Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physics Letters

On the difference between “classical” and quantum mechanical collision theories

L. Vriens

Published Jun 1, 1964• 13 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1016/0031-9163(64)90155-6

Related papers

Some fundamental difficulties with quantum mechanical collision theory

William Band, James L Park

Foundations of Physics•Oct 1, 1978•3 citations

The scattering of α-particles in helium

James Chadwick

Abstract The problem of the collision of two particles which act upon each other with forces varying as the inverse square of the distance between them has been solved exactly on the basis of the new quantum mechanics, and the solution is the same as that given by classical mechanics. In a recent paper, however, Mott has pointed out that this agreement between the predictions of classical mechanics and wave mechanics depends upon the dissimilarity of the colliding particles; if the particles are identical the scattering laws given by the wave mechanics will be very different from those of classical theory. Mott has considered the two types of collision between similar particles, (1) in which the particles possess spin, such as the collisions of electrons with electrons or protons with hydrogen nuclei, and (2) in which the particles have no spin, such as the collisions of α-particles with helium nuclei.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series A Containing Papers of a Mathematical and Physical Character•Jul 1, 1930•25 citations

Formulation of the quantum mechanical collision problem

Leonard Eisenbud

Journal of the Franklin Institute•Sep 1, 1954•0 citations

Quantum-Mechanical Transport Equation for Atomic Systems

P. R. Berman

A quantum-mechanical transport equation (QMTE) is derived which should be applicable to a wide range of problems involving the interaction of radiation with atoms or molecules which are also subject to collisions with perturber atoms. The equation follows the time evolution of the macroscopic atomic density matrix elements of atoms located at classical position $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{R}}$ and moving with classical velocity $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{v}}$ It is quantum mechanical in the sense that all collision kernels or rates which appear have been obtained from a quantum-mechanical theory and, as such, properly take into account the energy-level variations and velocity changes of the active (emitting or absorbing) atom produced in collisions with perturber atoms. The QMTE represents a somewhat different formulation of the problem than that considered in earlier works. The present formulation is better suited to problems involving high-intensity external fields, such as those encountered in laser physics.

Physical Review A•Feb 1, 1972•92 citations

Quantum-Mechanical Transport Equation for Atomic Systems. II. Inelastic Collisions and General Line-Shape Considerations

P. R. Berman

Inelastic-collisional effects are incorporated into a quantum-mechanical transport equation (QMTE) that was developed in an earlier paper. The QMTE enables one to follow the quantum-state evolution of moving atoms which are interacting with some external fields while undergoing collisions with perturber atoms. The collisional processes are treated quantum mechanically and then reinterpreted in terms of classical variables so that the QMTE becomes an integrodifferential equation for atomic density-matrix elements containing both well-defined quantum-mechanical collision parameters (i.e., scattering amplitudes) and densitymatrix elements which are functions of classical position and velocity variables. Solutions of the QMTE enable one to derive line-shape formulas, and a discussion will be given of the general features to be expected for spectral profiles, Hanle-effect line shapes, and laser output curves, as well as the manner in which these features differ from those predicted by theories that neglect some quantum-mechanical aspects of the collision events. The inclusion of inelastic-collisional effects does not cover cases in which the frequency spacing of the atomic levels under consideration is comparable to the inverse duration time of a collision; nevertheless, the QMTE to be derived will be applicable to the analysis of a large number of atomic systems.

Physical Review A•Dec 1, 1972•37 citations

Quantum Mechanics of Collision Processes

Max Born

Elsevier eBooks•Jan 1, 1968•16 citations
Abstract The problem of the collision of two particles which act upon each other with forces varying as the inverse square of the distance between them has been solved exactly on the basis of the new quantum mechanics, and the solution is the same as that given by classical mechanics. In a recent paper, however, Mott has pointed out that this agreement between the predictions of classical mechanics and wave mechanics depends upon the dissimilarity of the colliding particles; if the particles are identical the scattering laws given by the wave mechanics will be very different from those of classical theory. Mott has considered the two types of collision between similar particles, (1) in which the particles possess spin, such as the collisions of electrons with electrons or protons with hydrogen nuclei, and (2) in which the particles have no spin, such as the collisions of α-particles with helium nuclei.
A quantum-mechanical transport equation (QMTE) is derived which should be applicable to a wide range of problems involving the interaction of radiation with atoms or molecules which are also subject to collisions with perturber atoms. The equation follows the time evolution of the macroscopic atomic density matrix elements of atoms located at classical position $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{R}}$ and moving with classical velocity $\stackrel{\ensuremath{\rightarrow}}{\mathrm{v}}$ It is quantum mechanical in the sense that all collision kernels or rates which appear have been obtained from a quantum-mechanical theory and, as such, properly take into account the energy-level variations and velocity changes of the active (emitting or absorbing) atom produced in collisions with perturber atoms. The QMTE represents a somewhat different formulation of the problem than that considered in earlier works. The present formulation is better suited to problems involving high-intensity external fields, such as those encountered in laser physics.
Inelastic-collisional effects are incorporated into a quantum-mechanical transport equation (QMTE) that was developed in an earlier paper. The QMTE enables one to follow the quantum-state evolution of moving atoms which are interacting with some external fields while undergoing collisions with perturber atoms. The collisional processes are treated quantum mechanically and then reinterpreted in terms of classical variables so that the QMTE becomes an integrodifferential equation for atomic density-matrix elements containing both well-defined quantum-mechanical collision parameters (i.e., scattering amplitudes) and densitymatrix elements which are functions of classical position and velocity variables. Solutions of the QMTE enable one to derive line-shape formulas, and a discussion will be given of the general features to be expected for spectral profiles, Hanle-effect line shapes, and laser output curves, as well as the manner in which these features differ from those predicted by theories that neglect some quantum-mechanical aspects of the collision events. The inclusion of inelastic-collisional effects does not cover cases in which the frequency spacing of the atomic levels under consideration is comparable to the inverse duration time of a collision; nevertheless, the QMTE to be derived will be applicable to the analysis of a large number of atomic systems.