The British Journal for the Philosophy of Science
Is Standard Quantum Mechanics Technologically Inadequate?
Frederik Müller, M. P. Seevinck
Abstract
In a recent issue of this journal, P.E. Vermaas ([2005]) claims to have demonstrated that standard quantum mechanics is technologically inadequate in that it violates the ‘technical functions condition’. We argue that this claim is false because based on a ‘narrow’ interpretation of this technical functions condition that Vermaas can only accept on pain of contradiction. We also argue that if, in order to avoid this contradiction, the technical functions condition is interpreted ‘widely’ rather than ‘narrowly’, then Vermaas, argument for his claim collapses. The conclusion is that Vermaas' claim that standard quantum mechanics is technologically inadequate evaporates. 1. Introduction2. The Narrow Interpretation3. The Wide Interpretation4. The Teleportation Scheme5. Conclusions