We discuss the theory of Z. Deng and J. H. Eberly [Phys. Rev. A 34, 2492 (1986)] and present our point of view regarding coherent trapping and continua, which is not in agreement with that put forward by these authors.
We consider the problem of coherent population trapping in a model quantum system consisting of two (and briefly three) coupled continua of energy levels. While an earlier study [Z. Deng and J. H. Eberly, Phys. Rev. A 34, 2492 (1986)] has demonstrated population trapping in a closely related system, it has done so only for the case of a broad featureless continuum. We will demonstrate, on the other hand, that the time evolution of the continuum is qualitatively very different when different types of continua are allowed, and that population trapping is not likely to occur except in the broad featureless continuum. We do show, however, that in some cases other counterintuitive results surface.
The authors show that the population trapping phenomenon found by Deng and Eberly (1986, 1988) for free-free transitions between structureless continua occurs under much more general conditions. They solve the time-dependent models exactly and show for asymptotically long times that population trapping can occur for two continua with energy-dependent matrix elements, and for an infinite number of structureless continua with coupled bands. Furthermore, they show that the trapping persists for two continua coupled by a noisy laser. The amount of trapping depends on the initial conditions.