Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

American Journal of Physics

Comments on quantum reality

Robert K. Clifton

Published Dec 1, 1987• 0 citations
Publisher
DOI
10.1119/1.15286

Related papers

Physics and mathematical reality: comments on Aharonov et al, arXiv:1902.08798

Suresh Chandra Tiwari

Do we have two kinds of reality: physical and mathematical? What is the role of mathematics in physics? These fundamental questions have intrigued original and brilliant minds since ancient times. A recent article (Aharonov, Cohen and Oaknin, arXiv:1902.08798) offers a viewpoint on the use of abstract mathematics in quantum theory. They argue that, in some cases, it may result into a paradox focusing on an example in quantum mechanics regarding Aharonov-Bergmann-Lebowitz (ABL) rule. In this comment we discuss three issues: theory reduction and approximation, origin of a paradox, and the reality of time. It is pointed out that paradoxes appear even in mathematics; we explain them as the results of the acceptance of pure logical artifacts. In physics too, the impact of the so called quantum and relativity revolutions, have led to the emergence of counter-intuitive and mysterious notion of the physical reality. The most fundamental change has been on rejecting the reality of time. A radically new perspective that physics is the language of mathematics is suggested. The mathematical reality of the natural numbers manifests in the form of physical time.

arXiv:1906.05537•Jun 13, 2019•1 citation

Reality in the quantum world

Institute of Physics eBooks•Nov 26, 2004•0 citations

Comments: John Wheeler (1911‐2008): Quantum theory poses reality's deepest mystery

Science News•May 24, 2008•49 citations

Reality in the Quantum World

Taylor & Francis eBooks•Jan 1, 1994•0 citations

Quantum Reality

WORLD SCIENTIFIC eBooks•May 1, 2007•0 citations

Comment on Unruh's Paper

Henry Pierce Stapp

William Unruh has commented on my recent proof of the incompatibility of certain predictions of quantum theory with the idea that no influence of any kind can act backward in time in any Lorentz frame.He argues that my proof contains, contrary to my explicit claim, a tacit reality assumption that conflicts with the ideas quantum theory.I show here that Unruh's argument fails to draw a necessary distinction between statements that make an assertion about actual values and statements that make an assertion about correlations between possible values, and that consequently his argument fails demonstrate the occurrence in my proof of any reality assumption that is alien to the principles of quantum theory.

•Jan 23, 1998•1 citation
Do we have two kinds of reality: physical and mathematical? What is the role of mathematics in physics? These fundamental questions have intrigued original and brilliant minds since ancient times. A recent article (Aharonov, Cohen and Oaknin, arXiv:1902.08798) offers a viewpoint on the use of abstract mathematics in quantum theory. They argue that, in some cases, it may result into a paradox focusing on an example in quantum mechanics regarding Aharonov-Bergmann-Lebowitz (ABL) rule. In this comment we discuss three issues: theory reduction and approximation, origin of a paradox, and the reality of time. It is pointed out that paradoxes appear even in mathematics; we explain them as the results of the acceptance of pure logical artifacts. In physics too, the impact of the so called quantum and relativity revolutions, have led to the emergence of counter-intuitive and mysterious notion of the physical reality. The most fundamental change has been on rejecting the reality of time. A radically new perspective that physics is the language of mathematics is suggested. The mathematical reality of the natural numbers manifests in the form of physical time.
William Unruh has commented on my recent proof of the incompatibility of certain predictions of quantum theory with the idea that no influence of any kind can act backward in time in any Lorentz frame.He argues that my proof contains, contrary to my explicit claim, a tacit reality assumption that conflicts with the ideas quantum theory.I show here that Unruh's argument fails to draw a necessary distinction between statements that make an assertion about actual values and statements that make an assertion about correlations between possible values, and that consequently his argument fails demonstrate the occurrence in my proof of any reality assumption that is alien to the principles of quantum theory.