Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics

Quantum time scales and the classical limit: Analytic results for some simple systems

Adélcio C. Oliveira, Maria Carolina Nemes, K. M. Fonseca-Romero

Published Sep 23, 2003• 29 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We set up a semiclassical approximation which helps us clarify by means of several simple examples the rich variety of time scale in the quantum domain. The underlying structure of quantum and classical mechanics is so completly different that it is naive to expect to reach a classical regime by counting powers of the quantum scale variant Planck's over 2pi. We show although it is possible to define a time scale for nonclassical phenomena, but it is impossible to characterize quantum dynamics through a unique time scale, such as Ehrenfest's time. We use simple systems to critically discuss and illustrate these features of the quantum-classical limit.

DOI
10.1103/physreve.68.036214

Related papers

Classical limit of quantum mechanics (electron in a magnetic field)

E. G. Peter Rowe

Different classical limits of quantum mechanics are discussed in the setting of a simple example, the two-dimensional motion of a spinless electron in a uniform magnetic field. Both the time-independent energy eigenstates and the time-dependent states developing from initial localized states are exactly solvable. In the first example, an ℏ→0 limit with fixed energy leads to a simple ensemble of classical orbits. In the second, ℏ→0 with fixed initial mean position and momentum leads to a unique classical orbit.

American Journal of Physics•Dec 1, 1991•9 citations

Quantum Chaos and Quantum-Classical Correspondence

Joseph Emerson

The quantum dynamics of a classically chaotic model are studied in the approach to the macroscopic limit. The quantum predictions are compared and contrasted with the classical predictions of both Newtonian and Liouville mechanics. The time-domain scaling of the optimal quantum-classical correspondence is analyzed in detail in the case of both classical theories. In both cases the correspondence for observable quantities is shown to break down on a time-scale that increases very slowly (logarithmically) with increasing system size. In the case of quantum-Liouville correspondence such a short time-scale does not imply a breakdown of correspondence since the largest quantum-Liouville differences reached on this time-scale decrease rapidly (as an inverse power) with increasing system size. Therefore the statistical properties of chaotic dynamics are, as expected, well described by quantum theory in the macroscopic limit. In contrast, the largest quantum-Newtonian differences reached on the log time-scale actually increase in proportion to the system size. Since the invariance properties of the Hamiltonian impose functional constraints on the time-varying chaotic coordinates, it is possible to show, moreover, that if the quantum predictions are believed to describe the coordinates of individual chaotic systems, then they also predict macroscopic violations of any kinematic or dynamic constants of the motion. These results for chaotic systems indicate that a valid description of the time-varying properties of individual macroscopic bodies is not available within the standard interpretive framework of quantum theory.

arXiv:quant-ph/0211035•Nov 7, 2002•19 citations

Ehrenfest times for classically chaotic systems

P. G. Silvestrov, C. W. J. Beenakker

We describe the quantum-mechanical spreading of a Gaussian wave packet by means of the semiclassical WKB approximation of Berry and Balazs [J. Phys. A $2,$ 625 (1979)]. We find that the time scale $\ensuremath{\tau}$ on which this approximation breaks down in a chaotic system is larger than the Ehrenfest times considered previously. In one dimension $\ensuremath{\tau}=\frac{7}{6}{\ensuremath{\lambda}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}\mathrm{ln}(A/\ensuremath{\Elzxh}),$ with $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ the Lyapunov exponent and A a typical classical action.

arXiv:nlin/0111042•Physical review. E, Statistical physics, plasmas, fluids, and related interdisciplinary topics•Mar 7, 2002•38 citations

Dynamics in the quantum/classical limit based on selective use of the quantum potential

Sophya V. Garashchuk, David Dell’Angelo, Vitaly A. Rassolov

A classical limit of quantum dynamics can be defined by compensation of the quantum potential in the time-dependent Schrödinger equation. The quantum potential is a non-local quantity, defined in the trajectory-based form of the Schrödinger equation, due to Madelung, de Broglie, and Bohm, which formally generates the quantum-mechanical features in dynamics. Selective inclusion of the quantum potential for the degrees of freedom deemed "quantum," defines a hybrid quantum/classical dynamics, appropriate for molecular systems comprised of light and heavy nuclei. The wavefunction is associated with all of the nuclei, and the Ehrenfest, or mean-field, averaging of the force acting on the classical degrees of freedom, typical of the mixed quantum/classical methods, is avoided. The hybrid approach is used to examine evolution of light/heavy systems in the harmonic and double-well potentials, using conventional grid-based and approximate quantum-trajectory time propagation. The approximate quantum force is defined on spatial domains, which removes unphysical coupling of the wavefunction fragments corresponding to distinct classical channels or configurations. The quantum potential, associated with the quantum particle, generates forces acting on both quantum and classical particles to describe the backreaction.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Dec 16, 2014•11 citations

Quantum dynamics with two Planck constants and the semiclassical limit

Lajos Diósi

The mathematical possibility of coupling two quantum dynamic systems having two different Planck constants, respectively, is investigated. It turns out that such canonical dynamics are always irreversible. Semiclassical dynamics is obtained by letting one of the two Planck constants go to zero. This semiclassical dynamics will preserve positivity, as expected, so an improvement of the earlier proposals by Aleksandrov and by Boucher and Traschen is achieved. Coupling of quantized matter to gravity is illustrated by a simplistic example.

arXiv:quant-ph/9503023•Mar 28, 1995•45 citations

The Classical Limit as an Approximation

Benjamin H. Feintzeig

I argue that it is possible to give an interpretation of the classical ℏ→0 limit of quantum mechanics that results in a partial explanation of the success of classical mechanics. The interpretation is novel in that it allows one to explain the success of the theoretical structure of classical mechanics. This interpretation clarifies the relationship between physical quantities and propositions in quantum theories and provides a precise notion of a quantum theory holding “approximately on certain scales.”

Philosophy of Science•Apr 30, 2020•14 citations
We set up a semiclassical approximation which helps us clarify by means of several simple examples the rich variety of time scale in the quantum domain. The underlying structure of quantum and classical mechanics is so completly different that it is naive to expect to reach a classical regime by counting powers of the quantum scale variant Planck's over 2pi. We show although it is possible to define a time scale for nonclassical phenomena, but it is impossible to characterize quantum dynamics through a unique time scale, such as Ehrenfest's time. We use simple systems to critically discuss and illustrate these features of the quantum-classical limit.
Different classical limits of quantum mechanics are discussed in the setting of a simple example, the two-dimensional motion of a spinless electron in a uniform magnetic field. Both the time-independent energy eigenstates and the time-dependent states developing from initial localized states are exactly solvable. In the first example, an ℏ→0 limit with fixed energy leads to a simple ensemble of classical orbits. In the second, ℏ→0 with fixed initial mean position and momentum leads to a unique classical orbit.
The quantum dynamics of a classically chaotic model are studied in the approach to the macroscopic limit. The quantum predictions are compared and contrasted with the classical predictions of both Newtonian and Liouville mechanics. The time-domain scaling of the optimal quantum-classical correspondence is analyzed in detail in the case of both classical theories. In both cases the correspondence for observable quantities is shown to break down on a time-scale that increases very slowly (logarithmically) with increasing system size. In the case of quantum-Liouville correspondence such a short time-scale does not imply a breakdown of correspondence since the largest quantum-Liouville differences reached on this time-scale decrease rapidly (as an inverse power) with increasing system size. Therefore the statistical properties of chaotic dynamics are, as expected, well described by quantum theory in the macroscopic limit. In contrast, the largest quantum-Newtonian differences reached on the log time-scale actually increase in proportion to the system size. Since the invariance properties of the Hamiltonian impose functional constraints on the time-varying chaotic coordinates, it is possible to show, moreover, that if the quantum predictions are believed to describe the coordinates of individual chaotic systems, then they also predict macroscopic violations of any kinematic or dynamic constants of the motion. These results for chaotic systems indicate that a valid description of the time-varying properties of individual macroscopic bodies is not available within the standard interpretive framework of quantum theory.
We describe the quantum-mechanical spreading of a Gaussian wave packet by means of the semiclassical WKB approximation of Berry and Balazs [J. Phys. A 2,2,2, 625 (1979)]. We find that the time scale $\ensuremath{\tau}$ on which this approximation breaks down in a chaotic system is larger than the Ehrenfest times considered previously. In one dimension $\ensuremath{\tau}=\frac{7}{6}{\ensuremath{\lambda}}^{\ensuremath{-}1}\mathrm{ln}(A/\ensuremath{\Elzxh}),$ with $\ensuremath{\lambda}$ the Lyapunov exponent and A a typical classical action.
A classical limit of quantum dynamics can be defined by compensation of the quantum potential in the time-dependent Schrödinger equation. The quantum potential is a non-local quantity, defined in the trajectory-based form of the Schrödinger equation, due to Madelung, de Broglie, and Bohm, which formally generates the quantum-mechanical features in dynamics. Selective inclusion of the quantum potential for the degrees of freedom deemed "quantum," defines a hybrid quantum/classical dynamics, appropriate for molecular systems comprised of light and heavy nuclei. The wavefunction is associated with all of the nuclei, and the Ehrenfest, or mean-field, averaging of the force acting on the classical degrees of freedom, typical of the mixed quantum/classical methods, is avoided. The hybrid approach is used to examine evolution of light/heavy systems in the harmonic and double-well potentials, using conventional grid-based and approximate quantum-trajectory time propagation. The approximate quantum force is defined on spatial domains, which removes unphysical coupling of the wavefunction fragments corresponding to distinct classical channels or configurations. The quantum potential, associated with the quantum particle, generates forces acting on both quantum and classical particles to describe the backreaction.
The mathematical possibility of coupling two quantum dynamic systems having two different Planck constants, respectively, is investigated. It turns out that such canonical dynamics are always irreversible. Semiclassical dynamics is obtained by letting one of the two Planck constants go to zero. This semiclassical dynamics will preserve positivity, as expected, so an improvement of the earlier proposals by Aleksandrov and by Boucher and Traschen is achieved. Coupling of quantized matter to gravity is illustrated by a simplistic example.
I argue that it is possible to give an interpretation of the classical ℏ→0 limit of quantum mechanics that results in a partial explanation of the success of classical mechanics. The interpretation is novel in that it allows one to explain the success of the theoretical structure of classical mechanics. This interpretation clarifies the relationship between physical quantities and propositions in quantum theories and provides a precise notion of a quantum theory holding “approximately on certain scales.”