Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Log inSign up
Challenges
Datasets
Workspaces
Papers
Discussions
Leaderboard
Blog
Job Board
Q3AS

© 2026 Aqora Quantum S.A.S.

TermsPrivacyLegal Notice

Zeitschrift für Naturforschung A

When do Projections Commute?

W. Rehder

Published Apr 1, 1980• 13 citations
Publisher

Abstract

Abstract Necessary and sufficient conditions for commutativity of two projections in Hilbert space are given through properties of so-called conditional connectives which are derived from the conditional probability operator PQP. This approach unifies most of the known proofs, provides a few new criteria, and permits certain suggestive interpretations for compound properties of quantum-mechanical systems.

DOI
10.1515/zna-1980-0415

Related papers

What the complex joint probabilities observed in weak measurements can tell us about quantum physics

Holger Friedrich Hofmann

Quantum mechanics does not permit joint measurements of non-commuting observables.However, it is possible to measure the weak value of a projection operator, followed by the precise measurement of a different property.The results can be interpreted as complex joint probabilities of the two non-commuting measurement outcomes.Significantly, it is possible to predict the outcome of completely different measurements by combining the joint probabilities of the initial state with complex conditional probabilities relating the new measurement to the possible combinations of measurement outcomes used in the characterization of the quantum state.We can therefore conclude that the complex conditional probabilities observed in weak measurements describe fundamental state-independent relations between non-commuting properties that represent the most fundamental form of universal laws in quantum physics.

arXiv:1303.0078•AIP conference proceedings•Jan 1, 2014•6 citations

A simple sufficient condition for the coexistence of quantum effects

Teiko Heinosaari

Two quantum effects are considered coexistent if they can be measured together. It is known that commutativity and comparability are sufficient but not necessary for the coexistence of two effects. We unify those two conditions to a simple but more widely applicable sufficient condition.

arXiv:1303.7308•Journal of Physics A Mathematical and Theoretical•Apr 3, 2013•16 citations

A note on the logic of bounded quantum observables

Yuan Li, Xiu-Hong Sun

The set of bounded observables for a quantum system is represented by the set of bounded self-adjoint operators S(H) on a complex Hilbert space H, and the quantum effects for a physical system can be described by the set E(H) of positive contractive operators on a complex Hilbert space H. In this note, by the techniques of operator block and spectral, we give the simpler representation of A∧P and obtained the new necessary and sufficient conditions for A∨P, for A∊S(H) and P∊P(H), where P(H) is the set of all orthogonal projection operators on H. In particular, we get that if A∨P exists, then A∨P∊E(H) for A∊E(H) and P∊P(H). In addition, we consider the relations between the existence of A∨B, A−∨B−, and A+∨B+, where A+, B+, A−, and B− are the positive and negative parts of A,B∊S(H).

Journal of Mathematical Physics•Dec 1, 2009•6 citations

Relations Between Quantum Maps and Quantum States

M. Asorey, Andrzej Kossakowski, Giuseppe Marmo +1 more

The relation between completely positive maps and compound states is investigated in terms of the notion of quantum conditional probability.

arXiv:quant-ph/0602228•Open Systems & Information Dynamics•Nov 11, 2005•30 citations

Role of the extended Hilbert space in the attainability of the quantum Cramér–Rao bound for multiparameter estimation

Lorcán O. Conlon, Jun Suzuki, Ping Koy Lam +1 more

The symmetric logarithmic derivative Cramér–Rao bound (SLDCRB) provides a fundamental limit to the minimum variance with which a set of unknown parameters can be estimated in an unbiased manner. It is known that the SLDCRB can be saturated provided the optimal measurements for the individual parameters commute with one another. However, when this is not the case the SLDCRB cannot be attained in general. In the experimentally relevant setting, where quantum states are measured individually, necessary and sufficient conditions for when the SLDCRB can be saturated are not known. In this setting the SLDCRB is attainable provided the SLD operators can be chosen to commute on an extended Hilbert space. However, beyond this relatively little is known about when the SLD operators can be chosen in this manner. In this paper we present explicit examples which demonstrate novel aspects of this condition. Our examples demonstrate that the SLD operators commuting on any two of the following three spaces: support space, support-kernel space and kernel space, is neither a necessary nor sufficient condition for commutativity on the extended space. We present a simple analytic example showing that the Nagaoka–Hayashi Cramér-Rao bound is not always attainable. Finally, we provide necessary and sufficient conditions for the attainability of the SLDCRB in the case when the kernel space is one-dimensional. These results provide new information on the necessary and sufficient conditions for the attainability of the SLDCRB.

arXiv:2404.01520•Physics Letters A•Mar 18, 2025•10 citations

An elementary approach to quantum probability

John E. G. Farina

Compatibility of elementary propositions in quantum mechanics is usually defined as the commutativity of the corresponding projectors. It is shown that this is equivalent to the vanishing of interference, the theorem of total probabilities, Bayes’ theorem, indifference to the order of acquisition of information, and the validity of the rule for marginal probabilities

American Journal of Physics•May 1, 1993•5 citations
Abstract Necessary and sufficient conditions for commutativity of two projections in Hilbert space are given through properties of so-called conditional connectives which are derived from the conditional probability operator PQP. This approach unifies most of the known proofs, provides a few new criteria, and permits certain suggestive interpretations for compound properties of quantum-mechanical systems.
Quantum mechanics does not permit joint measurements of non-commuting observables.However, it is possible to measure the weak value of a projection operator, followed by the precise measurement of a different property.The results can be interpreted as complex joint probabilities of the two non-commuting measurement outcomes.Significantly, it is possible to predict the outcome of completely different measurements by combining the joint probabilities of the initial state with complex conditional probabilities relating the new measurement to the possible combinations of measurement outcomes used in the characterization of the quantum state.We can therefore conclude that the complex conditional probabilities observed in weak measurements describe fundamental state-independent relations between non-commuting properties that represent the most fundamental form of universal laws in quantum physics.
The set of bounded observables for a quantum system is represented by the set of bounded self-adjoint operators S(H) on a complex Hilbert space H, and the quantum effects for a physical system can be described by the set E(H) of positive contractive operators on a complex Hilbert space H. In this note, by the techniques of operator block and spectral, we give the simpler representation of A∧P and obtained the new necessary and sufficient conditions for A∨P, for A∊S(H) and P∊P(H), where P(H) is the set of all orthogonal projection operators on H. In particular, we get that if A∨P exists, then A∨P∊E(H) for A∊E(H) and P∊P(H). In addition, we consider the relations between the existence of A∨B, A−∨B−, and A+∨B+, where A+, B+, A−, and B− are the positive and negative parts of A,B∊S(H).
The symmetric logarithmic derivative Cramér–Rao bound (SLDCRB) provides a fundamental limit to the minimum variance with which a set of unknown parameters can be estimated in an unbiased manner. It is known that the SLDCRB can be saturated provided the optimal measurements for the individual parameters commute with one another. However, when this is not the case the SLDCRB cannot be attained in general. In the experimentally relevant setting, where quantum states are measured individually, necessary and sufficient conditions for when the SLDCRB can be saturated are not known. In this setting the SLDCRB is attainable provided the SLD operators can be chosen to commute on an extended Hilbert space. However, beyond this relatively little is known about when the SLD operators can be chosen in this manner. In this paper we present explicit examples which demonstrate novel aspects of this condition. Our examples demonstrate that the SLD operators commuting on any two of the following three spaces: support space, support-kernel space and kernel space, is neither a necessary nor sufficient condition for commutativity on the extended space. We present a simple analytic example showing that the Nagaoka–Hayashi Cramér-Rao bound is not always attainable. Finally, we provide necessary and sufficient conditions for the attainability of the SLDCRB in the case when the kernel space is one-dimensional. These results provide new information on the necessary and sufficient conditions for the attainability of the SLDCRB.