Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Inquiry

IV. Does a generalized Heisenberg principle operate in the social sciences?

Garrison Sposito

Published Jan 1, 1969• 5 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It is argued that a generalization of Heisenberg's principle of indeterminacy is possible in the social sciences. The empirical grounds for this contention lie with interference phenomena induced by transference distortions that may occur when human beings investigate the behaviour of one another.
DOI
10.1080/00201746908601571

Related papers

The Significance of Complementarity for the Life Sciences

William G. Pollard

A suggestion of Bohr's to the effect that numerous situations exist among the life sciences and the social sciences which exhibit characteristics of complementarity strikingly parallel to those of quantum physics is developed further in this paper. The supposition is advanced that there may exist for biological systems inherent relations of indeterminacy between sets of observable properties of such systems analogous to the Heisenberg indeterminacy relations between canonically conjugate pairs of observables in quantum mechanics. The existence of such indeterminacies would be manifested, as it is in physical systems, in disturbances, uncontrollable in principle, produced when such systems interact with instruments and apparatus used to gain information about them. The fact that radical disturbances, whether incidental or inherent, accompany the process of observation in the life sciences is, of course, quite obvious. If a well-defined portion of such disturbances should turn out to be inherent, indeterminacy and probability would be introduced into biological phenomena as basic elements. Further progress in scientific explanation and synthesis of knowledge in these fields would then require a redefinition of the state of a biological system analogous to the necessity for using quantum ψ-functions for specifying the state of a physical system with the attendant possibility of wholly new insights, such as those in physics which ultimately depend on the symmetry properties of ψ-functions. This new, and presently unknown, scheme for specifying the state of biological systems would then presumably result in the typically complementary aspects of phenomena in these fields to which Bohr has called attention. A number of familiar examples of apparently complementary phenomena among the biological and social sciences are described, and the possibility that they may arise from inherent indeterminacies basic to the systems which exhibit these phenomena is considered. It is concluded that these considerations lead to the expectation that an approach along such lines in future investigations in the life sciences holds considerable promise, and that the physics teacher is in a unique position to assist in stimulating such an approach and in pointing out by analogy the means at each stage which are likely to prove best suited for carrying it through.

American Journal of Physics•May 1, 1952•1 citation

QUANTUM PROBABILITY APPLIED TO SOCIAL AND BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES

Jerome R. Busemeyer, ZHENG WANG

Social and behavioral sciences rely on probabilistic models to describe the behavior of people. In the past, these models have been based on the classic (Kolmogorov) theory. We argue that it may be useful to develop models using quantum (Von Neumann) probabilities. Quantum theory provides a coherent understanding of interference produced by one measure disturbing another measure, which is a common problem that occurs with human judgments.

•Aug 1, 2010•2 citations

On the cognitive experiments to test quantum-like behaviour of mind

Andrei Yu. Khrennikov

We describe cognitive experiments (based on interference of probabilities for mental observables) that could verify quantum-like structure of mental measurements. In principle, such experiments could be performed in psychology, cognitive and social sciences.

•May 15, 2002•10 citations

Does quantum uncertainty have a place in everyday applied statistics?

Andrew Gelman, Michael Betancourt

We are sympathetic to the general ideas presented in the article by Pothos & Busemeyer (P&B): Heisenberg's uncertainty principle seems naturally relevant in the social and behavioral sciences, in which measurements can affect the people being studied. We propose that the best approach for developing quantum probability models in the social and behavioral sciences is not by directly using the complex probability-amplitude formulation proposed in the article, but rather, more generally, to consider marginal probabilities that need not be averages over conditionals.

Behavioral and Brain Sciences•May 14, 2013•8 citations

Heisenberg's Indeterminacy Principle and Life

Albert Bachem

Heisenberg's (3) principle of indeterminacy or uncertainty has led most theoretical physicists and philosophers to two important steps: 1) the denunciation of the law of physical causality; 2) the decision of biological and psychological problems in favor of indeterminism.

Philosophy of Science•Oct 1, 1952•6 citations

The Quantum Dependence in the Social Behavior

Gevorg Poghosyan, Rimma M. Poghosyan

This article deals with the problems of studying communication links in a digital society. An analysis is made of the heuristic possibilities of the classical causal model for describing the dependencies of social phenomena. In the world of quantum phenomena, however, any measurement affects the system. The mere fact that we measure, for example, the location of a particle, leads to an unpredictable change in its speed. The same phenomena can be observed in the social system: any empirical study of social phenomena automatically produces in itself, some changes in this system. Modern physics has discovered the quantum structure of the material world. And human beings, as material objects, really are quantum. Therefore, social life requires a quantum structure for its proper understanding. This means that we need to develop a “quantum social science”. The principles of quantum mechanics are relevant for social theory, and therefore quantum theory cannot be ignored in the social sciences. The quantum effect can be described as the propensity of certain individuals to modify their conduct due to their consciousness of being observed. This effect refers to the fact that people will modify their behavior simply because they are being observed. The new approaches are proposed for using the quantum dependence model of theoretical physics in relation to the human phenomena in the modern digital space.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations
A suggestion of Bohr's to the effect that numerous situations exist among the life sciences and the social sciences which exhibit characteristics of complementarity strikingly parallel to those of quantum physics is developed further in this paper. The supposition is advanced that there may exist for biological systems inherent relations of indeterminacy between sets of observable properties of such systems analogous to the Heisenberg indeterminacy relations between canonically conjugate pairs of observables in quantum mechanics. The existence of such indeterminacies would be manifested, as it is in physical systems, in disturbances, uncontrollable in principle, produced when such systems interact with instruments and apparatus used to gain information about them. The fact that radical disturbances, whether incidental or inherent, accompany the process of observation in the life sciences is, of course, quite obvious. If a well-defined portion of such disturbances should turn out to be inherent, indeterminacy and probability would be introduced into biological phenomena as basic elements. Further progress in scientific explanation and synthesis of knowledge in these fields would then require a redefinition of the state of a biological system analogous to the necessity for using quantum ψ-functions for specifying the state of a physical system with the attendant possibility of wholly new insights, such as those in physics which ultimately depend on the symmetry properties of ψ-functions. This new, and presently unknown, scheme for specifying the state of biological systems would then presumably result in the typically complementary aspects of phenomena in these fields to which Bohr has called attention. A number of familiar examples of apparently complementary phenomena among the biological and social sciences are described, and the possibility that they may arise from inherent indeterminacies basic to the systems which exhibit these phenomena is considered. It is concluded that these considerations lead to the expectation that an approach along such lines in future investigations in the life sciences holds considerable promise, and that the physics teacher is in a unique position to assist in stimulating such an approach and in pointing out by analogy the means at each stage which are likely to prove best suited for carrying it through.
We are sympathetic to the general ideas presented in the article by Pothos & Busemeyer (P&B): Heisenberg's uncertainty principle seems naturally relevant in the social and behavioral sciences, in which measurements can affect the people being studied. We propose that the best approach for developing quantum probability models in the social and behavioral sciences is not by directly using the complex probability-amplitude formulation proposed in the article, but rather, more generally, to consider marginal probabilities that need not be averages over conditionals.
This article deals with the problems of studying communication links in a digital society. An analysis is made of the heuristic possibilities of the classical causal model for describing the dependencies of social phenomena. In the world of quantum phenomena, however, any measurement affects the system. The mere fact that we measure, for example, the location of a particle, leads to an unpredictable change in its speed. The same phenomena can be observed in the social system: any empirical study of social phenomena automatically produces in itself, some changes in this system. Modern physics has discovered the quantum structure of the material world. And human beings, as material objects, really are quantum. Therefore, social life requires a quantum structure for its proper understanding. This means that we need to develop a “quantum social science”. The principles of quantum mechanics are relevant for social theory, and therefore quantum theory cannot be ignored in the social sciences. The quantum effect can be described as the propensity of certain individuals to modify their conduct due to their consciousness of being observed. This effect refers to the fact that people will modify their behavior simply because they are being observed. The new approaches are proposed for using the quantum dependence model of theoretical physics in relation to the human phenomena in the modern digital space.