Physical Review A•May 1, 1994•2 citations

Reliability of Bell-inequality measurements using polarization correlations in parametric-down-conversion photon sources

Liberato De, Augusto Garuccio

In recent years parametric-down-conversion photon sources have been proposed and used to test local realism via Bell-type inequalities. This study shows that this technique fails to discriminate between quantum mechanics and local realism in all those tests in which polarization correlations are measured, since dichotomic observables cannot be associated satisfactorily with the state produced in these experiments. A more adequate description of these photon sources leads to an alternative inequality for Einstein locality, which is always satisfied by quantum-mechanical predictions. The result can be extended to all the experiments in which only one-half of the emitted pairs are detected.

Physical Review A•Oct 1, 1994•51 citations

Proposed Experiment to Test Local Hidden-Variable Theories

John F. Clauser, Michael Horne, Abner Shimony +1 more

A theorem of Bell, proving that certain predictions of quantum mechanics are inconsistent with the entire family of local hidden-variable theories, is generalized so as to apply to realizable experiments. A proposed extension of the experiment of Kocher and Commins, on the polarization correlation of a pair of optical photons, will provide a decisive test between quantum mechanics and local hidden-variable theories.

Physical Review Letters•Oct 13, 1969•7,741 citations

Experimental Consequences of Local Hidden Variable Theories.

Michael Horne

A family of theories called "deterministic local hidden variable theories" (DLHV) is characterized and their consequences are investigated for an experimentally realistic situation. An experiment on the polarization correlation of optical photon pairs emitted in certain atomic cascades is proposed as a test of the family of DLHV theories. The model-independent hidden variable predictions applicable to the realistic experimental arrangement are obtained by a generalization of a previous theorem of Bell. Quantum mechanical predictions for the same experimental situation are calculated for two cases: a J = 0 + J = 1 + J = 0 and a J = 1 + J = 1 + J = 0 electric dipole cascade. For both cascades, it is shown that the quantum mechanical and the DLHV predictions are in sufficient disagreement for an actual experimental test to be possible. Restrictions on detector solid angle and polarizer efficiency, necessary to obtain a decisive experiment, are explicitly given. The Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen argument for the existence of a DLHV theory is reviewed.

•Jan 1, 1970•5 citations

Experimental Test of Local Hidden-Variable Theories

S. J. Freedman, John F. Clauser

We have measured the linear polarization correlation of the photons emitted in an atomic cascade of calcium. It has been shown by a generalization of Bell's inequality that the existence of local hidden variables imposes restrictions on this correlation in conflict with the predictions of quantum mechanics. Our data, in agreement with quantum mechanics, violate these restrictions to high statistical accuracy, thus providing strong evidence against local hidden-variable theories.

Physical Review Letters•Apr 3, 1972•2,062 citations

Proposed molecular test of local hidden-variables theories

Thomas K. Lo, Abner Shimony

The inefficiency of detectors of low-energy photons permits a loophole in the experimental refutation of local hidden-variables theories by observations of polarization correlations. A specific local hidden-variables model of Clauser and Horne shows that a hypothetical selectivity of detectors can yield the counting rates predicted by quantum mechanics. We therefore derive a new Bell-type inequality, which takes detection inefficiency into account. The loophole can then be blocked by observing spin correlations of atom pairs in an electronic singlet state, if both spin analysis and detection are sufficiently efficient. We propose to create Na atom pairs in the electronic singlet state, by using the induced Raman effect to excite ${\mathrm{Na}}_{2}$ molecules in the electronic ground state $X^{1}{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{g}^{+}$ to the continuum of the electronic ground state. Two laser beams are to be used, one for excitation to a virtual intermediate state in $A^{1}{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{u}^{+}$, one to induce the downward transition to the final state. The ensemble needed to test the new inequality consists of those pairs which enter the respective collimating apertures of two Stern-Gerlach analyzers.

Physical Review A•Jun 1, 1981•63 citations
A local hidden-variable model is exhibited for the experiments by Aspect, Grangier, and Roger [Phys. Rev. Lett. 47, 460 (1981); 49, 91 (1982)] and Aspect, Dalibard, and Roger [Phys. Rev. Lett. 49, 1804 (1982)] measuring polarization correlation of optical-photon pairs. The model agrees with quantum-mechanical predictions for all measurable quantities even with ideal polarizers and detectors, and emphasizes the need of a high degree of directional correlation, besides the correlation of spin (or polarization or other quantities), in any test of locality. It is proved that homogeneous inequalities, involving only coincidence detection rates, cannot discriminate between quantum mechanics and local theories, which invalidates all previously used empirical tests. The role of supplementary assumptions, like the so-called no enhancement, for the derivation of Bell's inequalities is discussed. Finally it is conjectured that quantum mechanics might be compatible with local realism, if we assume that not all self-adjoint operators represent observables and not all density operators represent states.
In recent years parametric-down-conversion photon sources have been proposed and used to test local realism via Bell-type inequalities. This study shows that this technique fails to discriminate between quantum mechanics and local realism in all those tests in which polarization correlations are measured, since dichotomic observables cannot be associated satisfactorily with the state produced in these experiments. A more adequate description of these photon sources leads to an alternative inequality for Einstein locality, which is always satisfied by quantum-mechanical predictions. The result can be extended to all the experiments in which only one-half of the emitted pairs are detected.
A family of theories called "deterministic local hidden variable theories" (DLHV) is characterized and their consequences are investigated for an experimentally realistic situation. An experiment on the polarization correlation of optical photon pairs emitted in certain atomic cascades is proposed as a test of the family of DLHV theories. The model-independent hidden variable predictions applicable to the realistic experimental arrangement are obtained by a generalization of a previous theorem of Bell. Quantum mechanical predictions for the same experimental situation are calculated for two cases: a J = 0 + J = 1 + J = 0 and a J = 1 + J = 1 + J = 0 electric dipole cascade. For both cascades, it is shown that the quantum mechanical and the DLHV predictions are in sufficient disagreement for an actual experimental test to be possible. Restrictions on detector solid angle and polarizer efficiency, necessary to obtain a decisive experiment, are explicitly given. The Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen argument for the existence of a DLHV theory is reviewed.
The inefficiency of detectors of low-energy photons permits a loophole in the experimental refutation of local hidden-variables theories by observations of polarization correlations. A specific local hidden-variables model of Clauser and Horne shows that a hypothetical selectivity of detectors can yield the counting rates predicted by quantum mechanics. We therefore derive a new Bell-type inequality, which takes detection inefficiency into account. The loophole can then be blocked by observing spin correlations of atom pairs in an electronic singlet state, if both spin analysis and detection are sufficiently efficient. We propose to create Na atom pairs in the electronic singlet state, by using the induced Raman effect to excite Na2{\mathrm{Na}}_{2}Na2​ molecules in the electronic ground state $X^{1}{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{g}^{+}$ to the continuum of the electronic ground state. Two laser beams are to be used, one for excitation to a virtual intermediate state in $A^{1}{\ensuremath{\Sigma}}_{u}^{+}$, one to induce the downward transition to the final state. The ensemble needed to test the new inequality consists of those pairs which enter the respective collimating apertures of two Stern-Gerlach analyzers.