Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Journal of Mathematical Physics

Absence of Long-Range Order in Thin Films

J. C. Garrison, Jack Wong, Harry L. Morrison

Published Nov 1, 1972• 11 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Thin films are described as idealized systems having finite extent in one direction but infinite extent in the other two. For systems of particles interacting through smooth potentials (e.g., no hard cores), it is shown that an equilibrium state for a homogeneous thin film is necessarily invariant under any continuous internal symmetry group generated by a conserved density. For short-range interactions it is also shown that equilibrium states are necessarily translation invariant. The absence of long-range order follows from its relation to broken symmetry. The only properties of the state required for the proof are local normality, spatial translation invariance, and the Kubo-Martin-Schwinger boundary condition. The argument employs the Bogoliubov inequality and the techniques of the algebraic approach to statistical mechanics. For inhomogeneous systems, the same argument shows that all order parameters defined by anomalous averages must vanish. Identical results can be obtained for systems with infinite extent in one direction only.

DOI
10.1063/1.1665901

Related papers

GAUGE INVARIANCE AND BROKEN SYMMETRIES IN ANYON SUPERFLUIDS

D. Boyanovsky

We review aspects of broken symmetry and the nature of long range order in theories of anyons starting with bosons with a statistical interaction. We introduce a novel gauge invariant quantization scheme that allows the identification of local and gauge invariant order parameters. The connection between spin and statistics is reviewed and the consequences of broken symmetries in the anyon representation are discussed. An anyon gas is studied in the Bogoliubov approximation, it is determined that the ground state is a condensate of charge-flux composites with “quasi-long-range order” at zero temperature, a “weak” gap in the spectrum and finite helicity modulus. The system is disordered at nonzero temperatures. The disorder is not caused by Goldstone bosons but by the strong infrared behavior arising from the Coulomb interaction induced by the long-range statistical interaction. The properties of topological vortices in nonrelativistic and in relativistic Landau-Ginzburg theories are studied in detail. We study the physics of the mean-field ansatz and quasi-long range order in a simple exactly soluble relativistic model. This model exhibits a novel phenomenon of charge redistribution to the boundaries and restoration of translational invariance in the infinite volume limit. It also illuminates the physics of quasi-long-range order with a gap in the spectrum, statistical charge polarization by external magnetic fields and the role of “large” gauge transformations.

International Journal of Modern Physics A•Sep 30, 1992•12 citations

Non-existence of spontaneous symmetry breakdown of time-translation symmetry on general quantum systems: Any macroscopic order parameter moves not!

Hajime Moriya

The Kubo–Martin–Schwinger (KMS) condition is a well-founded general definition of equilibrium states on quantum systems. The time invariance property of equilibrium states is one of its basic consequences. From the time invariance of any equilibrium state it follows that the spontaneous breakdown of time-translation symmetry is impossible. Moreover, triviality of the temporal long-range order is derived from the KMS condition. Therefore, the manifestation of genuine quantum time crystals is impossible as long as the standard notion of spontaneous symmetry breakdown is considered.

arXiv:2201.06051•Reviews in Mathematical Physics•Sep 30, 2023•2 citations

Proof of the Absence of Long-Range Temporal Orders in Gibbs States

Haruki Watanabe, Masaki Oshikawa, Tohru Koma

Abstract We address the question whether time translation symmetry can be spontaneously broken in a quantum many-body system. One way of detecting such a symmetry breaking is to examine the time-dependence of a correlation function. If the large-distance behavior of the correlation function exhibits a nontrivial time-dependence in the thermodynamic limit, the system would develop a temporal long-range order, realizing a time crystal. In an earlier publication, we sketched a proof for the absence of such time dependence in the thermal equilibrium described by the Gibbs state (Watanabe and Oshikawa in Phys Rev Lett 114:251603, 2015). Here we present a complete proof and extend the argument to a more general class of stationary states than the Gibbs states.

arXiv:1911.12939•Journal of Statistical Physics•Jan 16, 2020•24 citations

Long-range order in the spin van der Waals model

M. Howard Lee

Long-range order in the spin van der Waals model is considered when the number of spins is finite and also when infinite. We show explicitly that a finite system cannot support long-range order. An infinite system at high temperatures is found to be dominated by the entropy of degenerate states of the system and, as a result, the system behaves essentially like an ideal system. In an infinite system at low temperatures, long-range order exists, fully reflecting the spin symmetry of the Hamiltonian. For the XY-like regime (J≳Jz ), mx is finite but mz vanishes, where mx and mz are reduced order parameters for the transverse and longitudinal directions, respectively. For the Ising-like regime (J<Jz), mx vanishes but mz is finite. The isotropic interaction (Jz = J) behaves as a singularity and it must be considered separately. A physical interpretation of the behavior of long-range order is offered using the geometry of spin space.

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Mar 1, 1982•23 citations

Possible Existence of Bose-Einstein Condensation in One and Two Dimensions

Moorad Alexanian

The proof of Jasnow and Fisher that no spontaneous ordering can occur in one- and two-dimensional systems with continuous symmetry is shown to fail for nonlocal potentials of sufficiently long range. The occurrence of Bose-Einstein condensation for finite temperature (in the infinite-volume limit) is, therefore, not forbidden for such potentials. This result also follows from the postulate of the completeness of the noninteracting equilibrium states. Thus, the completeness postulate represents a weaker assumption on the nature of an interacting equilibrium state (or, equivalently, on the basic interactions between particles) than is usually found in the literature.

Physical Review A•Oct 1, 1971•2 citations

Decay of Order in Isotropic Systems of Restricted Dimensionality. I. Bose Superfluids

David Jasnow, Michael Ellis Fisher

The off-diagonal ordering of one- and two-dimensional Bose particle systems of finite thickness and cross-section is considered in the presence and absence of a symmetry-breaking field. It is shown rigorously, by applying Bogoliubov's inequality to a subdomain of the system, that no spontaneous ordering can occur; several definitions of long-range order are discussed. Explicit bounds on the order-order correlation function, integrated over a subdomain, are obtained which indicate how the short-range order decays with distance. Conditions under which information on the pointwise behavior of the correlation function can be inferred are also discussed. The inequalities are assessed numerically for real situations.

Physical review. B, Solid state•Feb 1, 1971•35 citations
Thin films are described as idealized systems having finite extent in one direction but infinite extent in the other two. For systems of particles interacting through smooth potentials (e.g., no hard cores), it is shown that an equilibrium state for a homogeneous thin film is necessarily invariant under any continuous internal symmetry group generated by a conserved density. For short-range interactions it is also shown that equilibrium states are necessarily translation invariant. The absence of long-range order follows from its relation to broken symmetry. The only properties of the state required for the proof are local normality, spatial translation invariance, and the Kubo-Martin-Schwinger boundary condition. The argument employs the Bogoliubov inequality and the techniques of the algebraic approach to statistical mechanics. For inhomogeneous systems, the same argument shows that all order parameters defined by anomalous averages must vanish. Identical results can be obtained for systems with infinite extent in one direction only.
We review aspects of broken symmetry and the nature of long range order in theories of anyons starting with bosons with a statistical interaction. We introduce a novel gauge invariant quantization scheme that allows the identification of local and gauge invariant order parameters. The connection between spin and statistics is reviewed and the consequences of broken symmetries in the anyon representation are discussed. An anyon gas is studied in the Bogoliubov approximation, it is determined that the ground state is a condensate of charge-flux composites with “quasi-long-range order” at zero temperature, a “weak” gap in the spectrum and finite helicity modulus. The system is disordered at nonzero temperatures. The disorder is not caused by Goldstone bosons but by the strong infrared behavior arising from the Coulomb interaction induced by the long-range statistical interaction. The properties of topological vortices in nonrelativistic and in relativistic Landau-Ginzburg theories are studied in detail. We study the physics of the mean-field ansatz and quasi-long range order in a simple exactly soluble relativistic model. This model exhibits a novel phenomenon of charge redistribution to the boundaries and restoration of translational invariance in the infinite volume limit. It also illuminates the physics of quasi-long-range order with a gap in the spectrum, statistical charge polarization by external magnetic fields and the role of “large” gauge transformations.
The Kubo–Martin–Schwinger (KMS) condition is a well-founded general definition of equilibrium states on quantum systems. The time invariance property of equilibrium states is one of its basic consequences. From the time invariance of any equilibrium state it follows that the spontaneous breakdown of time-translation symmetry is impossible. Moreover, triviality of the temporal long-range order is derived from the KMS condition. Therefore, the manifestation of genuine quantum time crystals is impossible as long as the standard notion of spontaneous symmetry breakdown is considered.
Abstract We address the question whether time translation symmetry can be spontaneously broken in a quantum many-body system. One way of detecting such a symmetry breaking is to examine the time-dependence of a correlation function. If the large-distance behavior of the correlation function exhibits a nontrivial time-dependence in the thermodynamic limit, the system would develop a temporal long-range order, realizing a time crystal. In an earlier publication, we sketched a proof for the absence of such time dependence in the thermal equilibrium described by the Gibbs state (Watanabe and Oshikawa in Phys Rev Lett 114:251603, 2015). Here we present a complete proof and extend the argument to a more general class of stationary states than the Gibbs states.
Long-range order in the spin van der Waals model is considered when the number of spins is finite and also when infinite. We show explicitly that a finite system cannot support long-range order. An infinite system at high temperatures is found to be dominated by the entropy of degenerate states of the system and, as a result, the system behaves essentially like an ideal system. In an infinite system at low temperatures, long-range order exists, fully reflecting the spin symmetry of the Hamiltonian. For the XY-like regime (J≳Jz ), mx is finite but mz vanishes, where mx and mz are reduced order parameters for the transverse and longitudinal directions, respectively. For the Ising-like regime (J<Jz), mx vanishes but mz is finite. The isotropic interaction (Jz = J) behaves as a singularity and it must be considered separately. A physical interpretation of the behavior of long-range order is offered using the geometry of spin space.
The proof of Jasnow and Fisher that no spontaneous ordering can occur in one- and two-dimensional systems with continuous symmetry is shown to fail for nonlocal potentials of sufficiently long range. The occurrence of Bose-Einstein condensation for finite temperature (in the infinite-volume limit) is, therefore, not forbidden for such potentials. This result also follows from the postulate of the completeness of the noninteracting equilibrium states. Thus, the completeness postulate represents a weaker assumption on the nature of an interacting equilibrium state (or, equivalently, on the basic interactions between particles) than is usually found in the literature.
The off-diagonal ordering of one- and two-dimensional Bose particle systems of finite thickness and cross-section is considered in the presence and absence of a symmetry-breaking field. It is shown rigorously, by applying Bogoliubov's inequality to a subdomain of the system, that no spontaneous ordering can occur; several definitions of long-range order are discussed. Explicit bounds on the order-order correlation function, integrated over a subdomain, are obtained which indicate how the short-range order decays with distance. Conditions under which information on the pointwise behavior of the correlation function can be inferred are also discussed. The inequalities are assessed numerically for real situations.