The author’s previously given method of representation of space-time relationships in restricted relativity, by means of oblique coordinates, is briefly reviewed (J.O. S. A. and R. S. I., 13, p. 155; 1926). The theory is then applied to the following problem: Two observers, S and S′, are moving at a relative velocity q. The S′ observer has in his system a set of pointers distributed parallel to q, and oscillating in synchronism and in phase with one another. It is required to describe the motion as seen by the observer S. By drawing two sine waves in the Lorentzian plane, it is shown graphically that for the S observer the pointers do not swing in synchronism, but form a traveling wave whose velocity of propagation, u, is connected with q by the familiar relationship uq=c2, where c is the velocity of light.Introducing the so-called velocity angle, α, determined by the relationship sin α=q/c, various other properties of the traveling wave, as seen by S, are deduced, such as the apparent frequency at a point in space, the apparent amplitude and its velocity of propagation, the Fitzgerald contraction of the oscillating system, and the slowing down of the frequency of oscillation.By assuming a large number of S′ systems whose velocity angles differ from each other by very small amounts, the group velocity of the “super-light” waves is shown to be equal to the velocity q of the original S′ system. Finally, de Broglie’s quantum principle is stated and transformed in terms of the velocity angle α.
The author’s previously given method of representation of space-time relationships in restricted relativity, by means of oblique coordinates, is briefly reviewed (J.O. S. A. and R. S. I., 13, p. 155; 1926). The theory is then applied to the following problem: Two observers, S and S′, are moving at a relative velocity q. The S′ observer has in his system a set of pointers distributed parallel to q, and oscillating in synchronism and in phase with one another. It is required to describe the motion as seen by the observer S. By drawing two sine waves in the Lorentzian plane, it is shown graphically that for the S observer the pointers do not swing in synchronism, but form a traveling wave whose velocity of propagation, u, is connected with q by the familiar relationship uq=c2, where c is the velocity of light.Introducing the so-called velocity angle, α, determined by the relationship sin α=q/c, various other properties of the traveling wave, as seen by S, are deduced, such as the apparent frequency at a point in space, the apparent amplitude and its velocity of propagation, the Fitzgerald contraction of the oscillating system, and the slowing down of the frequency of oscillation.By assuming a large number of S′ systems whose velocity angles differ from each other by very small amounts, the group velocity of the “super-light” waves is shown to be equal to the velocity q of the original S′ system. Finally, de Broglie’s quantum principle is stated and transformed in terms of the velocity angle α.
Louis-Victor de Broglie secured his place in the history of quantum physics by proposing the existence of matter waves. Following the concept accepted early in the twentieth century that light waves could display properties characteristic of particles (photons), de Broglie suggested the complementary principle that particles could display properties characteristic of waves. Within a few years, this far-reaching proposal was experimentally verified. The well-known formula for the wavelength λ of the wave associated with a particle of momentum p, namely λ=h/p, does not appear in de Broglie’s original paper, which was published in this journal in 1924. What is derived from the starting assumption that the frequency of the wave is the rest energy of the particle divided by Planck’s constant h, is the wave's velocity, which turns out to be c2/v, where v is the particle’s velocity. This velocity, being superluminal, means that the wave cannot transport energy. De Broglie called it a phase wave and postulated a group of such waves having virtually, but not exactly, the same velocity and wavelength. The group velocity of such a large number of almost identical phase waves is then shown, very satisfactorily, to be equal to the velocity of the particle. The proposal by de Broglie inspired Schrödinger to develop the mathematical foundations of wave mechanics. Whereas in conventional quantum theory, phase waves are considered fictional, de Broglie considered them to have a certain physical reality, renaming them pilot or guiding waves – a concept developed later by Bohm in 1952.
De Broglie waves are a simple consequence of special relativity applied to the complex-phase oscillations of stationary states. As de Broglie showed in his doctoral thesis, the synchronized oscillations of an extended system at rest, even a classical one, become de Broglie-like waves when boosted to finite velocity. The waves illustrate the well-known but seldom demonstrated relativistic effect of clock desynchroniation (or dephasing) in moving frames. Although common manifestations of stationary-state oscillations in interference experiments are sensitive only to energy differences, de Broglie wavelengths are inversely proportional to rest-frame oscillation frequency, and their observed values require that the oscillation frequencies are proportional to the the total absolute energy, including the rest component mc2. PACS Nos.: 03.65.Ta, 03.30.+p, 01.65.+g
The Lorentz transformation (LT) is explained by changes occurring in the wave characteristics of matter as it changes inertial frame. This explanation is akin to that favoured by Lorentz, but informed by later insights, due primarily to de Broglie, regarding the underlying unity of matter and radiation. To show the nature of these changes, a massive particle is modelled as a standing wave in three dimensions. As the particle moves, the standing wave becomes a travelling wave having two factors. One is a carrier wave displaying the dilated frequency and contracted ellipsoidal form described by the LT, while the other (identified as the de Broglie wave) is a modulation defining the dephasing of the carrier wave (and thus the failure of simultaneity) in the direction of travel. The superluminality of the de Broglie wave is thus explained, as are several other mysterious features of the optical behaviour of matter, including the physical meaning of the Schrödinger equation and the relevance to scattering processes of the de Broglie wave vector. Consideration is given to what this Lorentzian approach to relativity might mean for the possible existence of a preferred frame and the origin of the observed Minkowski metric.
The electromagnetic component waves, comprising together with their generating oscillatory massless charge a material particle, will be Doppler shifted when the charge hence particle is in motion, with a velocity v, as a mere mechanical consequence of the source motion. We illustrate here that two such component waves generated in opposite directions and propagating at speed c between walls in a one-dimensional box, superpose into a traveling beat wave of wavelength ${\mitΛ}_d$$=(\frac{v}{c}){\mitΛ}$ and phase velocity c2/v+v which resembles directly L. de Broglie's hypothetic phase wave. This phase wave in terms of transporting the particle mass at the speed v and angular frequency ${\mitΩ}_d=2πv /{\mitΛ}_d$, with ${\mitΛ}_d$ and ${\mitΩ}_d$ obeying the de Broglie relations, represents a de Broglie wave. The standing-wave function of the de Broglie (phase) wave and its variables for particle dynamics in small geometries are equivalent to the eigen-state solutions to Schrödinger equation of an identical system.
Within the framework of the ‘Pairwise Interference Model’ of light–matter interaction, it is postulated that light particles follow definite trajectories, and thus, for example, in the double-slit experiment, a particle can pass through only one of the two slits. On this premise, the interference of two photons is examined in greater detail. It is hypothesized that the interference of a photon pair requires the involvement of matter and, initially, that both molecular excitations and photons oscillate at the same frequency and that the continuity of the oscillation is not disrupted by absorption and emission. The molecular excitations in the light source are supposed to oscillate synchronously. Both photons arrive at the same point on the detector but may travel along different paths and therefore arrive at different times. Under these conditions, their phase difference, φ(2) – φ(1), is always zero. Consequently, no interference pattern can form on the detector screen and therefore the assumptions made are incorrect. Alternatively, one may assume that only the photon oscillates, whereas the excitation stores the phase, φ, possessed by the photon at the instant of absorption. In this case, φ(2) – φ(1) corresponds to the difference in travel times modulo the oscillation period, and an interference pattern can form. However, this assumption is problematic for some reasons: the nature of the matter-based memory remains unclear; according to the special theory of relativity, no time elapses for a particle travelling at the speed of light, meaning that it cannot oscillate; and the assumption contradicts Bohr’s correspondence principle. In a classical wave, the phase information propagates away from the source at the wave velocity without changing. This leads to the alternative possibility that the excitations oscillate, whereas the photons do not. Instead, the photons transport information about the phase of the excitation at the instant of emission. As can be shown, in this case, φ(2) – φ(1) likewise corresponds to the difference in travel times modulo the oscillation period. However, this hypothesis contradicts the de Broglie postulate, according to which all particles exhibit wave properties, and the relation ε = hν must therefore be interpreted differently. It also raises the question of how the dimensions of a laser, specifically the mirror separation, can influence the wavelength of the amplified light if a photon has no wavelength. Using replicator dynamics and the ‘Pairwise Interference Model’ of light–matter interaction, a simulation demonstrates that, in a simplified laser model, assuming that photons do not oscillate whereas excitations do, self-organisation gives rise to a phase pattern in the sequence of photons within the emitted light beam that corresponds to the pattern obtained by discretising a classical wave. Thus, coherent light can exhibit wave properties even if photons themselves do not. Finally, the possibility of how incoherent light acquires wave properties is briefly discussed.
Abstract The forgotten history of de Broglie waves as themselves artifacts of a Lorentz transform, not physical lengths and frequencies to be transformed, causes confusion for students and others. In this paper the de Broglie wavelength is derived and dependence of de Broglie frequency on velocity explained in terms of Einstein synchronized reference frame measurements of a single clock ( 2-on-1 ) versus measurements of an Einstein reference frame by an observer with a single clock ( 1-on-2 ). A new memory aid for the relativity of simultaneity, ‘leading clocks lag,’ is introduced that puts it on a par with the heuristics ‘time dilation’ and ‘length contraction’ for quick and easy problem visualization.