Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Comment on “Resonance fluorescence near a photonic band edge: Dressed-state Monte Carlo wave-function approach”

Klaus Mølmer, Søren Bay

Published Jan 1, 1999• 9 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Quang and John have, in a recent paper [Phys. Rev. A $56,$ 4273 (1997)], proposed a dressed-state Monte Carlo wave-function (MCWF) approach to a laser-driven two-level atom coupled to a structured radiation reservoir. In this Comment, we argue that this approach is at variance with the underlying physical idea of the MCWF technique, that it is at variance with basic formal requirements for the MCWF technique to apply, and that it produces spurious and unphysical quantitative results for wide ranges of parameters.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.59.904

Related papers

Resonance fluorescence near a photonic band edge: Dressed-state Monte Carlo wave-function approach

Tran Quang, Sajeev John

We introduce a dressed-state Monte Carlo wave-function technique to describe resonance fluorescence in a broad class of non-Markovian reservoirs with strong atom-reservoir interaction. The method recaptures photon localization effects which are beyond the Born and Markovian approximations, and describes the influence of the driving field on the atom-reservoir interaction. Using this approach, we predict a number of fundamentally new features in resonance fluorescence near the edge of a photonic band gap. In particular, the atomic population exhibits inversion for moderate applied field intensity. For a low external field intensity, the atomic system retains a long-time memory of its initial state.

Physical Review A•Nov 1, 1997•30 citations

Resonance fluorescence in a band-gap material: Direct numerical simulation of non-Markovian evolution

Michael W. Jack, J. J. Hope

A numerical method of calculating the non-Markovian evolution of a driven atom radiating into a structured continuum is developed. The formal solution for the atomic reduced density matrix is written as a Markovian algorithm by introducing a set of additional, virtual density matrices which follow, to the level of approximation of the algorithm, all the possible trajectories of the photons in the electromagnetic field. The technique is perturbative in the sense that more virtual density matrices are required as the product of the effective memory time and the effective coupling strength becomes larger. The number of density matrices required is given by ${3}^{M}$ where M is the number of time steps per memory time. The technique is applied to the problem of a driven two-level atom radiating close to a photonic band gap and the steady-state correlation function of the atom is calculated.

arXiv:quant-ph/0008093•Physical Review A•Mar 7, 2001•26 citations

Method of collective operators for resonance fluorescence near a photonic band edge

Dmitri S. Mogilevtsev, S. Ya. Kilin

In this work a formalism of collective atom-field operators is described and applied to study the dynamics of a classically driven two-level atom inside a band-gap material. We show that if a photon-atom bound state can exist when driving is absent, then it is possible to assume mutual independence of collective operators and develop an effective approximation for the case when driving is present.

Physical Review A•Feb 28, 2003•8 citations

Comment on “Resonance-fluorescence and absorption spectra of a two-level atom driven by a strong bichromatic field”

David L. Aronstein, Ryan S. Bennink, Robert W. Boyd +1 more

We identify discrepancies between two published predictions of the resonance fluorescence from a two-level atom driven by a strong bichromatic field [J. Opt. Soc. Am. B $8,$ 1163 (1991) and Phys. Rev. A $48,$ 3092 (1993)]. These discrepancies are shown to arise from subtleties in extracting the time-averaged resonance fluorescence from the expansions used to solve the optical Bloch equations. We construct a solution to these equations that corrects the results of the latter reference and reconciles the two predictions.

Physical Review A•Jun 17, 2002•22 citations

Theory of dressed-state lasers. I. Effective Hamiltonians and stability properties

Jakub Zakrzewski, Maciej Lewenstein, THOMAS W. MOSSBERG

We present a detailed theory of dressed-state lasers, i.e., the lasers that operate due to the gain on an inverted transition between dressed states of a coupled atom-field system. We derive effective Hamiltonians that describe such lasers for the case of one- and two-photon resonances. We argue that, due to the presence of nearly resonant intermediate states, the use of gain media consisting of strongly driven two-level atoms provides an unorthodox yet promising means for achieving cw optical two-photon laser oscillation. We disscuss the stability properties of radiation generated by such media.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1991•81 citations

Dressed Atom Revisited: Hamiltonian-Independent Treatment of the Radiative Cascade

Francesco Vincenzo Pepe, Karolina Słowik

The dressed atom approach provides a tool to investigate the dynamics of an atom-laser system by fully retaining the quantum nature of the coherent mode. In its standard derivation, the internal atom-laser evolution is described within the rotating-wave approximation, which determines a doublet structure of the spectrum and the peculiar fluorescence triplet in the steady state. However, the rotating wave approximation may fail to apply to atomic systems subject to femtosecond light pulses, light-matter systems in the strong-coupling regime or sustaining permanent dipole moments. This work aims to demonstrate how the general features of the steady-state radiative cascade are affected by the interaction of the dressed atom with propagating radiation modes. Rather than focusing on a specific model, we analyze how these features depend on the parameters characterizing the dressed eigenstates in arbitrary atom-laser dynamics, given that a set of general hypotheses is satisfied. Our findings clarify the general conditions in which a description of the radiative cascade in terms of transition between dressed states is self-consistent. We provide a guideline to determine the properties of photon emission for any atom-laser interaction model, which can be particularly relevant when the model should be tailored to enhance a specific line. We apply the general results to the case in which a permanent dipole moment is a source of low-energy emission, whose frequency is of the order of the Rabi coupling.

arXiv:2409.09454•Physical Review Letters•Aug 22, 2024•1 citation
Quang and John have, in a recent paper [Phys. Rev. A 56,56,56, 4273 (1997)], proposed a dressed-state Monte Carlo wave-function (MCWF) approach to a laser-driven two-level atom coupled to a structured radiation reservoir. In this Comment, we argue that this approach is at variance with the underlying physical idea of the MCWF technique, that it is at variance with basic formal requirements for the MCWF technique to apply, and that it produces spurious and unphysical quantitative results for wide ranges of parameters.
We introduce a dressed-state Monte Carlo wave-function technique to describe resonance fluorescence in a broad class of non-Markovian reservoirs with strong atom-reservoir interaction. The method recaptures photon localization effects which are beyond the Born and Markovian approximations, and describes the influence of the driving field on the atom-reservoir interaction. Using this approach, we predict a number of fundamentally new features in resonance fluorescence near the edge of a photonic band gap. In particular, the atomic population exhibits inversion for moderate applied field intensity. For a low external field intensity, the atomic system retains a long-time memory of its initial state.
A numerical method of calculating the non-Markovian evolution of a driven atom radiating into a structured continuum is developed. The formal solution for the atomic reduced density matrix is written as a Markovian algorithm by introducing a set of additional, virtual density matrices which follow, to the level of approximation of the algorithm, all the possible trajectories of the photons in the electromagnetic field. The technique is perturbative in the sense that more virtual density matrices are required as the product of the effective memory time and the effective coupling strength becomes larger. The number of density matrices required is given by 3M{3}^{M}3M where M is the number of time steps per memory time. The technique is applied to the problem of a driven two-level atom radiating close to a photonic band gap and the steady-state correlation function of the atom is calculated.
We identify discrepancies between two published predictions of the resonance fluorescence from a two-level atom driven by a strong bichromatic field [J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 8,8,8, 1163 (1991) and Phys. Rev. A 48,48,48, 3092 (1993)]. These discrepancies are shown to arise from subtleties in extracting the time-averaged resonance fluorescence from the expansions used to solve the optical Bloch equations. We construct a solution to these equations that corrects the results of the latter reference and reconciles the two predictions.
We present a detailed theory of dressed-state lasers, i.e., the lasers that operate due to the gain on an inverted transition between dressed states of a coupled atom-field system. We derive effective Hamiltonians that describe such lasers for the case of one- and two-photon resonances. We argue that, due to the presence of nearly resonant intermediate states, the use of gain media consisting of strongly driven two-level atoms provides an unorthodox yet promising means for achieving cw optical two-photon laser oscillation. We disscuss the stability properties of radiation generated by such media.
The dressed atom approach provides a tool to investigate the dynamics of an atom-laser system by fully retaining the quantum nature of the coherent mode. In its standard derivation, the internal atom-laser evolution is described within the rotating-wave approximation, which determines a doublet structure of the spectrum and the peculiar fluorescence triplet in the steady state. However, the rotating wave approximation may fail to apply to atomic systems subject to femtosecond light pulses, light-matter systems in the strong-coupling regime or sustaining permanent dipole moments. This work aims to demonstrate how the general features of the steady-state radiative cascade are affected by the interaction of the dressed atom with propagating radiation modes. Rather than focusing on a specific model, we analyze how these features depend on the parameters characterizing the dressed eigenstates in arbitrary atom-laser dynamics, given that a set of general hypotheses is satisfied. Our findings clarify the general conditions in which a description of the radiative cascade in terms of transition between dressed states is self-consistent. We provide a guideline to determine the properties of photon emission for any atom-laser interaction model, which can be particularly relevant when the model should be tailored to enhance a specific line. We apply the general results to the case in which a permanent dipole moment is a source of low-energy emission, whose frequency is of the order of the Rabi coupling.