Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physica Scripta

Gauge Transformations in Semiclassical Radiation Theory

W P Healy

Published Jan 1, 1988• 1 citation
Publisher

Abstract

The interpretation of gauge transformations in the semiclassical theory of radiation has been the subject of much discussion and controversy over the past ten years or so. A consistent formulation of this problem that involves a gauge-independent Heisenberg picture of the motion and related gauge-dependent Schrödinger pictures is presented. The role of the canonical momenta and their representation as differential operators on wave functions is clarified. Some discussion of the physical interpretation is also given.

DOI
10.1088/0031-8949/1988/t21/017

Related papers

Self-fields in semiclassical radiation theory

Michael D. Crisp

The interaction of an atomic system with an unquantized electromagnetic field is studied by means of the Heisenberg-operator equations of motion. The electromagnetic fields created by the atom are taken into account by assuming that the charge and probability current densities are the actual charge and current source terms in Maxwell's equation. When Ehrenfest's theorem is written to order (1/c${)}^{2}$, the equations of motion are found to have a constant of motion that can be interpreted as stating that the sum of the atomic energy, energy of interaction, and energy stored in the electromagnetic field is constant. This constant of integration can be expressed as an expectation of a new semiclassical Hamiltonian that now includes the effects of the atomic self-fields to order 1/${\mathit{c}}^{2}$. This Hamiltonian is related to the classical Darwin Lagrangian. Since the new approximate Hamiltonian is the sum of an atomic and a field Hamiltonian, it provides a formulation of semiclassical radiation theory that is formally close to the usual formulation of quantum electrodynamics. A Schr\"odinger equation can be derived by applying the variational principle to the expectation of the new Hamiltonian. The result is a nonlinear integro-differential equation, in \ensuremath{\Psi}, which is somewhat similar to Hartree's self-consistent equation for a multielectron atom.When the Heisenberg equations are written to include the next-higher-order terms, 1/${\mathit{c}}^{3}$, it is found that the total energy of the atom and the electromagnetic field in the vicinity of the atom decreases at a rate that is given by the Larmor power formula (2${\mathit{e}}^{2}$/3${\mathit{c}}^{3}$)(d〈v〉/dt${)}^{2}$, where 〈v〉 is the quantum-mechanical expectation of the electron's velocity operator. This approximate formulation of semiclassical radiation theory is applied to semiclassical calculations of atomic radiative shifts. It is then shown that, if some retardation effects are included to all orders of 1/c in the vector potential, the semiclassical analysis provides a formula for radiative energy-level shifts that are time dependent and that contain coefficients similar to the starting point of the Bethe calculation of the Lamb shift. The incorporation of mass renormalization in semiclassical theory is then discussed.

Physical Review A•Oct 1, 1990•17 citations

Gauge transformation of the time-evolution operator

Donald H. Kobe, Kuo‐Ho Yang

The time-evolution operator is in general gauge dependent. Its gauge transformation property follows from the gauge transformation of the wave function and ensures gauge-invariant matrix elements. The same transformation property is shown here to follow from the formal solution of the Schr\"odinger equation for the time-evolution operator, which is a time-ordered exponential of the time integral of the Hamiltonian. The gauge transformation property of the time-evolution operator in the interaction picture is also obtained. The perturbation expansion of the time-evolution operator in one gauge can be transformed to give the perturbation expansion for the time-evolution operator in another gauge. The A\ensuremath{\cdot}p versus E\ensuremath{\cdot}r controversy in the electric dipole approximation is resolved by specifying the correct initial and final states.

Physical Review A•Aug 1, 1985•37 citations

The physical significance of gauge independence and gauge covariance in quantum mechanics

T. E. Feuchtwang, Emil Kazes, Paul H. Cutler +1 more

The distinction between gauge independence and gauge covariance in electrodynamics is considered for quantities of physical interest. The gauge independence of directly observable quantities, such as the spectra of operators and energy conserving transition rates, is discussed and contrasted with the gauge covariance of other quantities such as scalar products. The quasigauge-invariance of the classical Lagrangian and the invariance of the Euler-Lagrange equations under the addition of a total time derivative to the Lagrangian are discussed. The consequent inherent nonuniqueness of the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian formulations of classical mechanics is pointed out. A physical interpretation of the explicit gauge dependence of classical canonical momenta and of the expectation values of the corresponding quantum mechanical operators is presented. The gauge independence of energy conserving transition rates calculated in the conventional finite-order time dependent perturbation theory is discussed and illustrated. The gauge dependence of the conventional time dependent transition amplitudes in the presence of electromagnetic fields is then discussed, and gauge independent transition amplitudes are constructed. An alternative formulation of the quantum mechanics of charged particles is obtained in terms of a new gauge independent Hamiltonian, which is, as might be expected, unique only within an arbitrary canonical transformation.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Jan 11, 1984•15 citations

Gauge-independent Wigner functions: General formulation

O. T. Serimaa, Juha Javanainen, Sándor Varró

We introduce a gauge-invariant Wigner operator (GIWO) and a gauge-independent Wigner function (GIWF) that allow for both quantized and classical electromagnetic fields. If only classical fields are present, a Weyl transform analogous to the one associated with ordinary Wigner functions can be defined for any operator; in the case of quantized fields this is at least possible for Weyl-ordered functions of the position and kinetic momentum operators. We show how the evolution of the operators having a Weyl transform can be followed with the aid of the GIWF defined as the Heisenberg-picture expectation value of the GIWO, and derive for the GIWO the Heisenberg equation of motion which only involves the physical electric and magnetic fields. Some aspects of the case of entirely classical fields are discussed in more detail. (i) The GIWF in conjunction with the postulate that physical observables can be measured without referring to the gauge permits a quantum-mechanical treatment of a full experimental run without the problem of relating the measured values to the gauge-dependent density operator. (ii) A closed equation of motion for the GIWF is obtained. (iii) In the dipole approximation quantum features of the dynamics are lost. (iv) Quantum corrections to dynamics are associated with recoil effects.

Physical Review A•May 1, 1986•80 citations

Operator Gauge Transformations in Nonrelativistic Quantum Electrodynamics

Raymond Dale Gray

A system of nonrelativistic charged particles and radiation is canonically quantized in the Coulomb gauge and Maxwell's equations in quantum electrodynamics are derived. By requiring form invariance of the Schrodinger equation under a space and time dependent unitary transformation, operator gauge transformations on the quantized electromagnetic potentials and state vectors are introduced. These gauge transformed potentials have the same form as gauge transformations in non-Abelian gauge field theories. A gauge-invariant method for solving the time-dependent Schrodinger equation in quantum electrodynamics is given. Maxwell's equations are written in a form which holds in all gauges and which has formal similarity to the equations of motion of non-Abelian gauge fields. A gauge-invariant derivation of conservation of energy in quantum electrodynamics is given. An operator gauge transformation is made to the multipolar gauge in which the potentials are expressed in terms of the electromagnetic fields. The multipolar Hamiltonian is shown to be the minimally coupled Hamiltonian with the electromagnetic potentials in the multipolar gauge. The model of a charged harmonic oscillator in a single-mode electromagnetic field is considered as an example. The gauge-invariant procedure for solving the time-dependent Schrodinger equation is used to obtain the gauge-invariant probabilities that the oscillator is in an energy eigenstate For comparison, the conventional approach is also used to solve the harmonic oscillator problem and is shown to give gauge-dependent amplitudes.

•Dec 1, 1982•0 citations

The Invariant Form of Quantum Equations and the Schroedinger-Heisenberg Parallelism

Edward M. Corson

Some years have passed since the appearance of Dirac's striking interpretation of the Heisenberg-Schroedinger parallelism in the equations of motion, and yet it appears that there still remain obscure points which have led to misunderstanding. Although the Schroedinger method suffices to deal with many practical problems, the flexibility of the Dirac-Jordan representation theory, aside from its intrinsic unity and beauty, recommends it to general theoretical investigation. The present paper considers the invariant form of the equations of motion in relation to the Schroedinger-Heisenberg pictures of quantum mechanics insofar as the latter refer to the "pictured" intrinsic motion of states (vectors) and observables (Hermitian operators). The discussion is divided roughly into 5-sections: Operator and Vector Transforms, Contact Transformations, Heisenberg-Schroedinger Operators, Equations of Motion and Invariant Properties, and the Density Operator and Operator Spur. Where possible, quasi-geometrical diagrams are given to illustrate the relation and transition between the several "pictures of the motion."

Physical Review•Feb 1, 1947•0 citations
The interpretation of gauge transformations in the semiclassical theory of radiation has been the subject of much discussion and controversy over the past ten years or so. A consistent formulation of this problem that involves a gauge-independent Heisenberg picture of the motion and related gauge-dependent Schrödinger pictures is presented. The role of the canonical momenta and their representation as differential operators on wave functions is clarified. Some discussion of the physical interpretation is also given.
The interaction of an atomic system with an unquantized electromagnetic field is studied by means of the Heisenberg-operator equations of motion. The electromagnetic fields created by the atom are taken into account by assuming that the charge and probability current densities are the actual charge and current source terms in Maxwell's equation. When Ehrenfest's theorem is written to order (1/c)2{)}^{2})2, the equations of motion are found to have a constant of motion that can be interpreted as stating that the sum of the atomic energy, energy of interaction, and energy stored in the electromagnetic field is constant. This constant of integration can be expressed as an expectation of a new semiclassical Hamiltonian that now includes the effects of the atomic self-fields to order 1/c2{\mathit{c}}^{2}c2. This Hamiltonian is related to the classical Darwin Lagrangian. Since the new approximate Hamiltonian is the sum of an atomic and a field Hamiltonian, it provides a formulation of semiclassical radiation theory that is formally close to the usual formulation of quantum electrodynamics. A Schr\"odinger equation can be derived by applying the variational principle to the expectation of the new Hamiltonian. The result is a nonlinear integro-differential equation, in \ensuremath{\Psi}, which is somewhat similar to Hartree's self-consistent equation for a multielectron atom.When the Heisenberg equations are written to include the next-higher-order terms, 1/c3{\mathit{c}}^{3}c3, it is found that the total energy of the atom and the electromagnetic field in the vicinity of the atom decreases at a rate that is given by the Larmor power formula (2e2{\mathit{e}}^{2}e2/3c3{\mathit{c}}^{3}c3)(d〈v〉/dt)2{)}^{2})2, where 〈v〉 is the quantum-mechanical expectation of the electron's velocity operator. This approximate formulation of semiclassical radiation theory is applied to semiclassical calculations of atomic radiative shifts. It is then shown that, if some retardation effects are included to all orders of 1/c in the vector potential, the semiclassical analysis provides a formula for radiative energy-level shifts that are time dependent and that contain coefficients similar to the starting point of the Bethe calculation of the Lamb shift. The incorporation of mass renormalization in semiclassical theory is then discussed.
The time-evolution operator is in general gauge dependent. Its gauge transformation property follows from the gauge transformation of the wave function and ensures gauge-invariant matrix elements. The same transformation property is shown here to follow from the formal solution of the Schr\"odinger equation for the time-evolution operator, which is a time-ordered exponential of the time integral of the Hamiltonian. The gauge transformation property of the time-evolution operator in the interaction picture is also obtained. The perturbation expansion of the time-evolution operator in one gauge can be transformed to give the perturbation expansion for the time-evolution operator in another gauge. The A\ensuremath{\cdot}p versus E\ensuremath{\cdot}r controversy in the electric dipole approximation is resolved by specifying the correct initial and final states.
The distinction between gauge independence and gauge covariance in electrodynamics is considered for quantities of physical interest. The gauge independence of directly observable quantities, such as the spectra of operators and energy conserving transition rates, is discussed and contrasted with the gauge covariance of other quantities such as scalar products. The quasigauge-invariance of the classical Lagrangian and the invariance of the Euler-Lagrange equations under the addition of a total time derivative to the Lagrangian are discussed. The consequent inherent nonuniqueness of the Lagrangian and Hamiltonian formulations of classical mechanics is pointed out. A physical interpretation of the explicit gauge dependence of classical canonical momenta and of the expectation values of the corresponding quantum mechanical operators is presented. The gauge independence of energy conserving transition rates calculated in the conventional finite-order time dependent perturbation theory is discussed and illustrated. The gauge dependence of the conventional time dependent transition amplitudes in the presence of electromagnetic fields is then discussed, and gauge independent transition amplitudes are constructed. An alternative formulation of the quantum mechanics of charged particles is obtained in terms of a new gauge independent Hamiltonian, which is, as might be expected, unique only within an arbitrary canonical transformation.
We introduce a gauge-invariant Wigner operator (GIWO) and a gauge-independent Wigner function (GIWF) that allow for both quantized and classical electromagnetic fields. If only classical fields are present, a Weyl transform analogous to the one associated with ordinary Wigner functions can be defined for any operator; in the case of quantized fields this is at least possible for Weyl-ordered functions of the position and kinetic momentum operators. We show how the evolution of the operators having a Weyl transform can be followed with the aid of the GIWF defined as the Heisenberg-picture expectation value of the GIWO, and derive for the GIWO the Heisenberg equation of motion which only involves the physical electric and magnetic fields. Some aspects of the case of entirely classical fields are discussed in more detail. (i) The GIWF in conjunction with the postulate that physical observables can be measured without referring to the gauge permits a quantum-mechanical treatment of a full experimental run without the problem of relating the measured values to the gauge-dependent density operator. (ii) A closed equation of motion for the GIWF is obtained. (iii) In the dipole approximation quantum features of the dynamics are lost. (iv) Quantum corrections to dynamics are associated with recoil effects.
A system of nonrelativistic charged particles and radiation is canonically quantized in the Coulomb gauge and Maxwell's equations in quantum electrodynamics are derived. By requiring form invariance of the Schrodinger equation under a space and time dependent unitary transformation, operator gauge transformations on the quantized electromagnetic potentials and state vectors are introduced. These gauge transformed potentials have the same form as gauge transformations in non-Abelian gauge field theories. A gauge-invariant method for solving the time-dependent Schrodinger equation in quantum electrodynamics is given. Maxwell's equations are written in a form which holds in all gauges and which has formal similarity to the equations of motion of non-Abelian gauge fields. A gauge-invariant derivation of conservation of energy in quantum electrodynamics is given. An operator gauge transformation is made to the multipolar gauge in which the potentials are expressed in terms of the electromagnetic fields. The multipolar Hamiltonian is shown to be the minimally coupled Hamiltonian with the electromagnetic potentials in the multipolar gauge. The model of a charged harmonic oscillator in a single-mode electromagnetic field is considered as an example. The gauge-invariant procedure for solving the time-dependent Schrodinger equation is used to obtain the gauge-invariant probabilities that the oscillator is in an energy eigenstate For comparison, the conventional approach is also used to solve the harmonic oscillator problem and is shown to give gauge-dependent amplitudes.
Some years have passed since the appearance of Dirac's striking interpretation of the Heisenberg-Schroedinger parallelism in the equations of motion, and yet it appears that there still remain obscure points which have led to misunderstanding. Although the Schroedinger method suffices to deal with many practical problems, the flexibility of the Dirac-Jordan representation theory, aside from its intrinsic unity and beauty, recommends it to general theoretical investigation. The present paper considers the invariant form of the equations of motion in relation to the Schroedinger-Heisenberg pictures of quantum mechanics insofar as the latter refer to the "pictured" intrinsic motion of states (vectors) and observables (Hermitian operators). The discussion is divided roughly into 5-sections: Operator and Vector Transforms, Contact Transformations, Heisenberg-Schroedinger Operators, Equations of Motion and Invariant Properties, and the Density Operator and Operator Spur. Where possible, quasi-geometrical diagrams are given to illustrate the relation and transition between the several "pictures of the motion."