Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry

On the brueckner and goldstone forms of the linked-cluster theorem

Peter W. Langhoff, A. J. Hernández

Published Jun 18, 2009• 8 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Connections between the Brueckner and Goldstone forms of the linked-cluster theorem are clarified in an elementary fashion employing a finite many-body system of electrons interacting via two-body forces as an illustrative example. It is shown that the order-by-order cancellations of Brueckner unlinked terms in the many-body wave function and energy occur in the Goldstone development upon the additions of the different time orderings of Feynman-Goldstone diagrams having disconnected vacuum parts. The factoring of the vacuum amplitude from the wave function, upon which customary presentations of the theorem focus attention, is seen to be irrelevant to the cancellations of Brueckner unlinked terms, and has to do, rather, with the presence of secular and normalization terms in the time-dependent perturbation functions for an adiabatically switched static perturbation. Similarly, the equivalence of the vacuum amplitude with the exponential of all connected vacuum diagrams, originally demonstrated by Feynman in the case of hole theory, is seen to be irrelevant to the cancellations of Brueckner unlinked terms in the energy, which occur in the Goldstone development upon the summations over all time orderings of disconnected vacuum diagrams. The distinction between Brueckner unlinked terms on the one hand, and secular and normalization terms on the other, is confused in customary presentations of the linked-cluster theorem by the use of exponential switching, following Gell-Mann and Low, and is clarified in the present development by considering the Friedrichs limit of ideal adiabatic switching.

DOI
10.1002/qua.560100838

Related papers

Many-Body Perturbation Theory

William Tobocman

The usual perturbation treatment of the many-body problem is modified by eliminating the two-body interaction and introducing in its place a $t$ matrix. The Watson, Brueckner, and Bethe (W.B.B.) treatment of the many-body problem is shown to be a special case of the modified perturbation treatment. The modified perturbation treatment involves no assumption except that of supposing the convergence of the perturbation expansion. Thus to each order in the expansion the results must be meaningful and no unphysical "unlinked cluster" terms can appear. Within the framework of the modified perturbation treatment it is easy to interpret the concepts of the Pauli principle for intermediate states and the self-consistent choice of the comparison potential which play such an important role in the W.B.B. treatment. This work is similar to that of J. Goldstone in that we relate the W.B.B. treatment to a perturbation treatment of the many-body problem. We differ from Goldstone in that we use the usual time-independent perturbation theory instead of the time-dependent one. The time-independent approach permits a direct comparison with the W.B.B. treatment and facilitates discussion of the Pauli principle for intermediate states and of the self-consistent potential.

Physical Review•Jul 1, 1957•30 citations

Linked-cluster perturbative expansion in correlated-basis theory

Stefano Fantoni

We give a brief outline of the perturbative expansion and the cluster properties of nondiagonal matrix elements in correlated-basis theory. A structural study of the perturbative series shows the presence of systematic cancellations among the terms of the series. It is proved by virtue of these cancellations that the expansion is linked and closely resembles the perturbative expansion of Brueckner-Goldstone theory. It is found that the ladder diagrams can be summed up by solving a Bethe-Goldstone---type equation which has recently been derived in correlated coupled-cluster theory. A brief discussion of some properties of ring diagrams is also given.

Physical review. B, Condensed matter•Mar 1, 1984•15 citations

How many‐body perturbation theory (MBPT) has changed quantum chemistry

Werner Kutzelnigg

Abstract The history of many‐body perturbation theory (MBPT) and its impact on Quantum Chemistry is reviewed, starting with Brueckner's conjecture of a linked‐cluster expansion and the time‐dependent derivation by Goldstone of such an expansion. A central part of this article is the time‐independent formulation of quantum chemistry in Fock space and its diagrammatic representation including the particle‐hole picture and the inversion of a commutator. The results of the time‐independent derivation of MBPT are compared with those of Goldstone. It is analyzed which ingredients of Goldstone's approach are decisive. The connected diagram theorem is derived both in a constructive way based on a Lie‐algebraic formulation and a nonconstructive way making use of the separation theorem. It is discussed why the Goldstone derivation starting from a unitary time‐evolution operator, ends up with a wave operator in intermediate normalization. The Møller–Plesset perturbation expansions of Bartlett and Pople are compared. Examples of complete summations of certain classes of diagrams are discussed, for example, that which leads to the Bethe‐Goldstone expansion. MBPT for energy differences is analyzed. The paper ends with recent developments and challenges, such as the generalization of normal ordering to arbitrary reference states, contracted Schrödinger k‐particle equations and Brillouin conditions, and finally the Nakatsuji theorem and the Nooijen conjecture. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2009

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Aug 26, 2009•41 citations

Linked-Cluster Expansions for the Nuclear Many-Body Problem

B. H. Brandow

The Goldstone expansion is rederived by elementary time-independent methods, starting from Brillouin-Wigner (BW) perturbation theory. Interaction energy terms $\ensuremath{\Delta}E$ are expanded out of the BW energy denominators, and the series is then rearranged to obtain the linked-cluster result. Similar algebraic methods lead to the linked expansions for the total wave function (Hugenholtz) and the expectation value of a general operator (Thouless). Starting again with a degenerate version of BW perturbation theory, these methods are used to obtain the Bloch-Horowitz energy expansion, as well as the corresponding wave function, expectation-value, and transition-amplitude expansions. A "reduced" form of the Block-Horowitz expansion is described, and also a "completely linked" version. The latter is suggested as a tool for investigating superfiuid phenomena in nuclear matter, and for establishing contact with the Landau theory of Fermi liquids. The physical interpretation of these expansions is carefully studied, especially with regard to nuclear applications, to determine how they handle such "physical" features as antisymmetry, self-energy effects, wave-function renormalizations, and the distinction between "true" and "model" single-particle occupation probabilities. The problem of a correct theoretical definition for the shell-model potential is carefully examined, and a specific theory is presented. These expansions are seen to form a convenient and very powerful set of tools for studying the structure of actual nuclei.

Reviews of Modern Physics•Oct 1, 1967•1,269 citations

Derivation of the Brueckner many-body theory

Jeffrey Goldstone

Abstract An exact formal solution is obtained to the problem of a system of fermions in interaction. This solution is expressed in a form which avoids the problem of unlinked clusters in manybody theory. The technique of Feynman graphs is used to derive the series and to define linked terms. The graphs are those appropriate to a system of many fermions and are used to give a new derivation of the Hartree-Fock and Brueckner methods for this problem.

Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A Mathematical and Physical Sciences•Feb 26, 1957•1,273 citations

The linked-diagram expansion of the ground state of a many-electron system: A time-independent derivation

Rolf Manne

A time-independent derivation of the linked-diagram expansion of the ground-state energy of a many-electron system is given for the case of a nondegenerate unperturbed system. The starting point is the Rayleigh-Schrödinger perturbation theory, and the derivation follows in many respects suggestions by Čížek and Paldus, including the use of the Frantz-Mills factorization theorem for the cancellation of unlinked and renormalization diagrams.

International Journal of Quantum Chemistry•Jun 18, 2009•6 citations
Connections between the Brueckner and Goldstone forms of the linked-cluster theorem are clarified in an elementary fashion employing a finite many-body system of electrons interacting via two-body forces as an illustrative example. It is shown that the order-by-order cancellations of Brueckner unlinked terms in the many-body wave function and energy occur in the Goldstone development upon the additions of the different time orderings of Feynman-Goldstone diagrams having disconnected vacuum parts. The factoring of the vacuum amplitude from the wave function, upon which customary presentations of the theorem focus attention, is seen to be irrelevant to the cancellations of Brueckner unlinked terms, and has to do, rather, with the presence of secular and normalization terms in the time-dependent perturbation functions for an adiabatically switched static perturbation. Similarly, the equivalence of the vacuum amplitude with the exponential of all connected vacuum diagrams, originally demonstrated by Feynman in the case of hole theory, is seen to be irrelevant to the cancellations of Brueckner unlinked terms in the energy, which occur in the Goldstone development upon the summations over all time orderings of disconnected vacuum diagrams. The distinction between Brueckner unlinked terms on the one hand, and secular and normalization terms on the other, is confused in customary presentations of the linked-cluster theorem by the use of exponential switching, following Gell-Mann and Low, and is clarified in the present development by considering the Friedrichs limit of ideal adiabatic switching.
The usual perturbation treatment of the many-body problem is modified by eliminating the two-body interaction and introducing in its place a ttt matrix. The Watson, Brueckner, and Bethe (W.B.B.) treatment of the many-body problem is shown to be a special case of the modified perturbation treatment. The modified perturbation treatment involves no assumption except that of supposing the convergence of the perturbation expansion. Thus to each order in the expansion the results must be meaningful and no unphysical "unlinked cluster" terms can appear. Within the framework of the modified perturbation treatment it is easy to interpret the concepts of the Pauli principle for intermediate states and the self-consistent choice of the comparison potential which play such an important role in the W.B.B. treatment. This work is similar to that of J. Goldstone in that we relate the W.B.B. treatment to a perturbation treatment of the many-body problem. We differ from Goldstone in that we use the usual time-independent perturbation theory instead of the time-dependent one. The time-independent approach permits a direct comparison with the W.B.B. treatment and facilitates discussion of the Pauli principle for intermediate states and of the self-consistent potential.
We give a brief outline of the perturbative expansion and the cluster properties of nondiagonal matrix elements in correlated-basis theory. A structural study of the perturbative series shows the presence of systematic cancellations among the terms of the series. It is proved by virtue of these cancellations that the expansion is linked and closely resembles the perturbative expansion of Brueckner-Goldstone theory. It is found that the ladder diagrams can be summed up by solving a Bethe-Goldstone---type equation which has recently been derived in correlated coupled-cluster theory. A brief discussion of some properties of ring diagrams is also given.
Abstract The history of many‐body perturbation theory (MBPT) and its impact on Quantum Chemistry is reviewed, starting with Brueckner's conjecture of a linked‐cluster expansion and the time‐dependent derivation by Goldstone of such an expansion. A central part of this article is the time‐independent formulation of quantum chemistry in Fock space and its diagrammatic representation including the particle‐hole picture and the inversion of a commutator. The results of the time‐independent derivation of MBPT are compared with those of Goldstone. It is analyzed which ingredients of Goldstone's approach are decisive. The connected diagram theorem is derived both in a constructive way based on a Lie‐algebraic formulation and a nonconstructive way making use of the separation theorem. It is discussed why the Goldstone derivation starting from a unitary time‐evolution operator, ends up with a wave operator in intermediate normalization. The Møller–Plesset perturbation expansions of Bartlett and Pople are compared. Examples of complete summations of certain classes of diagrams are discussed, for example, that which leads to the Bethe‐Goldstone expansion. MBPT for energy differences is analyzed. The paper ends with recent developments and challenges, such as the generalization of normal ordering to arbitrary reference states, contracted Schrödinger k‐particle equations and Brillouin conditions, and finally the Nakatsuji theorem and the Nooijen conjecture. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. Int J Quantum Chem, 2009
The Goldstone expansion is rederived by elementary time-independent methods, starting from Brillouin-Wigner (BW) perturbation theory. Interaction energy terms $\ensuremath{\Delta}E$ are expanded out of the BW energy denominators, and the series is then rearranged to obtain the linked-cluster result. Similar algebraic methods lead to the linked expansions for the total wave function (Hugenholtz) and the expectation value of a general operator (Thouless). Starting again with a degenerate version of BW perturbation theory, these methods are used to obtain the Bloch-Horowitz energy expansion, as well as the corresponding wave function, expectation-value, and transition-amplitude expansions. A "reduced" form of the Block-Horowitz expansion is described, and also a "completely linked" version. The latter is suggested as a tool for investigating superfiuid phenomena in nuclear matter, and for establishing contact with the Landau theory of Fermi liquids. The physical interpretation of these expansions is carefully studied, especially with regard to nuclear applications, to determine how they handle such "physical" features as antisymmetry, self-energy effects, wave-function renormalizations, and the distinction between "true" and "model" single-particle occupation probabilities. The problem of a correct theoretical definition for the shell-model potential is carefully examined, and a specific theory is presented. These expansions are seen to form a convenient and very powerful set of tools for studying the structure of actual nuclei.