Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Neutron Compton scattering by proton and deuteron systems with entangled spatial and spin degrees of freedom

E. Karlsson, Stephen William Lovesey

Published May 17, 2000• 67 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Several recent experiments on liquid and solid samples containing protons or deuterons have shown an interesting anomaly, which is apparently absent when the hydrogen isotopes are replaced by heavier particles. The anomaly is a shortfall in the intensity of energetic neutrons scattered by the samples; specifically, the intensity per hydrogen isotope in bulk samples is smaller than the intensity for total scattering by an isolated hydrogen isotope. Short-lived correlations in the spatial and spin degrees of freedom of the hydrogen isotopes have been proposed as an explanation of the anomaly. The correlations involve entanglements of the degrees of freedom created by the requirements of quantum mechanics applied to identical particles. By using energetic neutrons to perform Compton scattering experiments on the hydrogen isotopes, the time scale of the experimental probe covers the region of ${10}^{\ensuremath{-}16}--{10}^{\ensuremath{-}15}\mathrm{s}$ where entangled states might still be expected to survive. The proposed explanation is pursued here by reporting the cross section for Compton scattering, also known as deep inelastic scattering, by two identical nuclei occupying nonequivalent states. The model reproduces the observed dependence of the cross section on energy transfer, in which intensity accumulates at the recoil energy of a single nucleus. Several features of the model demand that the intensity at the recoil energy is indeed less than the intensity for total scattering by an isolated nucleus. Although the pair approximation used here is unquestionably a first approximation to real many-body entanglements, it is a compelling explanation of all the observations, including the restoration of the normal cross section at longer observation times achieved by moving to longer scattering times.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.61.062714

Related papers

Scattering by Entangled Spatial and Spin Degrees of Freedom

E. Karlsson, Stephen William Lovesey

Several recent experiments on liquid and solid samples containing protons or deuterons show an interesting anomaly, which is a shortfall in the intensity of energetic neutrons scattered by the samples. Previously we demonstrated that quantum correlations in the spatial and spin degrees of freedom of the hydrogen isotopes lead to entanglement in scattering and a reduction in the scattered intensity. The viability of short-lived quantum correlations as the cause of the observed anomalies is further explored and found to be entirely feasible. General features of the basic premiss, that quantum entanglement reduces the scattered signal, are discussed and the interpretation of the neutron scattering experiments is set in context to related work on other systems. For the experiments in question, the duration of a scattering event, τ s , is a fraction of a femtosecond which is extremely short compared to solid-state relaxation times. Increasing τ s , by suitably changing experimental conditions, restores the intensity to the standard value calculated from the single atom cross-section and concentration of particles. Our physical picture of the restoration is evolution with increasing τ s from a pure state of the particles (described by a wavefunction) to a mixed state (described by a density matrix) that is created, through decoherence, by steadily engaging the solid-state environment of the particles.

Physica Scripta•Jan 1, 2002•54 citations

Effects of Subfemtosecond Quantum Correlations in Neutron Scattering on Water

E. Karlsson

Several recent experiments have shown that protons, and to some extent also deuterons, show anomalous cross sections when the neutrons have energies in the range 10-100 eV (this results in a Compton scattering process where an essential part of the energy is transferred to one of the scattering particles). Here, an experiment on partially deuterated water, carried out by Chatzidimitriou-Dreismann et al., is analyzed in terms of a theory, which assumes that during the short duration (<10(-15) s) of this scattering process, protons are exchange correlated and cannot be considered as independent scattering objects. The quantum decoherence time for protons in liquid water is estimated from a simple model for the interaction of the water protons with hydrogen bonds.

Physical Review Letters•Mar 5, 2003•42 citations

Breaking time-inversion invariance through decoherence — Energetic consequences for attosecond neutron scattering

C. A. Chatzidimitriou‐Dreismann, Evan MacA. Gray, Tomasz P. Blach

Nuclei and electrons in condensed matter and/or molecules are usually entangled, due to the prevailing (mainly electromagnetic) interactions. However, the "environment" of a microscopic scattering system (e.g. a proton) causes ultrafast decoherence, thus making atomic and/or nuclear entanglement effects not directly accessible to experiments. However, our neutron Compton scattering experiments from protons (H-atoms) in condensed systems and molecules have a characteristic collisional time about 100–1000 attoseconds. The quantum dynamics of an atom in this ultrashort, but finite, time window is governed by non-unitary time evolution due to the aforementioned decoherence. Unexpectedly, recent theoretical investigations have shown that decoherence can also have the following energetic consequences. Disentangling two subsystems A and B of a quantum system AB is tantamount to erasure of quantum phase relations between A and B. This erasure is widely believed to be an innocuous process, which e.g. does not affect the energies of A and B . However, two independent groups proved recently that disentangling two systems, within a sufficiently short time interval, causes increase of their energies. This is also derivable by the simplest Lindblad-type master equation of one particle being subject to pure decoherence. Our neutron-proton scattering experiments with H 2 molecules provide for the first time experimental evidence of this effect. Our results reveal that the neutron-proton collision, leading to the cleavage of the H-H bond in the attosecond timescale, is accompanied by larger energy transfer (by about 2–3%) than conventional theory predicts. Preliminary results from current investigations show qualitatively the same effect in the neutron-deuteron Compton scattering from D 2 molecules. We interpret the experimental findings by treating the neutron-proton (or neutron-deuteron) collisional system as an entangled open quantum system being subject to fast decoherence caused by its "environment" (i.e., two electrons plus second nucleus of H 2 or D 2 ). The presented results seem to be of generic nature, and may have considerable consequences for various processes in condensed matter and molecules, e.g. in elementary chemical reactions.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Aug 24, 2012•0 citations

SHORT-LIVED PROTON ENTANGLEMENT IN YTTRIUM HYDRIDES

E. Karlsson, Tyno Abdul‐Redah, Terrence John Udovic +2 more

Previous experiments on NbH 0.8 and PdH 0.6 have shown large anomalies in the cross sections for protons, when studied by neutron Compton scattering. Here, these investigations are extended to the metallic hydrides YH 2 , YH 3 , YD 2 , YD 3 , and Y ( H x D 1- x ) 3 . Considerably reduced cross sections for hydrogen are observed both in YH 2 and YH 3 , but only minor ones for YD 2 and YD 3 . The scattering time depends on the neutron scattering angle, which allows a time-differential analysis where the time window lies around one femtosecond. The anomalies persist longer in YH 2 and YH 3 than in NbH 0.8 and PdH o.6 The reduced cross sections are interpreted as a result of quantum entanglement between protons, surviving for a few fs in the solids.

Foundations of Quantum Mechanics in the Light of New Technology•Oct 1, 2002•1 citation

SHORT-LIVED QUANTUM ENTANGLEMENT OF PROTONS AND DISSOCIATION OF C - H BONDS IN CONDENSED MATTER — A NEW EFFECT

C. A. Chatzidimitriou‐Dreismann, Tyno Abdul‐Redah

In earlier neutron Compton scattering (NCS) experiments on H 2 O / D 2 O mixtures at T ≈ 298 K we observed, for the first time, a striking "anomalous" decrease of the ratio σ H /σ D of the total scattering cross sections of H and D . This "anomaly" was found to depend strongly on the H / D composition of the liquid. Extending recent NCS results obtained from solid polystyrene, we present here new results concerning the quantum dynamics and dissociation of C - H bonds (at T ≈ 298 K ) in: ( a ) liquid benzene and C 6 H 6 / C 6 D 6 mixtures; ( b ) fully protonated and partially deuterated polystyrene; and ( c ) liquid mixtures of H -acetone ( CH 3 COCH 3 ) and D -acetone ( CD 3 COCD 3 ). The considered NCS effect was given a theoretical explanation based on short-lived protonic quantum entanglement (QE) and decoherence. The variety of the new results suggests that, in the short-time scale of the NCS experiment, protonic quantum dynamics is strongly correlated with that of electronic degrees of freedom participating in the various chemical bonds.

Foundations of Quantum Mechanics in the Light of New Technology•Oct 1, 2002•1 citation

Attosecond neutron scattering from open quantum systems: Entanglement and decoherence phenomena of protons in condensed matter and molecules

C. A. Chatzidimitriou‐Dreismann, Ingmari C. Tietje

In general, nuclei and electrons in condensed matter and/or molecules are entangled, due to the prevailing (electromagnetic) interactions. As a matter of fact, the "environment" interacting with a microscopic system of interest (e.g. a proton) causes the destruction of the entanglement. This process, called decoherence, has until now prevented experimenters from directly accessing atomic and/or nuclear entanglement effects in real experiments. However, our neutron and electron Compton scattering experiments from protons (H-atoms) in several condensed systems and molecules at ambient conditions demonstrated a new striking effect, i.e. an "anomalous" decrease of scattering intensity from protons, which seem to become partially "invisible" to the neutrons. This effect, which has no interpretation within conventional neutron scattering theory, is proposed to be caused by the non-unitary time evolution (due to decoherence) during the ultrashort, but finite, time-window of the neutron-proton scattering process. Due to the large energy (several eV) and momentum (20-200 Å −1 ) transfers of these experiments the collisional time between the probe particle and a struck proton is 100–1000 attoseconds long. It is shown that, due to this short timescale, the scattering process must be theoretically treated within quantum dynamics of open quantum systems. New experimental neutron Compton scattering results from a single crystal KHCO 3 are presented. They provide the first direct evidence for a connection between the momentum distribution and the "anomalous" scattering intensity of H. Additionally, recent experiments with electron-atom Compton scattering at momentum transfers are mentioned, which reveal the presence of this effect even in scattering from single H 2 molecules in the gas phase. Theoretical discussions "from first principles" are presented, also in relation to the quantum Zeno effect, which underline the crucial role of decoherence in the considered experiments. The experimental results and their qualitative interpretation show that epithermal neutrons being available at spallation sources (e.g. ISIS/UK, SNS/USA or ESS/Sweden), and electron spectrometers with large scattering angles, provide tools for investigating new physical and chemical phenomena in the sub-femtosecond timescale.

Journal of Physics Conference Series•Jun 1, 2010•8 citations
Several recent experiments on liquid and solid samples containing protons or deuterons have shown an interesting anomaly, which is apparently absent when the hydrogen isotopes are replaced by heavier particles. The anomaly is a shortfall in the intensity of energetic neutrons scattered by the samples; specifically, the intensity per hydrogen isotope in bulk samples is smaller than the intensity for total scattering by an isolated hydrogen isotope. Short-lived correlations in the spatial and spin degrees of freedom of the hydrogen isotopes have been proposed as an explanation of the anomaly. The correlations involve entanglements of the degrees of freedom created by the requirements of quantum mechanics applied to identical particles. By using energetic neutrons to perform Compton scattering experiments on the hydrogen isotopes, the time scale of the experimental probe covers the region of 10\ensuremath−16−−10\ensuremath−15s{10}^{\ensuremath{-}16}--{10}^{\ensuremath{-}15}\mathrm{s}10\ensuremath−16−−10\ensuremath−15s where entangled states might still be expected to survive. The proposed explanation is pursued here by reporting the cross section for Compton scattering, also known as deep inelastic scattering, by two identical nuclei occupying nonequivalent states. The model reproduces the observed dependence of the cross section on energy transfer, in which intensity accumulates at the recoil energy of a single nucleus. Several features of the model demand that the intensity at the recoil energy is indeed less than the intensity for total scattering by an isolated nucleus. Although the pair approximation used here is unquestionably a first approximation to real many-body entanglements, it is a compelling explanation of all the observations, including the restoration of the normal cross section at longer observation times achieved by moving to longer scattering times.
Several recent experiments on liquid and solid samples containing protons or deuterons show an interesting anomaly, which is a shortfall in the intensity of energetic neutrons scattered by the samples. Previously we demonstrated that quantum correlations in the spatial and spin degrees of freedom of the hydrogen isotopes lead to entanglement in scattering and a reduction in the scattered intensity. The viability of short-lived quantum correlations as the cause of the observed anomalies is further explored and found to be entirely feasible. General features of the basic premiss, that quantum entanglement reduces the scattered signal, are discussed and the interpretation of the neutron scattering experiments is set in context to related work on other systems. For the experiments in question, the duration of a scattering event, τ s , is a fraction of a femtosecond which is extremely short compared to solid-state relaxation times. Increasing τ s , by suitably changing experimental conditions, restores the intensity to the standard value calculated from the single atom cross-section and concentration of particles. Our physical picture of the restoration is evolution with increasing τ s from a pure state of the particles (described by a wavefunction) to a mixed state (described by a density matrix) that is created, through decoherence, by steadily engaging the solid-state environment of the particles.
Several recent experiments have shown that protons, and to some extent also deuterons, show anomalous cross sections when the neutrons have energies in the range 10-100 eV (this results in a Compton scattering process where an essential part of the energy is transferred to one of the scattering particles). Here, an experiment on partially deuterated water, carried out by Chatzidimitriou-Dreismann et al., is analyzed in terms of a theory, which assumes that during the short duration (<10(-15) s) of this scattering process, protons are exchange correlated and cannot be considered as independent scattering objects. The quantum decoherence time for protons in liquid water is estimated from a simple model for the interaction of the water protons with hydrogen bonds.
Nuclei and electrons in condensed matter and/or molecules are usually entangled, due to the prevailing (mainly electromagnetic) interactions. However, the "environment" of a microscopic scattering system (e.g. a proton) causes ultrafast decoherence, thus making atomic and/or nuclear entanglement effects not directly accessible to experiments. However, our neutron Compton scattering experiments from protons (H-atoms) in condensed systems and molecules have a characteristic collisional time about 100–1000 attoseconds. The quantum dynamics of an atom in this ultrashort, but finite, time window is governed by non-unitary time evolution due to the aforementioned decoherence. Unexpectedly, recent theoretical investigations have shown that decoherence can also have the following energetic consequences. Disentangling two subsystems A and B of a quantum system AB is tantamount to erasure of quantum phase relations between A and B. This erasure is widely believed to be an innocuous process, which e.g. does not affect the energies of A and B . However, two independent groups proved recently that disentangling two systems, within a sufficiently short time interval, causes increase of their energies. This is also derivable by the simplest Lindblad-type master equation of one particle being subject to pure decoherence. Our neutron-proton scattering experiments with H 2 molecules provide for the first time experimental evidence of this effect. Our results reveal that the neutron-proton collision, leading to the cleavage of the H-H bond in the attosecond timescale, is accompanied by larger energy transfer (by about 2–3%) than conventional theory predicts. Preliminary results from current investigations show qualitatively the same effect in the neutron-deuteron Compton scattering from D 2 molecules. We interpret the experimental findings by treating the neutron-proton (or neutron-deuteron) collisional system as an entangled open quantum system being subject to fast decoherence caused by its "environment" (i.e., two electrons plus second nucleus of H 2 or D 2 ). The presented results seem to be of generic nature, and may have considerable consequences for various processes in condensed matter and molecules, e.g. in elementary chemical reactions.
Previous experiments on NbH 0.8 and PdH 0.6 have shown large anomalies in the cross sections for protons, when studied by neutron Compton scattering. Here, these investigations are extended to the metallic hydrides YH 2 , YH 3 , YD 2 , YD 3 , and Y ( H x D 1- x ) 3 . Considerably reduced cross sections for hydrogen are observed both in YH 2 and YH 3 , but only minor ones for YD 2 and YD 3 . The scattering time depends on the neutron scattering angle, which allows a time-differential analysis where the time window lies around one femtosecond. The anomalies persist longer in YH 2 and YH 3 than in NbH 0.8 and PdH o.6 The reduced cross sections are interpreted as a result of quantum entanglement between protons, surviving for a few fs in the solids.
In earlier neutron Compton scattering (NCS) experiments on H 2 O / D 2 O mixtures at T ≈ 298 K we observed, for the first time, a striking "anomalous" decrease of the ratio σ H /σ D of the total scattering cross sections of H and D . This "anomaly" was found to depend strongly on the H / D composition of the liquid. Extending recent NCS results obtained from solid polystyrene, we present here new results concerning the quantum dynamics and dissociation of C - H bonds (at T ≈ 298 K ) in: ( a ) liquid benzene and C 6 H 6 / C 6 D 6 mixtures; ( b ) fully protonated and partially deuterated polystyrene; and ( c ) liquid mixtures of H -acetone ( CH 3 COCH 3 ) and D -acetone ( CD 3 COCD 3 ). The considered NCS effect was given a theoretical explanation based on short-lived protonic quantum entanglement (QE) and decoherence. The variety of the new results suggests that, in the short-time scale of the NCS experiment, protonic quantum dynamics is strongly correlated with that of electronic degrees of freedom participating in the various chemical bonds.
In general, nuclei and electrons in condensed matter and/or molecules are entangled, due to the prevailing (electromagnetic) interactions. As a matter of fact, the "environment" interacting with a microscopic system of interest (e.g. a proton) causes the destruction of the entanglement. This process, called decoherence, has until now prevented experimenters from directly accessing atomic and/or nuclear entanglement effects in real experiments. However, our neutron and electron Compton scattering experiments from protons (H-atoms) in several condensed systems and molecules at ambient conditions demonstrated a new striking effect, i.e. an "anomalous" decrease of scattering intensity from protons, which seem to become partially "invisible" to the neutrons. This effect, which has no interpretation within conventional neutron scattering theory, is proposed to be caused by the non-unitary time evolution (due to decoherence) during the ultrashort, but finite, time-window of the neutron-proton scattering process. Due to the large energy (several eV) and momentum (20-200 Å −1 ) transfers of these experiments the collisional time between the probe particle and a struck proton is 100–1000 attoseconds long. It is shown that, due to this short timescale, the scattering process must be theoretically treated within quantum dynamics of open quantum systems. New experimental neutron Compton scattering results from a single crystal KHCO 3 are presented. They provide the first direct evidence for a connection between the momentum distribution and the "anomalous" scattering intensity of H. Additionally, recent experiments with electron-atom Compton scattering at momentum transfers are mentioned, which reveal the presence of this effect even in scattering from single H 2 molecules in the gas phase. Theoretical discussions "from first principles" are presented, also in relation to the quantum Zeno effect, which underline the crucial role of decoherence in the considered experiments. The experimental results and their qualitative interpretation show that epithermal neutrons being available at spallation sources (e.g. ISIS/UK, SNS/USA or ESS/Sweden), and electron spectrometers with large scattering angles, provide tools for investigating new physical and chemical phenomena in the sub-femtosecond timescale.