Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review Letters

Semiclassical Theory of Light Detection in the Presence of Feedback

Jeffrey H. Shapiro, Malvin Carl Teich, Bahaa E. A. Saleh, Prem Kumar, G. Saplakoglu

Published Mar 17, 1986• 21 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The usual open-loop semiclassical theory of light detection is extended to include closed-loop operation in which there is feedback from the detector to the source. The revised theory takes the form of a self-exciting point process. It admits photocount statistics that are associated with non-classical light in open-loop configurations, e.g., sub-shot-noise spectra and sub-Poisson photocounts. The extended theory is used to explain two recent closed-loop experiments in which sub-Poisson photocount statistics were produced.

DOI
10.1103/physrevlett.56.1136

Related papers

Theory of light detection in the presence of feedback

Jeffrey H. Shapiro, Prem Kumar, Bahaa E. A. Saleh +3 more

The usual open-loop quantum and semiclassical theories of light detection are extended to include closed-loop operation in which there is feedback from the detector to the source. It is shown that the unmistakable signatures of nonclassical light associated with open-loop detection, such as sub-shot-noise spectra and sub-Poisson photo-counts, do not carry over to closed-loopsystems. This behavior is illustrated through quantitatively indistinguishable quantum and semiclassical analyses of two recent closed-loop experiments in which sub-Poisson photocount statistics were produced. It turns out that if the open-loop illumination does not require the use of quantum photodetection theory, then neither does the closed-loop illumination. Conversely, if the open-loop illumination is nonclassical, then the closed-loop behavior must be analyzed quantum mechanically. The use of nonclassical field correlations to obtain light beams that give sub-Poisson open-loop photocounts from these closed-loop arrangements is discussed and generalized into a synthesis procedure for producing light beams with arbitrary open-loop photocount statistics.

Journal of the Optical Society of America B•Oct 1, 1987•117 citations

Theory of light detection in the presence of feedback

Prem Kumar, G. Saplakoglu, Malvin Carl Teich +1 more

The usual formulations of the quantum and semiclassical theories of photodetection presume open-loop configurations, i.e., that there are no feedback paths leading from the output of the photodetector to the light beam impinging on that detector. In such configurations, the qualitative and quantitative distinctions between the quantum and semiclassical theories are well understood. In the quantum theory, photocurrent and photocount randomness arises from the quantum noise in the illumination beam, whereas in the semiclassical theory the fundamental source of randomness is associated with the excitations of the atoms forming the detector. Nevertheless, the quantum theory subsumes the semiclassical theory in a natural way.1

•Jun 9, 1986•0 citations

Sub-Poisson photo-electron statistics from a semiconductor laser with electronic feedback

James H. Churnside, Evgenii P. Gordov

We detected a portion of the output from a semi-conductor diode laser and used the detected signal as a source of negative feedback to the laser drive current. At frequencies below the characteristic frequency of the feedback loop, the power spectral density of the detected photocurrent was as much as 15 dB below the shot noise limit. This reduction can be described by a semiclassical theory of the effects of feedback on an injected shot noise current. Physically, this corresponds to a process whereby the laser output is changed in response to changes in the noise current.

Annual Meeting Optical Society of America•Jan 1, 1991•0 citations

Spectral and Correlation Properties of Two-Photon Light

Maria V. Chekhova

Although light quanta were known since the works by Planck and Einstein, for several decades after these works, there was no need to treat light quantum mechanically, and all experiments could be well explained using the quantum description of matter and classical description of light (the semiclassical approach). The situation changed with the development of sources of so-called nonclassical light, i.e., light whose properties cannot be understood in the framework of the semiclassical approach. Two simple examples can be given here. The first one is the suppression of shot noise in optical detectors. Shot noise, i.e., fluctuations of photocurrent scaling as the square root of the photocurrent mean value, can be, in principle, attributed to the discrete nature of the charge generated by the detector. At the same time, the effect of shot-noise suppression, which is observed with certain light sources (squeezed light) is clearly related to the statistics of light, and quantum mechanics is completely necessary for its description. Another example, which brings us closer to the subject of the present paper, is two-photon light. This type of light contains only pairs of photons (often called biphotons), and hence, a pair of properly aligned photon-counting detectors registering two-photon light, in an ideal case, will produce only simultaneous photocounts. This behavior, again, can only be explained in terms of a quantum-mechanical description for the light.

SPIE eBooks•Mar 16, 2010•0 citations

Quantum Gaussian noise

Jeffrey H. Shapiro

In semiclassical theory, light is a classical electromagnetic wave and the fundamental source of photodetection noise is the shot effect arising from the discreteness of the electron charge. In quantum theory, light is a quantum-mechanical entity and the fundamental source of photodetection noise comes from measuring the photon-flux operator. The Glauber coherent states are Gaussian quantum states which represent classical electromagnetic radiation. Quantum photodetection of these states yields statistics that are indistinguishable from the corresponding Poisson point-process results of semiclassical photodetection. Optical parametric interactions, however, can be used to produce other Gaussian quantum states, states whose photodetection behavior cannot be characterized semiclassically. A unified analytical framework is presented for Gaussian-state photodetection that includes the full panoply of nonclassical effects that have been produced via parametric interactions.

Proceedings of SPIE, the International Society for Optical Engineering/Proceedings of SPIE•May 16, 2003•19 citations

Sub-poissonian Light and Photocurrent Shot-noise Suppression in Closed Optoelectronic Loop

Anatoly Viktorovich Masalov, A. A. Putilin, Michael Vasilyev

Photocurrent shot-noise suppression is observed in closed optoelectronic loop below the limit (1 − η) of standard shot-noise level (SNL) imposed by conventional theory of photodetector with quantum efficiency η. Experimental results on photocurrent noise are presented for different values of feedback strength and quantum efficiency η of in-loop photodiode. It is shown that at fixed feedback strength the suppression factor does not depend on η. Minimum noise spectral density is observed below the SNL by a factor 17·8 (− 12·5 dB). Such large suppression cannot be explained in terms of an ordinary sub-Poissonian light state in the loop. We suggest the concept of an anticorrelation light state, where the light in the loop is described as a non-stationary state with Poissonian quantum fluctuations, and superimposed anticorrelated classical fluctuations. While the degree of noise reduction in the photocurrent can be arbitrary large, the degree of anticorrelation between the classical and quantum fluctuations in the light beam remains limited by the quantum efficiency of the feedback photodiode. Calculations based on this concept are in a good agreement with experimental data on super-shot-noise power, obtained for the beam extracted from the loop by a beam splitter.

Journal of Modern Optics•Oct 1, 1994•23 citations
The usual open-loop semiclassical theory of light detection is extended to include closed-loop operation in which there is feedback from the detector to the source. The revised theory takes the form of a self-exciting point process. It admits photocount statistics that are associated with non-classical light in open-loop configurations, e.g., sub-shot-noise spectra and sub-Poisson photocounts. The extended theory is used to explain two recent closed-loop experiments in which sub-Poisson photocount statistics were produced.
The usual open-loop quantum and semiclassical theories of light detection are extended to include closed-loop operation in which there is feedback from the detector to the source. It is shown that the unmistakable signatures of nonclassical light associated with open-loop detection, such as sub-shot-noise spectra and sub-Poisson photo-counts, do not carry over to closed-loopsystems. This behavior is illustrated through quantitatively indistinguishable quantum and semiclassical analyses of two recent closed-loop experiments in which sub-Poisson photocount statistics were produced. It turns out that if the open-loop illumination does not require the use of quantum photodetection theory, then neither does the closed-loop illumination. Conversely, if the open-loop illumination is nonclassical, then the closed-loop behavior must be analyzed quantum mechanically. The use of nonclassical field correlations to obtain light beams that give sub-Poisson open-loop photocounts from these closed-loop arrangements is discussed and generalized into a synthesis procedure for producing light beams with arbitrary open-loop photocount statistics.
The usual formulations of the quantum and semiclassical theories of photodetection presume open-loop configurations, i.e., that there are no feedback paths leading from the output of the photodetector to the light beam impinging on that detector. In such configurations, the qualitative and quantitative distinctions between the quantum and semiclassical theories are well understood. In the quantum theory, photocurrent and photocount randomness arises from the quantum noise in the illumination beam, whereas in the semiclassical theory the fundamental source of randomness is associated with the excitations of the atoms forming the detector. Nevertheless, the quantum theory subsumes the semiclassical theory in a natural way.1
We detected a portion of the output from a semi-conductor diode laser and used the detected signal as a source of negative feedback to the laser drive current. At frequencies below the characteristic frequency of the feedback loop, the power spectral density of the detected photocurrent was as much as 15 dB below the shot noise limit. This reduction can be described by a semiclassical theory of the effects of feedback on an injected shot noise current. Physically, this corresponds to a process whereby the laser output is changed in response to changes in the noise current.
Although light quanta were known since the works by Planck and Einstein, for several decades after these works, there was no need to treat light quantum mechanically, and all experiments could be well explained using the quantum description of matter and classical description of light (the semiclassical approach). The situation changed with the development of sources of so-called nonclassical light, i.e., light whose properties cannot be understood in the framework of the semiclassical approach. Two simple examples can be given here. The first one is the suppression of shot noise in optical detectors. Shot noise, i.e., fluctuations of photocurrent scaling as the square root of the photocurrent mean value, can be, in principle, attributed to the discrete nature of the charge generated by the detector. At the same time, the effect of shot-noise suppression, which is observed with certain light sources (squeezed light) is clearly related to the statistics of light, and quantum mechanics is completely necessary for its description. Another example, which brings us closer to the subject of the present paper, is two-photon light. This type of light contains only pairs of photons (often called biphotons), and hence, a pair of properly aligned photon-counting detectors registering two-photon light, in an ideal case, will produce only simultaneous photocounts. This behavior, again, can only be explained in terms of a quantum-mechanical description for the light.
In semiclassical theory, light is a classical electromagnetic wave and the fundamental source of photodetection noise is the shot effect arising from the discreteness of the electron charge. In quantum theory, light is a quantum-mechanical entity and the fundamental source of photodetection noise comes from measuring the photon-flux operator. The Glauber coherent states are Gaussian quantum states which represent classical electromagnetic radiation. Quantum photodetection of these states yields statistics that are indistinguishable from the corresponding Poisson point-process results of semiclassical photodetection. Optical parametric interactions, however, can be used to produce other Gaussian quantum states, states whose photodetection behavior cannot be characterized semiclassically. A unified analytical framework is presented for Gaussian-state photodetection that includes the full panoply of nonclassical effects that have been produced via parametric interactions.
Photocurrent shot-noise suppression is observed in closed optoelectronic loop below the limit (1 − η) of standard shot-noise level (SNL) imposed by conventional theory of photodetector with quantum efficiency η. Experimental results on photocurrent noise are presented for different values of feedback strength and quantum efficiency η of in-loop photodiode. It is shown that at fixed feedback strength the suppression factor does not depend on η. Minimum noise spectral density is observed below the SNL by a factor 17·8 (− 12·5 dB). Such large suppression cannot be explained in terms of an ordinary sub-Poissonian light state in the loop. We suggest the concept of an anticorrelation light state, where the light in the loop is described as a non-stationary state with Poissonian quantum fluctuations, and superimposed anticorrelated classical fluctuations. While the degree of noise reduction in the photocurrent can be arbitrary large, the degree of anticorrelation between the classical and quantum fluctuations in the light beam remains limited by the quantum efficiency of the feedback photodiode. Calculations based on this concept are in a good agreement with experimental data on super-shot-noise power, obtained for the beam extracted from the loop by a beam splitter.