Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Il Nuovo Cimento B

Popper's experiment and the centre-of-mass wave function

F. Miglietta

Published Apr 1, 2005• 0 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Popper's ideal experiment, concerning a pair of momentum-entangled particles, is analysed from the point of view of standard quantum mechanics, taking into account the centre-of-mass wave function.
DOI
10.1393/ncb/i2005-10038-y

Related papers

Understanding Popper’s experiment

Tabish Qureshi

An experiment proposed by Karl Popper is considered by many to be a crucial test of quantum mechanics. Although many loopholes in the original proposal have been pointed out, they are not crucial to the test. We use only the standard interpretation of quantum mechanics to point out what is fundamentally wrong with the proposal, and demonstrate that Popper’s basic premise was faulty.

arXiv:quant-ph/0405057•American Journal of Physics•May 13, 2005•26 citations

Critical analysis of Popper’s experiment

G. C. Ghirardi, Luca Marinatto, Francesco de Stefano

An experiment which could decide against the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics has been proposed by K. Popper and, subsequently, it has been criticized by M. J. Collett and R. Loudon. Here we show that both the above-mentioned arguments are not correct because they are based on a misuse of basic quantum rules.

arXiv:quant-ph/0702242•Physical Review A•Apr 17, 2007•8 citations

Comments on Space-Time

Kaushik Kiran Ghosh

What happens to the entropy increase principle as the Universe evolve to form the big-crunch singularity? What happens to the uncertainity relations along the process of gravitational collapses? What is the quantum mechanical description of a Radon atom in a rigid box when the distance of consecutive nodes and antinodes of $ψ$ is equal to or less than the diameter of the atom? What is the position-space wave function of two finite volume massive bosons if we take contact interaction into account? How a photon produce electron-positron pair with finite volume concentrate rest masses? What are the charges of the electron-positron pairs forming loops in the vacuum? How two particles with three-momentums $k_1, k_2$ $(k_1 \neq k_2)$ produced to form a loop at a space-time point always arrive at another spacial point simultaneously? What is the microscopic explanation in terms of particle exchanges of the force in the Casimir effect? What is the mechanism of the collapse of the momentum-space wave function of a particle knocking out an elctron from an atom? What is meant by $|Ψ> = {c_1 (t)}|Ψ_{U^{238}}> + {c_2 (t)}|Ψ_{Th^{234}}> ~?$ Quantum mechanically the region between the rigid walls (which is equiprobable in classical mechanics) is non-homogeneous for a particle in a rigid box. A photon can not reproduce Maxwell's equations apart from moving with velocity $c$. How can a process involving only a few photons be described starting from the Maxwell's equations? The large scale structure of the Universe is homogeneous. What is the screen in our brains to view objects, as they are, of sizes larger than our brains?

arXiv:gr-qc/0504083•Apr 19, 2005•0 citations

Popper’s Analysis of Probability in Quantum Mechanics

Patrick Suppes

Springer eBooks•Jan 1, 1993•4 citations

Studies on Some Aspects of the Fundamental Theory of Everything

Kaushik Kiran Ghosh

What happens to the entropy increase principle as the Universe evolve to form the big-crunch singularity? What happens to the uncertainity relations along the process of gravitational collapses? What is the quantum mechanical description of a Radon atom in a rigid box when the distance of consecutive nodes and antinodes of $ψ$ is equal to or less than the diameter of the atom? What is the position-space wave function of two finite volume massive bosons if we take contact interaction into account? How a photon produce electron-positron pair with finite volume concentrate rest masses? What are the charges of the electron-positron pairs forming loops in the vacuum? How two particles with three-momentums $k_1, k_2$ $(k_1 \neq k_2)$ produced to form a loop at a space-time point always arrive at another spacial point simultaneously? What is the microscopic explanation in terms of particle exchanges of the force in the Casimir effect? What is the mechanism of the collapse of the momentum-space wave function of a particle knocking out an elctron from an atom? What is meant by $|Ψ> = {c_1 (t)}|Ψ_{U^{238}}> + {c_2 (t)}|Ψ_{Th^{234}}> ~?$ Quantum mechanically the region between the rigid walls (which is equiprobable in classical mechanics) is non-homogeneous for a particle in a rigid box ! The large scale structure of the Universe is homogeneous.

arXiv:gr-qc/0503003•Mar 1, 2005•2 citations

Crtierion of effective centre-of-mass method in Quantum Mechanics

Bo‐Yuan Ning, Jun Zhuang, Xi‐Jing Ning

In describing the motion of atoms and clusters, we face with choosing quantum mechanics or classical mechanics under different conditions. In principle, there exist two criteria for this choice, but they do contradict in some cases though they are in agreement for other cases. Actually, this problem is closely related with the effective centre-of-mass method, the underlying application of quantum mechanics. It is shown that quantum mechanics must be selected for particle's motion when the de Broglie wave length of the mass centre is larger than the particle size, and in such case the effective centre-of-mass can be used in Quantum Mechanics. In order to test this conclusion, an easy-manufactured experiment is suggested.

arXiv:1105.3800•May 19, 2011•0 citations
What happens to the entropy increase principle as the Universe evolve to form the big-crunch singularity? What happens to the uncertainity relations along the process of gravitational collapses? What is the quantum mechanical description of a Radon atom in a rigid box when the distance of consecutive nodes and antinodes of ψψψ is equal to or less than the diameter of the atom? What is the position-space wave function of two finite volume massive bosons if we take contact interaction into account? How a photon produce electron-positron pair with finite volume concentrate rest masses? What are the charges of the electron-positron pairs forming loops in the vacuum? How two particles with three-momentums k1,k2k_1, k_2k1​,k2​ (k1≠k2)(k_1 \neq k_2)(k1​=k2​) produced to form a loop at a space-time point always arrive at another spacial point simultaneously? What is the microscopic explanation in terms of particle exchanges of the force in the Casimir effect? What is the mechanism of the collapse of the momentum-space wave function of a particle knocking out an elctron from an atom? What is meant by ∣Ψ>=c1(t)∣ΨU238>+c2(t)∣ΨTh234> ?|Ψ> = {c_1 (t)}|Ψ_{U^{238}}> + {c_2 (t)}|Ψ_{Th^{234}}> ~?∣Ψ>=c1​(t)∣ΨU238​>+c2​(t)∣ΨTh234​> ? Quantum mechanically the region between the rigid walls (which is equiprobable in classical mechanics) is non-homogeneous for a particle in a rigid box. A photon can not reproduce Maxwell's equations apart from moving with velocity ccc. How can a process involving only a few photons be described starting from the Maxwell's equations? The large scale structure of the Universe is homogeneous. What is the screen in our brains to view objects, as they are, of sizes larger than our brains?
What happens to the entropy increase principle as the Universe evolve to form the big-crunch singularity? What happens to the uncertainity relations along the process of gravitational collapses? What is the quantum mechanical description of a Radon atom in a rigid box when the distance of consecutive nodes and antinodes of ψψψ is equal to or less than the diameter of the atom? What is the position-space wave function of two finite volume massive bosons if we take contact interaction into account? How a photon produce electron-positron pair with finite volume concentrate rest masses? What are the charges of the electron-positron pairs forming loops in the vacuum? How two particles with three-momentums k1,k2k_1, k_2k1​,k2​ (k1≠k2)(k_1 \neq k_2)(k1​=k2​) produced to form a loop at a space-time point always arrive at another spacial point simultaneously? What is the microscopic explanation in terms of particle exchanges of the force in the Casimir effect? What is the mechanism of the collapse of the momentum-space wave function of a particle knocking out an elctron from an atom? What is meant by ∣Ψ>=c1(t)∣ΨU238>+c2(t)∣ΨTh234> ?|Ψ> = {c_1 (t)}|Ψ_{U^{238}}> + {c_2 (t)}|Ψ_{Th^{234}}> ~?∣Ψ>=c1​(t)∣ΨU238​>+c2​(t)∣ΨTh234​> ? Quantum mechanically the region between the rigid walls (which is equiprobable in classical mechanics) is non-homogeneous for a particle in a rigid box ! The large scale structure of the Universe is homogeneous.
In describing the motion of atoms and clusters, we face with choosing quantum mechanics or classical mechanics under different conditions. In principle, there exist two criteria for this choice, but they do contradict in some cases though they are in agreement for other cases. Actually, this problem is closely related with the effective centre-of-mass method, the underlying application of quantum mechanics. It is shown that quantum mechanics must be selected for particle's motion when the de Broglie wave length of the mass centre is larger than the particle size, and in such case the effective centre-of-mass can be used in Quantum Mechanics. In order to test this conclusion, an easy-manufactured experiment is suggested.