Quantal physics is established as a manifestation of symmetry more far-reaching than hitherto appears to have been recognized. In this primary manifestation, the coordinate transformations of spacetime invariance are themselves the elementary variables, which define their own properties without appeal to an assumed quantal formalism. In irreducible representations, the symmetry variables are inherently indeterminate, and the probabilistic laws invoked in the interpretation of traditional quantum physics are found to originate in geometric relations between these variables. Completeness is, therefore, not an issue, and the quantum of action is not part of the theory of symmetry variables. Quantal physics thus emerges as but an implication of relativistic invariance, liberated from a substance to be quantized and a formalism to be interpreted. A symmetry variable appears in a measurement with one of its eigenvalues, but does not have a value (cannot be represented by a number) in an irreducible representation, which combines sets of eigenvalues. It is this generalized significance of a measurement that allows for correlations that cannot arise for classical variables. The observation of symmetry variables is illustrated by an interferometer experiment measuring reflection symmetry and by the equivalent coincidence experiment registering the polarization of two quanta. The measurement process becomes a matter of following the state of affairs of the symmetry variables in their unitary evolution. For the resolution of the dilemmas that quantal phenomena have been felt to pose, it appears crucial to recognize that indeterminacy, as an inherent property of a symmetry variable in a multidimensional representation, is not affected by subsequent observations. A position variable and the canonical commutator with momentum, which are basic elements of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, emerge from spacetime symmetry, but require the link between space and time of relativistic invariance. The transition to the classical regime is analyzed in terms of a quenching of nonlocality in the state of affairs of the multidimensional symmetry variables. While the elementary variables constitute individual quanta in irreducible representations, product representations of spacetime symmetry describe systems of bosons and fermions, which form local fields with canonical properties. The discussion is focused on spacetime invariance (noninteracting quanta), but gauge invariance is itself a primary manifestation of symmetry and is as such encompassed by the theory of symmetry variables.
Quantal physics is established as a manifestation of symmetry more far-reaching than hitherto appears to have been recognized. In this primary manifestation, the coordinate transformations of spacetime invariance are themselves the elementary variables, which define their own properties without appeal to an assumed quantal formalism. In irreducible representations, the symmetry variables are inherently indeterminate, and the probabilistic laws invoked in the interpretation of traditional quantum physics are found to originate in geometric relations between these variables. Completeness is, therefore, not an issue, and the quantum of action is not part of the theory of symmetry variables. Quantal physics thus emerges as but an implication of relativistic invariance, liberated from a substance to be quantized and a formalism to be interpreted. A symmetry variable appears in a measurement with one of its eigenvalues, but does not have a value (cannot be represented by a number) in an irreducible representation, which combines sets of eigenvalues. It is this generalized significance of a measurement that allows for correlations that cannot arise for classical variables. The observation of symmetry variables is illustrated by an interferometer experiment measuring reflection symmetry and by the equivalent coincidence experiment registering the polarization of two quanta. The measurement process becomes a matter of following the state of affairs of the symmetry variables in their unitary evolution. For the resolution of the dilemmas that quantal phenomena have been felt to pose, it appears crucial to recognize that indeterminacy, as an inherent property of a symmetry variable in a multidimensional representation, is not affected by subsequent observations. A position variable and the canonical commutator with momentum, which are basic elements of nonrelativistic quantum mechanics, emerge from spacetime symmetry, but require the link between space and time of relativistic invariance. The transition to the classical regime is analyzed in terms of a quenching of nonlocality in the state of affairs of the multidimensional symmetry variables. While the elementary variables constitute individual quanta in irreducible representations, product representations of spacetime symmetry describe systems of bosons and fermions, which form local fields with canonical properties. The discussion is focused on spacetime invariance (noninteracting quanta), but gauge invariance is itself a primary manifestation of symmetry and is as such encompassed by the theory of symmetry variables.
Several recent studies have suggested that incompatible variables, which play an essential role in quantum mechanics (QM), are, somewhat surprisingly, not necessarily unique to QM. To investigate this possibility and obtain a better understanding of two central postulates of QM, namely the commutator postulate and the Born postulate, we introduce a classical probabilistic theoretical framework which is more general than QM and contains QM as a special case. We call this framework the General Incompatible Variables (GIV) theory, and we show that not only QM systems but also any probabilistic systems (classical or quantal) that possess incompatible variables will exhibit the quantal properties of uncertainty and interference, and we illustrate this with a roulette-like classical system (which we call the Arrow) that shows precisely these properties. We show that QM emerges naturally from the GIV framework when the fundamental variables are taken to be symmetries, so that the incompatibility of the QM variables is actually just the incompatibility of the corresponding symmetries (or their generators). Specifically, when the variables are taken to be the elements of the Poincare group (the symmetry of spacetime) we find that the commutator postulate and the Born postulate follow automatically, and are therefore no longer postulates. QM thus emerges as a special case of GIV theories for which the variables are symmetries.
As earlier conjectured by several authors and much later established by Solèr (relying on partial results by Piron, Maeda–Maeda and other authors), from the lattice theory point of view, Quantum Mechanics may be formulated in real, complex or quaternionic Hilbert spaces only. Stückelberg provided some physical, but not mathematically rigorous, reasons for ruling out the real Hilbert space formulation, assuming that any formulation should encompass a statement of Heisenberg principle. Focusing on this issue from another — in our opinion, deeper — viewpoint, we argue that there is a general fundamental reason why elementary quantum systems are not described in real Hilbert spaces. It is their basic symmetry group. In the first part of the paper, we consider an elementary relativistic system within Wigner’s approach defined as a locally-faithful irreducible strongly-continuous unitary representation of the Poincaré group in a real Hilbert space. We prove that, if the squared-mass operator is non-negative, the system admits a natural, Poincaré invariant and unique up to sign, complex structure which commutes with the whole algebra of observables generated by the representation itself. This complex structure leads to a physically equivalent reformulation of the theory in a complex Hilbert space. Within this complex formulation, differently from what happens in the real one, all selfadjoint operators represent observables in accordance with Solèr’s thesis, and the standard quantum version of Noether theorem may be formulated. In the second part of this work, we focus on the physical hypotheses adopted to define a quantum elementary relativistic system relaxing them on the one hand, and making our model physically more general on the other hand. We use a physically more accurate notion of irreducibility regarding the algebra of observables only, we describe the symmetries in terms of automorphisms of the restricted lattice of elementary propositions of the quantum system and we adopt a notion of continuity referred to the states viewed as probability measures on the elementary propositions. Also in this case, the final result proves that there exists a unique (up to sign) Poincaré invariant complex structure making the theory complex and completely fitting into Solèr’s picture. This complex structure reveals a nice interplay of Poincaré symmetry and the classification of the commutant of irreducible real von Neumann algebras.
The atomic world view is based on the notion that matter is built of elementary constituents called atoms, and quantum mechanics was created in the pursuit of this view with probabilistic events caused by atomic particles. This conception involves unresolved ambiguities linked to the notion of an elementary quantum of action. The resolution of these problems in quantum mechanics requires a new, geometric, world view, which recognizes the occurrence of events, clicks in counters, coming without a cause, referred to as fortuitous. The possibility of a rational theory of probabilities for such events is based on the assignment to the individual click of a proper value of an element of (flat) space–time symmetry. Thereby, the distributions of uncaused clicks can be endowed with a geometric content in terms of the irreducible representations of space–time symmetry. Through fortuity, space–time invariance itself thus acquires a hitherto unrecognized role. Departing from the norms of physical theory, the uncaused click is not a measurement of something, and the reality mirrored in the distributions is the geometry of space time itself, and not a property of an imagined object. The geometric world view involves only the dimensions of space and time, and the absence of an irreducible dimension of mass is seen as the result of the discovery of new physical phenomena. Accordingly Planck's constant has no place in fundamental theory and is seen as a relic of dimensions that have become superfluous.
We study deterministic and quantum dynamics from a constructive “finite” point of view, since the introduction of the continuum or other actual infinities in physics poses severe conceptual and technical difficulties, and while all of these concepts are not really needed in physics, which is in fact an empirical science. Particular attention is paid to the symmetry properties of discrete systems. For a consistent description of the symmetries of dynamical systems at different time instants and the symmetries of various parts of such systems, we introduce discrete analogs of gauge connections. These gauge structures are particularly important to describe the quantum behavior. The symmetries govern the fundamental properties of the behavior of dynamical systems. In particular, we can show that the moving soliton-like structures are inevitable in a deterministic (classical) dynamical system, whose symmetry group breaks the set of states into a finite number of orbits of the group. We demonstrate that the quantum behavior is a natural consequence of symmetries of dynamical systems. This behavior is a result of the fundamental inability to trace the identity of indistinguish-able objects during their evolution. Information is only available on invariant statements and values related with such objects. Using general mathematical arguments, any quantum dynamics can be shown to reduce to a sequence of permutations. The quantum interferences occur in the invariant subspaces of permutation representations of the symmetry groups of dynamical systems. The observables can be expressed in terms of permutation invariants. We also show that in order to describe quantum phenomena it is sufficient to use cyclotomic fields—the minimal extensions of natural numbers suitable for quantum mechanics, instead of a non-constructive number system—the field of complex numbers. The finite groups of symmetries play the central role in this review. In physics there is an additional reason for such groups to be of interest. Numerous experiments and observations in particle physics point to the importance of finite groups of relatively low orders in a number of fundamental processes. The origin of these groups has no explanation within presently recognized theories, such as the Standard Model.
Some aspects of the interpretation of quantum theory are discussed.It is emphasized that quantum theory is formulated in a Cartesian coordinate system; in other coordinates the result obtained with the help of the Hamiltonian formalism and commutator relations between 'canonically conjugated' coordinate and momentum operators leads to a wrong version of quantum mechanics.In this connection the Feynman integral formalism is also discussed.In this formalism the measure is not well-defined and there is no idea how to distinguish between the true version of quantum mechanics and an incorrect one; it is rather a mnemonic rule to generate perturbation series from an undefined zero order term.The origin of time is analyzed in detail by the example of atomic collisions.It is shown that the time-dependent Schrödinger equation for the closed three-body (two nuclei + electron) system has no physical meaning since in the high impact energy limit it transforms into an equation with two independent time-like variables; the time appears in the stationary Schrödinger equation as a result of extraction of a classical subsystem (two nuclei) from a closed three-body system.Following the Einstein-Rosen-Podolsky experiment and Bell's inequality the wave function is interpreted as an actual field of information in the elementary form.The relation between physics and mathematics is also discussed.
From the preceding exposition it follows that the quantum statistical representation of an individual atomic system does not imply any renunciation regarding further knowledge about the system. On the contrary the statistical character of quantum physics directly reflects the fundamental non-causal appearance of quantal recordings, and through the discovery of the complementarity of quantal phenomena a complete but necessarily statistical description of the atom has been accomplished. Furthermore quantum physics has afforded a statistical description of macroscopic bodies through their representation as assemblies of huge numbers of identical atomic systems, and, apart from accounting in a more fundamental way for the properties already described in classical physics(the correspondence principle, p. 36), quantum statistics explains several macroscopic phenomena which cannot be understood within the conceptual frame of classical physics only. It must be maintained, however, that when observing the properties of individual atomic objects the macroscopic observational apparatus cannot be represented in terms of atomic constituents because this would destroy the unambiguity of the description. The observational apparatus fulfils its basic function of being the spacetime frame of reference for the quantal recordings precisely through its description in classical physics alone. However, when refraining from the analysis of individual quantal processes it is possible to apply quantum statistics to macroscopic phenomena, that is, the causality of classical physical phenomena can be interpreted in the quantum formalism as the statistical result of the interplay of enormous numbers of atomic processes. It is possible, then, to talk of statistical causality as a fundamental aspect of physical reality.