Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Interference, distinguishability, and apparent contradiction in an experiment on induced coherence

Luiz Carlos Ryff

Published Oct 1, 1995• 9 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It has been shown in experiments on induced coherence without induced emission using two coherently pumped nonlinear crystals that (a) no second-order interference occurs as long as it is possible, even if only in principle, to determine which of the two crystals emitted the photon pair; (b) second-order interference does occur whenever it is intrinsically impossible to determine which of the two crystals emitted the photon pair. The present paper discusses a variant of the previous experiments in which, apparently, (c) each photon of the pair is emitted by a different crystal. It is also shown that interference is not necessarily reduced when there is no intrinsic indistinguishability. The experiment provides a proof of Bell's theorem for two particles without using an inequality and, at least in principle, could be used to test local realism against quantum mechanics. However, as in the case of the other experiments so far performed, some additional assumption would have to be introduced. It is then shown that the introduction of a reasonable assumption reduces the detectors's efficiencies needed to test local realism, even if nonenhancement is not assumed.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.52.2591

Related papers

Indistinguishable Photon Pairs from Independent True Chaotic Sources

Amir Nevet, Alex Hayat, Pavel Ginzburg +1 more

Indistinguishability of events in quantum mechanics is manifested by interference between their probability amplitudes. We report a unique kind of interference occurring between indistinguishable events of photon-pair emission, where each photon of the pair is emitted from a distinct true chaotic light source and has a different energy. The indistinguishability results in an interference which is observed as an ultrafast modulation of the second-order coherence function, measured on a femtosecond time scale by two-photon absorption in a semiconductor photomultiplier tube.

Physical Review Letters•Dec 16, 2011•23 citations

A Proposal for Testing Local Realism Without Using Assumptions Related to Hidden Variable States

Luiz Carlos Ryff

A feasible experiment is discussed which allows us to prove a Bell's theorem for two particles without using an inequality. The experiment could be used to test local realism against quantum mechanics without the introduction of additional assumptions related to hidden variables states. Only assumptions based on direct experimental observation are needed.

•Jan 1, 1996•0 citations

Induced coherence without induced emission

L. J. Wang, X. Y. Zou, L. Mandeļ

An interference experiment with signal and idler photons produced by parametric down-conversion in two nonlinear crystals is described and analyzed theoretically. It is found that when the idlers for the two crystals are superposed and aligned, the idler photon from the first crystal can induce coherence between the two signals, but without inducing any additional emission. Blocking the first idler wipes out the interference. The implications for the interpretation of the quantum state vector are discussed, and this leads to the conclusion that the state reflects not only what is known, but to some extent also what is knowable in principle.

Physical Review A•Oct 1, 1991•344 citations

Irrelevance of photon events distinguishability in a class of Bell experiments

Marek Żukowski, Dagomir Kaszlikowski, Emilio Santos

We show that the possibility of distinguishing between single- and two-photon detection events, usually not met in the actual experiments, is not a necessary requirement for proof that the experiments of Alley and Shih [Phys. Rev. Lett. 61, 2921 (1988)] and Ou and Mandel [Phys. Rev. Lett. 61, 50 (1988)] are modulo a fair sampling assumption, valid tests of local realism. We also give the critical parameters for the experiments to be unconditional tests of local realism, and show that some other interesting phenomena (involving bosonic-type particle indistinguishability) can be observed during such tests.

arXiv:quant-ph/9911027•Physical Review A•Oct 1, 1999•5 citations

Complementarity in biphoton generation with stimulated or induced coherence

Axel Heuer, R. W. Menzel, Peter W. Milonni

Coherence can be induced or stimulated in parametric down-conversion using two or three crystals when, for example, the idler modes of the crystals are aligned. Previous experiments with induced coherence [Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 053601 (2015)] focused on which-path information and the role of vacuum fields in realizing complementarity via reduced visibility in single-photon interference. Here we describe experiments comparing induced and stimulated coherence. Different single-photon interference experiments were performed by blocking one of the pump beams in a three-crystal setup. Each counted photon is emitted from one of two crystals and which-way information may or not be available, depending on the setup. Distinctly different results are obtained in the induced and stimulated cases, especially when a variable transmission filter is inserted between the crystals. A simplified theoretical model accounts for all the experimental results and is also used to address the question of whether the phases of the signal and idler fields in parametric down-conversion are correlated.

arXiv:1506.00457•Physical Review A•Sep 18, 2015•38 citations

Nonclassicality of induced coherence without induced emission

Mayukh Lahiri, Armin Hochrainer, Radek Łapkiewicz +2 more

Interference of two beams produced at separate biphoton sources was first observed more than two decades ago. The phenomenon, often called ``induced coherence without induced emission,'' has recently gained attention after its applications to imaging, spectroscopy, and measuring biphoton correlations have been discovered. The sources used in the corresponding experiments are nonlinear crystals pumped by laser light. The use of a laser pump makes the occurrence of induced (stimulated) emission unavoidable, and the effect of stimulated emission can be observed in the joint detection rate of the two beams. This fact raises the question whether the stimulated emission also plays a role in inducing the coherence. Here we investigate a case in which the crystals are pumped with a single-photon Fock state. We find that coherence is induced even though the possibility of stimulated emission is now fully ruled out. Furthermore, the joint detection rate of the two beams becomes ideally zero. Our results rule out any classical or semiclassical explanation of the phenomenon and also suggest that it is, in principle, possible to perform similar experiments with fermions, for which stimulated emission is strictly forbidden.

arXiv:1709.09974•Physical Review A•Nov 18, 2019•40 citations
It has been shown in experiments on induced coherence without induced emission using two coherently pumped nonlinear crystals that (a) no second-order interference occurs as long as it is possible, even if only in principle, to determine which of the two crystals emitted the photon pair; (b) second-order interference does occur whenever it is intrinsically impossible to determine which of the two crystals emitted the photon pair. The present paper discusses a variant of the previous experiments in which, apparently, (c) each photon of the pair is emitted by a different crystal. It is also shown that interference is not necessarily reduced when there is no intrinsic indistinguishability. The experiment provides a proof of Bell's theorem for two particles without using an inequality and, at least in principle, could be used to test local realism against quantum mechanics. However, as in the case of the other experiments so far performed, some additional assumption would have to be introduced. It is then shown that the introduction of a reasonable assumption reduces the detectors's efficiencies needed to test local realism, even if nonenhancement is not assumed.
Indistinguishability of events in quantum mechanics is manifested by interference between their probability amplitudes. We report a unique kind of interference occurring between indistinguishable events of photon-pair emission, where each photon of the pair is emitted from a distinct true chaotic light source and has a different energy. The indistinguishability results in an interference which is observed as an ultrafast modulation of the second-order coherence function, measured on a femtosecond time scale by two-photon absorption in a semiconductor photomultiplier tube.
An interference experiment with signal and idler photons produced by parametric down-conversion in two nonlinear crystals is described and analyzed theoretically. It is found that when the idlers for the two crystals are superposed and aligned, the idler photon from the first crystal can induce coherence between the two signals, but without inducing any additional emission. Blocking the first idler wipes out the interference. The implications for the interpretation of the quantum state vector are discussed, and this leads to the conclusion that the state reflects not only what is known, but to some extent also what is knowable in principle.
We show that the possibility of distinguishing between single- and two-photon detection events, usually not met in the actual experiments, is not a necessary requirement for proof that the experiments of Alley and Shih [Phys. Rev. Lett. 61, 2921 (1988)] and Ou and Mandel [Phys. Rev. Lett. 61, 50 (1988)] are modulo a fair sampling assumption, valid tests of local realism. We also give the critical parameters for the experiments to be unconditional tests of local realism, and show that some other interesting phenomena (involving bosonic-type particle indistinguishability) can be observed during such tests.
Coherence can be induced or stimulated in parametric down-conversion using two or three crystals when, for example, the idler modes of the crystals are aligned. Previous experiments with induced coherence [Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 053601 (2015)] focused on which-path information and the role of vacuum fields in realizing complementarity via reduced visibility in single-photon interference. Here we describe experiments comparing induced and stimulated coherence. Different single-photon interference experiments were performed by blocking one of the pump beams in a three-crystal setup. Each counted photon is emitted from one of two crystals and which-way information may or not be available, depending on the setup. Distinctly different results are obtained in the induced and stimulated cases, especially when a variable transmission filter is inserted between the crystals. A simplified theoretical model accounts for all the experimental results and is also used to address the question of whether the phases of the signal and idler fields in parametric down-conversion are correlated.
Interference of two beams produced at separate biphoton sources was first observed more than two decades ago. The phenomenon, often called ``induced coherence without induced emission,'' has recently gained attention after its applications to imaging, spectroscopy, and measuring biphoton correlations have been discovered. The sources used in the corresponding experiments are nonlinear crystals pumped by laser light. The use of a laser pump makes the occurrence of induced (stimulated) emission unavoidable, and the effect of stimulated emission can be observed in the joint detection rate of the two beams. This fact raises the question whether the stimulated emission also plays a role in inducing the coherence. Here we investigate a case in which the crystals are pumped with a single-photon Fock state. We find that coherence is induced even though the possibility of stimulated emission is now fully ruled out. Furthermore, the joint detection rate of the two beams becomes ideally zero. Our results rule out any classical or semiclassical explanation of the phenomenon and also suggest that it is, in principle, possible to perform similar experiments with fermions, for which stimulated emission is strictly forbidden.