Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Physics B Atomic and Molecular Physics

The wavefunction of the electron in a homogeneous magnetic field and the plane-wave state: adiabatic and sudden approximations

Michelangelo Zarcone, M R C McDowell, Farhad H. M. Faisal

Published Nov 14, 1983• 6 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Expansions of a plane wave in Landau states are derived corresponding to an adiabatic and to a sudden switching on of the magnetic field. Two earlier solutions given by Faisal (1982) and by Ohsaki (1983) are found to be valid alternative expansions in the adiabatic case, which differ only in the choice of normalisations of the basis states used. A result identical to Ohsaki's is reobtained, since the Landau states are confined by conservation of energy to a large but finite area L x L y approximately 1/ gamma , perpendicular to the field. This energy conservation requires the corresponding sum over the degenerate Landau states to be restricted within a finite range. The upper and lower limits of this range are derived. The completeness relation of Faisal's expansion shows that it is also effectively and automatically confined to the same range of states. In the limit gamma to 0 both sets of expansion coefficients become identical and the results go over to the desired plane-wave state. In the sudden case, when the field switches instantaneously from zero to a finite value, the expansion no longer consists of Landau states of a fixed energy, and the result is new. The two results correspond to different limiting cases of any experimental situation, and the sudden expansion is shown to be invalid at the highest laboratory field ( approximately 20 kG) in current use. The experimental situations corresponding to the two different expansions are discussed.

DOI
10.1088/0022-3700/16/21/021

Related papers

Energy and Magnetic Moment of a Quantum Charged Particle in Time-Dependent Magnetic and Electric Fields of Circular and Plane Solenoids

V. V. Dodonov, Matheus B. Horovits

We consider a quantum spinless nonrelativistic charged particle moving in the xy plane under the action of a time-dependent magnetic field, described by means of the linear vector potential A=B(t)-y(1+α),x(1-α)/2, with two fixed values of the gauge parameter α: α=0 (the circular gauge) and α=1 (the Landau gauge). While the magnetic field is the same in all the cases, the systems with different values of the gauge parameter are not equivalent for nonstationary magnetic fields due to different structures of induced electric fields, whose lines of force are circles for α=0 and straight lines for α=1. We derive general formulas for the time-dependent mean values of the energy and magnetic moment, as well as for their variances, for an arbitrary function B(t). They are expressed in terms of solutions to the classical equation of motion ε¨+ωα2(t)ε=0, with ω1=2ω0. Explicit results are found in the cases of the sudden jump of magnetic field, the parametric resonance, the adiabatic evolution, and for several specific functions B(t), when solutions can be expressed in terms of elementary or hypergeometric functions. These examples show that the evolution of the mentioned mean values can be rather different for the two gauges, if the evolution is not adiabatic. It appears that the adiabatic approximation fails when the magnetic field goes to zero. Moreover, the sudden jump approximation can fail in this case as well. The case of a slowly varying field changing its sign seems especially interesting. In all the cases, fluctuations of the magnetic moment are very strong, frequently exceeding the square of the mean value.

arXiv:2110.04811•Entropy•Nov 26, 2021•6 citations

Electron wave-functions in a magnetic field

D. K. Sunko

The problem of a single electron in a magnetic field is revisited from first principles. It is shown that the standard quantization, used by Landau, is inconsistent for this problem, whence Landau's wave functions spontaneously break the gauge symmetry of translations in the plane. Because of this Landau's (and Fock's) wave functions have a spurious second quantum number. The one-body wave function of the physical orbit, with only one quantum number, is derived, and expressed as a superposition of Landau's wave functions. Conversely, it is shown that Landau's wave functions are a limiting case of physical solutions of a different problem, where two quantum numbers naturally appear. When the translation gauge symmetry is respected, the degeneracy related to the choice of orbit center does not appear in the one-body problem.

arXiv:1111.6107•Nov 25, 2011•0 citations

Theoretical studies of the two-dimensional interacting electron system in high magnetic field

Matthew Brownlie

This is a mathematical study of certain aspects of the interacting electron system in very high perpendicular magnetic field.\nWe analyse restrictions imposed upon the density correlation functions of this system and propose a set of sum rules which they must obey.\nWe study the possibility of building a bosonisation scheme for the projected density operators in the lowest Landau level. We suggest a second order bosonisation, along with an approximation scheme, which may be useful for carrying out calculations in the lowest Landau level.\nWe analyse the possible ground states of the system. We suggest a set of variational wavefunctions which can have lower energy than the Laughlin state for sufficiently soft interaction potentials.\nWe study the collective excitations of the system, paying particular attention to its symmetries. We suggest a set of variational excited states and discuss their applicability to finite as well as infinite systems.

•Dec 10, 2013•0 citations

ON ADIABATIC INVARIANCE IN QUANTUM MECHANICS

Marius Kolsrud

A connection between quantum mechanical and classical adiabatic invariance is shown for the special case of a charged particle moving in a homogeneous, time-dependent magnetic field. The relationship consists of the fact that the transition probability between energy eigenstates corresponding to the magnnetic field at two different times is a function of a certain classical adiabatic invariant alone. From this relation follows the well-known result that during sufficiently slow changes of the magnetic field the particle will remain in one quantum state which passes continuously through the different instantaneous energies. The adiabatic invariance of this classical quantity is shown directly by solving the equations of niotion when the magnetic field changes linearly with time. (auth)

•Jan 1, 1958•0 citations

Geometrical Relations for Charged Particles in a Uniform Magnetic Field

D. M. Thomson

By using appropriate gauge transformations one can develop quasiclassical wavefunctions for charged particles in a uniform magnetic field which have large amplitudes only in the neighborhood of classical Larmor orbits centered at arbitrary points in a plane perpendicular to the field. Pairs of such wavefunctions are not orthogonal to each other. Interesting geometrical relationships between these solutions and the degenerate orthonormal sets of wave-functions in a particular gauge can be found as a result of evaluating overlap integrals. This has been done for both the cylindrical and Landau gauges. In the cylindrical gauge certain of the orthonormal wavefunctions corresponding to different energies give identical probability distributions. Relationships between quantum and classical results, and the effect of the uncertainty principle are discussed.

American Journal of Physics•Nov 1, 1972•1 citation

Magnetization dynamics of a harmonically confined quantum charged particle in time dependent magnetic fields inside a circular solenoid

V. V. Dodonov

Abstract I consider a quantum spinless charged particle moving in the xy plane under the action of a time-dependent magnetic field described by means of the linear vector potential in the ‘circular’ gauge A = B ( t )(− y , x )/2 and in the presence of the confining potential m g 2 x 2 + y 2 / 2 . This potential guarantees finite values of all second-order moments in the initial equilibrium (thermal) state. Time-dependent mean values of the energy and magnetic moment are expressed in terms of solutions to the classical equation of motion ε ̈ + Ω 2 ( t ) ε = 0 . Simple approximate results are found in the cases of the sudden jump of magnetic field, the parametric resonance, and the adiabatic evolution. They are compared with exact solutions in terms of the hypergeometric function for the specific function B ( t ) of the Epstein–Eckart type. A great amplification of the magnetic moment is discovered for the initial high-temperature states, both for the fast and slow monotonous variations of the magnetic field. Classical adiabatic invariants do not exist if the magnetic field slowly goes to zero or changes its sign.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Jun 8, 2021•6 citations
Expansions of a plane wave in Landau states are derived corresponding to an adiabatic and to a sudden switching on of the magnetic field. Two earlier solutions given by Faisal (1982) and by Ohsaki (1983) are found to be valid alternative expansions in the adiabatic case, which differ only in the choice of normalisations of the basis states used. A result identical to Ohsaki's is reobtained, since the Landau states are confined by conservation of energy to a large but finite area L x L y approximately 1/ gamma , perpendicular to the field. This energy conservation requires the corresponding sum over the degenerate Landau states to be restricted within a finite range. The upper and lower limits of this range are derived. The completeness relation of Faisal's expansion shows that it is also effectively and automatically confined to the same range of states. In the limit gamma to 0 both sets of expansion coefficients become identical and the results go over to the desired plane-wave state. In the sudden case, when the field switches instantaneously from zero to a finite value, the expansion no longer consists of Landau states of a fixed energy, and the result is new. The two results correspond to different limiting cases of any experimental situation, and the sudden expansion is shown to be invalid at the highest laboratory field ( approximately 20 kG) in current use. The experimental situations corresponding to the two different expansions are discussed.
We consider a quantum spinless nonrelativistic charged particle moving in the xy plane under the action of a time-dependent magnetic field, described by means of the linear vector potential A=B(t)-y(1+α),x(1-α)/2, with two fixed values of the gauge parameter α: α=0 (the circular gauge) and α=1 (the Landau gauge). While the magnetic field is the same in all the cases, the systems with different values of the gauge parameter are not equivalent for nonstationary magnetic fields due to different structures of induced electric fields, whose lines of force are circles for α=0 and straight lines for α=1. We derive general formulas for the time-dependent mean values of the energy and magnetic moment, as well as for their variances, for an arbitrary function B(t). They are expressed in terms of solutions to the classical equation of motion ε¨+ωα2(t)ε=0, with ω1=2ω0. Explicit results are found in the cases of the sudden jump of magnetic field, the parametric resonance, the adiabatic evolution, and for several specific functions B(t), when solutions can be expressed in terms of elementary or hypergeometric functions. These examples show that the evolution of the mentioned mean values can be rather different for the two gauges, if the evolution is not adiabatic. It appears that the adiabatic approximation fails when the magnetic field goes to zero. Moreover, the sudden jump approximation can fail in this case as well. The case of a slowly varying field changing its sign seems especially interesting. In all the cases, fluctuations of the magnetic moment are very strong, frequently exceeding the square of the mean value.
The problem of a single electron in a magnetic field is revisited from first principles. It is shown that the standard quantization, used by Landau, is inconsistent for this problem, whence Landau's wave functions spontaneously break the gauge symmetry of translations in the plane. Because of this Landau's (and Fock's) wave functions have a spurious second quantum number. The one-body wave function of the physical orbit, with only one quantum number, is derived, and expressed as a superposition of Landau's wave functions. Conversely, it is shown that Landau's wave functions are a limiting case of physical solutions of a different problem, where two quantum numbers naturally appear. When the translation gauge symmetry is respected, the degeneracy related to the choice of orbit center does not appear in the one-body problem.
This is a mathematical study of certain aspects of the interacting electron system in very high perpendicular magnetic field.\nWe analyse restrictions imposed upon the density correlation functions of this system and propose a set of sum rules which they must obey.\nWe study the possibility of building a bosonisation scheme for the projected density operators in the lowest Landau level. We suggest a second order bosonisation, along with an approximation scheme, which may be useful for carrying out calculations in the lowest Landau level.\nWe analyse the possible ground states of the system. We suggest a set of variational wavefunctions which can have lower energy than the Laughlin state for sufficiently soft interaction potentials.\nWe study the collective excitations of the system, paying particular attention to its symmetries. We suggest a set of variational excited states and discuss their applicability to finite as well as infinite systems.
A connection between quantum mechanical and classical adiabatic invariance is shown for the special case of a charged particle moving in a homogeneous, time-dependent magnetic field. The relationship consists of the fact that the transition probability between energy eigenstates corresponding to the magnnetic field at two different times is a function of a certain classical adiabatic invariant alone. From this relation follows the well-known result that during sufficiently slow changes of the magnetic field the particle will remain in one quantum state which passes continuously through the different instantaneous energies. The adiabatic invariance of this classical quantity is shown directly by solving the equations of niotion when the magnetic field changes linearly with time. (auth)
By using appropriate gauge transformations one can develop quasiclassical wavefunctions for charged particles in a uniform magnetic field which have large amplitudes only in the neighborhood of classical Larmor orbits centered at arbitrary points in a plane perpendicular to the field. Pairs of such wavefunctions are not orthogonal to each other. Interesting geometrical relationships between these solutions and the degenerate orthonormal sets of wave-functions in a particular gauge can be found as a result of evaluating overlap integrals. This has been done for both the cylindrical and Landau gauges. In the cylindrical gauge certain of the orthonormal wavefunctions corresponding to different energies give identical probability distributions. Relationships between quantum and classical results, and the effect of the uncertainty principle are discussed.
Abstract I consider a quantum spinless charged particle moving in the xy plane under the action of a time-dependent magnetic field described by means of the linear vector potential in the ‘circular’ gauge A = B ( t )(− y , x )/2 and in the presence of the confining potential m g 2 x 2 + y 2 / 2 . This potential guarantees finite values of all second-order moments in the initial equilibrium (thermal) state. Time-dependent mean values of the energy and magnetic moment are expressed in terms of solutions to the classical equation of motion ε ̈ + Ω 2 ( t ) ε = 0 . Simple approximate results are found in the cases of the sudden jump of magnetic field, the parametric resonance, and the adiabatic evolution. They are compared with exact solutions in terms of the hypergeometric function for the specific function B ( t ) of the Epstein–Eckart type. A great amplification of the magnetic moment is discovered for the initial high-temperature states, both for the fast and slow monotonous variations of the magnetic field. Classical adiabatic invariants do not exist if the magnetic field slowly goes to zero or changes its sign.