Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Ground State of Interacting Spins

Daniel Charles Mattis

Published Apr 1, 1963• 20 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The question is posed of how the ground state of the Heisenberg Hamiltonian $H=\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\Sigma}{F}_{\mathrm{ij}}{\mathbf{S}}_{i}\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{}{\mathbf{S}}_{j}$ depends on the magnitude $s$ of $N$ interacting spins, particularly in the case of long-ranged oscillatory interactions ${F}_{\mathrm{ij}}$. It is discussed whether fixing the geometry and the bond strengths ${F}_{\mathrm{ij}}$ suffices to determine the nature of the spin correlations in the ground state, and a review is given of known instances when this is the case; those are special situations in ferromagnetism and antiferromagnetism when qualitative ground-state properties such as "lack of nodes" can be proved to be independent of $s$. These are valuable examples for the application of semiclassical methods, which are strictly valid only for $s\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}$ and depend on the convergence of a series in powers of ${s}^{\ensuremath{-}1}$. But these examples are, after all, only special cases, and it is argued that, in general, the nature of the ground state can depend sensitively on $s$. The following situation is considered in some detail: An oscillatory interaction which leads to a ferromagnetic ground state in the correspondence limit $s\ensuremath{\gg}1$, but for which the ferromagnetic state of saturation magnetization may be unstable for small quantum mechanical spins, e.g., $s=\frac{1}{2} or 1$. Two distinct types of interaction are considered which lead to this result, and it is seen that the ferromagnetic instability is a consequence, not so much of the long range of the interaction as of the presence of some relatively strong antiferromagnetic (negative) bonds. However, the variational approach which is used casts no light on the nature of the true ground state or of the thermal properties, problems which are increasingly interesting in these instances when semiclassical procedures are seen to fail.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.130.76

Related papers

Ising models with long-range antiferromagnetic and short-range ferromagnetic interactions

Alessandro Giuliani, Joel L. Lebowitz, Élliott H. Lieb

We study the ground state of a $d$-dimensional Ising model with both long-range (dipole-like) and nearest-neighbor ferromagnetic (FM) interactions. The long-range interaction is equal to ${r}^{\ensuremath{-}p}$, $p>d$, while the FM interaction has strength $J$. If $p>d+1$ and $J$ is large enough the ground state is FM, while if $d<p\ensuremath{\leqslant}d+1$ the FM state is not the ground state for any choice of $J$. In $d=1$ we show that for any $p>1$ the ground state has a series of transitions from an antiferromagnetic state of period 2 to $2h$-periodic states of blocks of sizes $h$ with alternating sign, the size $h$ growing when the FM interaction strength $J$ is increased (a generalization of this result to the case $0<p\ensuremath{\leqslant}1$ is also discussed). In $d\ensuremath{\geqslant}2$ we prove, for $d<p\ensuremath{\leqslant}d+1$, that the dominant asymptotic behavior of the ground-state energy agrees for large $J$ with that obtained from a periodic striped state conjectured to be the true ground state. The geometry of contours in the ground state is discussed.

arXiv:cond-mat/0604668•Physical Review B•Aug 25, 2006•68 citations

Magnetism and structure of small clusters: An exact treatment of electron correlations

G. M. Pastor, R. Hirsch, Bernhard Mühlschlegel

The electronic, magnetic, and structural properties of small clusters are studied in the framework of the single-band Hubbard Hamiltonian. Results for various ground-state and excited-state many-body properties are presented, which were calculated exactly by means of Lanczos's numerical diagonalization method. A full geometry optimization is performed for N\ensuremath{\le}8 atoms by considering all possible nonequivalent cluster structures with fixed nearest-neighbor bond lengths. The most stable structure and the corresponding total spin S are obtained rigorously as a function of the Coulomb interaction strength U/t and number of electrons \ensuremath{\nu}. The resulting interplay between electron correlations, magnetism, and cluster structure is analyzed and the main trends as a function of N, U/t, and \ensuremath{\nu} are derived. The stability of cluster ferromagnetism is studied from two complementary points of view. First, for N\ensuremath{\le}8 and \ensuremath{\nu}=N+1, we determine exactly the stability of the ferromagnetic ground state with respect to electronic excitations and structural changes. It is shown that in small clusters the structural changes can be as important to the temperature dependence of the magnetization as the purely electronic excitations. Second, we determine the stability of the saturated ferromagnetic state with respect to single spin flips as a function of the band filling \ensuremath{\nu}/N. In this case a few selected larger clusters (7\ensuremath{\le}N\ensuremath{\le}43) in the strongly correlated limit (U/t\ensuremath{\rightarrow}+\ensuremath{\infty}) are considered. It is shown that the \ensuremath{\nu}/N dependence of the spin-flip energy \ensuremath{\Delta}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}_{\mathrm{sf}}$ shows interesting electronic-shell-like oscillations, which reflect the characteristics of the single-particle energy-level structure and its dependence on the symmetry and size of the cluster. Finally, we conclude by discussing some of the limitations of the model together with relevant extensions. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Apr 15, 1996•55 citations

Magnetic properties ofJ–J–J′ quantum Heisenberg chains with spinS= 1/2, 1, 3/2 and 2 in a magnetic field

Bo Gu, Gang Su, Song Gao

By means of the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) method, the magnetic properties of the J-J-J$^{\prime}$ quantum Heisenberg chains with spin $S=1/2$, 1, 3/2 and 2 in the ground states are investigated in the presence of a magnetic field. Two different cases are considered: (a) when $J$ is antiferromagnetic and $J^{\prime}$ is ferromagnetic (i.e. the AF-AF-F chain), the system is a ferrimagnet. The plateaus of the magnetization are observed. It is found that the width of the plateaus decreases with increasing the ferromagnetic coupling, and disappears when $% J^{\prime}/J$ passes over a critical value. The saturated field is observed to be independent of the ferromagnetic coupling; (b) when $J$ is ferromagnetic and $J^{\prime}$ is antiferromagnetic (i.e. the F-F-AF chain), the system becomes an antiferromagnet. The plateaus of the magnetization are also seen. The width of the plateaus decreases with decreasing the antiferromagnetic coupling, and disappears when $J^{\prime}/J $ passes over a critical value. Though the ground state properties are quite different, the magnetization plateaus in both cases tend to disappear when the ferromagnetic coupling becomes more dominant. Besides, no fundamental difference between the systems with spin half-integer and integer has been found.

arXiv:cond-mat/0508685•Journal of Physics Condensed Matter•Sep 9, 2005•26 citations

Exotic magnetic states in Heisenberg antiferromagnetism (invited) (abstract)

F. D. M. Haldane

When quantum effects are small, Heisenberg antiferromagnets have a Néel ordered ground state, but strong zero-point fluctuations can lead to new ‘‘exotic’’ spin-liquid ground states without long-range Néel order. These effects are strongest in low dimensions and frustrated systems, and always occur in one dimension. The nature of the new ground state can depend on whether the microscopic spins have integer or half-integer S. As an example of such systems the rich phase diagram of the one-dimensional S=1 Heisenberg antiferromagnet with additional biquadratic exchange and uniaxial on-site anisotropy will be discussed in detail.

Journal of Applied Physics•Apr 15, 1991•0 citations

Spin-distribution functionals and correlation energy of the Heisenberg model

Valter L. Líbero, Klaus Capelle

We analyze the ground-state energy and correlation energy of the Heisenberg model as a function of spin, both in the ferromagnetic and the antiferromagnetic case, and in one, two and three dimensions. First, we present a comparative analysis of known expressions for the ground-state energy ${E}_{0}(S)$ of homogeneous Heisenberg models. In the one-dimensional antiferromagnetic case we propose an improved expression for ${E}_{0}(S),$ which takes into account Bethe-ansatz data for $S=1/2.$ Next, we consider inhomogeneous Heisenberg models (e.g., exposed to spatially varying external fields). We prove a Hohenberg-Kohn-like theorem stating that in this case the ground-state energy is a functional of the spin distribution and that this distribution encapsulates the entire physics of the system, regardless of the external fields. Building on this theorem, we then propose a local-density-type approximation that allows us to utilize the results obtained for homogeneous systems in inhomogeneous situations too. We conjecture a scaling law for the dependence of the correlation functional on dimensionality, which is well satisfied by existing numerical data. Finally, we investigate the importance of the spin-correlation energy by comparing results obtained with the proposed correlation functional to ones from an uncorrelated mean-field calculation, taking as our example a linear spin-density wave state.

arXiv:cond-mat/0305690•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Jul 30, 2003•21 citations

Ground-state magnetization for interacting fermions in a disordered potential: Kinetic energy, exchange interaction, and off-diagonal fluctuations

Philippe Jacquod, A. Douglas Stone

We study a model of n interacting fermions in a disordered potential, which is assumed to generate uniformly fluctuating interaction matrix elements. We show that the ground-state magnetization is systematically decreased by off-diagonal fluctuations of the interaction matrix elements. This effect is neglected in the Stoner picture of itinerant ferromagnetism in which the ground-state magnetization is simply determined by the balance between ferromagnetic exchange and kinetic energy, and increasing the interaction strength always favors ferromagnetism. The physical origin of the demagnetizing effect of interaction fluctuations is the larger number K of final states available for interaction-induced scattering in the lower-spin sectors of the Hilbert space. We analyze the energetic role played by these fluctuations in the limits of small and large interactions U. In the small-$U$ limit we use second-order perturbation theory and identify explicitly transitions which are allowed for minimal spin and forbidden for higher spin. These transitions then on average lower the energy of the minimal spin ground state with respect to higher spin; we analytically evaluate the size of this reduction and find it to give a contribution ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}^{s}\ensuremath{\propto}{\mathrm{nU}}^{2}/\ensuremath{\Delta}$ to the spin gap between the two lowest-spin ground states. In terms of an average effective Hamiltonian, these contributions induce a ${\mathrm{nU}}^{2}{S}^{2}/\ensuremath{\Delta}$ term which decreases the strength of the ferromagnetic exchange, thereby delaying the onset of Stoner ferromagnetism, and generate a second, larger S term $\ensuremath{\propto}{S}^{3},$ which results in a saturation of the ground-state spin before full polarization is achieved, in contrast to the Stoner scenario. For large interactions U we amplify on our earlier work [Ph. Jacquod and A. D. Stone, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 3938 (2000)] which showed that the broadening of the many-body density of states is proportional to $\sqrt{K}U$ and hence favors minimal spin. Numerical results are presented in both limits. After evaluating the effect of fluctuations, we discuss the competition between fluctuations plus kinetic energy and the exchange energy. We finally present numerical results for specific microscopic models and relate them to our generic model of fluctuations. We discuss the different physical situations to which such models may correspond, the importance of interaction fluctuations, and hence the relevance of our results to these situations and recall an experimental setup which we proposed in an earlier work to measure the importance of interaction fluctuations on the ground-state spin of lateral quantum dots in the Coulomb blockade regime.

arXiv:cond-mat/0102100•Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Nov 13, 2001•40 citations
The question is posed of how the ground state of the Heisenberg Hamiltonian H=\ensuremath−\ensuremathΣFijSi\ifmmode⋅\else\textperiodcentered\fiSjH=\ensuremath{-}\ensuremath{\Sigma}{F}_{\mathrm{ij}}{\mathbf{S}}_{i}\ifmmode\cdot\else\textperiodcentered\fi{}{\mathbf{S}}_{j}H=\ensuremath−\ensuremathΣFij​Si​\ifmmode⋅\else\textperiodcentered\fiSj​ depends on the magnitude sss of NNN interacting spins, particularly in the case of long-ranged oscillatory interactions Fij{F}_{\mathrm{ij}}Fij​. It is discussed whether fixing the geometry and the bond strengths Fij{F}_{\mathrm{ij}}Fij​ suffices to determine the nature of the spin correlations in the ground state, and a review is given of known instances when this is the case; those are special situations in ferromagnetism and antiferromagnetism when qualitative ground-state properties such as "lack of nodes" can be proved to be independent of sss. These are valuable examples for the application of semiclassical methods, which are strictly valid only for s\ensuremath→\ensuremath∞s\ensuremath{\rightarrow}\ensuremath{\infty}s\ensuremath→\ensuremath∞ and depend on the convergence of a series in powers of s\ensuremath−1{s}^{\ensuremath{-}1}s\ensuremath−1. But these examples are, after all, only special cases, and it is argued that, in general, the nature of the ground state can depend sensitively on sss. The following situation is considered in some detail: An oscillatory interaction which leads to a ferromagnetic ground state in the correspondence limit s\ensuremath≫1s\ensuremath{\gg}1s\ensuremath≫1, but for which the ferromagnetic state of saturation magnetization may be unstable for small quantum mechanical spins, e.g., s=12or1s=\frac{1}{2} or 1s=21​or1. Two distinct types of interaction are considered which lead to this result, and it is seen that the ferromagnetic instability is a consequence, not so much of the long range of the interaction as of the presence of some relatively strong antiferromagnetic (negative) bonds. However, the variational approach which is used casts no light on the nature of the true ground state or of the thermal properties, problems which are increasingly interesting in these instances when semiclassical procedures are seen to fail.
We study the ground state of a ddd-dimensional Ising model with both long-range (dipole-like) and nearest-neighbor ferromagnetic (FM) interactions. The long-range interaction is equal to ${r}^{\ensuremath{-}p}$, p>dp>dp>d, while the FM interaction has strength JJJ. If p>d+1p>d+1p>d+1 and JJJ is large enough the ground state is FM, while if $d<p\ensuremath{\leqslant}d+1$ the FM state is not the ground state for any choice of JJJ. In d=1d=1d=1 we show that for any p>1p>1p>1 the ground state has a series of transitions from an antiferromagnetic state of period 2 to 2h2h2h-periodic states of blocks of sizes hhh with alternating sign, the size hhh growing when the FM interaction strength JJJ is increased (a generalization of this result to the case $0<p\ensuremath{\leqslant}1$ is also discussed). In $d\ensuremath{\geqslant}2$ we prove, for $d<p\ensuremath{\leqslant}d+1$, that the dominant asymptotic behavior of the ground-state energy agrees for large JJJ with that obtained from a periodic striped state conjectured to be the true ground state. The geometry of contours in the ground state is discussed.
The electronic, magnetic, and structural properties of small clusters are studied in the framework of the single-band Hubbard Hamiltonian. Results for various ground-state and excited-state many-body properties are presented, which were calculated exactly by means of Lanczos's numerical diagonalization method. A full geometry optimization is performed for N\ensuremath{\le}8 atoms by considering all possible nonequivalent cluster structures with fixed nearest-neighbor bond lengths. The most stable structure and the corresponding total spin S are obtained rigorously as a function of the Coulomb interaction strength U/t and number of electrons \ensuremath{\nu}. The resulting interplay between electron correlations, magnetism, and cluster structure is analyzed and the main trends as a function of N, U/t, and \ensuremath{\nu} are derived. The stability of cluster ferromagnetism is studied from two complementary points of view. First, for N\ensuremath{\le}8 and \ensuremath{\nu}=N+1, we determine exactly the stability of the ferromagnetic ground state with respect to electronic excitations and structural changes. It is shown that in small clusters the structural changes can be as important to the temperature dependence of the magnetization as the purely electronic excitations. Second, we determine the stability of the saturated ferromagnetic state with respect to single spin flips as a function of the band filling \ensuremath{\nu}/N. In this case a few selected larger clusters (7\ensuremath{\le}N\ensuremath{\le}43) in the strongly correlated limit (U/t\ensuremath{\rightarrow}+\ensuremath{\infty}) are considered. It is shown that the \ensuremath{\nu}/N dependence of the spin-flip energy \ensuremath{\Delta}${\mathrm{\ensuremath{\varepsilon}}}_{\mathrm{sf}}$ shows interesting electronic-shell-like oscillations, which reflect the characteristics of the single-particle energy-level structure and its dependence on the symmetry and size of the cluster. Finally, we conclude by discussing some of the limitations of the model together with relevant extensions. \textcopyright{} 1996 The American Physical Society.
By means of the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) method, the magnetic properties of the J-J-J′^{\prime}′ quantum Heisenberg chains with spin S=1/2S=1/2S=1/2, 1, 3/2 and 2 in the ground states are investigated in the presence of a magnetic field. Two different cases are considered: (a) when JJJ is antiferromagnetic and J′J^{\prime}J′ is ferromagnetic (i.e. the AF-AF-F chain), the system is a ferrimagnet. The plateaus of the magnetization are observed. It is found that the width of the plateaus decreases with increasing the ferromagnetic coupling, and disappears when % J^{\prime}/J passes over a critical value. The saturated field is observed to be independent of the ferromagnetic coupling; (b) when JJJ is ferromagnetic and J′J^{\prime}J′ is antiferromagnetic (i.e. the F-F-AF chain), the system becomes an antiferromagnet. The plateaus of the magnetization are also seen. The width of the plateaus decreases with decreasing the antiferromagnetic coupling, and disappears when $J^{\prime}/J $ passes over a critical value. Though the ground state properties are quite different, the magnetization plateaus in both cases tend to disappear when the ferromagnetic coupling becomes more dominant. Besides, no fundamental difference between the systems with spin half-integer and integer has been found.
When quantum effects are small, Heisenberg antiferromagnets have a Néel ordered ground state, but strong zero-point fluctuations can lead to new ‘‘exotic’’ spin-liquid ground states without long-range Néel order. These effects are strongest in low dimensions and frustrated systems, and always occur in one dimension. The nature of the new ground state can depend on whether the microscopic spins have integer or half-integer S. As an example of such systems the rich phase diagram of the one-dimensional S=1 Heisenberg antiferromagnet with additional biquadratic exchange and uniaxial on-site anisotropy will be discussed in detail.
We analyze the ground-state energy and correlation energy of the Heisenberg model as a function of spin, both in the ferromagnetic and the antiferromagnetic case, and in one, two and three dimensions. First, we present a comparative analysis of known expressions for the ground-state energy E0(S){E}_{0}(S)E0​(S) of homogeneous Heisenberg models. In the one-dimensional antiferromagnetic case we propose an improved expression for E0(S),{E}_{0}(S),E0​(S), which takes into account Bethe-ansatz data for S=1/2.S=1/2.S=1/2. Next, we consider inhomogeneous Heisenberg models (e.g., exposed to spatially varying external fields). We prove a Hohenberg-Kohn-like theorem stating that in this case the ground-state energy is a functional of the spin distribution and that this distribution encapsulates the entire physics of the system, regardless of the external fields. Building on this theorem, we then propose a local-density-type approximation that allows us to utilize the results obtained for homogeneous systems in inhomogeneous situations too. We conjecture a scaling law for the dependence of the correlation functional on dimensionality, which is well satisfied by existing numerical data. Finally, we investigate the importance of the spin-correlation energy by comparing results obtained with the proposed correlation functional to ones from an uncorrelated mean-field calculation, taking as our example a linear spin-density wave state.
We study a model of n interacting fermions in a disordered potential, which is assumed to generate uniformly fluctuating interaction matrix elements. We show that the ground-state magnetization is systematically decreased by off-diagonal fluctuations of the interaction matrix elements. This effect is neglected in the Stoner picture of itinerant ferromagnetism in which the ground-state magnetization is simply determined by the balance between ferromagnetic exchange and kinetic energy, and increasing the interaction strength always favors ferromagnetism. The physical origin of the demagnetizing effect of interaction fluctuations is the larger number K of final states available for interaction-induced scattering in the lower-spin sectors of the Hilbert space. We analyze the energetic role played by these fluctuations in the limits of small and large interactions U. In the small-UUU limit we use second-order perturbation theory and identify explicitly transitions which are allowed for minimal spin and forbidden for higher spin. These transitions then on average lower the energy of the minimal spin ground state with respect to higher spin; we analytically evaluate the size of this reduction and find it to give a contribution ${\ensuremath{\Delta}}^{s}\ensuremath{\propto}{\mathrm{nU}}^{2}/\ensuremath{\Delta}$ to the spin gap between the two lowest-spin ground states. In terms of an average effective Hamiltonian, these contributions induce a ${\mathrm{nU}}^{2}{S}^{2}/\ensuremath{\Delta}$ term which decreases the strength of the ferromagnetic exchange, thereby delaying the onset of Stoner ferromagnetism, and generate a second, larger S term $\ensuremath{\propto}{S}^{3},$ which results in a saturation of the ground-state spin before full polarization is achieved, in contrast to the Stoner scenario. For large interactions U we amplify on our earlier work [Ph. Jacquod and A. D. Stone, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 3938 (2000)] which showed that the broadening of the many-body density of states is proportional to KU\sqrt{K}UK​U and hence favors minimal spin. Numerical results are presented in both limits. After evaluating the effect of fluctuations, we discuss the competition between fluctuations plus kinetic energy and the exchange energy. We finally present numerical results for specific microscopic models and relate them to our generic model of fluctuations. We discuss the different physical situations to which such models may correspond, the importance of interaction fluctuations, and hence the relevance of our results to these situations and recall an experimental setup which we proposed in an earlier work to measure the importance of interaction fluctuations on the ground-state spin of lateral quantum dots in the Coulomb blockade regime.