Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Physical Review

Note on Kowalewski's Top in Quantum Mechanics

Otto Laporte

Published Apr 1, 1933• 10 citations
Publisher

Abstract

It is well known that in classical mechanics algebraic integrals of the top equations only exist in the cases of Euler (asymmetric top, no electric moment), of Lagrange (symmetric top, electric moment parallel to the axis of figure) and of Kowalewski. The latter case is that of a symmetric top whose two equal moments of inertia are twice as large as the third ($A=B=2C$) with an electric moment perpendicular to the axis of figure. The quantum mechanical analogue to Euler's and Lagrange's cases being well known, Kowalewski's case was tried. If $\ensuremath{\vartheta}$, $\ensuremath{\psi}$, $\ensuremath{\phi}$ are the Euler angles, ${Q}_{\mathrm{I}}={Q}_{1}+i{Q}_{2}$, ${Q}_{\mathrm{II}}={Q}_{1}\ensuremath{-}i{Q}_{2}$ linear combinations of the momenta around the principal axes and $U={{Q}_{\mathrm{I}}}^{2}+4C\ensuremath{\mu}sin\ensuremath{\vartheta}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}i\ensuremath{\psi}},$ then Kowalewski's integral becomes: $U{U}^{*}+{U}^{*}U+4{h}^{2}({Q}_{\mathrm{I}}{Q}_{\mathrm{II}}+{Q}_{\mathrm{II}}{Q}_{\mathrm{I}})=\mathrm{Diag}.\mathrm{Matrix},$ which differs from the classical result by the symmetrization and by the last term proportional to ${h}^{2}$.

DOI
10.1103/physrev.43.548

Related papers

The Symmetrical Top in the Undulatory Mechanics

R. de L. Kronig, Isidor Isaac Rabi

Schr\"odinger's method for determining the energy levels of an atomic system is applied to the case of the symmetrical top (moment of inertia about axis of symmetry $C$, the other one $A$). The energy values are found to be ${W}_{\mathrm{jn}}=\frac{{h}^{2}}{8{\ensuremath{\pi}}^{2}}\left[\frac{1}{A}j(j+1)+\left(\frac{1}{C}\ensuremath{-}\frac{1}{A}\right){n}^{2}\right]$ in agreement with the result obtained by Dennison from the matrix mechanics. The quantum numbers $j$ and $n$ must be integers restricted by $0\ensuremath{\leqq}j$, $|n|\ensuremath{\leqq}j$, while half-integral values are not permissible. The intensities of transitions are also calculated.

Physical Review•Feb 1, 1927•80 citations

The Torsion Oscillator-Rotator in the Quantum Mechanics

Harald H. Nielsen

The theory of a symmetric rotator which in addition to the usual three degrees of rotational freedom has about the axis of symmetry also a degree of torsional freedom between two of its principal parts, is treated quantum mechanically. The potential energy is taken to be expressible in the form: $V=L(1\ensuremath{-}cosm{\ensuremath{\varphi}}^{\ensuremath{'}})$ where $L$ is proportional to the restoring torque, ${\ensuremath{\varphi}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ is the angle of displacement, and $m$ the number of minima of the potential energy curve as ${\ensuremath{\varphi}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ increases from zero to $2\ensuremath{\pi}$. The Schr\"odinger equation is found to be separable into two differential equations, one being the quantum mechanical equation for an ordinary symmetric rotator, and the other being of the form of Mathieu's equation: $\frac{{d}^{2}M}{d{x}^{2}}+(a+16qcos2x)$ $M=0$ in which $a$ is proportional to the energy parameter of the oscillator, $q$ proportional to the restoring torque, and $x$ to ${\ensuremath{\varphi}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$. It is found that the solutions to this equation must satisfy the condition: $M(x\ensuremath{-}m\ensuremath{\pi})=(\mathrm{exp}\ensuremath{-}\frac{2\ensuremath{\pi}\mathrm{iK}{{A}_{z}}^{\ensuremath{'}}}{{A}_{z}}) M(x)$ where $K$ is the quantum number of angular momentum about the axis of symmetry, ${{A}_{z}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ and ${A}_{z}$ the moments of inertia of the lower part of the top and of the whole of the top respectively about the axis of symmetry. This ordinarily demands a general non-periodic solution to Mathieu's equation which, however, degenerates like the ordinary Mathieu functions to an exponential function as $q\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$. A qualitative discussion is given about the manner in which the energy states in the limiting case where $q=0$ go over into the other limiting case where $q=\ensuremath{\infty}$, and the calculation of the intensities and the selection rules for the rotator are finally determined where $q=0$ and where $q=\ensuremath{\infty}$. These it is believed will also be valid at least in first approximation in the neighborhoods of these limiting cases where $q$ no longer is quite zero and not quite equal to infinity.

Physical Review•May 1, 1932•147 citations

A special case of Neumann's system and the Kowalewski-Chaplygin-Goryachev top

Vadim B. Kuznetsov, Andrey Vladimirovich Tsiganov

The authors present L operators both for the special case of Neumann's system and the Kowalewski-Chaplygin-Goryachev top. These are quantum systems integrable by the quantum inverse scattering (R-matrix) method. L operators, being 2*2 matrices, satisfy an algebra generated by an R matrix of the XXX type. The close connection between the two models is demonstrated. They carry out a non-obvious separation of variables and also give a dynamical group scheme for the eigenstate problem of Neumann's system. This separation differs from those in Euler angles and allows them to find eigenenergies in an effective way.

Journal of Physics A Mathematical and General•Feb 7, 1989•45 citations

Equivalent forms of the complex classical equations of quantum mechanics.

Sylwester Kaliski

•Jan 1, 1972•0 citations

Separation of Angles in the Two-Electron Problem

GREGORY A. BREIT

Neglecting the spin, two electrons are described in quantum mechanics by means of a wave equation in six variables. It is shown that well-known relations between angular momentum operators make it possible to determine the dependence of the wave function on three variables. The problem is thus reduced from six to three dimensions. For a state with an assigned "orbital" angular momentum $l$, say an $S$, $P$, $D$ state the dependence of the wave function on three Euler angles is determined by the value of $l$. The wave function is a linear combination of products of distance and angle functions, the latter depending only on the three Euler angles. The angle functions are well-known solutions of the wave equation for a symmetrical top. The distance functions satisfy wave equations in three variables ${r}_{1}$, ${r}_{2}$, ${r}_{12}$ or ${r}_{1}$, ${r}_{2}$, $\ensuremath{\theta}$. The case of $P$ terms is worked out in detail. Equations (10), (25) apply to two electrons having the same asimuthal quantum number. Equations (18), (20), (24) describe all the other cases, for instance $S$ and $P$ electrons combining to give $^{1}P$ and $^{3}P$. Triplets are described by (18) and singlets by (20).

Physical Review•Mar 15, 1930•130 citations

Classical Mechanics Is not the ħ, → 0 Limit of Quantum Mechanics

Olga V. Man’ko, Vladimir I. Man’ko

arXiv:quant-ph/0407183•Journal of Russian Laser Research•Sep 1, 2004•43 citations
It is well known that in classical mechanics algebraic integrals of the top equations only exist in the cases of Euler (asymmetric top, no electric moment), of Lagrange (symmetric top, electric moment parallel to the axis of figure) and of Kowalewski. The latter case is that of a symmetric top whose two equal moments of inertia are twice as large as the third (A=B=2CA=B=2CA=B=2C) with an electric moment perpendicular to the axis of figure. The quantum mechanical analogue to Euler's and Lagrange's cases being well known, Kowalewski's case was tried. If \ensuremathϑ\ensuremath{\vartheta}\ensuremathϑ, \ensuremathψ\ensuremath{\psi}\ensuremathψ, \ensuremathϕ\ensuremath{\phi}\ensuremathϕ are the Euler angles, QI=Q1+iQ2{Q}_{\mathrm{I}}={Q}_{1}+i{Q}_{2}QI​=Q1​+iQ2​, QII=Q1\ensuremath−iQ2{Q}_{\mathrm{II}}={Q}_{1}\ensuremath{-}i{Q}_{2}QII​=Q1​\ensuremath−iQ2​ linear combinations of the momenta around the principal axes and U=QI2+4C\ensuremathμsin\ensuremathϑe\ensuremath−i\ensuremathψ,U={{Q}_{\mathrm{I}}}^{2}+4C\ensuremath{\mu}sin\ensuremath{\vartheta}{e}^{\ensuremath{-}i\ensuremath{\psi}},U=QI​2+4C\ensuremathμsin\ensuremathϑe\ensuremath−i\ensuremathψ, then Kowalewski's integral becomes: UU∗+U∗U+4h2(QIQII+QIIQI)=Diag.Matrix,U{U}^{*}+{U}^{*}U+4{h}^{2}({Q}_{\mathrm{I}}{Q}_{\mathrm{II}}+{Q}_{\mathrm{II}}{Q}_{\mathrm{I}})=\mathrm{Diag}.\mathrm{Matrix},UU∗+U∗U+4h2(QI​QII​+QII​QI​)=Diag.Matrix, which differs from the classical result by the symmetrization and by the last term proportional to h2{h}^{2}h2.
Schr\"odinger's method for determining the energy levels of an atomic system is applied to the case of the symmetrical top (moment of inertia about axis of symmetry CCC, the other one AAA). The energy values are found to be ${W}_{\mathrm{jn}}=\frac{{h}^{2}}{8{\ensuremath{\pi}}^{2}}\left[\frac{1}{A}j(j+1)+\left(\frac{1}{C}\ensuremath{-}\frac{1}{A}\right){n}^{2}\right]$ in agreement with the result obtained by Dennison from the matrix mechanics. The quantum numbers jjj and nnn must be integers restricted by $0\ensuremath{\leqq}j$, $|n|\ensuremath{\leqq}j$, while half-integral values are not permissible. The intensities of transitions are also calculated.
The theory of a symmetric rotator which in addition to the usual three degrees of rotational freedom has about the axis of symmetry also a degree of torsional freedom between two of its principal parts, is treated quantum mechanically. The potential energy is taken to be expressible in the form: $V=L(1\ensuremath{-}cosm{\ensuremath{\varphi}}^{\ensuremath{'}})$ where LLL is proportional to the restoring torque, ${\ensuremath{\varphi}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ is the angle of displacement, and mmm the number of minima of the potential energy curve as ${\ensuremath{\varphi}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ increases from zero to $2\ensuremath{\pi}$. The Schr\"odinger equation is found to be separable into two differential equations, one being the quantum mechanical equation for an ordinary symmetric rotator, and the other being of the form of Mathieu's equation: d2Mdx2+(a+16qcos2x)\frac{{d}^{2}M}{d{x}^{2}}+(a+16qcos2x)dx2d2M​+(a+16qcos2x) M=0M=0M=0 in which aaa is proportional to the energy parameter of the oscillator, qqq proportional to the restoring torque, and xxx to ${\ensuremath{\varphi}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$. It is found that the solutions to this equation must satisfy the condition: $M(x\ensuremath{-}m\ensuremath{\pi})=(\mathrm{exp}\ensuremath{-}\frac{2\ensuremath{\pi}\mathrm{iK}{{A}_{z}}^{\ensuremath{'}}}{{A}_{z}}) M(x)$ where KKK is the quantum number of angular momentum about the axis of symmetry, ${{A}_{z}}^{\ensuremath{'}}$ and Az{A}_{z}Az​ the moments of inertia of the lower part of the top and of the whole of the top respectively about the axis of symmetry. This ordinarily demands a general non-periodic solution to Mathieu's equation which, however, degenerates like the ordinary Mathieu functions to an exponential function as $q\ensuremath{\rightarrow}0$. A qualitative discussion is given about the manner in which the energy states in the limiting case where q=0q=0q=0 go over into the other limiting case where $q=\ensuremath{\infty}$, and the calculation of the intensities and the selection rules for the rotator are finally determined where q=0q=0q=0 and where $q=\ensuremath{\infty}$. These it is believed will also be valid at least in first approximation in the neighborhoods of these limiting cases where qqq no longer is quite zero and not quite equal to infinity.
The authors present L operators both for the special case of Neumann's system and the Kowalewski-Chaplygin-Goryachev top. These are quantum systems integrable by the quantum inverse scattering (R-matrix) method. L operators, being 2*2 matrices, satisfy an algebra generated by an R matrix of the XXX type. The close connection between the two models is demonstrated. They carry out a non-obvious separation of variables and also give a dynamical group scheme for the eigenstate problem of Neumann's system. This separation differs from those in Euler angles and allows them to find eigenenergies in an effective way.
Neglecting the spin, two electrons are described in quantum mechanics by means of a wave equation in six variables. It is shown that well-known relations between angular momentum operators make it possible to determine the dependence of the wave function on three variables. The problem is thus reduced from six to three dimensions. For a state with an assigned "orbital" angular momentum lll, say an SSS, PPP, DDD state the dependence of the wave function on three Euler angles is determined by the value of lll. The wave function is a linear combination of products of distance and angle functions, the latter depending only on the three Euler angles. The angle functions are well-known solutions of the wave equation for a symmetrical top. The distance functions satisfy wave equations in three variables r1{r}_{1}r1​, r2{r}_{2}r2​, r12{r}_{12}r12​ or r1{r}_{1}r1​, r2{r}_{2}r2​, $\ensuremath{\theta}$. The case of PPP terms is worked out in detail. Equations (10), (25) apply to two electrons having the same asimuthal quantum number. Equations (18), (20), (24) describe all the other cases, for instance SSS and PPP electrons combining to give 1P^{1}P1P and 3P^{3}P3P. Triplets are described by (18) and singlets by (20).