Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

The Journal of Physical Chemistry

Comment on Quantum Transition State Theory

Stuart A. Rice, Soonmin Jang, Meishan Zhao

Published Jan 1, 1996• 9 citations
Publisher

Abstract

In a previous paper ( J . Phys . Chem . 1994, 98, 3444), we showed, within the framework of the reaction coordinate representation of the dynamics of a chemical reaction, that application of a complex scaling transformation to the reaction coordinate leads naturally to the definition of transition states with complex energies and to the definition of an operator whose expectation values are the lifetimes of these states. That analysis has the unphysical feature of not eliminating the dependence of the lifetime operator on the positive angle parameter of the unitary transformation that generates the scaling of the reaction coordinate. In this paper, we reexamine the approach used earlier and remove this unphysical feature of the analysis. We recover the results of our earlier analysis and provide an interpretation of other related results in the literature.

DOI
10.1021/jp9607881

Related papers

Revisiting the Schrödinger Equation in Molecular Reaction Dynamics and a New Perspective of Quantum Chemistry

Hiroyuki Nohira, Toshiyuki Nohira

The applicability of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation to molecular reaction dynamics is discussed from several perspectives. First, with reference to Schrödinger's original paper, we point out that he himself stated that what is now called the time-dependent Schrödinger equation is insufficient to solve the problems of non-conservative systems like chemical reactions. Second, the detonation velocity of some explosives has been demonstrated as a new parameter that directly illustrates the timescales of elementary chemical reactions. The calculated values of ~30 fs are in good agreement with the timescale of 10–100 fs for chemical reactions, as experimentally demonstrated by the Nobel laureate Zewail. Third, we consider the state of an electron in a box when the length of the box suddenly increases from L to 2L, which is often found in textbooks as the simplest example of the application of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation to chemical reactions, and highlight the inconsistency between this model and an actual chemical reaction. Finally, we re-iterate that only quantum steady states can be accurately described by the Schrödinger equation and that it is the most natural to connect changes between adjacent quantum steady states by the variational principle.

•Jun 30, 2025•0 citations

Quantum Dynamics

Uri Peskin

Explicitly time-dependent Hamiltonians are ubiquitous in applications of quantum theory. It is therefore necessary to solve the time-dependent Schrödinger equation directly. The system’s dynamics is associated with a unitary time-evolution operator (a propagator), formally given as an infinite Dyson series. Time-dependent observables are invariant under unitary time-dependent transformations, where it is sometimes useful to transform the time-evolution from the states into the corresponding operators. This is carried out in part (in full) by transforming to the interaction (Heisenberg) picture. The corresponding equations of motion for the time-dependent operators are introduced. For quadratic potential energy functions, the time evolution of quantum expectation values coincides with the corresponding classical dynamics. This is demonstrated and analyzed in detail for Gaussian wave packets and a coherent state. Finally, we derive exact and approximate expressions for time-dependent transition probabilities and transition rates between quantum states. The validity of time-dependent perturbation theory is analyzed by comparison to exact dynamics.

Cambridge University Press eBooks•May 11, 2023•0 citations

III. An unsolved problem in the application of the quantum theory to chemical reactions

William C. Lewis

1. 1.On applying the quantum theory to a unimolecutar chemical reaction, it is shown that very different results are obtained according as we assume the continuous or discontinuous view of the abso...

The London Edinburgh and Dublin Philosophical Magazine and Journal of Science•Jan 1, 1920•17 citations

反応速度定数の量子論的定式化 : Wigner表示

Keisho Umesaki, Kei Odai

The reaction rate constant is defined as the rate at which a reactant annihilates or a product creates in a chemical reaction. The Hamiltonian of the reaction system describing elementary reactions has already been formulated by Miller et al(J. Chem. Phys. 1980, 72, 99-112) In addition, the reaction coordinates representing the progress of the reaction are also formulated by Fukui.(J. Phys. Chem. 1970, 74, 4161-4163) In the present paper, on the basis of these two theories, we first formulated the reaction rate constants of elementary reactions using classical statistical mechanics. Then we rewrited the rate constans quantum-mechanically according to the method of Wigner representations. By this rewriting, a correction term representing the quantum effect of the reaction rate constant was naturally derived.

•Mar 31, 2022•0 citations

A quantum mechanical representation in phase space

Go. Torres-Vega, John H. Frederick

A quantum mechanical representation suitable for studying the time evolution of quantum densities in phase space is proposed and examined in detail. This representation on ℒ2 (2) phase space is based on definitions of the operators P̂ and Q̂ in phase space that satisfy various correspondences for the Liouville equation in classical and quantum phase space, as well as quantum position and momentum ℒ2 (1) spaces. The definitions presented here, P̂=p/2−iℏ∂/∂q and Q̂=q/2+iℏ∂/∂p, are related to definitions that have been recently proposed [J. Chem. Phys. 93, 8862 (1990)]. The resulting quantum phase space representation shares many of the mathematical properties of usual representations in coordinate and momentum spaces. Within this representation, time evolution equations for complex-valued functions (wave functions) and their square magnitudes (distribution functions) are derived, and it is shown that the coordinate and momentum space time evolution equations can be recovered by a simple Fourier projection. The phase space quantum probability conservation equation obtained is a good illustration of the quantization rule that requires one to replace the classical Poisson bracket between the Hamiltonian and the probability density with the quantum commutator between the corresponding operators. The possible classical analogs to quantum probabilities densities are also considered and some of the present results are illustrated for the dynamics of the coherent state.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Feb 15, 1993•92 citations

Coherent chemical kinetics as quantum walks. I. Reaction operators for radical pairs

A. Chia, Kok Chuan Tan, Łukasz Pawela +3 more

Classical chemical kinetics uses rate-equation models to describe how a reaction proceeds in time. Such models are sufficient for describing state transitions in a reaction where coherences between different states do not arise, in other words, a reaction that contains only incoherent transitions. A prominent example of a reaction containing coherent transitions is the radical-pair model. The kinetics of such reactions is defined by the so-called reaction operator that determines the radical-pair state as a function of intermediate transition rates. We argue that the well-known concept of quantum walks from quantum information theory is a natural and apt framework for describing multisite chemical reactions. By composing Kraus maps that act only on two sites at a time, we show how the quantum-walk formalism can be applied to derive a reaction operator for the standard avian radical-pair reaction. Our reaction operator predicts the same recombination dephasing rate as the conventional Haberkorn model, which is consistent with recent experiments [K. Maeda et al., J. Chem. Phys. 139, 234309 (2013)], in contrast to previous work by Jones and Hore [J. A. Jones and P. J. Hore, Chem. Phys. Lett. 488, 90 (2010)]. The standard radical-pair reaction has conventionally been described by either a normalized density operator incorporating both the radical pair and reaction products or a trace-decreasing density operator that considers only the radical pair. We demonstrate a density operator that is both normalized and refers only to radical-pair states. Generalizations to include additional dephasing processes and an arbitrary number of sites are also discussed.

arXiv:1506.04213•Physical review. E•Mar 10, 2016•17 citations
In a previous paper ( J . Phys . Chem . 1994, 98, 3444), we showed, within the framework of the reaction coordinate representation of the dynamics of a chemical reaction, that application of a complex scaling transformation to the reaction coordinate leads naturally to the definition of transition states with complex energies and to the definition of an operator whose expectation values are the lifetimes of these states. That analysis has the unphysical feature of not eliminating the dependence of the lifetime operator on the positive angle parameter of the unitary transformation that generates the scaling of the reaction coordinate. In this paper, we reexamine the approach used earlier and remove this unphysical feature of the analysis. We recover the results of our earlier analysis and provide an interpretation of other related results in the literature.
The applicability of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation to molecular reaction dynamics is discussed from several perspectives. First, with reference to Schrödinger's original paper, we point out that he himself stated that what is now called the time-dependent Schrödinger equation is insufficient to solve the problems of non-conservative systems like chemical reactions. Second, the detonation velocity of some explosives has been demonstrated as a new parameter that directly illustrates the timescales of elementary chemical reactions. The calculated values of ~30 fs are in good agreement with the timescale of 10–100 fs for chemical reactions, as experimentally demonstrated by the Nobel laureate Zewail. Third, we consider the state of an electron in a box when the length of the box suddenly increases from L to 2L, which is often found in textbooks as the simplest example of the application of the time-dependent Schrödinger equation to chemical reactions, and highlight the inconsistency between this model and an actual chemical reaction. Finally, we re-iterate that only quantum steady states can be accurately described by the Schrödinger equation and that it is the most natural to connect changes between adjacent quantum steady states by the variational principle.
Explicitly time-dependent Hamiltonians are ubiquitous in applications of quantum theory. It is therefore necessary to solve the time-dependent Schrödinger equation directly. The system’s dynamics is associated with a unitary time-evolution operator (a propagator), formally given as an infinite Dyson series. Time-dependent observables are invariant under unitary time-dependent transformations, where it is sometimes useful to transform the time-evolution from the states into the corresponding operators. This is carried out in part (in full) by transforming to the interaction (Heisenberg) picture. The corresponding equations of motion for the time-dependent operators are introduced. For quadratic potential energy functions, the time evolution of quantum expectation values coincides with the corresponding classical dynamics. This is demonstrated and analyzed in detail for Gaussian wave packets and a coherent state. Finally, we derive exact and approximate expressions for time-dependent transition probabilities and transition rates between quantum states. The validity of time-dependent perturbation theory is analyzed by comparison to exact dynamics.
The reaction rate constant is defined as the rate at which a reactant annihilates or a product creates in a chemical reaction. The Hamiltonian of the reaction system describing elementary reactions has already been formulated by Miller et al(J. Chem. Phys. 1980, 72, 99-112) In addition, the reaction coordinates representing the progress of the reaction are also formulated by Fukui.(J. Phys. Chem. 1970, 74, 4161-4163) In the present paper, on the basis of these two theories, we first formulated the reaction rate constants of elementary reactions using classical statistical mechanics. Then we rewrited the rate constans quantum-mechanically according to the method of Wigner representations. By this rewriting, a correction term representing the quantum effect of the reaction rate constant was naturally derived.
A quantum mechanical representation suitable for studying the time evolution of quantum densities in phase space is proposed and examined in detail. This representation on ℒ2 (2) phase space is based on definitions of the operators P̂ and Q̂ in phase space that satisfy various correspondences for the Liouville equation in classical and quantum phase space, as well as quantum position and momentum ℒ2 (1) spaces. The definitions presented here, P̂=p/2−iℏ∂/∂q and Q̂=q/2+iℏ∂/∂p, are related to definitions that have been recently proposed [J. Chem. Phys. 93, 8862 (1990)]. The resulting quantum phase space representation shares many of the mathematical properties of usual representations in coordinate and momentum spaces. Within this representation, time evolution equations for complex-valued functions (wave functions) and their square magnitudes (distribution functions) are derived, and it is shown that the coordinate and momentum space time evolution equations can be recovered by a simple Fourier projection. The phase space quantum probability conservation equation obtained is a good illustration of the quantization rule that requires one to replace the classical Poisson bracket between the Hamiltonian and the probability density with the quantum commutator between the corresponding operators. The possible classical analogs to quantum probabilities densities are also considered and some of the present results are illustrated for the dynamics of the coherent state.
Classical chemical kinetics uses rate-equation models to describe how a reaction proceeds in time. Such models are sufficient for describing state transitions in a reaction where coherences between different states do not arise, in other words, a reaction that contains only incoherent transitions. A prominent example of a reaction containing coherent transitions is the radical-pair model. The kinetics of such reactions is defined by the so-called reaction operator that determines the radical-pair state as a function of intermediate transition rates. We argue that the well-known concept of quantum walks from quantum information theory is a natural and apt framework for describing multisite chemical reactions. By composing Kraus maps that act only on two sites at a time, we show how the quantum-walk formalism can be applied to derive a reaction operator for the standard avian radical-pair reaction. Our reaction operator predicts the same recombination dephasing rate as the conventional Haberkorn model, which is consistent with recent experiments [K. Maeda et al., J. Chem. Phys. 139, 234309 (2013)], in contrast to previous work by Jones and Hore [J. A. Jones and P. J. Hore, Chem. Phys. Lett. 488, 90 (2010)]. The standard radical-pair reaction has conventionally been described by either a normalized density operator incorporating both the radical pair and reaction products or a trace-decreasing density operator that considers only the radical pair. We demonstrate a density operator that is both normalized and refers only to radical-pair states. Generalizations to include additional dephasing processes and an arbitrary number of sites are also discussed.