Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review A

Connection between the maximal entropy and the scattering theoretic analyses of collision processes

Y. Alhassid, Raphael David Levine

Published Jul 1, 1978• 264 citations
Publisher

Abstract

The information-theoretic maximal-entropy procedure for the analysis of collision processes is derived as a consequence of the dynamics, be they quantal or classical. The method centers attention on the minimal number of operators (the "dynamic constraints") whose expectation values are both necessary and sufficient to completely characterize the collision dynamics. For a given Hamiltonian and initial state, the constraints required to obtain an exact solution of the equations of motion are determined by a purely algebraic procedure. It is furthermore found possible to derive equations of motion for the conjugate Lagrange parameters. Immediate applications are noted, e.g., a family of similar reactions is shown to have a common set of dynamic constraints and simple illustrative applications are provided. The determination of the scattering matrix is discussed, with examples. The general formalism consists in solving the scattering problem in two stages. The first is purely algebraic. At the end of this stage one obtains the functional form of, say, the scattering matrix or of the density matrix after the collision expressed in terms of parameters whose number equals the number of dynamic constraints. The end result of this algebraic stage suffices to analyze the scattering pattern for any initial state. The second stage is the predictive procedure. Explicit coupled first-order nonlinear differential equations are obtained for the parameters.

DOI
10.1103/physreva.18.89

Related papers

Maximization Of Arrangements and Quantum Bound States

Francesco R. Ruggeri

The Maxwell-Boltzmann MB distribution is often derived by maximizing the number of possible arrangements of particles with different energies subject to the constraint of a fixed number of particles and fixed energy. Using the canonical approximation that only average energy is conserved and using Stirling’s approximation for large number factorials leads to the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution. The ln of total number of arrangements using Stirling’s approximation is linked to a math form called Shannon’s entropy i.e. - Sum over i f(ei) ln(f(ei)). Interestingly this same MB result may be obtained through reaction balance which makes no use of the idea of arrangements or entropy or maximization. It is concerned with including all possible physical reactions (for example two body reactions between all energy particles) subject to conservation of energy. In this sense it deals directly with the dynamics of the problem while the arrangement approach does not. The dynamical approach considers all possible reactions with notions of independence or lack of information and ensures the system remains unchanged. Why are they the same? We argue that it is because the “recipe” for the probability of two body reactions namely n(e1)n(e2) is of the same form as the leading factor of n(e1)! n(e2)!. In the case of quantum mechanics one may apply the dynamical approach to obtain the time-independent Schrodinger equation. In such a case one does not need to think in terms of “maximizing” any quantity although one considers all possible reactions with a potential V(x). a(p) factors in W(x) = wavefunction = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) are interrelated, but retain their identity after all possible interactions occur. This we argue is the idea for the eigenvalue equation. At the same time, Shannon’s entropy, which is directly linked to the notion of arrangements, is applied to a bound state and possibly linked to thermodynamics i.e. dE = TdS -PdV which may be applied to an adiabatic expansion. Shannon’s entropy is created from existing probabilities in this case which do not arise from explicitly maximizing entropy subject to constraints as the probabilities follow directly from the Schrodinger equation. One might ask why Shannon’s entropy has any relevance if it is the dynamics which determines the value of W(x) and a(p). It seems, however, that one may knock out a particle in a state p with probability P(p)= a*(p)a(p) or find a particle at x with probability P(x)=W*(x)W(x). These are classical type probabilities linked to the quantum dynamical probabilities a(p) and W(x). It seems Shannon’s entropy is only applied to P(x) and P(p) or a product P(x)P(p) which may give it physical meaning in a quantum bound state. We examine these ideas in this note.

•Jun 20, 2022•0 citations

Perturbative treatment of electronic correlations in time-dependent collision processes

E. C. Goldberg, Mario C. G. Passeggi

The Green function formalism introduced by Keldysh for irreversible processes is applied to the calculation of the time-dependent charge exchange probabilities in scattering problems. Considering the initial state of two non-interacting subsystems described by an independent particle model, their interaction is taken in a first stage, as evolving in time according to a time-dependent Hartree - Fock (TDHF) scheme. The equations of motion for the two-times Green functions are subsequently obtained in Dyson-like form by including the residual electronic correlations expanded perturbatively up to second order. It is shown that, by solving these equations of motion, this in turn allows one to calculate the two-particle correlation functions at equal times, as required to describe the fractions of charge in each subsystem. This procedure contrasts with that of considering expectation values of the correlation functions taken between the corrected TDHF state up to an equivalent order in the perturbation. In order to test the advantages of this method we have applied this scheme to the scattering of an atom from a three-substrate atom chain described by an Anderson Hamiltonian, where comparisons with exact solutions can be easily established. We found that, in this case, the fractions of charges carried by the scattered particle obtained with our proposal compare fairly well with exact results, within an ample range of parameter selection.

Journal of Physics Condensed Matter•Oct 7, 1996•3 citations

Initial states of maximal entropy in formal scattering theory

Peter Pfeifer, Raphael David Levine

For a precollision state which is not sharply defined, not all details of the dynamics can be obtained by examination of the final state. A version of formal collision theory which takes full advantage of the inherent loss of detail is provided. Only the relevant aspects of the dynamics need then be computed and an explicit identification of the relevant details is provided by a generalized intertwining theorem. Several explicit examples where this point of view can be implemented are worked out.

The Journal of Chemical Physics•Apr 15, 1983•13 citations

Information Theoretical Approaches to Quantum Chemistry

Shridhar Ramachandra Gadre

The development of the concept of entropy is traced briefly from the time of Boltzmann to the present. The axiomatic formulation of the Shannon information entropy functional [C. E. Shannon, Bell System Tech. J. 27 , 379 (1948)], viz. S = - k Σ p i ln p i is presented. The maximum entropy principle (MEP) due to Jaynes [E.T. Jaynes, Phys. Rev. 106 , 620 (1957)] is summarized and the existence and uniqueness of such maximum entropy solution with the constraints of moments of the distribution is discussed. This is followed by an account of the practical reconstruction of the electron momentum distributions and Compton profiles by employing the first and second moment constraints. Connections of information entropy encompassing kinetic energy functional, reaction dynamics, loges as well as surprisal analysis are brought out. The pioneering contribution of Białynicki-Birula and Mycielski [I. Białynicki-Birula, and J. Mycielski, Commun. Math. Phys. 44 , 129 (1975)] highlighting the connection between the sum of information entropies in conjugate spaces and the Heisenberg uncertainty relation is outlined. The problem of characterizing the quality of atomic and molecular wave functions has been considered in terms of the sum of information entropies in conjugate spaces. This is followed by the discussion of a new maximum entropy principle [S. R. Gadre and R. D. Bendale, Int. J. Quantum Chem. 28 , 311 (1985)] stipulating the maximization of the sum of the Shannon entropies in conjugate spaces. Some applications of this new maximum entropy principle for obtaining the probability distributions in conjugate spaces are summarized.

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•Dec 1, 2002•31 citations

Martingale models for quantum state reduction

Stephen L. Adler, Dorje C. Brody, Todd A. Brun +1 more

Stochastic models for quantum state reduction give rise to statistical laws that are in most respects in agreement with those of quantum measurement theory. Here we examine the correspondence of the two theories in detail, making a systematic use of the methods of martingale theory. An analysis is carried out to determine the magnitude of the fluctuations experienced by the expectation of the observable during the course of the reduction process and an upper bound is established for the ensemble average of the greatest fluctuations incurred. We consider the general projection postulate of Lüders applicable in the case of a possibly degenerate eigenvalue spectrum, and derive this result rigorously from the underlying stochastic dynamics for state reduction in the case of both a pure and a mixed initial state. We also analyse the associated Lindblad equation for the evolution of the density matrix, and obtain an exact time-dependent solution for the state reduction that explicitly exhibits the transition from a general initial density matrix to the Lüders density matrix. Finally, we apply Girsanov's theorem to derive a set of simple formulae for the dynamics of the state in terms of a family of geometric Brownian motions, thereby constructing an explicit unravelling of the Lindblad equation.

arXiv:quant-ph/0107153•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Oct 15, 2001•114 citations

Entropy on charge density: making the quantum mechanical connection

Douglas MacPherson Collins

Entropy maximization has proven effective in treating certain aspects of the phase problem of X-ray diffraction. Much of its development has been expressed in probabilistic language, although image enhancement has been somewhat more physical or geometric in description. Here phasing and entropy maximization are embedded in the quantum mechanical problem of reconstructing an electronic one-matrix under experimental constraints. Entropy on an N-representable one-particle density matrix is well defined. The entropy is the expected form, and it is a simple function of the one-matrix eigenvalues which all must be non-negative. Certain other properties are pertinent to phasing which is implicit in one-matrix reconstruction governed by entropy maximization. Throughout this work reference is made to informational entropy, not the entropy of thermodynamics.

Acta Crystallographica Section D Biological Crystallography•Jan 1, 1993•3 citations
The information-theoretic maximal-entropy procedure for the analysis of collision processes is derived as a consequence of the dynamics, be they quantal or classical. The method centers attention on the minimal number of operators (the "dynamic constraints") whose expectation values are both necessary and sufficient to completely characterize the collision dynamics. For a given Hamiltonian and initial state, the constraints required to obtain an exact solution of the equations of motion are determined by a purely algebraic procedure. It is furthermore found possible to derive equations of motion for the conjugate Lagrange parameters. Immediate applications are noted, e.g., a family of similar reactions is shown to have a common set of dynamic constraints and simple illustrative applications are provided. The determination of the scattering matrix is discussed, with examples. The general formalism consists in solving the scattering problem in two stages. The first is purely algebraic. At the end of this stage one obtains the functional form of, say, the scattering matrix or of the density matrix after the collision expressed in terms of parameters whose number equals the number of dynamic constraints. The end result of this algebraic stage suffices to analyze the scattering pattern for any initial state. The second stage is the predictive procedure. Explicit coupled first-order nonlinear differential equations are obtained for the parameters.
The Maxwell-Boltzmann MB distribution is often derived by maximizing the number of possible arrangements of particles with different energies subject to the constraint of a fixed number of particles and fixed energy. Using the canonical approximation that only average energy is conserved and using Stirling’s approximation for large number factorials leads to the Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution. The ln of total number of arrangements using Stirling’s approximation is linked to a math form called Shannon’s entropy i.e. - Sum over i f(ei) ln(f(ei)). Interestingly this same MB result may be obtained through reaction balance which makes no use of the idea of arrangements or entropy or maximization. It is concerned with including all possible physical reactions (for example two body reactions between all energy particles) subject to conservation of energy. In this sense it deals directly with the dynamics of the problem while the arrangement approach does not. The dynamical approach considers all possible reactions with notions of independence or lack of information and ensures the system remains unchanged. Why are they the same? We argue that it is because the “recipe” for the probability of two body reactions namely n(e1)n(e2) is of the same form as the leading factor of n(e1)! n(e2)!. In the case of quantum mechanics one may apply the dynamical approach to obtain the time-independent Schrodinger equation. In such a case one does not need to think in terms of “maximizing” any quantity although one considers all possible reactions with a potential V(x). a(p) factors in W(x) = wavefunction = Sum over p a(p)exp(ipx) are interrelated, but retain their identity after all possible interactions occur. This we argue is the idea for the eigenvalue equation. At the same time, Shannon’s entropy, which is directly linked to the notion of arrangements, is applied to a bound state and possibly linked to thermodynamics i.e. dE = TdS -PdV which may be applied to an adiabatic expansion. Shannon’s entropy is created from existing probabilities in this case which do not arise from explicitly maximizing entropy subject to constraints as the probabilities follow directly from the Schrodinger equation. One might ask why Shannon’s entropy has any relevance if it is the dynamics which determines the value of W(x) and a(p). It seems, however, that one may knock out a particle in a state p with probability P(p)= a*(p)a(p) or find a particle at x with probability P(x)=W*(x)W(x). These are classical type probabilities linked to the quantum dynamical probabilities a(p) and W(x). It seems Shannon’s entropy is only applied to P(x) and P(p) or a product P(x)P(p) which may give it physical meaning in a quantum bound state. We examine these ideas in this note.
The Green function formalism introduced by Keldysh for irreversible processes is applied to the calculation of the time-dependent charge exchange probabilities in scattering problems. Considering the initial state of two non-interacting subsystems described by an independent particle model, their interaction is taken in a first stage, as evolving in time according to a time-dependent Hartree - Fock (TDHF) scheme. The equations of motion for the two-times Green functions are subsequently obtained in Dyson-like form by including the residual electronic correlations expanded perturbatively up to second order. It is shown that, by solving these equations of motion, this in turn allows one to calculate the two-particle correlation functions at equal times, as required to describe the fractions of charge in each subsystem. This procedure contrasts with that of considering expectation values of the correlation functions taken between the corrected TDHF state up to an equivalent order in the perturbation. In order to test the advantages of this method we have applied this scheme to the scattering of an atom from a three-substrate atom chain described by an Anderson Hamiltonian, where comparisons with exact solutions can be easily established. We found that, in this case, the fractions of charges carried by the scattered particle obtained with our proposal compare fairly well with exact results, within an ample range of parameter selection.
For a precollision state which is not sharply defined, not all details of the dynamics can be obtained by examination of the final state. A version of formal collision theory which takes full advantage of the inherent loss of detail is provided. Only the relevant aspects of the dynamics need then be computed and an explicit identification of the relevant details is provided by a generalized intertwining theorem. Several explicit examples where this point of view can be implemented are worked out.
The development of the concept of entropy is traced briefly from the time of Boltzmann to the present. The axiomatic formulation of the Shannon information entropy functional [C. E. Shannon, Bell System Tech. J. 27 , 379 (1948)], viz. S = - k Σ p i ln p i is presented. The maximum entropy principle (MEP) due to Jaynes [E.T. Jaynes, Phys. Rev. 106 , 620 (1957)] is summarized and the existence and uniqueness of such maximum entropy solution with the constraints of moments of the distribution is discussed. This is followed by an account of the practical reconstruction of the electron momentum distributions and Compton profiles by employing the first and second moment constraints. Connections of information entropy encompassing kinetic energy functional, reaction dynamics, loges as well as surprisal analysis are brought out. The pioneering contribution of Białynicki-Birula and Mycielski [I. Białynicki-Birula, and J. Mycielski, Commun. Math. Phys. 44 , 129 (1975)] highlighting the connection between the sum of information entropies in conjugate spaces and the Heisenberg uncertainty relation is outlined. The problem of characterizing the quality of atomic and molecular wave functions has been considered in terms of the sum of information entropies in conjugate spaces. This is followed by the discussion of a new maximum entropy principle [S. R. Gadre and R. D. Bendale, Int. J. Quantum Chem. 28 , 311 (1985)] stipulating the maximization of the sum of the Shannon entropies in conjugate spaces. Some applications of this new maximum entropy principle for obtaining the probability distributions in conjugate spaces are summarized.
Stochastic models for quantum state reduction give rise to statistical laws that are in most respects in agreement with those of quantum measurement theory. Here we examine the correspondence of the two theories in detail, making a systematic use of the methods of martingale theory. An analysis is carried out to determine the magnitude of the fluctuations experienced by the expectation of the observable during the course of the reduction process and an upper bound is established for the ensemble average of the greatest fluctuations incurred. We consider the general projection postulate of Lüders applicable in the case of a possibly degenerate eigenvalue spectrum, and derive this result rigorously from the underlying stochastic dynamics for state reduction in the case of both a pure and a mixed initial state. We also analyse the associated Lindblad equation for the evolution of the density matrix, and obtain an exact time-dependent solution for the state reduction that explicitly exhibits the transition from a general initial density matrix to the Lüders density matrix. Finally, we apply Girsanov's theorem to derive a set of simple formulae for the dynamics of the state in terms of a family of geometric Brownian motions, thereby constructing an explicit unravelling of the Lindblad equation.
Entropy maximization has proven effective in treating certain aspects of the phase problem of X-ray diffraction. Much of its development has been expressed in probabilistic language, although image enhancement has been somewhat more physical or geometric in description. Here phasing and entropy maximization are embedded in the quantum mechanical problem of reconstructing an electronic one-matrix under experimental constraints. Entropy on an N-representable one-particle density matrix is well defined. The entropy is the expected form, and it is a simple function of the one-matrix eigenvalues which all must be non-negative. Certain other properties are pertinent to phasing which is implicit in one-matrix reconstruction governed by entropy maximization. Throughout this work reference is made to informational entropy, not the entropy of thermodynamics.