Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

THE CLASSICAL LIMIT OF THE LATTICE-THEORETICAL ORTHOCOMPLEMENTATION IN THE FRAMEWORK OF THE HIDDEN-MEASUREMENT APPROACH

Thomas Durt, Bart D’Hooghe

Published Jun 1, 2002• 6 citations
Publisher

Abstract

We study the Grib-Zapatrin orthocomplementation for the epsilon model, and show that it does not allow a Boolean orthoclosure in the deterministic limit of the model. We generalize the epsilon model to a model in which the change of state induced by the measurement process is controlled by a continuous parameter such that in the classical limit this change of state vanishes. As a consequence, the Grib-Zapatrin orthoclosure will become Boolean, showing that determinism by itself is not sufficient to ensure a complete classical character for the system. Finally, we use Wooters topology for physical systems to show that this theorem holds in general.

DOI
10.1142/9789812778024_0005

Related papers

ON THE ORTHOCOMPLEMENTATION OF STATE-PROPERTY-SYSTEMS OF CONTEXTUAL SYSTEMS

Bart D’Hooghe

We describe a model in which the maximal change of state of the system due to interaction with the measurement context is controlled by a parameter which corresponds with the number N of possible outcomes in an experiment. In the limit N = 2 the system reduces to a model for the spin measurements on a quantum spin- particle. This model fits in the hidden measurement approach to quantum mechanics in which quantum probabilities are explained as due to an uncontrollable fluctuation in the measurement process. In the limit N → ∞ the system is classical, i.e. the experiments are deterministic and its set of properties is a Boolean lattice. For intermediate situations the change of state due to measurement is neither ‘maximal’ (i.e. quantum) nor ‘zero’ (i.e. classical). We show that two of the axioms used in Piron's representation theorem for quantum mechanics are violated, namely the covering law and weak modularity. Next, we discuss a modified version of the model for which it is even impossible to define an orthocomplementation on the set of properties. Another interesting feature for the intermediate situations of this model is that the probability of a state transition in general not only depends on the angular distance between the two states but also on the measurement context which induces the state transition. Therefore our models also shed new light on Gleason's theorem and suggest that transition probability maybe is not a secondary concept which can be derived from the structure on the set of states and properties, but instead should be regarded as a primitive concept by its own right for which the measurement context is crucial.

•Mar 5, 2014•0 citations

General methods and properties for evaluation of continuum limits of discrete time quantum walks in one and two dimensions

Michael Manighalam

Models of quantum walks which admit continuous time and continuous spacetime limits have recently led to quantum simulation schemes for simulating fermions in relativistic and non relativistic regimes (Di Molfetta and Arrighi, 2020). This work continues the study of relationships between discrete time quantum walks (DTQW) and their ostensive continuum counterparts by developing a more general framework than was done in (Di Molfetta and Arrighi, 2020) to evaluate the continuous time limit of these discrete quantum systems. Under this framework, we prove two constructive theorems concerning which internal discrete transitions ("coins") admit nontrivial continuum limits in 1D+1. We additionally prove that the continuous space limit of the continuous time limit of the DTQW can only yield massless states which obey the Dirac equation. We also demonstrate that for general coins the continuous time limit of the DTQW can be identified with the canonical continuous time quantum walk (CTQW) when the coin is allowed to transition through the continuum limit process. Finally, we introduce the Plastic Quantum Walk, or a quantum walk which admits both continuous time and continuous spacetime limits and, as a novel result, we use our 1D+1 results to obtain necessary and sufficient conditions concerning which DTQWs admit plasticity in 2D+1, showing the resulting Hamiltonians. We consider coin operators as general 4 parameter unitary matrices, with parameters which are functions of the lattice step size 𝜖. This dependence on 𝜖 encapsulates all functions of 𝜖 for which a Taylor series expansion in 𝜖 is well defined, making our results very general.

•Jan 1, 2021•0 citations

Classical World Arising out of Quantum Physics under the Restriction of Coarse-Grained Measurements

Johannes Kofler, Časlav Brukner

Conceptually different from the decoherence program, we present a novel theoretical approach to macroscopic realism and classical physics within quantum theory. It focuses on the limits of observability of quantum effects of macroscopic objects, i.e., on the required precision of our measurement apparatuses such that quantum phenomena can still be observed. First, we demonstrate that for unrestricted measurement accuracy, no classical description is possible for arbitrarily large systems. Then we show for a certain time evolution that under coarse-grained measurements, not only macrorealism but even classical Newtonian laws emerge out of the Schrödinger equation and the projection postulate.

arXiv:quant-ph/0609079•Physical Review Letters•Nov 2, 2007•237 citations

Robust Model Predictive Control for Quantum Systems

Yun-Yan Lee

The application of Model Predictive Control (MPC) to quantum systems faces fundamental challenges arising from measurement-induced disturbances and the probabilistic nature of quantum dynamics. Unlike classical nonlinear systems, quantum measurements inherently disturb the system state, making feedback control intrinsically model-dependent and stochastic. Within the framework of Positive Operator-Valued Measures (POVMs), this thesis focuses on strong quantum measurements, where each observation induces a complete state collapse on the system. When uncertainty is introduced, the measurement process itself becomes a dominant source of disturbance. To address this, a lower bound on the measurement uncertainty is imposed, quantified as the predicted deviation between the measured quantum state and the nominal MPC trajectory, ensuring that the quantum state can be steered along the designed MPC trajectory while maintaining physical realizability and stability. The thesis further develops a stochastic MPC (SMPC) formulation based on quantum filtering equations, describing the conditional evolution of quantum states under continuous observation. A theoretical equivalence between the proposed SMPC scheme and an optimal control problem is established, providing a tractable computational approach for feedback design in quantum stochastic systems. Finally, to address the limitations imposed by explicit identification of quantum systems in complex quantum systems, a data-driven MPC framework is introduced. Using locally observable dynamics and trajectory data, a data-driven MPC formulation is introduced to realize predictive quantum control without explicit system identification. This framework lays the foundation for measurement-aware and physically consistent quantum MPC.

•Jan 1, 2026•0 citations

Precision Limit for Observation: The Bridge for Quantum Classical Transitions

Suyu Li, Canneng Liang, Mingxing Jin

Quantum mechanics (QM) is an extremely successful theory; however, there is still no consensus regarding its interpretation. Among the controversies, the quantum classical transitions are the outstanding questions. In this paper, starting from measurement theory, we discuss the role that the precision limit for observation plays in QM and attempt to lubricate the relationship between the precision limit and some unique characters and nature of QM. By reviewing Bohmian mechanics, one of the nonlocal hidden variable theories, we discuss the possibility of restoring determinism in QM. We conclude that it is the existence of the precision limit that makes it impossible to restore determinism in QM, and it is the root that makes QM different from classical physics. Finally, the boundary between the so-called classical and quantum worlds is discussed. We hope these philosophical arguments can provide a kind of epistemic understanding for QM.

Journal of Quantum Information Science•Jan 1, 2025•1 citation

Continuous quantum measurement and the quantum to classical transition

Tanmoy Bhattacharya A, Salman Habib, Kurt A. Jacobs

While ultimately they are described by quantum mechanics, macroscopic mechanical systems are nevertheless observed to follow the trajectories predicted by classical mechanics. Hence, in the regime defining macroscopic physics, the trajectories of the correct classical motion must emerge from quantum mechanics, a process referred to as the quantum to classical transition. Extending previous work [Bhattacharya, Habib, and Jacobs, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 4852 (2000)], here we elucidate this transition in some detail, showing that once the measurement processes that affect all macroscopic systems are taken into account, quantum mechanics indeed predicts the emergence of classical motion. We derive inequalities that describe the parameter regime in which classical motion is obtained, and provide numerical examples. We also demonstrate two further important properties of the classical limit: first, that multiple observers all agree on the motion of an object, and second, that classical statistical inference may be used to correctly track the classical motion.

arXiv:quant-ph/0211036•Physical Review A•Apr 8, 2003•50 citations
We study the Grib-Zapatrin orthocomplementation for the epsilon model, and show that it does not allow a Boolean orthoclosure in the deterministic limit of the model. We generalize the epsilon model to a model in which the change of state induced by the measurement process is controlled by a continuous parameter such that in the classical limit this change of state vanishes. As a consequence, the Grib-Zapatrin orthoclosure will become Boolean, showing that determinism by itself is not sufficient to ensure a complete classical character for the system. Finally, we use Wooters topology for physical systems to show that this theorem holds in general.
We describe a model in which the maximal change of state of the system due to interaction with the measurement context is controlled by a parameter which corresponds with the number N of possible outcomes in an experiment. In the limit N = 2 the system reduces to a model for the spin measurements on a quantum spin- particle. This model fits in the hidden measurement approach to quantum mechanics in which quantum probabilities are explained as due to an uncontrollable fluctuation in the measurement process. In the limit N → ∞ the system is classical, i.e. the experiments are deterministic and its set of properties is a Boolean lattice. For intermediate situations the change of state due to measurement is neither ‘maximal’ (i.e. quantum) nor ‘zero’ (i.e. classical). We show that two of the axioms used in Piron's representation theorem for quantum mechanics are violated, namely the covering law and weak modularity. Next, we discuss a modified version of the model for which it is even impossible to define an orthocomplementation on the set of properties. Another interesting feature for the intermediate situations of this model is that the probability of a state transition in general not only depends on the angular distance between the two states but also on the measurement context which induces the state transition. Therefore our models also shed new light on Gleason's theorem and suggest that transition probability maybe is not a secondary concept which can be derived from the structure on the set of states and properties, but instead should be regarded as a primitive concept by its own right for which the measurement context is crucial.
Models of quantum walks which admit continuous time and continuous spacetime limits have recently led to quantum simulation schemes for simulating fermions in relativistic and non relativistic regimes (Di Molfetta and Arrighi, 2020). This work continues the study of relationships between discrete time quantum walks (DTQW) and their ostensive continuum counterparts by developing a more general framework than was done in (Di Molfetta and Arrighi, 2020) to evaluate the continuous time limit of these discrete quantum systems. Under this framework, we prove two constructive theorems concerning which internal discrete transitions ("coins") admit nontrivial continuum limits in 1D+1. We additionally prove that the continuous space limit of the continuous time limit of the DTQW can only yield massless states which obey the Dirac equation. We also demonstrate that for general coins the continuous time limit of the DTQW can be identified with the canonical continuous time quantum walk (CTQW) when the coin is allowed to transition through the continuum limit process. Finally, we introduce the Plastic Quantum Walk, or a quantum walk which admits both continuous time and continuous spacetime limits and, as a novel result, we use our 1D+1 results to obtain necessary and sufficient conditions concerning which DTQWs admit plasticity in 2D+1, showing the resulting Hamiltonians. We consider coin operators as general 4 parameter unitary matrices, with parameters which are functions of the lattice step size 𝜖. This dependence on 𝜖 encapsulates all functions of 𝜖 for which a Taylor series expansion in 𝜖 is well defined, making our results very general.
Conceptually different from the decoherence program, we present a novel theoretical approach to macroscopic realism and classical physics within quantum theory. It focuses on the limits of observability of quantum effects of macroscopic objects, i.e., on the required precision of our measurement apparatuses such that quantum phenomena can still be observed. First, we demonstrate that for unrestricted measurement accuracy, no classical description is possible for arbitrarily large systems. Then we show for a certain time evolution that under coarse-grained measurements, not only macrorealism but even classical Newtonian laws emerge out of the Schrödinger equation and the projection postulate.
The application of Model Predictive Control (MPC) to quantum systems faces fundamental challenges arising from measurement-induced disturbances and the probabilistic nature of quantum dynamics. Unlike classical nonlinear systems, quantum measurements inherently disturb the system state, making feedback control intrinsically model-dependent and stochastic. Within the framework of Positive Operator-Valued Measures (POVMs), this thesis focuses on strong quantum measurements, where each observation induces a complete state collapse on the system. When uncertainty is introduced, the measurement process itself becomes a dominant source of disturbance. To address this, a lower bound on the measurement uncertainty is imposed, quantified as the predicted deviation between the measured quantum state and the nominal MPC trajectory, ensuring that the quantum state can be steered along the designed MPC trajectory while maintaining physical realizability and stability. The thesis further develops a stochastic MPC (SMPC) formulation based on quantum filtering equations, describing the conditional evolution of quantum states under continuous observation. A theoretical equivalence between the proposed SMPC scheme and an optimal control problem is established, providing a tractable computational approach for feedback design in quantum stochastic systems. Finally, to address the limitations imposed by explicit identification of quantum systems in complex quantum systems, a data-driven MPC framework is introduced. Using locally observable dynamics and trajectory data, a data-driven MPC formulation is introduced to realize predictive quantum control without explicit system identification. This framework lays the foundation for measurement-aware and physically consistent quantum MPC.
Quantum mechanics (QM) is an extremely successful theory; however, there is still no consensus regarding its interpretation. Among the controversies, the quantum classical transitions are the outstanding questions. In this paper, starting from measurement theory, we discuss the role that the precision limit for observation plays in QM and attempt to lubricate the relationship between the precision limit and some unique characters and nature of QM. By reviewing Bohmian mechanics, one of the nonlocal hidden variable theories, we discuss the possibility of restoring determinism in QM. We conclude that it is the existence of the precision limit that makes it impossible to restore determinism in QM, and it is the root that makes QM different from classical physics. Finally, the boundary between the so-called classical and quantum worlds is discussed. We hope these philosophical arguments can provide a kind of epistemic understanding for QM.
While ultimately they are described by quantum mechanics, macroscopic mechanical systems are nevertheless observed to follow the trajectories predicted by classical mechanics. Hence, in the regime defining macroscopic physics, the trajectories of the correct classical motion must emerge from quantum mechanics, a process referred to as the quantum to classical transition. Extending previous work [Bhattacharya, Habib, and Jacobs, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 4852 (2000)], here we elucidate this transition in some detail, showing that once the measurement processes that affect all macroscopic systems are taken into account, quantum mechanics indeed predicts the emergence of classical motion. We derive inequalities that describe the parameter regime in which classical motion is obtained, and provide numerical examples. We also demonstrate two further important properties of the classical limit: first, that multiple observers all agree on the motion of an object, and second, that classical statistical inference may be used to correctly track the classical motion.